Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-08-01 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT P. O. Box 399 Redwood Valley CA 95470 (707) 485-0679 Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:00 P.M. on August 1, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California. Directors Present: Sanford A. Dwight, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Robert F. Parker, Mark D. Edwards Directors Absent: None Staff Present: Keith Tiemann, Linda Groth Others Present: None Agenda Item #1. Hearing of comments or questions from the attending public. Chairman Butow said that when the Meeting opened, there was no public in attendance, but now members of the public have arrived and he opened the meeting to public comment, limited to three minutes per person. Rosalind Peterson said there was no one from the Redwood Valley County Water District Board at the last meeting held by the Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District this past Monday. She expressed her disappointment that Board Members did not attend. She also said the Redwood Valley County Water District is going to be on the LAFCO Agenda for Monday. Chairman Butow said the District had not received notice of that information. Ms. Peterson went on to say she takes exception to Redwood Valley County Water District spending $15,000 for Ross Mayfield and she takes exception to the high cost of all of the bills that are paid for legal fees, as well. She said she feels Redwood Valley should pay the Flood Control District for both fiscal years that they owe, and wants her feelings to be on the record. Chairman Butow thanked Ms. Peterson. Agenda Item #2: Customer request for waiver of fee increase. Chairman Butow said the Directors have a letter in the Board Meeting packet regarding Mr. Gates … Director Edwards interrupted Chairman Butow to say that Mr. Gates is a personal friend of his, and that he will not only ask to be excused from the discussion, he will leave the Board Members Table during this topic and will not participate. Chairman Butow accepted that request. Director Edwards then left the Board Members Table. Chairman Butow read Mr. Gate's letter submitted for this meeting. He asked Mr. Gates how long it was after the hardship water service connection was awarded that Mr. Gates actually hooked up the water service. Mr. Gates responded that it had been about 2 years. Chairman Butow wondered why, if the need was for a hardship, it took 2 years to hook up. There was quite a bit of discussion about the history of Mr. Gates' attempts over a period of time, to get his application for water service awarded. His point being that by the time his service was actually installed, the costs exceeded the original "estimate" for what they might be. He felt that the fees and rates that are quoted when the application is made, should "freeze" from future increases. Chairman Butow itemized that Mr. Gates delayed taking action until after the price went up on hook-ups. He asked Manager Tiemann what information he can provide. Manager Tiemann itemized and read the historical letters between the District and Mr. Gates. Director Dwight asked Manager Tiemann what kicked the costs up so high during that time. Manager Tiemann said there was a $900.00 increase in the connection fee that was in effect at the time of the installation, and the Encroachment Permit fees at the County increased by $350.00. That leaves a balance of $150.00, which could be attributed to inflation. Director Howe said the District can offer Mr. Gates a payment schedule to pay this off. Mr. Gates thanked the Board for hearing his concerns and indicated it is not necessary to enact a payment schedule. He left the Meeting at 7:30 P.M. Agenda Item #3: Approval of Consent Calendar. Financial Statement. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting. Bills Payable. Special Expenditure Fund status report. Director Parker questioned, on Consent Calendar d. Special Expenditure Fund, the first item: Funds for Securing Water Rights. What did the $53,930.92 get us? Manager Tiemann said it goes back to legal fees and litigation, of which he detailed attempts to fight the moratorium, etc. Chairman Butow asked if any of those fees went towards the Eel River? Manager Tiemann responded that they did not. Chairman Butow asked if any of those fees went towards the Flood Control District?.. Place of use or any of that? Manager Tiemann said no. He informed the Board that all the invoices are here for those details, which range from the late '80's and mid-'90's, and that the last fees on the list are almost to 1999. He added that in 1988 the Board of Directors authorized that $310,000.00 be set aside for securing water rights. Chairman Butow asked if the $53,930.92 is a portion of that $310,000.00 and if the $310,000.00 was not actually spent and Manager Tiemann confirmed. There was discussion about this item being closed at this point. The District has the Mill Creek and the Eel River Projects which are being tracked individually now. We don't want to commingle these current projects with the previous years historical efforts that those Boards were working on at that time. Director Parker said we don't want to lose the history. Chairman Butow said that now that the Board knows what is in that category; it is an old issue. He feels that attorney fees for fighting the moratorium should not be part of Funds for Securing Water Rights. Fighting the moratorium is long-gone. Director Edwards asked that if this item is closed, does that then mean we won't be spending more money? Chairman Butow said we will be spending more money but not on that category. We will be spending it on the Eel River and the Mill Creek issues, which are separate categories. Director Dwight suggested leaving that category as part of the Consent Calendar at least until the end of the year when it can be reevaluated. Director Edwards/Director Dwight: Motion to leave the item on the status report, but expand the explanation that this account for the moment is inactive, and that it reflects legal fees for the moratorium issues from 1988-1999. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Director Edwards restated his concerns from last month: He is troubled by the accumulation of expenses for fees. He said that at the last Meeting he asked for some kind of budget and some kind of status report. He cannot support projects without a budget and a status report. Chairman Butow asked which fees he is concerned with. Director Edwards said he is concerned about the fees from Recovery Operations Specialty Services. He had asked for a budget, for a cap, for a summary to be presented to the Board. He said he believes in paying our bills; but after today, he is going to be a diehard for getting a resolution to a budget and for having a cap. Director Parker added that from earlier comments from the floor, it seems apparent that the public objects and thinks we retained these people for $15,000.00, which is not the case. He said he wants to make that clear. Director Parker/Director Dwight: Motion to Approve Consent Calendar. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Agenda Item #4: Approval of Minutes of July 2, 2002. Director Parker referred to bottom of page 8, the Mill creek & Eel River projects. He explained to Manager Tiemann what Directors Parker and Edwards are asking as a history on these projects. Manager Tiemann said he has a tally sheet on each item, with invoice numbers, dates, amounts of all the invoices charged to those accounts. Director Parker said he would request a summary, not copies of invoices. A summary providing a clear picture of the project history, expenditures and status, expenditures pending and probable cost; and a projection of where those expenditures will take us. Manager Tiemann said it's probably incumbent on Ross Mayfield to put this together. Director Parker asked Mr. Mayfield if he could do that. Ross Mayfield responded, absolutely, they will work with Keith Tiemann any time after August 6th. He said the Board of Supervisors keeps moving the presentation date on their agenda but it is scheduled for August 6, 2002 at 11:00 A.M. Mr. Mayfield added that they will get Keith Tiemann everything he needs. Director Edwards said, ultimately the decision as to where we stop with expenditures is up to the Board and we need this information to help make that decision, and we would like to have it this month. Director Parker said that at the bottom of page 5 of the Minutes, the subject should be corrected to reflect Eel River, not Mill Creek. The Correction was Ordered. Director Dwight/Director Parker: Approve July 2, 2002 Minutes as Corrected. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Agenda Item #5: Consider hearing of urgent items received since the Agenda was posted. Manager Groth presented Auditor Rick Bowers Letter of Engagement for the Audit of Financial Statement F/Y ending 6/30/02. Director Dwight/Director Edwards: Hear the urgent item, Letter of Engagement from Auditor. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Upon review of the Letter of Engagement the Board took exception to the wording on page 3 concerning the fee, which appears to be open-ended. The Board requests that Manager Groth ask Mr. Bowers to revise the next to last paragraph in his letter, showing an hourly rate for each of the categories of parties involved to prepare the audit, or a statement from the auditor saying "Not To Exceed $_____". Manager Groth brought the Boards attention to a conversation she had with Attorney Rapport before he left for his vacation. From time to time, a document may arrive that requires the signature of a General Manager or an Executive Officer. Because of the reorganization of District staff by abolishing the General Manager position and establishing two new positions, the Operations & Maintenance Manager and the Office Manager, the Board of Directors needs to appoint an Executive Officer who would be authorized to sign such documents. She said that Attorney Rapport said that those types of documents will come up, and before they come up, an Executive Officer should be authorized to sign. Chairman Butow said he agrees it needs to be done but he wants to discuss the matter further with Attorney Rapport before the Board appoints an Executive Officer. Manager Groth presented the L.A.I.F. 25th Anniversary Open House, enrollment form. The registration fee to attend must be submitted by August 30, 2002. The Board discussed the invitation and decided to decline. Agenda Item #6: Directors' reports and discussion of non-action topics. Director Edwards said he wishes to discuss the State Water Resources Control Board letter of July 18, 2002 to the Redwood Valley County Water District. Chairman Butow followed this comment with an update, saying after receiving that letter, he had called Attorney Minasian's office and learned Mr. Minasian was on vacation. As a result, a law firm partner contacted Mr. Kassel at the State Water Resources Control Board and explained that Mr. Minasian was on vacation. Mr. Kassel then extended the response date to October 1, 2002. Director Edwards referred to Ms. Peterson saying earlier that the Flood Control District Meeting mentioned Redwood Valley County Water District, and he is asking about that. Chairman Butow responded that he has asked Judy Hatch for the opportunity enter into discussions and she responded that she didn't want to pay any more attorney fees in order to talk to Redwood Valley. Director Edwards pointed out that the Board has had this conversation at the previous Board Meetings and he wishes to go on record as saying he feels that Redwood Valley should pay its bill to the Flood Control District. There was further discussion regarding the wording of the bills and the disagreements of the wording of some of the billings, including charges for winter water for which the District has not been billed for, for many years. The Flood Control District later revised that billing. Director Edwards said if the bill is due, let's pay it. Let's promote goodwill between the agencies. The ultimate solution to a lot of our problems is a political solution, in the future we are all going to have to work together. If we would be willing to pay money to Sonoma County for that water, why wouldn't we pay the Flood Control District what we owe them for the water. Chairman Butow offered Director Edwards a recent history of billings, and his discussions with Attorney Minasian, and the reason for wanting to meet with the Flood Control District to discuss these billings. Director Dwight and Director Parker also brought up historical items of information regarding attempts to communicate, and the Flood Control Districts responsibilities to Redwood Valley, for Director Edwards to consider. Chairman Butow said we need to speak with our attorney again to clarify his reasoning for withholding the funds. We need to let him know the Board wishes to pay this debt. Director Edwards said we should articulate to the Flood Control District why we did what we did and not just send a check into the void. Chairman Butow responded that we did not send a check into the void. It was enclosed with a letter stating that this is a partial payment and that we want to sit down with the Russian River Flood Control District to discuss certain issues. He said that Ms. Hatch's statement to him after receiving that letter was, the Flood Control District attorney took that check and told us not to deposit it because Redwood Valley made that a conditional endorsement. Director Edwards proposed that we look forward and not backward. Chairman Butow agreed and said he wants to tell Attorney Minasian that we are going to pay the summer amount. He needs to discuss what it is that Attorney Minasian feels is the advantage we are giving away by paying the money. Chairman Butow agrees with Director Edwards that this is in the way of the two Districts sitting down and talking about what needs to be discussed. Director Dwight offered his support of the need for open lines of communications. Director Edwards said we want to pay the Russian River Flood Control District soon and we want to pay a reasonable amount. We need to request a meeting with the Flood Control District Board; and if we need more than one meeting, we need to meet as necessary to discuss the issues and to try to resolve them. Chairman Butow said he would go to those meetings. Chairman Butow announced that all the above discussion has been under the Agenda Item #6: Directors reports and discussion of non-action topics. This should have all been discussed under Agenda Item #5: Consider hearing of urgent items received since the Agenda was posted. He will attend to that right now so that the Board can vote on the directive to the Chairman to request a Special Meeting, with the full Board present, to discuss this matter. Director Dwight/Director Edwards: Motion to place the item of the Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District bill on the Agenda for tonight. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Director Dwight/Director Edwards: Motion to direct the Chairman to call a Special Meeting to have a phone conference with Attorney Minasian and to report on conversation. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Chairman Butow will get in touch with Attorney Minasian to set up a 3-way discussion to discuss paying winter water rights. AGENDA ITEM #6, continued: Director Parker asked that the Mail Log and the District Activity that are included in the Board Packet, be added to the Agenda Item of "discussion of non-action topics", so that he can make comments or ask questions about those items. He asked Manager Tiemann about an Action Alert listed on the Mail Log, urging support of legislation, and who responds to these alerts? Manager Tiemann said that usually a sample letter is enclosed, which would be presented to the Board for action. Director Parker referred to an entry in the Mail Log from Mendocino County Water Agency last June. Manager Tiemann said that what Director Parker is looking at is a letter from Mendocino County Water Agency to all the agencies in the county, urging them to submit a list of projects. He further explained that Sonoma County Water Agency had a similar request, to which the District responded and that the Mendocino County Water Agency request and the Sonoma County Water Agency request are two separate items, and that we did not respond to the Mendocino County Water Agency request. Chairman Butow directed the Secretary to add the Managers' Report of District Activity to the Consent Calendar as item #e. The Mail Log is to be added to the Consent Calendar as item #f. Agenda Item #7: Consider merit increase for Michael McBride. Manager Tiemann said Michael McBride was given a merit increase of 2% three months ago, contingent upon a 90-day evaluation for making improvement in certain areas. He said that those improvements have been made and at this time he is recommending that the remaining 3% be given. Director Dwight/Director Parker: The remaining 3% of a 5% merit increase be awarded to Michael McBride based on his performance and improvement as reported by Manager Tiemann. The Motion passed by a vote of 5-0. Chairman Butow called a break in the Meeting at 8:55 P.M. The Meeting reconvened at 9:07 P.M. Agenda Item #8: Status Report on the Eel River Project. Chairman Butow introduced Ross Mayfield and Dallas Miller, representing Recovery Operations Specialty Services, and turned the meeting over to Mr. Mayfield, who handed out a packet to the Board members. Mr. Mayfield said the July 18, 2002 meeting had a very good turn-out including the water agencies, and 90% of the Indian tribes. He added that the Board of Supervisors was represented by Supervisor Delbar. Director Parker asked who invited all the above? Mr. Mayfield responded that Recovery Operations Specialty Services invited them. Mr. Mayfield said that a lot of people attended this meeting that had not attended other meetings. He then handed a packet to Ms. Peterson, a member of the attending public, for her reference. Mr. Mayfield explained the pie charts and historical data. Dallas Miller added they had consulted a 15-year study, a 50-year study and an 88-year study. Ross Mayfield said at the July 10, 2002 meeting, the representatives of the Willits Environmental Center brought out the 1984 Wild & Scenic Rivers Code. He said his firm has a newer Wild & Scenic Rivers Code and we shared that with him. It has 3 categories: Wild, and then Scenic, and then Recreational. Our use would be recreational and Mr. Mayfield listed historical high, intense use of the water, the riprap & railroad switchyard and the area we are talking about. He showed a map showing what was Recreational, what was Scenic, and what was Wild. Dallas Miller provided additional details of the packet enclosures. Director Dwight asked if the environmental group was taking a blocking posture at the meeting or did they seem to be understanding of our position? Mr. Mayfield said they are blocking; the outcome in our discussion, the environmentalist was talking from his heart, not how the document actually read. Mr. Mayfield asked him to consider talking about the document as it reads and not how he wished it read. Director Dwight said then, that a third party would be needed to help open the local view of the project. Mr. Mayfield said that David Drell of the Willits Environmental Center even hammered home a solution: There is no solution. Other than to have no more people, and not do anything else to go forward. Chairman Butow added that Mr. Drell made an offensive statement to the Native Americans there. He said that at that point, many of the attendees got up and left the meeting. Dallas Miller said that R.O.S.S. called the State Water Resources Control Board. The State said, based upon the application on the Wild & Scenic Rivers, especially on the Eel, that water can be used for irrigation, industrial and recreational. Ross Mayfield said that we are canvassing support for a feasibility study to get all these questions and concerns answered; whether it is environmentally sound or not. Chairman Butow added that whatever we said, the Willits Environmental Center said the opposite. Mr. Mayfield said one of the other issues they quoted was in regards to the flushing effect of the Eel River, the basic factor that it needs to be able to flush itself out. They quoted some document out of Canada. He asked for a copy of that and they haven't provided it. R.O.S.S. is searching for it, to see exactly what they are talking about because then we could turn around address their concerns. So you can see, that, again would come out in the feasibility study. Mr. Mayfield said they are continuing with meetings with other tribes and organizations. More and more people are interested in getting involved in this and they are presenting letters of support to their Boards for approval and signature. We are actively, aggressively pursuing getting funding for bond and grant money. Director Dwight asked what we are looking for with the Board of Supervisors. Chairman Butow said the Board of Supervisors wants to modify the resolution somewhat. Mr. Mayfield reported that Supervisor Delbar said that if you can get everybody's positive support, he would take it all the way to Washington, D.C. He wants us to give him a call to meet with him before the presentation is made to the Board of Supervisors. Rosalind Peterson asked where all this water would be stored? Ross Mayfield responded that all of that would be taken care of in the feasibility study. He then provided her with several potential sites. He said the purpose of the feasibility study is to address those issues. Mr. Mayfield said that it's really a well-designed vision to work for the whole county. It would take one-and-a-half to two years to get the study prepared. He added that Mendocino County, county-wide, really has no water rights. This is the best-case scenario; it's a functional, operational system. It can't be built all at one time; it has an overall beneficial use. Director Parker added that not only is it a County-wide solution, it bonds the County together. Mr. Mayfield said we are not stating that anything we're saying here is definitely going to happen. We are going for a feasibility study. It has to go to the State Water Resources Control Board. There are environmental procedures; there are steps to go through. We don't know what the outcome will be, but we have to go through those steps, to file and see what the outcome will be. We have done the steps that are required. We have contacted 38 agencies with forms of letters of support to present to their Boards. Director Edwards commented that with 38 agencies county-wide, it would seem that it would be necessary to create a county-wide agency. Mr. Mayfield said this is something the whole group is going to have to iron out with the Board of Supervisors. First we need a resolution letter of support and the next thing would be the list. We only provide the information and we don't tell the agencies what they have to do; that's up to them. He added that the Mendocino County Water Agency is set up as a working office and it would seem to be the best possibility. Mendocino County Water Agency is really taking an active roll in the water needs of the County. Mr. Mayfield reiterated that it still has to be the overall group, an advisory council of all the groups to make sure the lead agency does what the groups want to do, There was a great deal of discussion throughout this status report. The Board has made it clear they cannot be the lead agency for the county. Ross Mayfield continued through the pages of the packet and an invitation to the total agencies involved to attend the Board of Supervisors Meeting of August 6, 2002. Chairman Butow said he wants to list the budget and goals: Get this whole thing to a feasibility study. Once the Board of Supervisors meeting is established, we will need to follow up. Hopefully, Jim Stretch of the Mendocino County Water Agency will step in. The Board of Supervisors probably expects some more follow-up from us. We have the support of various agencies, we may have to spend some more money to get to the point of passing the torch, so to speak. We need to continue going at this in a first class manner, that is, as professionally as possible. In the past 22 years, no Board has worked as hard as this Board to find water. Chairman Butow added that it's too bad that several years ago we gave $275,000 to Russian River Flood Control District to be part of that District and to date we have gotten nothing from that money. Director Edwards suggested putting out a budget, and the Redwood Valley County Water District Board will say how much it will do and then we ask other agencies for monetary support. Agenda Item #9: Status report on the Mill creek Project. Ross Mayfield said that at the same time he met with Redwood Valley Rancheria, he found full support for the Mill Creek Dams. There is a great deal of interest from the tribes in the area and they are looking forward to further discussions. Dallas Miller said they had had good meetings with Jim Stretch at the Mendocino County Water Agency. There was further discussion on the subject. Rosalind Peterson offered her opinions of the Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District's approach on this topic. Ross Mayfield answered Ms. Petersons comments and questions and gave her some of his calculations as to how this could actually be done, and listed the agencies he had spoken with and how they had looked at all the possibilities of what could go wrong, and addressed them. He then reminded her that we have not reached the negotiations stage yet but many scenario's are very encouraging and workable. Dallas Miller added that the Corps of Engineers was very cooperative and helpful in working up a draft. Chairman Butow included that there are many avenues that are being considered and it is very encouraging. Mr. Mayfield said there are other issues that will come up, but if everyone involved was willing to come to an agreement, there are ways it can be worked out. Mr. Mayfield also emphasized that Redwood Valley County Water District is a County agency; Mendocino County Water Agency is a County agency and that the water up there is Mendocino County water. Dallas Miller added that there are also two or three alternative methods, other than wheeling through the Flood Control District. Chairman Butow said we are leading to the feasibility study. We are aggressively pursuing water. We will explore avenues to get water. Chairman Butow thanked Ross Mayfield and Dallas Miller for their professionalism; he added that he has always been proud to show up with them and he is looking forward to the Board of Supervisors Meeting. Ross Mayfield and Dallas Miller left the Meeting at 10:20 P.M. Director Dwight suggested that due to the lateness of the hour, the remaining Agenda Items be carried forward to a Continued Regular Meeting. Director Dwight/Director Parker: Continue this Meeting to 7:00 P.M. on August 7, 2002 to finish up the Agenda Item Numbers 10-17. The Motion carried by a vote of 5-0. The Meeting was adjourned by Chairman Butow at 10:24 P.M. to reconvene at the Continued Regular Meeting on Wednesday, August 7, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California. Approved: Board of Directors Date: Secretary, Board of Directors Redwood Valley County Water District