HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-04-04 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
Redwood Valley County Water District Meeting Minutes
Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:00 P.M. on April 4, 2002 at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Directors Present: Robert F. Parker, Sanford A. Dwight, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe
Directors Absent: None
Staff Present: Keith Tiemann, David Rapport
Others Present: Rosalind Peterson, Mark Edwards, Michael Smith
Agenda Item #1 – Hearing of comments or questions from the attending public.
There were none.
Agenda Item #2 – Consent Calendar
Director Parker/Director Howe: Approve Consent Calendar as presented.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #3 – Consider approval of Minutes of Meetings held March 7, 2002 and March 19, 2002.
Director Dwight/Director Parker: Minutes for Meetings of March 7, 2002 and March 19, 2002
be approved as presented.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #5 – Directors' reports and discussion of non-action topics.
Director Parker requested that the mail log be typed in the future.
Agenda Item #6 – Consider hearing of urgent items received since the Agenda was posted.
Chairman Butow said he had a couple of items to be added to the Agenda.
Director Howe moved to hear the urgent items.
Attorney Rapport advised Chairman Butow that he needed to briefly describe the items to be heard and state why they could not wait for the next scheduled meeting for action.
Chairman Butow said Ross Mayfield was very busy and could not be at the meeting, but he wanted Chairman Butow to schedule the informational meeting for participating agencies in the
Eel River Project. He reported that Mr. Mayfield wants to hold the meeting at 10:00 A.M. on May 15, 2002 at his offices on Talmage Road.
Chairman Butow went on to say that Mr. Mayfield wants to also hold a special meeting on May 1, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. to do a dry run on the presentation for the Board of Directors.
Chairman Butow asked Attorney Rapport how to set up those two meetings.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Hold a Special Meeting on May 1, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. for rehearsal
of presentation of Eel River Project informational meeting format
and content.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Chairman Butow asked Attorney Rapport if the May 15, 2002 meeting date needs to be set by the Board by motion.
Attorney Rapport suggested continuing the meeting of May 2, 2002 to May 15, 2002.
Manager Tiemann and Attorney Rapport reminded the Board that it has not passed a motion to hear the urgent items just acted upon.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Urgent items received since the Agenda was posted be heard.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #4 – Award of contract for Surge Tank No. 2 project.
Tom Yokoi arrived at 7:09 P.M. during the discussion of the previous item.
Tom Yokoi explained that the existing surge tank site is not large enough for the placement of a second surge tank. He said there is an adjacent pipeline easement that is large enough
for the second surge tank, but the easement is for pipelines only and does not allow for the construction of a surge tank. He said the District has a good bid for construction of the
surge tank and the contractor is reputable, so he recommends that the District either pursue acquiring the necessary easement for the second surge tank or to re-bid the project sometime
in the future.
He reported that he has a call in to the contractor to see if he will hold the bid while the right-of-way is acquired. He said the contractor will be back on April 8, 2002 and he has
asked the contractor to call Manager Tiemann to let him know if he will hold the bid for an additional time period. Mr. Yokoi said that the contractor was only required to hold the
bid for 60 days which expires near the end of April.
Mr. Yokoi said that after talking with Attorney Rapport, he believes it may take up to 90 days to secure a right-of-way on the property.
Director Parker asked if that means the District has to find a new site for the surge tank.
Tom Yokoi said no, that the planned site adjacent to the existing tank is at the same elevation with a very short pipeline run and is the only location where the new tank can logically
be built. He repeated that the tank cannot be built on the pipeline easement, but it is possible for the District to acquire that location.
Attorney Rapport said that the pipeline easement wording can be changed to include the new surge tank site and the District can then negotiate with the property owner to acquire that
easement or property, possibly in exchange for some of the pipeline easement which is not needed.
Attorney Rapport said the tank site property would have to be appraised. Then the matter of severance damages would need to be negotiated with the property owner. If the property owner
doesn't accept the offer, the Board would pass a resolution of necessity to condemn the property and get an order of immediate possession to allow the project to be constructed. In
that case, the final amount of the settlement would be ordered by the Court at a later date.
Attorney Rapport said that at the next Board meeting, it would be reported that the contractor agreed to extend his bid and negotiations on the site acquisition are going ahead or else
the contractor would not extend his bid and all would have to be rejected and the project re-bid after the site is acquired.
Director Howe asked if the property owner owns both sides of the surge tank site. He wondered if a tank site on the side not owned by Larned could be acquired.
Tom Yokoi said that is a possibility, but it is more likely that the District could negotiate with Larned to return some of the unnecessary pipeline easement in exchange for a tank site.
Rosalind Peterson asked if some landscaping could be put in, to hide the tank.
Attorney Rapport said that could be negotiated.
Attorney Rapport left at 7:27 P.M.
Agenda Item #11 – Report of bid tabulations for Emergency Generator and recommendation for award of contract.
Tom Yokoi reported the bid tabulations on the Emergency Generator project. He said the engineer's estimate was $55,000.00 and four of the six bids were below that amount. He reported
that Bartley Pump, Inc. was the apparent low bidder at $51,946.00. He said that Bartley Pump is a reputable firm and he recommended award to Bartley Pump, Inc.
Director Howe/Director Dwight: The bid of Bartley Pump, Inc. for $51,946.00 for the Emergency
Generator be accepted.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Tom Yokoi left at the conclusion of this Agenda item.
Agenda Item #7 – Consider re-instating hardship water service application approval for Michael Smith.
Comments and recommendation from State Health Department.
Chairman Butow asked Michael Smith if he is now ready to go ahead with the hardship water service installation.
Mr. Smith said he is working with contractors to get a cost estimate on running a line to his property from the meter.
Chairman Butow asked Mr. Smith if he could be ready in 15 days to hook up to the meter and get service going.
Manager Tiemann said that there is no coordination needed with the customer. The District only needs a completed Application to begin the installation process.
Director Parker confirmed with Manager Tiemann that the approved hardship application by Mr. Smith was nullified by default when it wasn't installed within the time limit set by the
Board of Directors.
Director Parker asked Mr. Smith if he had received notice that his hardship approval was going to lapse.
Mr. Smith confirmed that he had received notification during his period of unemployment and that it had lapsed.
Chairman Butow reported that it was the committee's recommendation that approval would be reinstated if installation could be accomplished in 15 days.
Director Parker confirmed with Mr. Smith that the fees for the service installation would not be a problem for Mr. Smith to provide.
Director Howe asked Chairman Butow if the State Health Department approval is required for reinstating the hardship approval and Chairman Butow said he didn't think
the State Health Department needed to be involved again.
Director Dwight/Director Parker: The hardship committee recommendation to reinstate the hardship service approval
if Mr. Smith makes application and pays the required fees within 15 business days.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Mr. Smith left the Meeting at the conclusion of this item.
Agenda Item #8 – Approval of Progress Payment #5 for water storage tank rehabilitation contract.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Payment of Progress Payment #5 for the storage tank rehabilitation project
in the amount of $3,240.00 be approved.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Howe/Director Dwight: Notice of Completion for the storage tank rehabilitation project be filed,
as the project is now complete.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #9 – Consider appointment to fill vacancy on Board of Directors.
Chairman Butow announced that he and Director Parker had interviewed Mark Edwards. He announced that Director Parker and Director Dwight had interviewed Richard Rhodes.
Director Parker recommended the appointment of Mark Edwards since Director Parker was the only member who had interviewed both candidates. Director Dwight concurred in the recommendation.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Mark Edwards be appointed to the Board of Directors to serve out the unexpired
term of Derek Ross.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Manager Tiemann was directed to notify the County Clerk of the appointment and make arrangements for swearing in.
Director Dwight asked Chairman Butow if Mr. Edwards should receive a briefing on Board operation. He said Manager Tiemann has always been nice about taking new directors under his wing
and showing them the ropes.
Chairman Butow said they would try to get him the latest copy of the Brown Act.
Director Parker offered for Mr. Edwards to call him any time to ask any questions of him.
Chairman Butow said he would bring Mr. Edwards up to speed as soon as he is sworn in.
Agenda Item #10 – Consider Palm Pilot meter reading for new billing program.
Manager Tiemann said that the Palm Pilot for reading meters was part of the new billing program, but it wasn't implemented until the new program was up and running and operating outside
of the old program. He explained this would involve still manually reading the meters, but punching the numbers into the Palm Pilot when prompted and then plugging the Palm Pilot into
the computer and downloading the reads. He reported that the cost of the device is $785.00.
Director Parker asked Manager Tiemann if this is a labor saving device for the District.
Manager Tiemann said it was, not only for the District, but for all the Districts if a program could be undertaken to convert all meters to automated meter reading.
Mark Edwards said he uses a similar device in his work and he recommends it. He asked if it was protected from rough use.
Manager Tiemann said it has a rugged case and is easily replaced if damaged.
Director Parker asked if there would be training provided.
Director Howe/Director Parker: The District purchase a Palm Pilot for meter reading in the amount
of approximately $785.00.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #12 – Request by David Wallen for prepayment of registration fees for treatment plant operator review course for certification.
Agenda Item #13 – Request by David Wallen to attend a math review course for treatment plant operator certification examination at District expense for time off work.
These Agenda items were discussed together.
Director Parker confirmed with Manager Tiemann that David Wallen is asking for a total of 4 days off with pay to attend 2 seminars for a total of $300.00 registration fees.
Director Parker asked if the District had a policy regarding financial assistance for educational advancement.
Manager Tiemann read the pertinent section from the Personnel Handbook.
Director Parker asked Manager Tiemann if he was withholding approval on the request.
Manager Tiemann said he was not withholding approval of this request but that he had an opinion against reimbursement for a payment of certification fees. Manager Tiemann said it would
be another year before David Wallen can qualify for certification even if he passes his certification exam.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Payment of registration fees, wages and travel expenses for treatment plant operator
review course for certification examination for David Wallen be approved.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Payment of travel expenses, lodging, meals and wages for a math review course for
treatment plant operator certification exam for David Wallen be approved.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Parker asked for David Wallen to provide to the District any text books that go with either of the review courses.
The audience left at 8:07 P.M. when a Closed Session was announced.
Agenda Item #14 – Closed Session – Public Employee Performance Evaluation – Maintenance Supervisor – Government Code 54959.
Chairman Butow returned the Meeting to Open Session with no report of action taken in the Closed Session.
Agenda Items #15 and #16 were postponed to the next Regular Meeting.
Director Parker said he was offended by receiving copies of a letter Rosalind Peterson had sent to the Board of Directors at the District Office. He felt Ms. Peterson should have sent
copies to each director individually and not have them copied at District expense.
Director Howe suggested that Ms. Peterson should be charged for the copies that the District made and distributed for her.
Manager Tiemann will so charge Ms. Peterson's account.
Manager Tiemann requested further description of Agenda Item #16 as the description provided to him for the Agenda was meaningless to him and did not provide adequate information to
the public for it to decide if it wanted to hear the item discussed.
Chairman Butow said that it was a matter that the committee was holding in confidence with Attorney Rapport until he supplied the committee with information on the item.
Manager Tiemann asked the Board if it seemed like a good idea for the Board to be not communicating with the Manger on a matter like District organization structure over which the Manager
has responsibility.
Chairman Butow said he was unwilling to discuss the matter any further until he had received certain information from Attorney Rapport.
Manager Tiemann suggested that since it seemed to be an internal organizational matter, it would seem to make sense to discuss the matter within the committee and bring a recommendation
to the full Board of Directors once it is worked out what impact the proposal would have on District operations.
Director Parker wanted the Board to hear the matter in closed session.
Manager Tiemann said he knew of no basis for holding a closed session for such a matter.
Chairman Butow said he would discuss the matter further with Attorney Rapport and try to have the matter ready for discussion at the next regular meeting.
The Meeting was adjourned by Chairman Butow at 8:35 P.M. to reconvene at a Special Meeting on May 1, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Approved: Board of Directors
Date:
Secretary, Board of Directors
Redwood Valley County Water District