HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-08-07 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
Continued Regular Meeting, called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:04 P.M. on August 7, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Directors Present: Sanford A. Dwight, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Robert F. Parker, Mark D. Edwards
Staff: Linda Groth
Staff Absent: Keith Tiemann
Others Present: Andre' Siedentopf
Agenda Item #1: Hearing of comments or questions from the attending public.
No public in attendance at this time.
Agenda Item #2: Consider cost proposal for installing a network package and a phone system upgrade for the office.
Chairman Butow turned the Meeting over to Andre' Siedentopf.
Andre' discussed his revised figures and the reasons for same.
Chairman Butow asked Mr. Siedentopf to look at a complete networking system for the District Office and Water Treatment Plant for immediate implementation and the possible future needs
that will arise, including the Operations and Maintenance Managers' desk. He also reminded Andre' to consider all the phone lines that would be necessary for each of the phones, computers
and modems, remote access, etc.
Mr. Siedentopf suggested that the Water District should qualify for government program discounts and he will do further research later this week to learn what discounts would be available
to such a small district as Redwood Valley.
Andre' mentioned the phone system upgrade and his recommendation to go with TelMar Inc., who would do the phone system network and computer wiring at the same time, and that would be
done in advance of the delivery of the new phones and new computers. It was agreed that Andre' would talk to the employees to inquire as to their needs and suggestions and then come
back at the September 2002 meeting with the final presentation and figures.
Andre' Siedentopf left the Meeting at 7:21 P.M.
Agenda Item #3: Status Report for the shop expansion project and container cost estimates.
The Board Members received copies of Manager Tiemann's written comments and recommendations on the subject.
In regards to the container cost estimates, Director Howe questioned whether or not 1, 110-volt electrical outlet and 1, 4' fluorescent light would be adequate for the container. It
was decided that after the containers are delivered, if any more outlets or lighting fixtures are found to be necessary, those items can be added at that time.
Director Edwards clarified that this project is phased so that we get the driveway done, then set the containers and then go to some sort of bid process for the bathroom/shop expansion.
Chairman Butow said that is correct and that Manager Tiemann didn't want to go to bid on the bathroom/shop expansion project until the driveway contractor installed the piping to the
shop building for water and for the septic tank. Chairman Butow wondered if the light standard between the two buildings is being removed by the driveway construction contractor.
Director Parker/Director Dwight: Purchase two (2) steel containers at $3,470.00 each for
delivery at the appropriate time.
The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0.
Agenda Item #4: Status Report on tank site acquisition for surge tank #2.
Chairman Butow reported the Board did approve the rehabilitation of the existing surge tank this coming winter.
This item is to be continued to the next meeting.
Agenda Item #5: Status report on standby generator.
The Board read Manager Tiemann's written update on this topic. This item will be continued to the next Meeting.
Chairman Butow said that on a related item, during his conversation with Ross Mayfield they spoke at length about going forward with searching for Grant's to help with projects we have
in progress. He asked if the Board would entertain a motion to have Mr. Mayfield search for Grant monies for these projects?
Director Edwards said he is troubled by not having a budget or costs in mind to pass such a motion.
Chairman Butow said these projects have already been approved and passed. He provided some examples of previously approved projects that are in progress, such as the Ag Improvement
Project, which would balance the system and contribute to water conservation. He said that Ross Mayfield has indicated that this project could be eligible for Grant monies either in
combination with ag or by itself. Chairman Butow suggests the Board pursue the Grant applications to recover some money for the previously authorized projects.
Also, Ross Mayfield told Chairman Butow that there is a Grant in regards to our Eel River Project that he came across and that more details will be available in the near future.
Chairman Butow asked Director Edwards if he would agree to the Board making a request of Recovery Operations Specialty Services (R.O.S.S.) that they present a proposal as to how much
it would cost to obtain specific grants for specific projects.
Director Edwards said if R.O.S.S. is going to search for grants and not take any fees unless it is out of grant monies, he is all for it. We would not pay R.O.S.S. unless they obtained
the grant.
Chairman Butow agreed to ask Ross Mayfield to bring written proposals to the Board for consideration of costs to seek out grant monies to assist in the costs of projects in progress.
The Board would vote on each particular proposal.
Rosalind Peterson, a member of the public who arrived earlier during the Meeting, wondered about the possibility of Keith Tiemann being able to locate available grants for a much lower
cost than Ross Mayfield.
Chairman Butow said Mr. Tiemann could possibly do that, but then there is the process of grant writing. He said that Mr. Tiemann probably couldn't research as quickly as Mr. Mayfield
and that often the timing and the wording of the
grant applications are crucial. He added that Mr. Mayfield has the resources and experience and expertise in this area and that it was Keith Tiemann who brought Ross Mayfield to the
Board for his expertise.
Agenda Item #6: Consider pond circulator equipment for aquatic weed control.
Chairman Butow read Manager Tiemann's information prepared for the Board regarding this item and ordered that the item be carried forward to the September Board Meeting.
When the diver's report is available, it is to be distributed to the Board members.
Agenda Item #7: Discuss water service allocations.
Chairman Butow said that it appears that prior to the Moratorium, people reserved a number of hook-ups and paid the monthly service fee as if it was hooked-up. This is outside of the
Moratorium.
A situation has come to our attention that a customer is selling property with 11 service allocations to a developer. The developer wants to install individual services out of those
allocations.
Chairman Butow contacted Attorney Rapport about the situation and to the best of our knowledge, we are obligated to allow the property owner to install the services.
Director Parker asked if the State is aware of this situation.
Chairman Butow said the State is aware of this. The rationale behind this is that because the customers have reserved them and are paying the monthly fees, they are considered active
services. He added that at Monday's LAFCO Meeting, the allocation topic was brought up; LAFCO said they are aware of the situation and that they were contacted by the real estate agent
regarding the above mentioned property. LAFCO said these are legitimate; and, that there are water agencies up and down the State with these allocation situations. LAFCO said these
allocations are causing problems because they often go for many years, during which many physical and other factors have changed since the original time that these allocations were
allowed, before anyone decides to install them individually. LAFCO stated their new policy is that they will not approve these anymore and will do all they can to discourage the assignment
of allocations.
Director Parker said that in figuring the build-out of the plant capacity, these allocations have to be considered, at the least, as minimum users and Chairman Butow agreed and said
the 315 allocations are added to the 1100 service count, making 1415 services.
Chairman Butow then lead a discussion pertaining to the many of the possibilities of the allocations either being individually installed, or returning back to the District for reassignment,
or other scenarios that might develop.
Director Parker clarified that these allocations are separate from the hardship water service program.
Director Edwards suggested it would be appropriate to have Attorney Rapport come to the Board and explain this to us, or at least give the Board a memo describing these properties and
how we can't deny the service. Director Edwards also asked how this is any different from any other customer who has been receiving water from the District, and it was determined that
there is no difference.
The Board decided to request Attorney Rapport to discuss and advise on this matter in detail at the September 2002 Meeting and to possibly prepare a statement/public notice to be distributed
to customers and the realtors association, lenders, etc., for the disclosure obligations.
Agenda Item #8: Consider request from customer for installing two meters out of his allocation allotment.
A customer has a mobile home park with 13 allocations and only one meter and he is requesting permission to install two meters inside the park.
Chairman Butow indicated he had spoken to Attorney Rapport about this request and was advised by Attorney Rapport that the District is legally obligated to honor the allocation installation(s).
Agenda Item #9: Consider attendance at seminars offered since the last Meeting.
Dir. Dwight suggested that perhaps Secretary Groth would be interested in attending the Board Secretary Workshop in October and the other Directors encouraged her to consider the offer
and to come to the September Board Meeting with her request so that the Board can act on it.
Chairman Butow called a break in the Meeting at 8:10 P.M.
The Meeting reconvened at 8:18 P.M.
Agenda Item #10: Discuss Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District payment.
Chairman Butow reported he spoke with Attorney Minasian about the State Water Resources Control Board letter and also about the Flood Control District having returned the $15,000.00
check recently submitted by Redwood Valley. During that conversation, Attorney Minasian said that in regards to the issue of Redwood Valley taking water in the wintertime outside our
Permit, that Redwood Valley has the Place of Use to draw the water out of the lake and that the Place of Use is not limited to any particular time, we can do it 12 months out of the
year. There are issues as to whether or not the Flood Control District has the right to bill Redwood Valley for winter flow water which was just flowing through the lake when the lake
was full.
Director Parker said the whole thing speaks to whether we buy it from the Flood Control District or from the State. Chairman Butow added, or from Sonoma County.
Chairman Butow reported that Attorney Minasian said, the second thing about that issue is the fact that this was a contractual matter between Redwood Valley and the Flood Control District.
He added that whether or not Redwood Valley wanted to pay it or go to the arbitration clause and go to court, or whatever Redwood Valley decided, was not the State's right to come
in there and direct traffic between the two agencies.
Then the issue about owing the money, Attorney Minasian disagrees solely with the paragraph stating, "it is not the intent of this District to do anything other than comply with the
terms of the 1984 judgment".
He said they are not honoring the Agreement; in 2000 they went to Sonoma County Water Agency and told Randy Poole they did not like this contract. This activity does not constitute
a good-faith effort to comply with the Judgment. Attorney Minasian then itemized the three or four apparent choices as to which direction the District might choose to move at this
time. Attorney Minasian said he does not feel that Redwood Valley has been treated fairly by Russian River, at least during the time this Redwood Valley Board has been serving. Redwood
Valley has tried so many times to work through the issues with them, to try to resolve our problem of getting extra water. They indicate in this letter that Redwood Valley was going
to try to get the full 13,000 acre-feet; again, inaccurate information. We were going to try to get 4,000-4,500 acre-feet and the rest of it would benefit them, and we were going to
pay a lot more for it than we are paying now. We were willing to do that. Attorney Minasian further said there is so much misinformation in the letter and he has a hard time thinking
that the misinformation came to them from Mark Atlas.
Chairman Butow then reported on other aspects of his conversation with Attorney Minasian.
He asked Attorney Minasian, Have you or anybody you know, on behalf of Redwood Valley or the Flood Control District , been able to find out if there is any way we can go back to Sonoma
County and renegotiate this thing and get this reopened? The way we got it from Attorney Del Piero is that it is a dead issue; that they closed the door and locked it. Attorney Minasian
recommends that Redwood Valley hold off payment until the September Meeting and he will try to get to Attorney Mark Atlas one more time to discuss this. He said if Redwood Valley pays,
it is like approving the letter. For them to say Redwood Valley didn't pay in a timely manner for something that was a negotiated item 20 years after the event, just isn't right.
Director Edwards suggested we pay the summer water monies now.
Chairman Butow supported this suggestion. He said it was our original Agreement, and we should honor our end of the Agreement anyway.
Director Edwards asked for some historical information.
The Board discussed the Flood Control District billings for interest and penalties and the idea of selling surplus water when they have passed Resolution #1-83 stating they have no surplus
water.
The Board further discussed various aspects of historical interactions between the two Districts and hopeful future cooperative solutions between the two agencies.
It was agreed and reiterated that although it is surplus water, the Redwood Valley County Water District does have some water rights.
Director Edwards/Director Parker: Pay the summer usages for the period of 2000-2001 in the amount
Of $29,775.27 and for the period of 2001-2002 in the amount of
$31,982.51 and approve the cover letter as discussed.
The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0.
Director Dwight asked if it would be possible to get a joint session together with the two Boards and the response was supportive.
Director Parker/Director Howe: The cover letter to the Flood Control District is to be seen by each of
The Board Members before it is mailed.
The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0.
The Meeting was adjourned by Chairman Butow at 9:10 P.M. to reconvene at the Regular Meeting on Wednesday, September 11, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive,
Redwood Valley, California.
Approved: Board of Directors
Date:
Secretary, Board of Directors
Redwood Valley County Water District