Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-05-30 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT P. O. Box 399 Redwood Valley CA 59470 (707) 485-0679 Redwood Valley County Water District, Meeting Minutes Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:08 P.M. on May 30, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California. Directors Present: Robert F. Parker, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe Directors Absent: Sanford A. Dwight, Mark D. Edwards Staff Present: Keith Tiemann, Paul Minasian Others Present: Ross Mayfield, Dallas Miller Agenda Item #1 – Hearing of comments or questions from the attending public. There were none. Agenda Item #2 – Discussion of Water Rights Procedures regarding State Hospital dam sites. Attorney Minasian summarized the water rights process regarding the State Hospital dam sites. He explained that there exist physical structures on County property and there are legal and historical arguments that there is a pre-1914 water right and that an appropriative right filing was not necessary. To use either water right, the District has to get physical access to the site. The first thing to do is try to get an agreement with the County for right of access. Ross Mayfield said he thinks the Mendocino County Water Agency will end up negotiating for the County in a hand-off from County Building and Grounds. Attorney Minasian said we should start negotiating for access even before we know if the project is feasible. The question is how much money does the District want to commit to this and what does it want to propose. If the project is feasible, you'll be able to utilize the site in return for maintenance costs on the dam. That is no-risk as the District will not expend any money until it knows it has a feasible project. When it is determined to be a feasible project and you have the water right, go back to 2002 and see how much money the County has spent on the dam and reservoir and offer to compensate the County for that period of time. Chairman Butow says that Ross Mayfield has looked at costs in anticipation to know how much the District might be expected to pay. Attorney Minasian made sure the District was not planning to compensate the County for last year's costs. Chairman Butow said they were only using those figures as an indication of what the District might offer to pay in the future. Attorney Minasian cautioned the Board against paying for all operational and maintenance costs of the dams before it is found out if the project is feasible. Director Parker said the District would not agree to that proposal. Attorney Minasian asked if the Board wanted Ross Mayfield and Dallas Miller, or Chairman Butow, to make an opening offer to the County and draft up an agreement. Chairman Butow thinks the County is ready to talk about this now. Director Parker asked why the District needs access to the dams. Attorney Minasian explained that to get the water right, the District has to have a contract or a condemnation action which says that the District has the right to operate the dams and take water out of the dams and transport it to wherever it is going to be used. You can't get the water right until you have the legal right of access. If you don't have access and you are ready for a water right hearing, they will take it off the calendar and will not give you a water right hearing. Attorney Minasian said he will make a recommendation to the Board that you make an offer to the County with no money and the District will pursue the water right, and, if it works, we'll reimburse the County back to 2002 for all operational, maintenance and repair costs and will pay those costs in the future and the County gets to use the dams and reservoirs for swimming and recreation. He said that offer would not represent a lot of money to the County and they may come back with a counter offer. Attorney Minasian asked if the Board thought that was too cheap an offer. He wanted to hear from the other two Board members about what they thought of that offer. Attorney Minasian said that if the County acted uninterested in that offer, Ross and Dallas should ask what they would be interested in. Ross Mayfield said the County costs are about $11,000 per year which breaks down to $2.20 per acre foot for the water compared to what the District pays the Flood Control District now. Manager Tiemann was asked what the District pays to the Flood Control District and he said it is $12 - $15 per acre foot. Manager Tiemann asked Attorney Minasian if he was looking for a motion from the Board for that opening negotiating position. He said that depends on what this specific Board wants. He said some Boards want to authorize its negotiator with a specific proposal and want it voted on so the negotiator doesn't get accused of giving away the store. He asked if the Board wants to put it in a motion. Chairman Butow said he would like to have a motion to have him open negotiations with the County of Mendocino with regards to access to the dams while the District pursues the water right. Director Parker/Director Howe: Chairman Butow be authorized to open negotiations with the County of Mendocino with no terms defined. The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0. Attorney Minasian stressed again that the issue of access to the dams has to be resolved first before anything else. He said if the County agrees to access, the District will have a gold-bonded contract. But to spend the money on water rights depending on the County to remember what they agreed to back in 2002 would not work. Attorney Minasian then explained the water rights process that will be pursued once an agreement for access is obtained. He said Ross and Dallas have a filing and they have finalized some of the figures of the filing and the State Water Resources Control Board engineers are helping them figure out what 100% of the capacity of the dams would be. Ross Mayfield interrupted to suggest that Attorney Minasian put some clause in the agreement that would allow the District to take advantage of some grant funding, should it become available while negotiations are underway, so the District would not lose an opportunity for funding. Attorney Minasian agreed to provide such a mechanism in the agreement. Attorney Minasian went on to say he doesn't want the District to spend a lot of money on processing the water right or pursuing physically building this project because the water rights are real iffy. He said the District needs to keep its eye on the ball which is obtaining a long-term, reliable water supply. He said water rights on the Russian River are generally not granted except in some years from December 1 to December 30 and March 1 to April 1, and that isn't going to do us much good. We have to get out of the category of someone who is applying for water rights like the 300 other applicants that already exist on the Russian River that are ahead of us. Ross and Dallas have carried this pretty far. The State Board is going to put the filing in a notice and the District will have to pay a publication bill and all water rights holders will be notified. The District will get dozens of protests. At that point, we will see if the State Board will take the District out of the category of just another appropriator. He wants to keep costs to a minimum from a lawyer and staff point of view until it is known if they will take us out of that category. That can't be done until the protests are received. He said the State Board is fast about putting the notices out to protest, but they are really slow when it comes to saying the District is the lead agency and directing them to do a CEQA study. They are also really slow about scheduling the hearings. He said the hearings are scheduled for five applicants in Sonoma County and the hearings have been postponed for six months. He thinks it will be a year before the hearing process is over. He said it will be longer than that to do the CEQA study. He said you don't want to spend $75,000 - $100,000 on a CEQA study unless you knew they were going to give you a permit to take water at least 4 or 5 months of the year. He doesn't think it will be a year around permit. Chairman Butow said he thought it would be a year around permit because that was what was delivered to the State Hospital with the pre-1914 water right. Attorney Minasian said to get that, they would have to claim the pre-1914 right which gives them the priority of 1914. That might be a year around right. He said that also means they would have to drop the appropriative right they have on file and go for a pre-1914 filing. That is a matter of claiming a right which is subject to court approval, not the State Board. Chairman Butow asked if the District could just offer to buy the water from the County and have the County keep its right. Attorney Minasian said that if there is a pre-1914 right out there, it is owned by the owner of the land, which is the County. He said there will be a paragraph in the agreement that gives whatever form or nature of rights which exist to the District. Director Dwight arrived at 7:31 P.M. Dallas Miller said that the State Water Resources Control Board staff told him he would be filing for a new water right and not a pre-1914 water right. Attorney Minasian confirmed that because it had not been used for 5 years it could be argued to be lost. Dallas Miller said he was confused because the water had been used year around by the State Hospital and he had been led to believe they were applying for a year around right and not just for part of the year. Attorney Minasian explained that the District application has a priority date of 2002. It is junior to all applications, all riparian rights and all pre-1914 rights up and down the Russian River. The person with the oldest right gets the first water and the most junior are the first cut off when there is no more water available. He said the State Board has issued an edict that says no water is available in the Russian River except during those periods in December and March in some normal years. In drought years, there is no water to be appropriated. He said the State Board will file the water right application and say it will give you a water right in December and March unless you are in a different category. County of origin is a different category that has been used by the Flood Control District. That could possibly be used to get a year around right, but it is not likely. When the State Board engineer says that you can get so much water through a pipe, he is simply quantifying a year around right, which cannot be issued to Redwood Valley unless it falls into a special category. Dallas Miller said that this is a water source that has fallen through the cracks and it is unknown to everyone. Attorney Minasian said that all the downstream water rights holders have an expectation and right to uninterrupted flow from even the Mill Creek dams. Dallas Miller said he presented it to the State Board as a pre-1914 water right that has been abandoned and the State Board engineers encouraged him to file an appropriative right on that water. Attorney Minasian said Dallas did nothing wrong. He suggests seeing what the State Board will do with what he has done. Ross Mayfield said Attorney Minasian was giving a worst case scenario and Attorney Minasian countered that he was giving a probable case scenario. The worst case scenario is to spend $50,000 and get nothing. Ross Mayfield suggested that the District negotiate something with the County and then the District could drop the appropriative right application and re-instate the County's pre-1914 right. Attorney Minasian explained that the State Board loves to kill pre-1914 rights because they are not on paper and not subject to State Board jurisdiction. They are always telling people that if they are not used for five years, they are lost. He said that is a legal principle, but it can be interpreted two ways. There is no clear precedent in this issue. The State Board will tell you that if a pre-1914 right is not used in five years, it is lost. He doesn’t want the District to have to go to the Supreme Court to get a pre-1914 water right in this case. Ross Mayfield explained again that it is only the goal to preserve the right for the County and to buy the water that the District needs from that right. He says they had to file the water rights application to keep someone else, like Sonoma County Water Agency, from filing on it and the County losing it. Attorney Minasian said he would rather see the District go the pre-1914 route if he thought they could win it. You don't have to complete and EIR and you don't have to go through any bureaucratic procedure. If other water rights holders through the State Board recognize the pre-1914 right, all you have to do is change the place of use to include Redwood Valley and you are done. That is a perfect world. He can't recommend an investment of $2 million in pipeline based on a theory. He has to get a judge to say that is right. He said it was not wrong to file an appropriative right. He said the State Board may say they have to give it to the District because there is no hydraulic continuity, they are in the county of origin and maybe it is a pre-1914 right. When and if they can get that piece of paper, they don't have to go to court. Dallas Miller said that the intent of filing the appropriative right was to give the District some kind of negotiating position. Without the application, there is no basis for negotiating. Chairman Butow said they now have something to discuss with the County in case they want to see the water rights application go away. Attorney Minasian warned to not give up much, if any, cash in the negotiation, because this filing is a flier and very risky. Ross Mayfield asked if it would be better to say we want the County to keep its pre-1914 right and try to buy water from them. Attorney Minasian said we are going to get both. We are going to get the right of access and the right to pursue our new water right filing and we're going to use catch-all language that any consumptive water right that they hold or that their predecessors held are part of the deal. Dallas Miller expressed concern that if the District accepted responsibility for maintenance of the dams and they were found to have major flaws, requiring expensive repairs, the District shouldn't get saddled with those costs. Attorney Minasian said that when the District has its pipeline and the flow has to be regulated by the water level in the reservoir, the District has to be willing to pay for 100% of the maintenance costs of the dam. Chairman Butow said the District should attempt to only buy the water and let the County retain responsibility for operation, maintenance and repair of the dams so the District is not responsible for large infrastructure repairs. Attorney Minasian said if you ever get someone who is in charge of swimming and boating to pay a water provider for maintaining the dam, call him up because he wants to see that. Agenda Item #3 – Closed Session. Conference with Real Property Negotiator, Government Code Section 54956l.8. Identification of property and entity. The interest in real property is the potential presence of pre-1914 water rights for the dams at the former State Hospital, and the owner of those dams is the County of Mendocino. Went into closed session at 8:00 P.M. Remained in closed session for the following agenda items: Agenda Item #4 – Closed Session: Pending Litigation: Government Code Section 54956.9(a). Complaint of Rosalind Peterson to State Water Resources Control Board. Agenda Item #5 – Closed Session: Significant Exposure to Litigation: Government Code Section 54956.9(b)1: Russian River Improvement District Stipulated Judgment/Billings. Agenda Item #6 – Closed Session: Significant Exposure to Litigation: Government Code Section 54956.9(b)1, balance owed to Bureau of Reclamation upon P.L. 984 Loan. Returned to open session at 9:45 P.M. It was announced by Chairman Butow that no action was taken on Agenda Item #3. The Board received legal direction from staff on how to proceed. Regarding Agenda Item #4, Director Dwight/Director Howe: Chairman Butow be authorized to sign the response letter to the State Water Resources Control Board as prepared by legal counsel. The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0. Regarding Agenda Item #5, Director Parker/Director Howe: A payment of $15,000.00 be made on account to the Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District with the conditions discussed. Director Parker read from previous Minutes which authorized the payment of summer water use along with conditions. It was noted that the current Motion modifies the action taken at the Board Meeting of May 2, 2002. The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0. Director Parker/Director Howe: Chairman Butow be authorized to send a letter accompanying the $15,000 check with modification suggested by Manager Tiemann and Director Dwight. Passed by a vote of 4-0. Regarding Agenda Item #6, no action was taken. Agenda Item #7 – Discussion of application for Extension of State Water Resources Control Board Permit prior to December 31, 2002 expiration. Director Parker/Director Howe: Attorney Minasian is authorized to prepare a request for an extension of time to State Water Resources Control Board for the District's winter water right. The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0. Attorney Minasian advised the Board that they are starting to turn down requests for extensions of time at the State Water Resources Control Board. Ross Mayfield asked the Board to authorize a letter to the Corps of Engineers regarding the Mill Creek Dams. The Board went back into closed session at 9:53 P.M. under Agenda Item #3. The Board came out of closed session at 9:58 P.M. and announced the following action: Director Dwight/Director Howe: Chairman Butow be authorized to send a letter to the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers regarding use of Mill Creek Dams water out of Lake Mendocino. The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0. The Meeting was adjourned by Chairman Butow at 9:58 P.M. to reconvene at the next regular Meeting on June 6, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California. Approved: Board of Directors Date: Secretary, Board of Directors Redwood Valley County Water District