HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-04-09 RVCWD Minutes SpecialREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
Redwood Valley County Water District, Special Meeting
Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:06 P.M. on Tuesday, April 9, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Directors Present: Sanford A. Dwight, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe
Directors Absent: Robert F. Parker
Staff Present: Linda Groth
Others Present: Ross Mayfield, Dallas Miller
Agenda Item #1 – Hearing of comments or questions from the attending public.
No public was in attendance.
Agenda Item #2 – Discuss the possible use of a Mendocino County Water Right.
Chairman Butow announced that this Special Meeting is called to discuss a single issue, that being the Mill Creek Dams and the water rights thereof. He said the sub-committee of himself
and Director Parker are in support of the findings of Mr. Ross Mayfield, the board appointed contractor in the District's search for water rights, and his associate, Mr. Dallas Miller.
The purpose of this Meeting is to provide a status report to the full Board of Directors for their information and support.
Ross Mayfield distributed information packets as he began describing the packet contents. He indicated they include some information on Lake Mendocino's size and capacity and also that
of two other sites that are public dams.
Chairman Butow asked if these were the Mill Creek dams.
Mr. Mayfield confirmed that they are called the Mill Creek dams and that many years ago they were called the Talmage dams. He said there are actually three dams which had been owned
by the State Hospital, including their water rights. They are located on Mill Creek Road up the canyon and are actually an 85-acre-foot dam, a 25 acre-foot dam and a diversion dam
down at the bottom of the canyon which is really small. If it was empty it would hold approximately a half-acre-foot.
Dallas Miller confirmed that approximation.
Ross Mayfield said the #1 dam is the half-acre-foot diversion dam, which is just a pick-up point. The #2 dam is called the middle dam which is 25 acre-feet and the #3 dam is called
the upper dam and is 85 acre-feet.
Chairman Butow asked if that is the maximum storage acres and Mr. Mayfield said yes. Chairman Butow asked if that maximum storage takes in any sedimentation or if it is the original
design.
Mr. Mayfield said that is the original design.
Chairman Butow stated that we don't know what the actual capacity will end up being, but that is the original design.
Ross Mayfield said that in doing his research with Dallas Miller and Keith Tiemann, who also helped with the research, they learned that the dams are presently owned by the Mendocino
County Buildings & Grounds Department.
Chairman Butow commented that when the State took the property back, they sold off the hospital property but retained the dams and the water rights and transferred those over to the
County of Mendocino.
Mr. Mayfield confirmed, and said the history and how that transaction was traded is shown in his informational packet distributed earlier in the meeting. He then continued his itemization
of the packet contents, as follows:
The history and status report.
The Application for Water which was submitted in Sacramento last week.
The Mill Creek Dams; an index and a site location map; photos of the dams.
Mill Creek County Park at the upper east end of the top of the dams.
The dts and the quads; the USGS map and the degree of elevation, etc.
List of property owners and AP#'s of adjacent properties.
The story of how the County received the dams and a legal opinion of Peter Klein, Mendocino County
attorney, as to who owns the water.
Director Dwight asked if these aerials photographs were taken by Mr. Mayfield.
Ross Mayfield said no; these photographs were taken off the aerials, flown by quads, that are taken on a regular basis.
Mr. Mayfield then returned to a report that gives a history of when the ownership was transferred from the State Hospital, the water rights there were, and the list of some property
owners that thought they had water rights. The Mendocino County decision was that the County owned the water in the dams as well as the water rights. In reading the packet, you will
note that it comes back up to when Supervisor Delbar requested the County to check it out and find out how much water there was in the dam, but the only amount of water that Supervisor
Delbar was actually looking at was the 112 acre-feet. He wasn't thinking of the flow in the pipe.
Chairman Butow clarified that this is a diversionary right as well as a storage right and Mr. Mayfield confirmed.
Ross Mayfield said they researched further because they had to know what the flow calculations were, what water was coming in, what the wildlife services could pull for flow counts at
the beginning of the dam, the top of dam and the middle of the dam. The report lays out where the calculations were picked, above the dam, at the dam and below the base of the dam,
and then it gives an actual reading of where the water is passing through. To back up what they were doing, the next picture shows the diversionary point. They had to get the Ruzika
Associates (engineer) calculations of what the flow through that 8" pipe would be, so that they could turn around and estimate the actual yield. Those calculations are the back-up
documentation at one-half mile increments, for a mile-and-a-half.
There are also photos of dam #1 were flow is actually picking up at the pipes.
The last document is a letter of agreement which Mr. Mayfield received from Attorney Minasian and the suggestion is that the best method to keep everyone happy is to enter into a contract
with water rights with Mendocino County Building & Grounds Department.
Dallas Miller spoke about last Friday's trip to Sacramento, saying they filed for 2,075 acre-feet per year based on about 1,900 acre-feet of diverted water, 175 acre-feet of storage
water.
He said they were told by the Sacramento people at the State Water Resources Control Board to claim as much water as they thought we could get out of it, and the turnover; in other words,
we realize there is more than 2,075 acre-feet.
Chairman Butow commented that particularly as it is a large stream, claiming more would be the logical thing to do.
Ross Mayfield said he did some calculations the Board can look over. He said the District Manager thought we should file for 175 acre-feet.
Director Dwight asked what district manager that would be? He was informed that would be Mr. Tiemann.
Mr. Dwight responded that he felt that all this information was being delivered awfully fast.
Chairman Butow said that this happened fast, but that they should back up a little and explain that Manager Tiemann went with Mr. Miller to Sacramento because an agent from our District
was needed to assist with the application.
Director Dwight asked if this was the formal application and Mr. Miller confirmed that it was.
Dallas Miller said they talked to the State Water Resources Control Board and scheduled an appointment for Friday, April 5, 2002, between 10A.M.-12:00 Noon, which was to accommodate
the State Water Resources Control Board's schedule. He and Keith Tiemann arrived at 10:00 A.M. and discussed this water rights issue with the State for two hours. The State was making
recommendations on how we could correctly fill out the application for it to be successful in agreement with the Permit. But it took another hour to actually fill it out. By 1:00
P.M. the application had been completed and submitted to the State along with the $100.00 required fee.
Chairman Butow asked what exactly the application was for and Dallas Miller said it was for the total water right, 2,075 acre-feet. He said 1,900 acre-feet for diverted water and 175
acre-feet for stored water.
Ross Mayfield stated that filing the application on April 5, 2002 is where we stand now but that he wanted to back up a bit to provide more background information. He said after they
found out who owned the dams, and after researching several sources, they called the water permitting agency. Scott Williams did the research, and he notified Mr. Mayfield's office
that his findings are that there is no active permit for the water rights and that nobody has used the water rights since 1982. So, the timeframe was overwith, and he told us that
those water rights are available. They checked that out, and also researched other information from the county agencies and poked around in other documents for support of that information.
The more they checked this out, the more they were getting a little nervous that somebody behind them would start picking up on what they were doing. At that point they notified Director
Parker and Director Butow of the findings and their concerns; so the decision was to move forward quickly. They then called the attorney.
Director Dwight asked if this was Attorney Minasian.
Ross Mayfield answered that it was. He said Mr. Minasian thought this was very well worth going forward on. They did a little brainstorming session and that is how they came up with
the document in the back of the packet, which is to buy the water from the County. Even though that document was being formulated, further research made it more obvious that we need
to file something on this right away to have the District secured in some place where they were to have control of the water source which they could give back to the County, but which
would actually save the water rights from going to somebody else such as Sonoma County.
Mr. Mayfield clarified that this is a source of water that is not counted in the 8,000 acre-feet the County has in Lake Mendocino. This is totally separate.
Director Howe asked if this water source is outside the District boundary.
Mr. Mayfield confirmed that it is.
Chairman Butow reported that three weeks ago, as he was preparing to go on vacation, he was approached by Director Parker and Ross Mayfield and at that point they got in touch with Attorney
Minasian. Mr. Minasian said it is possible this is not going to work because this is a pre-1914 right, which is inviolate of etc., etc., and he quoted State law. So, Chairman Butow
asked Ross Mayfield to check with Sacramento, because they seemed to feel that this water right hasn't been put to beneficial use for 20 years. Chairman Butow went on to say that,
in fact, that is two years longer than Redwood Valley County Water District has been under a moratorium. And yet, nobody at the county level has ever taken the initiative to help us
get some of that water or anything. So, Chairman Butow asked Ross Mayfield to double check again.
Ross Mayfield said they talked to them three times.
Chairman Butow reported that Director Parker said he thought the District better go file for the permit; and Chairman Butow said he wondered if we ought to just make out all the paperwork
and then go approach them.
Director Dwight asked who they were considering approaching.
Ross Mayfield said the County of Mendocino.
Chairman Butow continued that the discussion got around to the possibility that if the we went to the County first, they could very easily say, well, thanks for the information but no
thanks, we want to give the water to someone else, or that they have other needs for this water and want to use this water for the 10,000 Buddhas or something. So before he left for
vacation, Chairman Butow spoke to Director Parker and said, "Talk this over some more; you are the Vice-Chair, you proceed as you see fit." When Chairman Butow returned from vacation,
Director Parker told him that they decided that they could not negotiate without having at least some sort of position of power, of having already filed ahead of anybody else. So they
decided they were going to go ahead and file. They felt the worst that could happen was that the State could throw it back at us later. The State could say that they had made a mistake
and return our fee's and application, although they seemed to be pretty confident that would not be the case.
Chairman Butow reported that when he returned from vacation, he called Ross Mayfield and asked how it went. Ross Mayfield told him they had filed; they had gotten it done.
Chairman Butow mentioned that there was only one problem, the District should have had a Board Meeting. Although, if we go back in our records we can find that we did direct Ross Mayfield
and the committee of Director Parker and Director Butow to go forward as expeditiously as possible in finding water for the District.
Director Dwight said he had a couple of questions when there is an appropriate time.
Chairman Butow acknowledged Director Dwight's interjection and went on to say that the purpose of the meeting tonight is to get an explanation of where we're at with this situation,
what's been done by the committee and Mr. Mayfield. The committee has now reported back to the full Board and now we would like to have the Board entertain a motion approving our actions
and allowing us to proceed down the road of now negotiating with the County to get some sort of an agreement worked out with them and then in turn approach Russian River Flood Control
District for a wheeling agreement in which we can trade dam water for lake water.
Director Dwight agreed.
Director Howe asked if we should make a motion first, to approve the filing and the expenditure of the filing fee and the actions of the committee.
Chairman Butow said Yes.
Director Dwight asked them to "back up a little bit…you said you were going to talk to the Flood Control District and ask them to trade the water that we would get under the permit,
with the water in the lake to replace what we would be taking out of the lake. Is that correct?"
Chairman Butow apologized for not clarifying. He said that the only way, since it is obvious that Redwood Valley is "up here" and Mill Creek is "way down here" and the question is,
how do we make this thing work? The only way we can make the thing work is if you can make an agreement with the Flood Control District to trade some of their 8,000 acre-feet for their
gain of our 2,075 acre-feet. In other words, we take this to trade for the same amount over there. That would be a permanent agreement, not a surplus agreement and for the first time,
actually strengthen Redwood Valley's position in regards to the moratorium.
Director Dwight said it appears that in effect, we would end up negotiating not only with the County and arriving at maybe even a nice, friendly agreement inasmuch as they are overseeing
the economic future of Redwood Valley, but we would have to also negotiate with the Flood Control District to get some sort of agreement.
Chairman Butow clarified that it is called a wheeling agreement.
Director Dwight wondered what the impact might be on the adjacent property owners and what they might do.
Ross Mayfield said the right-of-way is already there. He has prepared a list of the property owners and their AP#'s for reference, if anything comes up.
Director Dwight asked if anybody there has agricultural interests, sheep, or anything like that; or if these properties are small residentials.
Ross Mayfield said that, No, it's vertical canyon. You could say "ag" but it is vertical canyon.
Chairman Butow said he thought it belonged to the Bureau of Land Management and that he was surprised to see the list of names.
Ross Mayfield said that when you get down toward the base, and toward the flatter portion, yes, you have that. But you really don't have a problem because the County has the right-of-way
for the 8" main all the way down to the bottom of Mill Creek Road.
Director Dwight wondered if the county could convey the right-of-way to Redwood Valley.
Ross Mayfield responded that Redwood Valley could get it conveyed. They County owns it, according to their attorney.
Director Dwight asked if we have talked to them about all that and Ross Mayfield said No.
Chairman Butow said that he wanted to bring everyone up to date on his conversations yesterday. He said that after he talked to Ross Mayfield, his second phone call was to Supervisor
Delbar to bring him up to date. He told Supervisor Delbar, "Well, I wanted to start your Monday off". He said Supervisor Delbar was not happy to learn about this and that even though
he had investigated the water availability in the dams two years ago, he was sitting on that information figuring that a political opportunity would present itself in which he could
massage something for Redwood Valley and Millview through the Board of Supervisors.
Chairman Butow responded to Supervisor Delbar that, "Well, that's fine, but nobody told us that. We are approaching you to ask for your good offices help in getting together with the
Parks & Recreation people because we want to make it plain that we want to pay for this water and we feel that this payment would certainly be beneficial to the parks people that are
maintaining the dams."
Chairman Butow continued that in Mr. Mayfield's report you will find that the County has to have a dam inspection every year and that is costing them some money; plus they also maintain
the picnic areas and everything else up there. We want them to know that we want to be fair, we want to be just - we were thinking in terms of what we pay the Flood Control District
each year for our surplus, $35-$40 per acre-foot. We want to benefit from it, we want them to benefit from it. This is the first opportunity that has been presented to this District
to get a permanent water supply rather than a surplus supply and it almost is one-third of our total annual use. So, back to Supervisor Delbar; he wasn’t happy, and he asked that we
be quiet about this. He has to have a chance to think about this. Chairman Butow told Supervisor Delbar that we are going to try to have a Closed Session, but didn't know if we could.
Chairman Butow said his third phone call was to Attorney Rapport, who informed him that this topic doesn't qualify for a Closed Session at this point, unless we are discussing the actual
agreement as if we got to a point with the County where they were telling us how much water they would take, and so forth; then we could have a Closed Session. But for our purposes
this evening, we had to have a public meeting. So that is why the 24-hour notice.
Director Dwight wondered if we need to get together with the Corps of Engineers.
Ross Mayfield responded that we don't. The beauty of this particular project is that all the infrastructure is there. It may be old, some of it's almost a hundred years old, but it
has already been inspected. Mr. Mayfield has talked to the County; they inspected the dam and it's in good shape. The only thing that isn't in really great shape is the 8" water main.
If the main goes out, you may have to throw a liner inside it, or whatever you do with it. Other than that, the right-of-way is there, you can throw in the liner, you don't necessarily
have to dig up everything.
Chairman Butow asked why, if the water is free-flowing down Mill Creek and flowing into the Russian River and becoming part of the Russian River flow, why, then do we need to use a pipe?
We're not going to send that water directly anywhere, unless Russian River Flood Control District decided they want to assign some of that water someplace else, right?
Ross Mayfield said, well, this brings up one of the problems. The problem is that, actually, it's diverted water. In order to show that we really have that water, and can turn it loose
in the summertime, we are actually going to have to have a pond.
Chairman Butow questioned, a pond?
Mr. Mayfield said, yes, to hold the water you capture over the wintertime. Because the water you release down that pipe in the wintertime, you just turn into the stream, nobody is going
to give you any credit for it.
In the summertime, you would have to divert this over to a pond to release it. You would still have the same flow coming out of the existing pipe.
Chairman Butow said, Oh, I see, it's a capturing situation, and Mr. Mayfield said yes, it's a capturing situation.
Chairman Butow asked if there was some acreage or a pond site or an old pond that hadn't been used.
Ross Mayfield said there are other ponds or pond sites existing there and that you could put in a pond.
Chairman Butow said that would cost the District some money to make this thing work. We would have to do some construction work in order to capture the water. He asked if there would
be an amount that we would have to capture to make it work, an acre-foot or more?
Ross Mayfield said he thinks you would have to capture at least a winter flow, at least a thousand acre-feet.
Chairman Butow clarified, We'd have to have a pond for 1,000 acre-feet?
Mr. Mayfield said it would have to be pretty close to that amount.
Chairman Butow, Director Dwight and Director Howe expressed surprise.
Chairman Butow asked where we would find such a location and Mr. Mayfield said that there is enough acreage there. Chairman Butow said he knew there is the acreage, but he is wondering
just how we would do it?
Dallas Miller said that he thinks that Keith Tiemann was saying that we should have a pond with 500 acre-feet and the idea is that we divert the water, even in the summer, along with
the winter runoff also. You store it for the summer usage then you re-release it as an advantage to the Flood Control District in the summer months, and you transfer the amount of
water you put in there.
Chairman Butow summed it up that we would be metering the water out at the Mill Creek site, not just at the two dams that are there, but of course they are flowing all year round, so
they would flow down into our pond of whatever acre-feet, then we would release it by meter down into the river and we would take that metered water and that would be credited against
what we draw out of Lake Mendocino.
Ross Mayfield said, That's right.
Chairman Butow responded, So, we are going to have to build a pond.
Ross Mayfield said that if we are going to just dump it in a pond and dump it out, there is a pond right there at the corner, up from where this water main is, about a quarter-mile or
less.
Chairman Butow asked if he is talking about something that was part of the infrastructure at one time; but Ross Mayfield said he didn't think so.
Dallas Miller said they did have a pond originally. It was located 2,000 feet south of the Mill Creek Road intersection with Eastside Road on the west side of Eastside Road.
Chairman Butow asked if it was down there towards the old dairy.
Mr. Miller answered it was toward where the school is at the intersection about 2,000 feet south on the west side.
Ross Mayfield said that is the pond he was thinking of. He said it is still there, if it's what everyone is talking about.
Chairman Butow asked if the pond has to be redone.
Dallas Miller said it's not that big.
Ross Mayfield said he thinks it's about 4 – 5 acre-feet. If it's the one he is thinking of, it's pretty big and deep.
Director Dwight asked Mr. Mayfield about the Park and Recreation Departments commitment to the public for swimming privileges. Are we going to create a furor there?
Ross Mayfield said Let's go back in history. This line used to feed the rearing ponds where the Mill Creek comes into Eastside Road and at that location they had fish rearing ponds
there. This line fed them continuously. During the drought in 1982, which is discussed in your packet, they had to draw the ponds down quite a ways and they were complaining about
that because it was hard on them, recreation-wise.
But after that, I haven't seen those things. I don't remember any problems except once in the drought year.
Chairman Butow said that everybody suffers in a drought year; look back at the 1976-1977 situation. He doesn't know if these ponds were drawn down during that time, but of course we
all know what Lake Mendocino looked like. Everyone has severe problems during a drought. The downside of the wheeling agreement in doing something with the lake, we could conceivably
find ourselves in the weird situation of releasing water and getting credit out of the Mill Creek system and having the lake getting down so low we can't pump out of it. There doesn't
seem to be any free lunch in any of this, but for 98% of the time, this would give us the credit we need to give us a base that we can work off of.
Now, say we are filing for 2,075 acre-feet provided we can get a pond thing. Keith Tiemann said something to me briefly last night before he signed off; he said we've got to finish
up some report that they wanted to know in Sacramento what we are going to do about a pond site. So this must be the pond site he was referring to.
Ross Mayfield said that is listed on the tasks-to-do list that he passed out tonight.
Director Dwight asked if we get our water rights permit passed, and if we negotiate with the Flood Control District and get their blessing, and everybody signs on, is the County Parks
and Recreation Department still going to exercise jurisdiction over the public park use area?
Ross Mayfield said, Yes.
Chairman Butow said we don't want to interfere with the public use area. The only interference we can project is what Ross Mayfield mentioned, that would be the scenario of a dry year
drawdown.
Dallas Miller pointed out that in the discussion with members of the State Water Resources Control Board for the Application for Water that would be processed with the SWRCB, we would
have to list a proposed site for the storage pond. That would suffice to get the application through, then we go back and develop and implement the program and utilize the water, then
that goes back to the operational plan.
Chairman Butow commented, so you've got something showing what your overall plan is, then what you actually come up with, is your operational plan.
Mr. Miller confirmed.
Ross Mayfield said there are a lot of things still unanswered, a lot of things that still need to be addressed.
Once we started really researching this thing, a lot of people at other places began asking why we were doing this. We were worried that if we didn't file immediately, someone would
file in front of us. So we did it, we filed in front of anybody else. It's better to be in there, inside; even though the application has to be completed and gone on through with.
And we will be doing more research because there are some other things we don't know about; there might be some other water also available.
Chairman Butow asked if we did find other water available, would we go back to Sacramento and say we discovered that by doing thus and so with this infrastructure, we might get even
more water, whatever it might be?
Ross Mayfield said, Right. We filed on all three pick-up points, all three dams. But there is the possibility that the first dam is really the second pickup point and not the primary,
and the second, middle dam (giving you year-to-year) is really the pickup point and that the County was using this to feed the fish hatchery, well then we would have actually captured
almost twice the amount of water.
Chairman Butow said, Oh, because you would have utilized that third dam. Would that allow us to go forward without having to build a dam someplace?
Mr. Mayfield said the water would still need to be stored someplace.
Chairman Butow commented it has to go someplace to hold it for summertime.
Ross Mayfield clarified that it has to be stored so you get credit on it.
Chairman Butow said that in the summertime it is a year-round stream, summertime obviously at a lesser rate, but we've got a pick-up dam for winter storage rights. When we deliver water
to that pond, we can deliver it year-round, so that increases our beneficial use water, does it not?
Mr. Mayfield said, Yes, it does.
Chairman Butow asked if that helps get ourselves up to this 2,000 acre-foot figure.
Ross Mayfield answered that the real positive thing about this, is you've got a source of water you can actually divert, that Sonoma County has no claim to. You have a winter source.
The way the attorney explained it to us…
Chairman Butow interjected, this is the State attorney?
Ross Mayfield said, No, the District's attorney.
Chairman Butow asked, Paul Minasian?
Ross Mayfield said Yes, he explained that basically, Sonoma County has all the water rights for winter flows as well as summer flows, in the Russian River Basin; they have already claimed
all that. So we've actually found diverted water, which dates back before the 1914 dams. We've actually found diversion rights for 2,000 acre-feet of water; we've just got to find
someplace to store it. The possibility, if that first dam is not the main feed line up to the second dam, then we have the possibility of that 8-inch main, which would carry up to
1,800 acre-
feet per year within the first half-mile. Basically you have 1,800 acre-feet more of water than you can store and divert as well. That makes it even more interesting. We don't know,
we have to do more research to find out what exactly is there. We moved very quickly on this but there is a lot of research to be done yet.
Chairman Butow said, Not only that, in order for us to be able to expend the time necessary to do this extra research, we couldn't be sitting around with this thing hanging around our
neck, not having filed, and not putting ourselves at least in a first position. Now the question of whether or not we have the right to file for the pre-1914 rights or not, that will
need to be determined at a later date. But we feel that nobody else can do it better than we can do it and if the County chooses to sell us the water, then that works it out. So,
we are going to have to wait for Mr. Delbar to get back to us. Right now what we need is the full Boards approval of what the sub-committee has done to date and that motion to approve
should include the approving of our filing in Sacramento for the water rights to the Mill Creek Dams. Then we can go forward comfortably. We may be criticized for moving too quickly
but I think, considering the difficulties of this District, we would have done the District a disservice by not filing.
Director Dwight said he understands what is being said. We still have to come up with the money for the holding pond, and the repairs to the existing system to make it safe and reliable.
We don't have any idea of the bottom line of what the costs will be.
Chairman Butow said we are not trying to "de-recognize" or do away with Mendocino County's rights. We are trying to file for the beneficial use of that water and we are willing to negotiate
with the County of Mendocino, and we are willing to pay them for the uncontested rights to use that water. We don't want to get into a big legal fight with them.
Director Dwight commented that the purpose of all of this is on lifting the moratorium.
Chairman Butow responded that it will not lift the moratorium, because it is not enough water. It's only a third of what we already use or need every year. But the fact is that right
now, we assume that Russian River Flood Control is going to rescind its notification to the State Water Resources Control Board that there is no more surplus water (they have not rescinded
that letter yet). And if that statement is rescinded now, however three or four years down the road they determine there is no more surplus water, at least we've got our foot in the
door and they can't cut us out of the picture. That 1,000 acre-feet for summertime use could at least be used for our domestic users.
Mr. Mayfield clarified that, technically, if you use that storage, you would have 2,000 acre-feet summertime use.
Chairman Butow said that's more than what we need for domestic. So, we are looking to put ourselves in a firmer position than we have been in before. And we are going to emphasize
the fact that Redwood Valley has been under a moratorium for two years less than this water has not been put to beneficial use.
Director Dwight felt that that is a significant point.
Ross Mayfield said that if we didn't file on this, and Sonoma County filed because they have the money and power to do this, they could really beat us up.
Dallas Miller asked to make a comment on Mendocino County: basically, they have no infrastructure. They have no way to beneficially use the water of the Mill Creek Dams. They could
use it in Lake Mendocino by wheeling it as mentioned before, but he is sure their own infrastructure, or any water system that the County has, is non-existing. They won't be using
it for years, or possibly longer.
Chairman Butow said he supports the decisions and actions taken, as already stated. The other thing that occurred to him is the issue before the Board of Supervisors and that is the
10,000 Buddhas, which was mentioned to him by Supervisor Delbar. They really haven't come up with the arguments yet, but its due to come up soon – where are you going to get the water?
Well, they're getting the water from Rogina Water Company. Where is Rogina getting extra water? He would want to hook up to the dams. Now he would have to apply for a permit like
we did, file on it and have Mendocino County sign on the water then he would put in an infrastructure to sell the water to the Buddhists. Now, Russian River Flood Control District,
if we can do an arrangement with them, they could sell to the Buddhists. But meanwhile we're getting a tradeoff on what's going on with the Lake. Now if all of this comes to pass
- that was one my concerns, I was afraid of Rogina Water filing over the top of us more than I was concerned that Sonoma County would file for it. It's here now; it's a problem
the Board of Supervisors will hear in the next ten days.
Director Dwight commented that the proposal is before the County Planning & Building Department and that a lot of people are for it and a lot against it.
Chairman Butow said that Supervisor Delbar felt there was some support on the Board of Supervisors because they were looking at it as some sort of tax base increase. He seemed to feel
that this thing is very much alive.
Dallas Miller said the State people that we met with also suggested that possibly we would use the water and transfer it or sell it to local districts also (like Rogina Water).
Chairman Butow responded that we could, except we wouldn't get a transfer out of the lake. That's the problem. We don't need the money as much as we need the water.
Ross Mayfield said that you could take the money and use it to pay off some of the costs. It adds a value. You could also sell it to some other district that has water rights in the
Lake and wheel that to them and come up strong.
Chairman Butow said the only other agency that has water rights in the Lake is the Flood Control District. They're the only agencies, Sonoma County and Russian River Flood Control and
thats it. If we want to pump out of the lake, they are the players we have to do business with. The Flood Control District has a board that is pretty pro-Redwood Valley for a change,
and we do have a wheeling arrangement that we have to work out with them already, in regard to the 25 hook-ups that we serve, that are also in the Flood Control District. Chairman
Butow mentioned to Attorney Minasian that if we are going to make one wheeling agreement, we might as well make another one to go with it; plus a modification of our place-of-use, etc.
Director Dwight said we must be very careful in forming a motion, because the Board members who are not on the sub-committee are playing catch-up.
Director Howe/Director Dwight: A motion that we approve the actions of the sub-committee, and with Ross
Mayfield and Dallas Miller, for the application to appropriate water from the
Mill Creek/Talmage Dams, as well as the expenditure of the $100.00 filing
fee.
The Motion passed by a vote of 3-0.
Chairman Butow said the next step is to go back and start doing the detail work. He said Bob Parker pointed out that it could very well be, that because of the pre-1914 right that somebody
is going to make a squawk, and then it's going to come back. But the worst that's going to happen at this point is that they return the paperwork and say they made a big mistake and
we can't do it this way.
Now, the County of Mendocino, Supervisor Delbar's response was, You can't do that; that is Mendocino County's water. That was his statement to me at first, and right at the end he said
it again. And this is our Supervisor we are counting on to help us; but we had a long discussion including other times and we got the dust cleared and so we are friends again. At
the end, Mr. Delbar said, Just give me a chance to work on this to develop a strategy. I said, Fine; when do you want to meet with myself and Bob Parker and Ross Mayfield? Why don't
we sit down and have a nice long lunch together one of these day; when do you want to do that? He said, Well, give me a chance to think about it. So that's where it's at with him
right now.
Director Dwight: Mr. Delbar and Mr. Shoemaker are probably the only two Supervisors that you would have to sell on this topic. The others probably don't care.
Ross Mayfield said there are a couple of positive things here. The County knew that Redwood Valley was in a world of hurt. Let's look at it from the other aspect – if the county has
pre-1914 rights, if they do in fact have that right, they may not have to have a dam to be able to claim that water pool. So, that would mean we would be entitled to that water right
without having to put a pond in there. We would just turn a spigot. Now, Redwood Valley is in line to buy it, we are not trying to steal it.
Chairman Butow said we are not trying to take their water right and transfer it to Redwood Valley; we are trying to take that money and pay the County, so the County can put that money
in the General Fund so they can pay for park and dam maintenance. We're not looking for a fight, we're looking for a deal.
Ross Mayfield said that the packet he distributed indicates that there are 6 other groups that wanted to get this water. One of them was the Buddhist group but they were overruled.
The end result was that the county came back in 2001, he thinks, with the decision that the water is the County's, and no one else could take it. That was a quote of case law.
Chairman Butow said that Redwood Valley's action is a challenge to that decision. How far that challenge will go, the State is saying Yes. When this hits, the attorneys are going to
go to the State and say, What are you doing? They will start quoting case law.
My question to those attorneys is, How long can you sit on water and not put it to beneficial use, regardless of what kind of water right you've got?
Dallas Miller said that we have a history on that. He commented that the people they met with at the State Water Resources Control Board said that pre-1914 water is not an issue. This
issue will be like a new Right. There are only two ways you can lose your water rights: One, you can abandon it. Two, if you have not used it beneficially in five years, you lose
it.
Chairman Butow said he was aware of that, but he was told by Attorney Minasian that yes, that's true in all of the cases except pre-1914 riparian water rights. Mr. Butow's own riparian
right says that you don't lose the right, it stays with the property. You might have to file how you want to use it; you can't use it unbeneficially, you've got to put it to beneficial
use, you can't waste it.
We've got a "funny" issue here, we might be writing new case law, but that's not the problem. We're just pointing out the practical economics; isn't it better that we pay them for the
water, they don't have to find an attorney to challenge it, they just have to make some sort of a lease agreement. We'll use our water filing to make the thing function as far as the
State is concerned and we'll become partners or whatever.
Director Howe said that Mr. Miller was saying, they recognize they haven't used it in over 20 years. They've lost their rights to it, and Redwood Valley has filed for it.
Ross Mayfield added, We are the first to file.
Director Dwight suggested that to get political backing, perhaps Mr. Mayfield and Mr. Miller might make a presentation to the Farm Bureau people.
Chairman Butow said he doesn't think we need to plan to present it to anyone at this point. We need to talk with Supervisor Delbar and find out what type of political plan to follow
to make it work, if that's possible. If it comes to political hardball, yes, probably we will all be down before the Board of Supervisors explaining why we’ve taken these steps, and
maybe even saying shame on you, for abandoning us for the last 20 years when they had water they could have given us. Let's hope it doesn’t ever get to that point.
Director Dwight asked if this would affect people along the river.
Mr. Mayfield said no, this water was used for domestic as well as agricultural at the State Hospital, as you will see in your documents. This is good quality and a good source of water.
Not only that, if the Eel River flow is shut down by PG&E, you have 2,000 acre-feet of water. This is a source that could be a good negotiating tool and the worse case scenario if
you look at it from that point, is, for the common good you "JPA" with the local water agencies and it goes back into the pool for everybody and Redwood Valley is part of that pool.
There are so many things you can do with this thing. We can talk about those at another time.
Chairman Butow suggested that the official position be that we filed for two reasons: 1. So we have the opportunity to develop a firm water right for whatever water we can develop
out of that site. 2. Most importantly, we filed to prevent anybody else, like Sonoma County, from filing over the top of us. We felt this thing was an exposure that could not be
ignored.
Director Dwight asked if this goes back to committee now.
Chairman Butow said that unless there are any other suggestions, it will go back to committee to work with Mr. Miller and Mr. Mayfield to try to expand this. And the next item, in addition
to Mr. Miller and Mr. Mayfield continuing their research, is to meet with Supervisor Delbar and work out a game plan.
Ross Mayfield suggested referring to the Task List in the packet.
Director Howe said he would like to see how things develop. The State is supposed to get back to us within a week; instead of saying let's all do this, let's all do that, he would like
to wait and see what happens, because we don't really know for sure. We might be exposing ourselves or taking a wrong step when we could have sat back. Then we can say, OK, now let's
go this way. Let's not jump into anything; then we can talk to people and see what their feelings are.
Director Butow said we have to find out financing things, and answers to other questions, but the main thing is that this is the first time Redwood Valley has had the opportunity to
possibly develop a permanent water right that we can count on instead of the surplus water right. It's not going to lift the moratorium, there's no chance of doing that, but it's going
to assure the people that we do serve, at least a better, stable source of water.
Dallas Miller said he wanted to put out some information that the Board may or may not know; that we filed for appropriative water right, which is separate from riparian water right.
Riparian right is the right that stays with the property; we filed for the appropriative water right which is beneficial usage of the water that's stored.
Director Howe said that people look at the smaller picture. Just keeping water in Mendocino County and not seeing the water go down south is significant. As a whole County we need
to get together to keep our water here.
Chairman Butow adjourned the Meeting at 8:07 P.M.
Approved: Board of Directors
Date:
Interim Secretary