HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-07-18 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
Redwood Valley County Water District, Continued Meeting Minutes
Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:02 P.M. on July 18, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Directors Present: Robert F. Parker, Donald E. Butow, William E. Howe
Directors Absent: Sanford A. Dwight, Mark D. Edwards
Staff Present: Keith Tiemann, Linda Groth
Others Present: Tom Yokoi
Chairman Butow announced this is a Continuation of the Regular Meeting of July 2, 2002, and, at that Meeting the Board felt there were some items that could not be touched on during
the absence of Manager Tiemann or Mr. Yokoi, both of whom are present tonight.
Chairman Butow suggested that since there is no public in attendance at this time, the Meeting could go into Closed Session to accommodate Mr. Yokoi. Mr. Yokoi indicated that would
be agreeable with him.
The Meeting went into Closed Session at 7:05 P.M.
Agenda Item #2: Closed Session: Tank site acquisition for Surge Tank #2
Conference with Real Property Negotiator, Government Code Section 54956.8.
Property: Mendocino County A.P. #168-080-07
Agency Negotiator: Keith Tiemann
Negotiating Parties: Richard Larned
Under Negotiation: Price and terms of payment.
The Meeting returned to Open Session at 7:38 P.M.
Chairman Butow announced the Board has decided to take no action at this time, on this subject.
Agenda Item #3: Discussion and possible action concerning bids for Surge Tank #2.
Chairman Butow said the Board will decline action concerning bids for Surge Tank #2.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Motion to go ahead with rehabilitation of Surge Tank #1.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Director Dwight and Director Edwards absent.
Chairman Butow asked Mr. Yokoi if there was anything else he needed to discuss before leaving the Meeting.
Mr. Yokoi said that Manager Tiemann has informed him that one of the clarifiers needs a new interior coating. This is a facility that would be shut down in the winter and it would make
a lot of sense, on an economic scale, to do this in conjunction with the rehabilitation of Surge Tank #1.
Chairman Butow said that now that we've decided to go forward with rehabilitating the Surge Tank, this is a good suggestion. He asked if we would need a new estimate.
Mr. Yokoi said we would need a new bid. This is a good opportunity to get both projects done during the winter.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Motion to put out a single bid package for the combined project of
rehabilitating Surge Tank #1 and recoating the interior of one of the
clarifiers.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Director Dwight and Director Edwards absent.
Manager Tiemann asked if Mr. Yokoi is authorized to get the bid process going now.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Motion to amend the previous Motion and to authorize Tom Yokoi
to proceed immediately in putting this project out to bid
for work to be done this winter.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Director Dwight and Director Edwards absent.
Agenda Item #6: Consider tabulation of bids for Coyote Valley Indian Reservation main extension and recommendation by Brelje & Race for award of contract.
Mr. Yokoi said he believes this item wasn't addressed at the last meeting because there were some questions and there was no one available to answer them.
Chairman Butow said he believes Director Edwards had some questions at that time. He said that the bid tabulation looks pretty straight-forward; there was some question as to the contractor
who supplied the lowest bid.
Mr. Yokoi mentioned his cover letter attached to the bid tabulation. The contractor has not yet done work for Brelje & Race, so Mr. Yokoi said he called a number of references and all
indicated that the contractor did a very good job, they were reliable, they got to work on time, and they did good quality work. They would recommend to anybody, to have Groundhog
do the work. One reference was a contractor, another was a mutual water company, and two were vineyards, so there were three different jobs that were all pleased with their work.
The Directors and staff reviewed notes from the July 2 meeting and asked Director Howe what he meant when he said we need to come up with a good contract.
Director Howe said he was comparing this to the Bel Arbres contract where we are still dealing with some issues to this day.
Manager Tiemann said the contract in effect with Coyote Valley Indian Reservation is a contract from a previous Board.
Chairman Butow said this appears pretty straightforward. He asked Manager Tiemann to confirm that the District gets reimbursed by the Reservation; we put it out to bid, we have it built
and they pay for it all.
Manager Tiemann confirmed.
Tom Yokoi said the actual bids are lower than the engineers estimates. He mentioned that a couple of days after the July 2, 2002 Meeting, Groundhog Construction called for the bid results
and was informed that the matter had been continued to this Meeting.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Motion to award contract for the main extension at Coyote Valley
Indian Reservation to Groundhog Construction in the amount of
$45,350.00.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Director Dwight and Director Edwards absent.
Tom Yokoi left the meeting at 7:40 P.M.
Agenda Item #4: Status report and consider acceptance of easement documents and Resolution approving withdrawal of Lis Pendens for property on Road C.
Manager Groth distributed to each Board Member the packets containing the documents required for the partial release of lis pendens for the property on Road C as was previously discussed
at the June 6, 2002 Meeting, including the proposed Resolution No. 02-4.
Chairman Butow read aloud the July 2, 2002 cover letter from Attorney Rapports office instructing the action to be taken by the Board.
Manager Groth clarified that there are three assessor parcels affected and that Mr. Rapport's office had been informed by the Title company that the parties involved had already signed
their documents, which are now in escrow pending the Board's acceptance, and that Mr. Rapport's office said the Board could go forward with approval of the Resolution.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Motion to pass Resolution 02-4 approving partial withdrawal of lis
pendens on property on Road C as presented. The Chairman of the
Board of Directors is approved to be the authorized signer of the
Acceptances of the easements.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Director Dwight and Director Edwards absent.
Agenda Item #5: Status report and consider acceptance of easement documents and Resolution approving withdrawal of Lis Pendens for property on Road B.
Manager Tiemann said there is a property owner who is selling property on Road B that has a district transmission line easement going through it and the lis pendens on the property is
clouding the title for the sale of the property. He said Attorney Rapports office has provided the documents for the purpose of clearing the title and that the Board can follow along
as he describes the documents. He then described in detail each of the documents and the necessary steps to follow at this Meeting and also the follow-up that he and the Board Secretary
will have to attend to tomorrow.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Motion to accept the Grant of Easement for Pipelines for the Sorby
property on Road B and also to pass a Resolution for the
Partial Withdrawal of Lis Pendens; and, that the Chairman of the
Board of Directors be authorized to sign the required documents.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Director Dwight and Director Edwards absent.
Manager Tiemann had Chairman Butow sign the documents, including Resolution No. 02-5 at this time.
Agenda Item #7: Status report for the shop expansion project and container cost estimates.
Chairman Butow said the Board did review the estimate that Keith Tiemann had provided for the July 2, 2002 Meeting and that Director Edwards suggested that at least one or two more estimates
be submitted. Chairman Butow stated that Director Edwards mentioned that his relative had purchased a used storage unit from the local Hertz company and that it was delivered in excellent
condition. So, Director Edwards suggested we find out what is available from Hertz. Chairman Butow added that the Aztec list that Manager Tiemann provided seemed fairly reasonable
and that he didn't see anything really wrong with it, but there might be something else that the Board should be looking at.
Manager Tiemann clarified that what he provided is not a bid. It is an ad that came across his desk and he called the company to get a price list, which was included to the Board.
He added that he called Hertz today and they don't have any brochure or any printed information on the units. They have used units that are 8x20 & 8x40 which the top price is $1,600
for the 8x20 and it goes down from there depending on the condition. With the 8x40, the top price is $2,600 and it goes down from there, depending on the condition.
Chairman Butow asked how that compares with the information Manager Tiemann had on hand.
Manager Tiemann responded that the 20' container from Aztec is $1,995 and the 40' container is $2,395. He added the Aztec containers come with a fresh coat of paint and some modifications
and he said he doesn't know if the Hertz prices include modifications.
The Board entered into a lengthy discussion about sources of availability and the container modifications that the District might need and indicated they would want units in the best
condition possible, with the modifications included, and that the most the District should actually have to add would be the locks for the units.
Director Parker said that from what he concludes from this discussion is that the Hertz outlet has these storage units as a surplus sideline and that for Aztec, it is their business.
He then asked where Aztec is located.
Manager Tiemann said it is located at French Camp.
Director Parker asked what Keith Tiemann's thoughts are about ordering 2 containers, one for the shop and one for the office.
Manager Tiemann said he sees no reason for units larger than 20'.
Director Parker asked if a traveling agent might be available?
Manager Tiemann said he can check, but that he doubts they have an agent on the road. He then referred the Directors to the brochure he had provided for a previous meeting and said
it shows several combinations of options, and that the options to be selected will depend on what the Board wants and how much they want to spend.
Director Parker asked Manager Tiemann if he could go through the brochure and pick and choose the items that he wants.
Manager Tiemann responded that this topic is the committee's idea and he doesn't want to have any input for fear of racking up $950.00 for a double locking door and then finding out
that's not what the Board wants. He doesn't want to be responsible for details and improvements.
Chairman Butow directed Director Parker and Manager Tiemann to work up the final container modifications list and the price list and get that information back to the Board for the August
meeting.
Director Howe suggested asking Aztec if there is a price break for ordering more than 1 or 2 containers, which would also give the Board something to consider.
Agenda Item #8: Report on Manager Tiemann's acceptance of new job description and which of two titles he preferred.
Chairman Butow said the Board had requested that he make up a new job description and hand it to Keith Tiemann covering items discussed in committee; he reported that he had given it
to Keith Tiemann the other day. He said if Keith had any issues with the job description, he should bring them up at this Board meeting and if there are no issues to discuss, to go
ahead and sign the document. He then asked Keith Tiemann if he had had a chance to review the new job list and if he had any issues to discuss.
Keith Tiemann responded that he has no problem with the list. He mentioned that there are a number of job description items that have changed since seeing the list that was discussed
in committee, but for the most part…
Chairman Butow asked if he can be specific.
Keith Tiemann said that a number of the items, such as #11 say "and report as a summary to the Board each month". He said that the State Health Department receives summary reports each
month and he is asking if the Board wants to receive copies of those summary reports. He said he is not sure what the Board is asking for.
Director Howe said what they were looking for is a quick draft of what goes out.
Director Parker added that on #11 for example, if the District received modified regulations from the State Health Department and they are now on file, perhaps a bullet chart similar
to a monthly activity report could be submitted.
Keith Tiemann questioned in detail other item numbers that had the phrase "and report to the Board in summary" added. He said that he is not used to doing this type of report now, and
he's not sure he will remember to do so in the future.
Director Howe said they are not looking for any lengthy report, and Chairman Butow agreed.
There was further discussion about determining the type of reports the Board is expecting.
Director Parker said that he wasn't trying to bring on a overload, his intention is to just avoid any surprises. After this discussion he would be willing to have Keith use his judgment
in determining what the Board needs or would want to know about what has come in and what action was taken and where it stands at the time of the report.
Keith Tiemann said he is still trying to get an idea what they want, because it's pretty broadly based.
Chairman Butow said that Keith needs flexibility. There will be overlap items that may not pertain to Keith's desk. The Board wants to keep it smooth.
Director Parker suggested that on Items #11, #12, #16, #30, delete the phrase "and report to the Board in summary". Director Parker then said, Just remember, Keith, if you have any
problems, or any surprises, or any inspections or anything like that, it should be entered in your Status Report. And if there is anything that you feel that should be done, we want
you to bring that to our attention.
Chairman Butow said on Items #11, #12, #16, #30 we will initial our copies of the job descriptions here tonight with the removal of "and report to the Board in summary".
Chairman Butow then initialed his copy with the changes and Keith Tiemann did the same.
Director Parker asked which job title had been selected.
Keith Tiemann said it makes no difference.
Chairman Butow offered to leave it as it is or to change it.
Keith Tiemann said he doesn't care.
Chairman Butow, Director Parker and Director Howe then agreed the title would be Operations & Maintenance Manager.
Chairman Butow said he would like the record to show Keith Tiemann has accepted the new position of Operations & Maintenance Manager for the District, as described, effective July 16,
2002. He offered Keith Tiemann to sign the agreement at this time. He then directed that the signed agreement be placed in the personnel file.
Further comments, other topics:
Director Parker asked if the District has made any donations in the past, to the Water Education Foundation.
Manager Tiemann answered that the District never had.
Director Parker urged the Members and staff to look up the website, which is filled with a great amount of information.
Manager Tiemann indicated the Water Education Foundation does send the District a magazine.
Director Parker then brought up the District's letter to the Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District with a partial payment. He said he
felt the content was somewhat objectionable.
Director Butow responded that the letter corresponded with Attorney Minasian's input.
The Meeting was adjourned by Chairman Butow at 8:30 P.M. to reconvene at the next Regular Meeting on Thursday, August 1, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive,
Redwood Valley, California.
Approved: Board of Directors
Date:
Secretary, Board of Directors
Redwood Valley County Water District