HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-06-14 RVCWD Minutes SpecialREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. BOX 399
REDWOOD VALLEY CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
Redwood Valley County Water District, Special Meeting Minutes
Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:00 P.M. on Friday, June 14, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Directors Present: Robert F. Parker, Sanford A. Dwight, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe
Directors Absent: Mark D. Edwards
Staff Present: Linda Groth
Others Present: Paula Berezay
Chairman Butow announced this is a Special Meeting. The topic before the Board is in regards to creating three new positions and he handed out the lists of job descriptions stating
that these are the final revised editions of the positions of Office Manager, Assistant Office Manager and Plant & Field Manager. It has been suggested that we consider an alternate
title for the Plant & Field Manager, that being the Operations & Maintenance Manager. It seems to make sense, because when attending meetings or classes this seems to be the job title
more used in the industry. He said this item could be discussed later.
Chairman Butow: Since Ms. Groth and Ms. Berezay are in attendance tonight, why don't we go ahead and discuss the Office Manager job description and then the Assistant Office Manager
job description, and see if there are any questions.
Director Dwight: Can you give us a minute here.
Chairman Butow: Why certainly, why don't you read it over and we'll just go ahead –
Dir. Parker: While we're reading it over, I would like to have you think about the answers to this question but do not answer it now. We will get back to it later. Is this reorganization
going to increase stress or decrease it among the employees of Redwood Valley County Water District? That is my question.
Director Howe: Just for your information, the subcommittee sat down with Linda Groth and went over the previous list, we added her comments to this list, and arrived at the Office Manager
job description. She also provided us with Paula's duties as well as some more duties Paula will be getting from Linda's desk because of Linda's increased duties.
Director Parker: Has this been run by Keith Tiemann?
Director Howe/Chairman Butow: Yes.
Chairman Butow: In fact, he was present at both meetings, he sat and monitored what Linda had submitted.
Director Howe: He had a lot of comments.
Chairman Butow: He did originally, and we embodied those comments in our previously revised descriptions. But with Linda's job description, he sat and monitored what Linda discussed.
These lists are a result of our subcommittee meeting on this past Monday.
Director Parker: In general, if I may ask, what was Keith Tiemann's reaction to Office Manager and the Plant & Field Manager changes?
Chairman Butow: Fine. He said it's fine. He's fine with it.
Director Parker: But do you sense any hostility? Or more hostility, or less hostility?
Director Dwight: I feel we are getting into closed session topics. I feel we should just go over the job descriptions handed us first, and dot the I's and cross the T's at this time
and review the lists until we are all comfortable with them. Then later in the meeting if we feel there are some difficulties, we can discuss any concerns and lay them on the table
and really clarify those issues.
Chairman Butow: Right. William and I and Linda walked away from this past Monday's meeting feeling comfortable; because Keith was there and he didn't display a hostile attitude or
that he was unhappy, he didn't indicate anything but that he wants to go forward.
Director Howe: At the previous meeting he indicated he wanted to implement the changes immediately.
Chairman Butow: Right, but we wanted to wait until we went over the list with Linda and that was this past Monday and it ended on a very positive note. Then William and I adjourned
down to my place and we hammered out more stuff until we got to a good place and here we are. Just ask us any questions about any of this.
Director Dwight: I think we all ought to look at this over a period of time; we need to give it time to take shape, to give it time to work out the wrinkles.
Director Howe: It will be implemented now, and we will see what changes are needed as time goes by.
Director Parker: At the same time, if we vote on this tonight, and it goes forward –
Chairman Butow: We would like it to go forward, they would like it to go forward -
Director Parker: But from meeting to meeting if something needs to be changed, if Linda feels that it should be changed, it can be changed.
Chairman Butow: Yes, there are going to be modifications.
Director Howe: There will be issues that arise that will need to be resolved. There will be questions that arise as to who's responsibility is it and we will need to address those
issues.
Chairman Butow: We don't have a crystal ball but the remark was made on Monday when Keith was here and there was a brief discussion as to a situation arising when they didn't know which
employee would do what; they might need to come to the Board and say, this isn't working out because it would be better if Keith did this, or that Linda did this, or that Paula did
this. Now, Paula and Linda – as far as the office detail is concerned, there is going to be some adjustment until the bugs are worked out. Now, it's going be between Keith and Linda
on some of these almost co-op duties, if you will.
Director Parker: I think there are a lot of those items.
Chairman Butow: They both agree to that. If they can't work it out, they will come to the Board for clarification.
Director Parker: That's good, because after all, it's still going to be one staff. I mean, there might be five people involved, but it is still one staff. There are an awful lot of
things they have to do together and everything they do has to be done with cooperation.
Director Dwight: I think there are things that have to be weighed in the future, such as Linda's workload. I think the committee has done an awful lot of work on this and the Board
appreciates all the work and we are going to accept what you are saying in full merit and good faith, what your take is on this. But I think we have to weigh if Paula and Linda feel
they are comfortable with this, because it is locked in.
Ms. Groth, Director Howe, Chairman Butow, Director Parker: No.
Ms.Groth: The Board has just said, that even from meeting to meeting, if something comes up -
Director Dwight: OK, you know yourself, with your own level of expertise; myself, I wouldn't feel comfortable with high level accounting or maybe personnel matters or something.
Ms. Berezay: There is one thing that needs to be started soon. The auditor is coming in for the general ledger on July 1st.
Chairman Butow: To start training.
Ms. Berezay: Yes, because the general ledger needs to begin July 1st. If Linda and I, I am going to be taking the training on it also because if Linda is out on vacation or for sick
leave, I will need to know how to do it. But I don't think Keith is going to be learning it because it is going to be transferring over to a new system, so it has to start on July
1st. That part does.
Director Dwight: We need built-in continuity here. We need to keep cross-trained, to share things, but Keith may not have shared before. Keith has to do his share, to share with you,
because there is a lot of osmosis that is going to have to take place here for this to work.
Director Parker: I assume, Mr. Chairman, that the intention is that we vote on this tonight.
Chairman Butow: We would like to entertain a motion. May I offer that we take a break in the meeting at this time to allow Director Parker and Director Dwight to read this over and
then we will come back into session once you have had a chance to read it quietly, and then you will have some questions or modifications which we can discuss later.
Director Dwight: I see you have recommended wage adjustments for two of the staff involved. Are you planning to discuss this tonight?
Chairman Butow: Yes, we would like to address the whole package tonight if at all possible, particularly the Office and Assistant Office duties because those employees are here tonight.
Chairman Butow adjourned the Meeting until 7:17 P.M. to allow the Board Members to review the information at hand.
Chairman Butow reconvened the Meeting at 7:30 P.M. after a break to allow Director Dwight and Director Parker to review the job descriptions of Office Manager, Assistant Office Manager
and Operations & Maintenance Manager. He stated the Meeting can proceed with discussion of the recommendations of Director Howe and Director Butow regarding the new positions of Office
Manager and Assistant Office Manager and the Meeting is now open to suggestions.
Director Dwight: I suggest we take the positions one at a time, by the item numbers as listed.
Chairman Butow: That is a great suggestion. Do you have any problems with that, Director Parker?
Director Parker: No.
Chairman Butow: OK, I will start with Item #1. Any objections? Item #2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #12?
Director Parker: Item #12, "Prepare annual job evaluations of office staff." add: and submit evaluation to Board for action.
Chairman Butow: Item #13, #14, #15, #16, #17, #18, #19, #20, #21?
Director Parker: What is the difference between #21 & #18?
Chairman Butow: Oops, it appears as a duplicate item.
Director Dwight: Should something else have been entered there that didn't get on the list?
Director Howe: No. I had so many lists to go on that items listed jumped around on me, it is simply a duplicate entry.
Director Dwight: We will delete the duplicate entry, Item #21.
Director Howe: O.K., it's just an error.
Chairman Butow: Item #22, 23, 24?
Director Parker: Items #23, & #24. I would like summary reports of those items presented to the Board. I checked off items which I would like summary reports of those items presented
to the Board.
Director Butow: Item #25. Schedule water service installations.
Director Parker: I'm sure that’s not Linda's responsibility – I'm sure it has to be in conjunction, does it not, with Keith?
Ms. Groth: It's not mine. I would not be scheduling water service installations.
Chairman Butow: That should be dropped and given to Keith?
Ms. Groth: Yes. That is definitely a field operation.
Director Howe: When somebody comes in, and you take their application & money, do you hand it over to Keith to schedule the work and crews?
Ms. Groth: Well, this is all new in a sense, because Keith has handled this in the past. He is the one, basically. Paula & I have done it; in years past we would take their request
for an installation, and perhaps their Application Deposit and forward the information to Keith.
The first thing that occurs, their first conversation with us is for us to determine whether or not they are within the District; and if they want domestic or irrigation water. We have
to determine if there is a transmission pipeline available in front of their property. And then, of course now there are so many things to establish, with the moratorium, that they
can only get a hardship water service connection if they qualify, but Keith has to talk to them about where the meter would be set and all of those types of things.
Chairman Butow: Now if someone came into the office for a water service -
Ms. Groth: Do you mean and brand new water service, or are you talking about someone just moving into a house that already has water service?
Chairman Butow: A brand new installation. If we didn't have a moratorium, someone came to you in the office for a service, you would give them information, etc.
Ms. Groth: We would go over the criteria to determine if they are eligible for water service.
Chairman Butow: You would go over the criteria, and then you would turn it over to Keith.
Ms. Groth: Yes, because he would then have to calculate figures for a form we call an Installation Cost Estimate to provide to the customer in order for them to determine if they want
to pay that kind of money for a service.
Chairman Butow: Of course, we now have a hardship situation. But after the Board would approve the application, then you would have to turn it over to Mr. Tiemann who would have to
go out on site and he would determine a best figure for the cost estimate.
Ms. Groth: Well, a lot of all that, because of all of his years of experience, he doesn't really have to go out on site each time to calculate the installation cost estimate. It would
be his decision as to whether or not he needed to go out on site.
Chairman Butow: But he would develop the cost estimate.
Ms. Groth: Yes, he would be doing the job of developing the cost estimate.
Chairman Butow: And then, if costs are over or under we let them know.
Ms. Groth: Yes, they sign a paragraph Statement acknowledging that the deposit is totally an estimate and that actual costs might be higher or lower than the deposit. When actual costs
are known, they will either receive a refund or a request for the additional funds. Then they decide whether or not they want to participate.
Chairman Butow: How do we want to word Item #25? Receive water service installation application upon completion of documents and forward information to Field Manager for further action.
Director Parker: You can take the application.
Chairman Butow: She would be the first contact.
Ms. Groth: Yes. Before I would take the application I would need to determine whether or not the service could be provided. If they are requesting a service that would be subject
to a hardship application, all that criteria would need to be addressed.
Chairman Butow: Let's just say, Receive water service installation application and refer it to Field Manager for further action.
Chairman Butow: Item #26.
Director Parker: Comment. That, too, has to be in concert with Keith, I think; I don't know how you say that, "in conjunction with Keith". There will be areas that overlap between
the two Managers.
Ms. Groth: Yes. There are areas, such as water quality, that I turn over to Keith.
Director Parker: Well, you'll learn which topics you can handle and which would be turned over to Keith.
Chairman Butow: Basically, what's happening here if somebody comes in with a complaint, such as they were charged too much or the meter was read wrong, or something like that, you would
have to get in touch with Keith to see what happened. Then, if something arises that can't be resolved, then you would bring the item before the Board.
Chairman Butow: Item #27. You would have to work out an insurance claim procedure based upon what our carrier wants, then submit the paperwork to the insurance company.
Item #28: This can be combined with Item #27. This could simply say, handle insurance claims.
Director Dwight: Is she going to have to do some fact-finding in conjunction with this duty?
Chairman Butow: No, the insurance carriers have a certain way they want claims handled. What you do is just call the insurance carrier and they give you a format to follow, and you
can't go wrong.
The last thing you want to do is get involved with the claim. No one is qualified for that except at the carriers office.
Ms. Berezay: Does this also apply to employee insurance claims? Or workers' comp claims?
Chairman Butow: Well, this pertains to District liabilities. Why don't we just combine things and just say, insurance claims of the District?
Director Dwight: O.K., when you get to Item #30, I have a question.
Chairman Butow: O.K. Item #29.
Item #30 - Supervise the work of office staff.
Director Dwight: Who is going to do the interviewing or screening of prospective new employees? Is it going to be her sole and exclusive responsibility for that, or is it going to
go to committee? Doing character checks, employment history? Do you feel comfortable with that?
Ms. Groth: The only thing I can foresee where this description would apply to the Office Manager would be for an applicant for work within these four walls, the office. I would have
nothing to do with plant and field operation at all. It would only be if Paula or I needed more staff. I would approach the Board for permission to hire.
Director Dwight: So, the Plant Manager would responsible for that field, and you would do the screening for the office.
Ms. Groth: Yes.
Director Dwight: I would like to put in conjunction with that, "Any prospective employees are brought before the Board for approval".
Director Howe: Do you think that would be necessary for temporary hires?
Director Dwight: Well I think that could be handled differently. But on long-term hires I would like to put that in: that either the Office Manager or the Plant and Field Manager
bring their final choice to the Board for final approval. If you say "yes" on a prospective applicant, you bring it before the Board.
Ms. Groth: That should be no problem.
Director Dwight: O.K.
Chairman Butow: So, on #30A you could put -
Director Howe: On any prospective permanent new hires you go to the Board of Directors for final approval.
Chairman Butow: O.K.
Item #31: Refer any unresolvable employee, customer or public problems to the Board of Directors.
Director Parker: There can be urgent items, or some can wait until the Board Meeting. If it's an urgent matter, it should brought to the Chairman or the Vice-Chair. This gives her
a line to follow.
Item #32: Review all work orders completed by office staff.
Ms. Groth: In subcommittee, we were talking about the fact that work orders are basically a field-type procedure that eventually comes into this part of the office after they have been
performed. At that point office staff determines whether we apply that information to the customers account or if we just file the completed work order away.
Chairman Butow: How should we word that? Review all work orders completed by staff?
Director Howe: Review all work?
Ms. Berezay: I think Linda is talking about the field work orders and requests for moving in or out. After the reads are taken, it comes back to us for closing bills, etc.
Chairman Butow: So, the "reviewing" refers to the completed field orders and Linda would review it and then give to Paula to post. So just leave those words, because that's what is
meant here by work orders.
Ms. Groth: It could be left the way it is; Paula is quite experienced and capable. Certainly whenever we have any questions we talk to each other.
Chairman Butow: The thing is, too, you are both cross-trained to the point where either one of you can jump in and get it done.
Ms. Berezay: Yes.
Ms. Groth: Yes.
Chairman Butow: When you come in, in the mornings it's a matter of who starts posting and the other person just starts on something else.
Ms. Berezay: Yes.
Ms. Groth: Right.
Chairman Butow: We have a sort of an odd situation where we have two such senior employees with this much experience and we are fortunate.
Ms. Groth: You know, you could just say "Process all work orders". Don't say completed by office staff.
Ms. Berezay: Just say Process.
Ms. Groth: Because when we process them, we are reviewing them and if something is missing, we have to get our answer.
Chairman Butow: All right. Process all work orders.
Item #33: Be ultimately responsible to the District Board of Directors for all office operations.
This would go into that little monthly status report that an issue was resolved.
Director Parker: Unless urgent.
Director Howe: Problems - customer complaints.
Chairman Butow: Yes, and that would also be included in the monthly statement. We spent 20 minutes on a $5.00 complaint and it gets back to me that the customer is still unhappy.
He feels insulted. That's what we want to change. We want to improve our communications with the community – and you two can do that very easily.
Director Howe: And it can mostly be resolved without having to pay our Attorney to sit here and evaluate it.
Chairman Butow: Item #35 – Any Brown Act complaints are processed through R.V.C.W.D.'s attorney, Mr. David Rapport.
Director Dwight: It should go to the Chairman first and if he can handle it and short-stop it before to goes to the attorney; if Mr. Rapport has to be called in, then -
Chairman Butow: She has to have the authority to go to Attorney Rapport. Her instincts are good. Then she can report it later.
Director Parker: Yes, if her instincts tell her to call Attorney Rapport, she should do so.
Director Howe: We'll say she should go to the Chairman first, or the Vice-Chairman second, and if neither one is available, then contact R.V.C.W.D.'s attorney.
Director Dwight: I wish to interject an Item #36. I need a lot of help with a newsletter for mailing. I need someone to help with all it takes to get a newsletter out quarterly.
Chairman Butow: We have to think about any communications to the public.
Director Dwight: Well everything needs to go by the Board first, but I need cooperation.
Director Parker: Cooperate with various Board members on communication needs.
Director Dwight: I will work up my rough draft and run it by the Chairman. But then it goes to the office staff for preparations and to become a completed document to mail to our customers.
We'll need to keep track of costs; I don't want that to get out of hand.
Chairman Butow: No, but what we're doing right now is setting up a description so that if someone comes on the Board and gets this responsibility, we can just show that person this
list as a guideline and then there would be no surprises.
Director Dwight: Is Linda allowed overtime?
Director Howe: Both employees will be working full-time, with full-time benefits.
Chairman Butow: Overtime is earned as necessary.
Director Parker: Are Meetings overtime?
Director Butow: Yes, Linda will be attending Board Meetings and making minutes of those meetings, and she could very easily run into overtime if it exceeds a 40-hour week.
Ms. Groth: During Keith's review and comments of the job descriptions, he requested that all items on the Agenda pertaining to areas of his job assignments be listed early, (just as
those relating to Attorney Rapport's are listed early so that Attorney Rapport can leave the meeting after those topics have been discussed). He said he would like to leave the Meeting
after his related topics have been discussed.
Director Parker: That won't do. I want Keith available through the meetings. There are occasional questions that come up during a discussion, of which I want him available to answer
quick questions, or clarify here or there.
Is Keith getting overtime to attend Meetings?
Chairman Butow: He's charging us for it, you bet.
Director Dwight: I can see midnight oil with this job.
Ms. Groth: It's different, because he is salaried and that's part of his job.
Chairman Butow: Well, he is and he isn't. He's on salary, but he is charging the District if you look on his time sheet.
Director Parker: He's charging for taking notes at the Board Meetings?
Chairman Butow: I don't know what he's charging for, it's confusing to me.
Ms. Groth: No, his overtime is if he works more than 8 hours daily, or if he is on call. I would think that before you say that, you need to look at his timesheets for Board days,
or ask him if he is charging overtime for Meetings. I thought the Employee's Handbook stated that salaried employees have a job to do for that salary, and they don't get overtime.
Chairman Butow: You see, that is one of the many things that started this. I was looking at his paycheck and it lists an hourly wage, that he's getting paid also.
Director Howe: We offered him exempt status and he refused it.
Chairman Butow: That's correct. He didn't want that, he wanted the overtime.
Director Parker: So, we don't have any exempt employees.
Chairman Butow: No. When Linda comes up with more than 8-hours a day or 40 hours a week, she earns overtime.
Director Parker: And if she has to transcribe Minutes on her own time simply because her office work keeps her too busy to get to it at the office, she has to charge overtime.
Chairman Butow: And we have to trust her, that she will charge us.
Director Parker: And if we see excessive overtime, we will ask about it. Is her workload too much? Should we hire someone else?
Ms. Groth: That makes sense.
Chairman Butow: If we don't talk about this now, sometimes feelings or misunderstandings can happen. It pays to spell it out.
Director Parker: So we are going to 8 hour days? Or 7 hour days?
Director Howe: Once we agree on it, I can add it to the list.
Director Parker: Full hours with full benefits.
Ms. Groth: I'd like to share that in my comments to the subcommittee I mentioned that the District is very fortunate to have the employee on staff who has been handling the tasks that
are being transferred, by the Board's wishes, to an Office Manager position. On items that I have questions about, I can talk to Keith and ask how it should be done. I will be in
a learning phase on many of these items for a few months. I want to let you know that the Board has come to us asking us to consider these things, and we have considered them and accept
the Boards wishes; we will do these tasks to the best of our capabilities. Hand-in-hand with that is the wonderful attitude of the Board that "we will be willing to help you in any
way that we can". We are all learning. Paula and I have years of experience in certain job skills and office duties and we are willing to expand our value to ourselves and to the
District. It will obviously be a transitional, learning time for the next few months. A transitional time in which we have already suggested in a few comments throughout the Meeting
so far – we may find things that show us that a job can be handled much better, more competently with a different change and perhaps it should be looked at again.
Director Parker: Do you have any problem going to Keith and asking him about a task he used to do? Will tensions be alleviated or increased?
Ms. Groth: I don't anticipate any problems with this. Everybody is on the same page. We want to see this work.
Director Parker: O.K., fine.
Director Dwight: Again, it's like a machine. The gears are going to move slowly at first. If you need help in any area, call us. Communications are the key.
Chairman Butow: We are going to be the grease to make this work.
Director Dwight: If in a year, it's not working and you want to change this, you can come to us.
Chairman Butow: I want to modify that: Don't wait a year. You come to us immediately if it's not working, you come to the Board.
Ms. Groth: The subcommitee has made that very clear. It is all for the betterment of the District. It is to support the instituting of these changes. If we have problems, we come
to you.
Director Parker: We are available any time.
Director Dwight: Come to us.
Chairman Butow: Don't wait if something requires attention.
Director Howe: Call us.
Chairman Butow: Mark Edwards commented that the valley is unhappy with the District. This is their District; everybody up here running the show, we are their employees. You ladies
have the right attitude in dealing with the public. You have people skills to relate to the customers.
Chairman Butow: Now, on to the Assistant Manager Job Description.
Item #1? OK. Item #2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8?
Director Parker: Item #8. What is the change drawer?
Ms. Berezay: It is for providing change to customers.
Director Dwight: You keep change, petty cash, etc.
Ms. Groth: Petty cash is a different matter.
Chairman Butow: Oh; there is something else – petty cash. This is a drawer for change for the customers. Does Paula also do the petty cash?
Ms. Groth: No, I do.
Director Parker: Have you been over this list, Paula?
Berezay: Yes, I have.
Director Parker: Any surprises? Anything missing here?
Ms. Berezay: Well, there are some things that I do, that aren't on this list and that's fine. The main thing I'm concerned about here – and we'll see how it goes after a while – after
we're both on for 8 hours; because we have been working more than 6 hours a day and we're quite busy.
Chairman Butow: Your are on such a learning phase, you're spending more than those 6 hours.
Ms. Berezay: Yes; and then Linda will have more responsibility and I will get more of hers, so as long as we can get it done -
Director Howe: Keep this listing handy, so you can add to it. Let me know so I can update these lists.
Ms. Berezay: O.K.
Butow: Item #9. Item #10, #11, #12, #13?
Director Dwight: Item #13, Close customer accounts. I would like to add "and refer the delinquent accounts to Office Manager for collection."
Ms. Berezay: Actually, I do the delinquent accounts.
Director Parker: Oh, you do. How do you handle them?
Ms. Berezay: I do them on the computer and they are printed and sent on a post card billing and then in 9 days I give a "doorhanger" list to Keith and he goes -
Director Dwight: OK, I'm going down the wrong road here.
Director Howe: So, "Close customers accounts" is for customers moving out.
Ms. Berezay: Yes and that is part of the work orders.
Chairman Butow: Item #14. William Howe is our personnel type on the Board and is anxious to get the description fine-tuned.
Director Parker: If you find you're doing different functions, let him know so he can change the list.
Ms. Groth: Well, the question of Petty Cash has come up. I have that responsibility.
Chairman Butow: Let's just add an item #: Reconcile and maintain the petty cash fund.
Director Howe: That will be Item #21 on the Office Manager list.
Director Parker: Do you keep a certain amount in the petty cash fund?
Ms. Groth: The Board gave us authority to maintain $50.00 in the fund.
Director Parker: So you use that for coffee and filters, etc.
Ms. Groth: Also for nuts, bolts, etc. Sometimes the field staff has to pick up something at the hardware store or the parts shop. Or we might need to pay postage on a large item or
-
Ms. Berezay: Or go to the dumps.
Director Parker: Right. Whenever we need immediate cash.
Ms. Groth: Yes, and on the List of Bills Paid, under Petty Cash, it lists all the items that were purchased since the last time, up to the $50.00 limit.
Chairman Butow: If the limit amount needs to be increased because of inflation, just come to us and request an increase.
Chairman Butow: Now we have the proposed Wage Adjustments for New Jobs. We have listed a starting wage for these positions. The way the County does, is they list a beginning and a
cap. We have not put in a cap.
Parker: Do you have a beginning?
Butow: We do, the proposed amount is $16.50 per hour for the Office Manager and $13.50 per hour for the Assistant Office Manager. They have new responsibilities. We did bounce around
a couple of top end caps but we didn't write them down.
Director Parker: I don't think we should.
Chairman Butow: We don't have to. It is customary in public agencies to list an opening with a wage scale, depending on experience.
Director Dwight: Leave it as it is.
Director Parker: Just leave it; it will be subject to review.
Chairman Butow: We will review it after the first 6 months and then it becomes annual after that. We are treating them just like new hires in that sense right now. After a 6 month
review, we will determine what we want to increase at that time, then we go semi-annual and then a year after that. So in a sense, they get a 6 month review.
Director Parker: I would like that.
Director Howe: When is your annual review?
Ms. Groth: We haven't had annual reviews since, perhaps, a year or 2 after our last merit increase. I would have to look in our personnel files. If the review has to be discussed
with the employee, then that's a fair guess as to the last review; if there are other reviews, we don't know about them.
Chairman Butow: We can leave this open.
Director Dwight: We can leave this as an open agenda item.
Chairman Butow: We have a bottom dollar end already established. If we advertise and there are new applicants for these positions, the new Boards can -
Director Dwight: You might want to check uptown with like positions to compare. Perhaps a survey, to come up with wage suggestions at your reviews.
Director Parker: What are the ladies' comments?
Ms. Berezay: Let's say Open to Review, where we discuss it later, that would be okay.
Director Parker: I sense, Paula, that you are sensitive to some issues with this.
Ms. Berezay: Well, I want to see how it goes later. For right now, it's fine. I just hope we can do it in the amount of time – in 40 hours per week. Because we won't know that until
we get into it.
Chairman Butow: You ladies will be really busy.
Director Parker: If there are problems with the work loads, you don't have to wait 6 months to talk to us about it. You can bring that up any time.
Chairman Butow: It will take 6 months to a year, I imagine, for this to work itself out and to get the budget worked and the sharp edges worked out. I don't see any reason as long
as we're all trusted with this attitude; this is our starting spot. We are changing the hours to 8-hours.
Director Dwight: You might want to consider someone in the office with advanced computer skills, etc., and that would give the ladies the time they need for other tasks.
Ms. Berezay: Most of our tasks are on the computer.
Director Dwight: If you find yourself tied up over here with other things -
Ms. Berezay: We have a lot of work right now.
Ms. Groth: But we haven't been working 8-hours per day.
Ms. Berezay: I'm starting vacation Monday. Last February when Linda was on 3 weeks vacation, it was hard. I didn't have enough hours in a day. I was swamped. This coming Monday,
I'm going on 2 weeks vacation, but I'm coming in on Monday because of the deadline workload.
Director Parker: Those things are always going to be occurring. I was talking earlier to somebody else about these suggested changes and the only comment I got was, Well, you're going
to need more help in the office. If you people feel that way as time goes on, say it. Say you're bogged down.
Chairman Butow: I could see this happening. In a way we are victims of our own success. We've got two employees here that are long-term and have racked up a lot of vacation time.
There are large amounts of time to use. I saw this happen with Paula when Linda was gone. She was working like crazy. So, when you're both here and there is time to do the jobs,
that's one thing. But when one is out, I might suggest that you get someone in for a couple of hours a day or 20-hours a week or
something, to get them broken in so they could step in when someone is on vacation. Right now, it's not going to work because you'd be going crazy trying to train someone. You've got
to do it when you're both here and you can make the time to train. I'm glad that Sandy Dwight and Bob Parker brought this up. So, think about it. When Paula gets back from vacation
you ladies will have to implement this and we are open for suggestions. We on the Board come from business offices and we're familiar with what it takes to have a smoothly running
office. Maybe you'll be able to find someone who could be on-call.
Director Parker: The hourly wage is a good increase, compounded by 8 hours per day. It should help the bottom line on your paycheck. Is that a welcome thing or do you just not need
the extra work?
Ms. Berezay: Eight hours is fine.
Ms. Groth: I'd like to give it a try and I'd like to see it work. I don't know how we could do the tasks you've asked us to do, to deal with the public, and not be here 8 hours per
day. William was just asking how the hours would be structured. I'm thinking of talking to Paula about the options of a ½ hour lunch and 8A-4:30P or 8:30A-5:00P. We'd still be 8
hours.
Chairman Butow: You will be the Office Manager; you work it out. We will go along with your suggestions.
Ms. Groth: I'm sure the Board wishes to continue its directive to have the office open through the lunch hour.
Chairman Butow: Oh, yes. Because so many people have to make a mad dash on their lunch hours to get a payment made to avoid getting their water turned off.
Ms. Groth: Yes.
Director Dwight: I don't think a ½ hour lunch break is enough in an 8-hour day.
Director Parker: It's up to them to see how it works.
Chairman Butow: It's the Office Manager's job to decide that. Okay: It's 8 hours per day; 40 hours per week with full benefits.
Director Howe: We don't want their salaries to start from scratch. They have years of service without raises other than cost-of-living; we are respecting that.
Chairman Butow: We don't want them to give up their longevity appreciation bonuses.
Director Parker: Oh, you're stating that because a new hire would not get the longevity appreciation until after so many years.
Director Howe: Yes.
Chairman Butow: What are our intentions for this to start? This pay period ends the 15th, and Paula has stated that the computer training for general ledger starts July 1st. I would
entertain a Motion that we make these new positions effective tomorrow.
Director Parker: So move.
Director Howe: Start these positions on the 16th of June, 2002.
Chairman Butow: All in favor?
AYES: Parker, Dwight, Howe, Butow
NOES: None
ABSTAIN: None
ABSENT: Edwards
Director Parker: To clarify, the new positions means Salary Rates and the different Hourly Rates.
Chairman Butow: Yes.
Director Howe: Exactly.
Director Dwight: Right.
Director Parker: O.K.
Chairman Butow: The Motion is So Moved.
Director Howe: We have the next topic, Operations & Maintenance Manager now.
Chairman Butow: Do we go to Operations & Maintenance Manager now?
Director Parker: That's why we're here.
Chairman Butow: But it is Keith's job, do we want to go forward with this?
Director Howe: I have no problem with it.
Director Parker: Sure.
Chairman Butow: Alright. The only thing we will have missing are his further comments; he can do that later.
Director Parker: He has reviewed this and you have tried to incorporate his comments?
Director Howe: Yes.
Chairman Butow: We sat down with Keith and Linda when he reviewed his list first and we got his comments.
Director Parker: O.K.
Chairman Butow: The next item on the Agenda is Plant & Field Manager.
Director Howe: I'd like to go back and call it the Operations & Maintenance Manager.
Director Butow: O.K.
Director Parker: How did that come about?
Director Butow: Dave Wallen thought of that as the more appropriate name of the position throughout the industry.
Director Parker: Have you run that term Operations & Maintenance Manager past Keith?
Chairman Butow: Not yet.
Director Parker: Well, run it past him and see if he agrees.
Director Howe: O.K. I'll put it in here.
Director Parker: I think that it's more descriptive and it is accepted in the industry.
Chairman Butow: We weren't aware what to call it when we were working this up. But we will get back to him on it.
Director Dwight: Have you discussed a salary adjustment for Keith?
Chairman Butow: We have the situation where we have taken away a lot of his duties, but at the same time -
Director Dwight: I think you should get his input on it.
Director Howe: We will. We want to discuss it.
Director Dwight: It's a bilateral agreement. Let him propose the amount and take his suggestion before the Board. I think the understanding that his O/T will be considerably less
in the coming year, based on the discussion the other night -
Director Howe: This is going on the tape.
Director Butow: I think the matter before the Board is do we let him maintain his same income level, with much less duties and responsibilities or do we freeze it in place because now
he is earning more than the reduced duties warrant? We would not suffer any loss on this but we do expect him to work very heavily on the various projects we have out there, and utilize
his expertise at that end. I'm just throwing these things out as thoughts. As Sandy pointed out, this is a very sensitive issue. We have a fellow now that’s going in reverse of where
these two office staff have gone, we are reducing his responsibilities.
Director Parker: I disagree. We have clarified his responsibilities.
Chairman Butow: Yes, we have.
Director Parker: I think that a lot of these responsibilities that he has taken on, have been by default. I think the fault is with the Board. I think he has accepted and taken responsibilities
that the Board has passed on. He has also, because he didn't have guidance from the Board, he has imposed himself on the office staff. Like he said to me directly, Nothing comes into
the office or goes out of the office that I don't see. He said, Frankly, I would be relieved of doing that. He's a typical, square-headed engineer in that respect, he is a control
freak, like a lot of us are. Nothing can be unseen. He has to be all-knowing, all-seeing and so-on and he doesn't like that. I think, frankly, that you'll see a significantly different
man, in his attitude and also in his job performance and his willingness to help us with these other ancilliary budgets like the Eel River or Mill Creek or whatever. And I think that
eventually we will see a better working staff, with better relationships between the office and the operations with the Board. This isn't three completely different things. It's still
the Board and still the District and the same staff with just a little more tightly defined responsibilities and authority. I think that with his experience and the experience that
these people have, we are going to benefit very nicely.
Director Dwight: I like your comments.
Director Parker: And, I don't think Keith is overpaid for the tasks that we are asking him to do. I think these ladies were underpaid for what we asked them to do.
Chairman Butow: That's right.
Director Parker: I think we've corrected that, or at least tried to, and I don't think Keith is overpaid for what he had been doing or what he will be doing.
Director Howe: I like your positive aspect. I would like to see it happen that way; I hope it heads that direction. I have felt that he has just been sitting there letting us flounder
and not adding to the discussions in helping the Board of Directors guide this District where it needs to go.
Director Parker: In a lot of ways; not just this personnel thing. We all agree with that.
Director Dwight: You're getting into personalities there.
Director Parker: You bet we are.
Chairman Butow: When I made this decision to go forward with this job reallocation, I realized Keith might get upset and leave. I do have a back-up if necessary, although he has encouraged
the Board to try and keep Keith on staff because his history and knowledge of projects, etc., are so valuable to the District. However, he is a Class IV water treatment plant operator
and if Keith decides to leave, we have a back-up. If Keith stays on, I agree with you, if we give Keith an opportunity, we can see this thing work out.
Director Dwight: I'd like to see this take shape. Bob Parker has shared some good ideas and so has Don Butow.
Chairman Butow: I think we've gone about as far as we can go in open session. I will entertain a motion that we change Keith's job description as reviewed this evening to the Operations
& Maintenace Manager and that his wage will not change.
Director Howe: Let's talk to Keith about changing his title to Operations & Maintenance Manager.
Chairman Butow: We will say that hours and wages will be left in place and I will consult with him on whether he wishes to be Plant & Field Manager or if he prefers Operations & Maintenance
Manager.
Director Dwight: Excellent.
Director Parker: That's good.
Director Dwight: Treat him with respect, that he has done the job to the best of his abilities and confined to the restrictions of his background. Treat him as an adult and ask what
he wishes to do. I think we are being more than generous with his salary but I think he deserves respect for his years of service here, and let him come back to you on these questions.
Director Howe: O.K.
Director Butow: I'd like to clarify that he has already agreed to his job description. The only question to resolve tonight is his salary. On several occasions he has said, I want
to go forward with this.
Director Howe: At our last scheduled Board Meeting, he wanted to go ahead and start this right away, immediately, without further ado.
Director Dwight: I think you've handled this very well.
Director Parker: Nothing is going to happen overnight, if it doesn't work out, we'll change it.
Director Butow: When he returns we'll tell him the Board has accepted the committee recommendations and we are looking forward to him working in an accelerated manner to get all these
projects done; and that his salary has not changed. I'll entertain a Motion so stating.
Director Parker: Exactly.
Parker/Dwight: Motion made. Motion Seconded.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4 – 0.
Director Edwards absent.
Chairman Butow: I will entertain a Motion to adjourn the Meeting.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Motion made. Motion Seconded.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4 – 0.
Director Edwards absent.
The Meeting was adjourned at 9:30 P.M. to reconvene at the next Regular Meeting to be held at 7:00 P.M. on Tuesday, July 2, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley,
California.
Approved: Board of Directors
Date: July 2, 2002
Secretary, Board of Directors
Redwood Valley County Water District
Job Descriptions are attached hereto
And are made a part hereof.