HomeMy WebLinkAbout1105 Sewer Ordinance and replacement or repair of sewer lateralsORDINANCE NO. 1105
ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
UKIAH AMENDING ARTICLES 1 AND 78 OF DIVISION 4,
CHAPTER 2 OF THE UKIAH CITY CODE, PERTAINING TO
THE DEFINITIONS USED IN THE CITY OF UKIAH SEWER
ORDINANCE AND TO THE REPLACEMENT OR REPAIR OF
SEWER LATERALS
The City Council of the City of Ukiah hereby ordains as follows:
SECTION ONE. FINDINGS.
1. The City of Ukiah (City) owns, operates and maintains a sewer collection system within its limits.
2. The Ukiah Valley Sanitation District (District) contracts with the City to operate and maintain the
collection system it owns.
3. The City owns, operates and maintains a sewer treatment plant to treat, recycle and dispose of
wastewater generated within the limits of the City and District.
4. The City's ability to effectively manage its sewer collection system can be affected by the proper
maintenance of private sewer laterals.
5. The City's ability to regulate private sewer laterals is outlined in Division 4, Chapter 2 of the Municipal
Code.
6. The modifications set forth below will facilitate the proper maintenance of private sewer laterals;
SECTION TWO.
Division 4, Chapter 2, Article 1 of the Ukiah City Code is amended to read as follows:
ARTICLE 7. SEWERS AND SANITATION
§ 3700.0: DEFINITIONS
The following definitions apply to this chapter. Terms not defined in this article shall have
their ordinary and common meaning, or if applicable, the meaning set forth in the Plumbing
Code as adopted in the City.
§ 3700.1: APPLICANT DEFINED:
Applicant shall mean a person or entity making application under the provisions of this
division for a permit for a sewer or plumbing application. An applicant shall be the property
owner or an authorized agent of the property owner.
§ 3700.2: BOARD DEFINED:
Board shall mean the Board of Directors of the Ukiah Valley Sanitation District, California.
February 6, 2008
§ 3700.3: BUILDING LATERAL DEFINED:
Building lateral shall mean that portion of a sewer lateral beginning at the foundation wall of
any building or industrial facility and running to the property line or to a private sewage
disposal system.
§ 3700.4: CERTIFICATE OF SEWER LATERAL COMPLIANCE DEFINED:
Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance shall mean the certificate issued by the Director of
Ukiah Public Utilities or his/her designee certifying that the sewer lateral complies with the
standards set forth in this Chapter. Certificates of Sewer Lateral Compliance shall be valid
for a period of twenty five (25) years for all sewer laterals that, as a result of inspection and
testing occurring after Dec. 31, 2006, are confirmed to meet the current building material,
testing and pertormance standards of the City for new sewer laterals. Certificates of Sewer
Lateral Compliance shall be valid for a period ten (10) years for sewer laterals that
satisfactorily pass inspection and testing occurring after Dec. 31, 2006 and do not exfiltrate
at a rate greater than that allowed by the City's testing standards or that meet the
requirements outlined in Section 3799.6
§ 3700.5: CITY DEFINED:
City shall mean the City of Ukiah, California.
§ 3700.6: CITY ENGINEER DEFINED:
City Engineer shall mean the City Engineer of the City.
§ 3700.7: CONTRACTOR DEFINED:
Contractor shall mean a person or entity duly licensed by the State of California to perform
the type of work to be done under the permit.
§ 3700.8: COUNTY DEFINED:
County shall mean the County of Mendocino, California.
§ 3700.9: DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Director of Planning and Community Development shall mean the Director of Planning and
Community Development of the City.
§ 3700.10: DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS DEFINED:
Director of Public Works shall mean the Director of Public Works of the City.
§ 3700.11: DIRECTOR OF UKIAH PUBLIC UTILITIES DEFINED:
Director of Ukiah Public Utilities shall mean the Director of the Public Utilities Department of
the City. The Director of Ukiah Public Utilities or his/her designee shall perform all duties of
sewer inspector under the terms of this ordinance.
February 6, 2008
§ 3700.12: DISTRICT DEFINED:
District shall mean the Ukiah Valley Sanitation District, California.
§ 3700.13: DOMESTIC SANITARY SEWAGE DEFINED:
Domestic sanitary sewage shall mean water carried wastes from residences, hotels, motels,
restaurants and business establishments, but excluding all ground water, surface water,
storm water and industrial wastes.
§ 3700.14: GOOD CAUSE DEFINED
Good cause shall mean practical difficulties, including interference with the use or safety of
the public right of way, adverse weather conditions, or demonstrated economic hardship.
§ 3700.15: GARBAGE DEFINED:
Garbage shall mean solid waste from the preparation, cooking and dispensing of food and
from the handling, storage and sale of produce.
§ 3700.16: INDUSTRIAL WASTES DEFINED:
Industrial wastes shall mean the wastes of producing, manufacturing and processing
operations of every kind and nature. It shall not include domestic sanitary sewage.
§ 3700.17: MAIN SEWER DEFINED:
Main sewer shall mean a public sewer designed to accommodate more than one sewer
lateral.
§ 3700.18: MULTIPLE DWELLING DEFINED:
Multiple dwelling shall mean a building or buildings on a single parcel for residential
purposes containing more than one kitchen or having facilities for the occupancy of more
than one family, including, but not limited to, the following: hotels, motels, auto courts, trailer
courts, apartment houses, condominiums, duplex, rooming house, boarding house, guest
house and dormitories.
§ 3700.19: NOTICE TO REPAIR:
Notice to Repair shall mean notice issued by the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities to a
property owner that the property owner is in violation of the City Code with respect to the
property owner's sewer lateral, which order directs the abatement of the violation.
§ 3700.20: OUTSIDE SEWER DEFINED:
Outside sewer shall mean a sanitary sewer beyond the limits of the City not subject to the
control or jurisdiction of City.
February 6, 2008
§ 3700.21: PERMIT DEFINED:
Permit shall mean any written authorization required pursuant to this Division or any other
regulation of City for the installation of any sewerage work.
§ 3700.22: PERSON DEFINED:
Person shall mean any human being, individual, firm, company, partnership, association
and private or public or municipal corporations, the United States of America, the State of
California, districts, and all political subdivisions and governmental agencies thereof.
§ 3700.23: PLUMBER DEFINED:
Plumber shall mean a person or entity duly licensed by the State of California to perform the
type of plumbing work to be done under the permit.
§ 3700.24: PRE-AUTHORIZED LIST:
Pre-authorized list shall mean the list of qualified plumbers, contractors, or other inspectors
qualified by training and experience to conduct the required inspections, developed by the
Director of Ukiah Public Utilities that may perform sewer lateral inspections without direct
City oversight, in accordance with the provisions of this chapter.
§ 3700.25: PROPERTY OWNER:
Property owner shall mean the owner of the property as shown on the last equalized
assessment roll or in the records of the Mendocino County Recorder.
§ 3700.26: PUBLIC DISTRICT DEFINED:
Public district shall mean any district organized under the laws of the State of California
which is authorized to engage in and is engaged in collecting and disposing of sewage.
§ 3700.27: PUBLIC PREMISES DEFINED:
Public premises shall mean any premises owned of record by the City of Ukiah, the Ukiah
Valley Sanitation District, the County of Mendocino, the State of California, or the United
States of America.
§ 3700.28: PUBLIC SEWER DEFINED:
Public sewer shall mean a main sewer lying within a street or easement which is maintained
and controlled by or under the jurisdiction of the City andlor the District.
§3700.29: QUALIFYING SEWER LATERAL SERVICE CALL DEFINED:
A Qualifying Sewer Lateral Service Call means work on a sewer lateral pertormed by a
septic or sewer line cleaning business, plumber or similar service provider, where the
service provider in the course of providing service encounters conditions indicating root
intrusion or other permanent damage to the sewer lateral, such as deflection or separation
of the lateral.
February 6, 2008
§ 3700.30: QUALITY CHARACTERISTICS AND ANALYSES DEFINED
Quality characteristics and analyses shall mean as defined in the latest edition of "Standard
Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater" published by the American Public
Health Association, or EPA Standard Procedures, and all sample collection, laboratory
procedures of analyses, tests, measurements and data reporting.
§ 3700.31: SANITARY SEWER DEFINED:
Sanitary sewer shall mean a sewer which carries sewage and to which storm, surface and
ground waters are not intentionally admitted
§ 3700.32: SEWAGE DEFINED:
Sewage shall mean water carried wastes from residences, business buildings, institutions
and industrial establishments.
§ 3700.33: SEWERAGE WORKS DEFINED:
Sewerage works shall mean all facilities owned or controlled by the City except private
sewers, for collecting, pumping, treating and disposing of sewage.
§ 3700.34: SEWER DEFINED:
Sewer shall mean a pipe or conduit for carrying sewage
§ 3700.35: SEWER COLLECTION SYSTEM DEFINED:
Sewer Collection System shall mean the network of public sewers, including main sewers
that transport flow by gravity, main sewers that transport flow under pressure and pumping
stations, which carry sewage to the sewer treatment plant.
§ 3700.36: SEWER LATERAL DEFINED:
Sewer lateral shall mean the sewer line beginning at the foundation wall of any building and
terminating at the main sewer and shall include the building lateral and street lateral
together, also referred to herein as "the side lateral."
§ 3700.37: SEWER SERVICE UNIT DEFINED:
One sewer service unit is defined as being a single unit of sewer discharge having
characteristics of flow, biochemical oxygen demand (B.O.D.) and suspended solids
equivalent to that generated and discharged by a typical single family residential unit.
§ 3700.38: SEWER TREATMENT PLANT DEFINED:
Sewer treatment plant shall mean the Sewer Treatment Plant owned and operated by the
City.
§ 3700.39: SINGLE-FAMILY UNIT DEFINED:
Single-family unit shall mean and refer to the place of residence for asingle-family.
February 6, 2008
§ 3700.40: STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS DEFINED:
Standard specifications shall mean a set of documents containing design and construction
standards for all sewage works and sewer laterals as adopted by the City/District and as
amended from time to time
§ 3700.41: STATE DEFINED:
State shall mean the State of California.
§ 3700.42: STORM SEWER OR DRAIN DEFINED:
Storm sewer or storm drain shall mean a conveyance which carries storm waters, non-
storm surface flows or ground waters and drainage, but in or through which sewage is
prohibited.
§ 3700.43: STORM WATER DEFINED:
Storm water shall mean the water running off or draining from the surface and sub-surface
of an area during and after a period of rain or irrigation.
§ 3700.44: STREETS DEFINED:
Streets shall mean any public highway, street, alley, public place, public easement or right
of way.
§ 3700.45: STREET LATERAL DEFINED:
Street lateral shall mean the portion of a sewer lateral lying within a public street connecting
a building lateral to the main sewer.
SECTION THREE.
Division 4, Chapter 2, Article 18 shall be amended to read as follows:
ARTICLE 18. SEWER LATERAL TESTING
3799.1: PURPOSE, POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION:
A. The purpose of this article is to codify requirements for the inspection, testing, repair and
replacement of sewer laterals within the City.
B. It is the policy of the City to reasonably prevent infiltration, exfiltration and better protect
the Sewer Treatment Plant and the environment by requiring a reasonable program of
inspection, testing, and if necessary repair and replacement, of private sewer laterals.
C. The Director of Ukiah Public Utilities shall administer these requirements and has the
authority to alter or waive the requirements prescribed in this Article 18, if such
requirements are impractical, because of the nature or physical location of the sewer lateral
D. Administrative Guidelines for Inspections and Testing
February 6, 2008
Within ninety (90) days of the adoption of the Ordinance enacting this article, the Director of
Ukiah Public Utilities shall prepare and promulgate the public administrative guidelines
which shall, among other things, establish the following:
1. A certification program for licensed plumbers, contractors and other qualified inspectors
who will be placed on the Pre-Authorized List and the basis for obtaining and maintaining
such a certification or for decertification;
2. Standard Inspection Report Forms and Guidelines for completing and using Sewer
Lateral Inspection Reports;
3. A standard Notice to Repair and enforcement procedures for repair and replacements;
4. A standard Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance.
3799.2: APPLICABILITY:
A. This Article shall apply to property located within the City and to property which is located
outside the boundaries of both the City and the District which are served by the City Sewer
Treatment Plant or the City's sewer mains.
B. This Article shall not apply to properties located within the District or within both the City
and the District, if the District has adopted a sewer lateral inspection program that complies
with the Consent Decree in River Watch v. City of Ukiah and Ukiah Valley Sanitation
District, U.S.Dist.Ct., N.D. Cal., C04 4518 CW.
C. All sewer laterals that have been repaired or replaced, including gravity and pressure
laterals, shall be tested in accordance with the applicable provisions of this article. No
person constructing, repairing or replacing a sewer lateral, shall use that lateral to introduce
sewage into the public sewer until the person has complied with sections 3799.3 through
3799.6 of this article, as appropriate.
D. All sewer laterals connected to the public sewer, including sewer laterals serving
residential, multi-family residential, commercial or industrial uses, shall be cleaned and
tested in accordance with the appropriate provisions of section 3799.3 through 3799.6 of
this article, upon the occurrence of any of the following, unless a valid Certificate of Sewer
Lateral Compliance is on file with the City:
1. Upon the occurrence of a sanitary sewer overflow from the private lateral;
2. Upon the discovery of either an illegal connection as described in Section 3702.3 or an illegal
discharge as described in Section 3706.4 to the public sewer system;
3. Upon application for a building permit for work on an existing structure with a sewer service,
where the value of the work, as set forth in the permit, exceeds $100,000, provided, however, that
the value of work required by the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA") or to add fire sprinklers
as required by the California Fire Code as adopted in the City of Ukiah, shall not be included when
determining whether a sewer lateral is subject to inspection and testing; provided, further, that
beginning on March 7, 2009, the $100,000 amount shall be adjusted annually by the percentage
increase in the Consumer Price Index over the same month in the previous year. CPI means the
Consumer Price Index for San Francisco, Oakland-San Jose, CA, all items (base year 1982- 1984
=100) published by the United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. In the
event the CPI is discontinued or otherwise not available, "CPI" shall mean comparable statistics on
the purchasing power of the consumer dollar as determined by the City Manager.
February 6, 2008
4. The addition of a plumbing fixture having assigned to it two or more fixture units as are
assigned by the California Plumbing Code as adopted in the City;
5. Upon a change of use of the property served from a residential to a commercial use or from a
commercial use to a restaurant;
6. In conjunction with the replacement or rehabilitation of the public sewer main to
which the lateral is connected;
7. Upon the occurrence of a Qualifying Sewer Lateral Service Call; and
8. Sewer laterals serving parcels that are located within 100 feet of any creek or stream which is
declared by City Council resolution to be impacted by the sewer system.
3799.3 APPROVED TESTING METHODS
The sewer lateral shall be inspected and tested, using the following methods as allowed by
and in accordance with standards adopted by the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities:
1. TV inspection.
2. Exfiltration testing.
3. Other similar inspection or testing methods as approved by the Director of Ukiah Public
Utilities.
3799.4: REQUIREMENTS FOR TESTING SEWER LATERALS PURSUANT TO SECTION
3799.1.D.1-5 and 7-8.
A. Sewer Lateral Service Providers:
1. On and after March 7, 2008, any person or business entity providing sewer lateral
service in the City of Ukiah for compensation shall file a written report with the Public
Utilities Department of each Qualifying Sewer Lateral Service Call it makes in the City of
Ukiah. The report shall contain the date of the call, the address where the sewer lateral is
located, and a brief description of the service and of the conditions making it a Qualifying
Sewer Lateral Service Call.
2. The Public Utilities Director may adopt a form for use in filing the reports.
3. Within fifteen (15) days of the receipt of a report of a Qualifying Sewer Later Service Call
for an address in the City, the Public Utilities Director or designee shall provide written
notice to the property address that a sewer lateral inspection is required. The mailing of the
notice is the event giving rise to the obligation to conduct an inspection and test of the
sewer lateral.
5. The Public Utilities Director shall coordinate with the Finance Director to monitor whether
businesses that provide septic and sewer Tine cleaning, plumbing and similar services which
have been issued a City business license are filing reports as required by this subsection.
February 6, 2008
B. Testing Procedure:
1. Testing shall be completed within the time periods specified in the fourth column in the
five column chart contained in Section 3799.8.
2. Testing shall be performed by a licensed plumber, contractor, or other person who
possesses any license required by law, if any, to perform the test, and who is determined by
the Director of Public Utilities to be qualified to perform the test based on training and
experience.
3. Permits and Inspection. Testing shall not commence without a valid permit issued by the
City and testing may be witnessed by the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities or his/her
designee.
4. Access. Access to the sewer lines to be tested and conditions necessary to conduct the
test shall be made ready prior to scheduling a sewer lateral test.
C. Failure of Test and Requirement for Repair: It shall be the responsibility of the property
owner to repair and/or replace any sewer lateral which has been found through testing
andlor inspection to exhibit conditions which would permit infiltration to enter the sewer
system. Upon completion of the repair and/or replacement of the sewer lateral, re-
inspections shall be conducted until the sewer lateral passes the required test.
D. The property owner must complete the required repair or replacement of the sewer later
and the sewer lateral must pass a retest within the time specified in the fifth column in the
table contained in Section 3799.8. This deadline may be extended by the Public Utilities
Director for good cause, not to exceed 90 days. If repair is not completed within the
required time period, the City may complete the required repairs and may add a surcharge
onto the property's utility account until the costs are recovered in not more than five (5)
years.
E. Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance:
Once the sewer lateral has successfully passed the testing procedure, the Director of Ukiah
Public Utilities or his/her designee shall execute a Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance
which shall be filed with the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities and the Director of Planning
and Community Development, and to the extent authorized by law, the Mendocino County
Recorder.
F. Role of the Director of Planning and Community Development
The Director of Planning and Community Development and the Director of Ukiah Public
Utilities, in consultation with each other, are hereby authorized to take the actions
necessary to implement this section through the building permit process and to integrate its
implementation with the requirements of the Plumbing Code as adopted in the City.
§ 3799.5 REQUIREMENTS FOR SEWER LATERALS UPON REHABILITATION OR
REPLACEMENT OF THE PUBLIC SEWER MAIN OR UPON DETERMINATION OF THE
DIRECTOR OF UKIAH PUBLIC UTILITIES.
A. Testing Procedure: Testing may be performed in accordance with the requirements of
section 3799.4 or, if authorized by City Council resolution, testing may be performed by the
City in conjunction with its rehabilitation or replacement work. Upon completion of the
Februazy 6, 2008
testing, the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities of his/her designee shall issue either a
Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance or a Notice to Repair
B. Failure of Test and Requirement for Repair: It shall be the responsibility of the property
owner to repair and/or replace any sewer lateral which has been found through testing
and/or inspection to exhibit conditions which would permit infiltration to enter the sewer
system. Upon completion of the repair and/or replacement of the sewer lateral, re-
inspections shall be conducted until the sewer lateral passes the required test.
1. All repair or replacement work shall be completed by a person properly licensed to
perform the work, including licensed plumber and/or contractor and shall be completed
under all appropriate permits from the City including, as appropriate, building and
encroachment permits.
2. All repairs must be completed within time specified in the fifth column of the table in
Section 3799.8, unless, for good cause shown, an extension is granted by the Director of
Ukiah Public Utilities, not to exceed 90 days
3. If repair is not completed within the required time period, the City may complete the
required repairs and may add a surcharge onto the property's utility account until the costs
are recovered in not more than five (5) years.
4. The City Council may, by Resolution, prescribe alternative procedures, by which the
repair or replacement work shall be performed including, but not limited to, the degree to
which the City shall offer to perform all or a portion of the work or contribute towards the
cost of the work, using loans or grants.
C. Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance:
Once the sewer lateral has successfully passed the testing procedure, the Director of Ukiah
Public Utilities or his/her designee shall execute a Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance
which shall be filed with the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities, the Director of Planning and
Community Development and to the extent authorized by law, the Mendocino County
Recorder.
3799.6 CERTIFICATE OF SEWER LATERAL COMPLIANCE WITHOUT INSPECTION.
A Property Owner may apply for and the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities of his/her
designee may issue a Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance without inspection under the
following circumstances:
1. The Property Owner provides evidence, satisfactory to the Director of Ukiah Public
Utilities, that the building on the property is ten (10) years old or less; or
2. The Property Owner provides evidence, satisfactory to the Director of Ukiah Public
Utilities, that the sewer lateral was repaired or replaced and passed inspection within the
previous ten (10) years; or
3. The Property Owner provides evidence, satisfactory to the Director of Ukiah Public
Utilities, that the lateral has passed an inspection within the past five (5) years.
February 6, 2008
In such cases, the Director of Ukiah Public Utilities or his/her designee shall execute a
Certificate of Sewer Lateral Compliance which shall be filed with the Director of Ukiah
Public Utilities, the Director of Planning and Community Development.
3799.7 FEES
The City Council may establish fees by Resolution for administration of this Article.
3799.8 SEWER LATERAL INSPECTION AND TESTING PROGRAM, EVENTS AND
TIME FRAMES TO COMPLETE WORK ON SEWER LATERAL
TIME FRAMES TO PERFORM WORK ON SEWER LATERAL
EVENT Clean & Video Water Test
Inspect Repair or Replace
When Complete
Inspection indicates Within 30 days of
Qualifying Sewer Lateral At time of service damage, Within 7 days of Failed Water Test
Service Call displacement, or Service Call or Notice with Max of 90 day
deflection of lateral Extension for Cause
Within 7 days of Inspection indicates Within 30 days of
Sanitary Sewer Overflow Notice or At Time of damage, Within 7 days of Failed Water Test
Service displacement, or Service Call or Notice with Max of 90 day
deflection of lateral Extension for Cause
Remodels to Structure Being
Served of $100k or Greater prior to Permh Final Prior to Permit Final Prior to Permit Final Prior to Permit Final
Addition of 2 FU or Greater to
Building or Site Plumbing prior to Permit Final Prior to Permit Final Prior to Permit Final Prior to Permit Final
Addition of Bedroom Prior to Permit Final Prior to Permft Final Prior to Permit Final Prior to Permit Final
Change of Property Use:
Residential to Commercial and prior to Opening Prior to Opening Prior to Opening Prior to Opening
Non-Restaurant Commercial Under New Permitted Under New Permitted Under New Permitted Under New
to Restaurant Commercial Use Use Use Permitted Use
Within 30 days of
Illegal Connection Within 7 days of Within 7 days of yvithin 7 days of Notice Failed Water Test
Notice Notice with Max of 90 day
Extension for Cause
Within 30 days of
Prohibfted Discharge Within 7 days of Wfthin 7 days of trrfthin 7 days of Notice Failed Water Test
Notice Notice with Max of 90 day
Exension for Cause
Rehabilitation or Replacement Wfthin 1 year of Wfthin 1 year of Within 1 year of Within 2 years of
of Sewer Main Completion of Sewer Completion of Sewer Completion of Sewer Failed Water Test
Main Work Main Work Main Work
Parcel Served is within 100 Within 1 Year of Wfthin 1 Year of Wfthin 1 Year of
feet of Creek which is
Adoption of
Adoption of
Adoption of Resolution Within 2 years of
Declared Impaled by Sewer
Resolution (or Notice)
Resolution (or Nolice)
(or Notice) Failed Water Test
System
February 6, 2008
SECTION FOUR. SEVERABILITI(.
If any section, subsection, sentence, clause or phrase of this Ordinance is for any reason
held to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this
Ordinance. The City Council hereby declares that it should have adopted the Ordinance
and each section, subsection, sentence, clause or phrase thereof, irrespective of the fact
that any one or more sections subsections, sentences, clauses or phrases be declared
unconstitutional.
SECTION FIVE. CEQA.
This Ordinance is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act under Public
Resources Code Sections 21065 and 21080(b) (8).
SECTION SIX. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Ordinance shall be in full force and effective thirty (30) days after its adoption and shall
be published and posted as required by law.
Introduced by title only on January 16, 2008, by the following roll call vote:
AYES: Crane, McCowen, Thomas
NOES: Baldwin
ABSENT: Rodin
ABSTAIN:
Adopted on Feb. 6. , 2008, by the following roll call vote:
AYES: Councilmember Thomas, McCowen, Rodin, and Mayor Crane
NOES: Baldwin ~
ABSENT: None )
ABSTAIN: None
Douglas .Crane, Mayor
ATTEST:
~ __~
Brown, erk
February 6, 2008