HomeMy WebLinkAbout2002-02-07 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley Ca 95470
(707) 485-0679
Redwood Valley County Water District Meeting Minutes
Called to Order by Chairman Butow at 7:00 P.M. on February 7, 2002 at the District Office, Redwood Valley, California.
Directors Present: Robert F. Parker, Sanford A. Dwight, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe
Directors Absent: Derek G. Ross
Staff Present: Keith Tiemann, David Rapport
Others Present: Robert Van Hoy, Ross Mayfield, Rosalind Peterson, and Laura & Robert Lovato.
Agenda Item #1 – Hearing of comments or questions from the attending public.
There were no comments or questions from the attending public.
Agenda Item #2 – Consent Calendar.
Director Parker pointed out a typographical error and asked why the District needed to purchase a wind sock. Manager Tiemann explained that employees need to know which direction is
upwind in the case of a chlorine gas release.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Consent Calendar is approved as presented.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Items #3 – Consider approval of Minutes from Meeting of January 3, 2002.
Director Howe/Director Dwight: Minutes for the Meeting of January 3, 2002 be approved as
presented.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #5 – Discussion of options for Shop Building and Office Expansion
Chairman Butow explained that he and Director Parker had decided to recommend no changes to the office building at this time.
Director Parker said the committee is recommending improved layout of parking, completion of the looped driveway and removal of the light standard. He further proposed the placement
of cargo containers for storage beside both the office buildings and the shop building. They propose to move equipment and other items out of both building into the storage units to
create more working room in the existing building. Additionally, there is proposed a full bathroom facility to be built in the shop building as part of this project.
Chairman Butow proposed to advise Tom Yokoi of Brelje & Race that the storage containers need to be outfitted with power and lights and a modification to the doors to make them easily
accessible. The committee will ask Tom Yokoi to draw up a proposal based on the ideas described here.
Agenda Item #6 – Status Report by Ross Mayfield on Phase I of Eel River Water Project and other projects for which he is seeking funding.
Ross Mayfield reported that he has looked at the Gabrielli reservoir site and he thinks it is a good project. He has analyzed the yield roughly off the topographic maps and thinks there
is about 600 acre-feet yield. He thinks there is a second reservoir site further up the drainage which may yield another 100 acre-feet. He suggests that the engineers take a closer
look at it. He doesn’t think there are fish problems because there is an existing dam below it. He thinks there will be feasibility study funding coming available from the State Department
of Water Resources of up to $250,000. That funding won’t be available until September of this year, but the funding application needs to be ready by then.
On the Eel River Water Project, Mr. Mayfield said he has met with five water agencies (Hopland P. U.D., Roginia Water Co., Willow C.W.D., Calpella C.W.D. and Millview C.W.D.) and has
received favorable responses from them all. He has also met with several Indian tribes (Hopland, Redwood Valley, and Sherwood) and got favorable responses from them as well. He has
met with Budge Campbell of the North Coast Rail Authority about using the railroad right-of-way for the project pipeline. He will be working on the application and the proposal which
he will have ready by the next meeting. At that time, he will be prepared to go to each agency and tribe with a solid proposal. He is not asking for any financial commitments at this
time. He will be looking for grant funding between $800,00 and $1,000,000 for the feasibility study. He asked to be able to meet with the committee of Director Parker and Chairman
Butow to meet with Steve Casebier to discuss a proposal for a water supply from a group of investors.
Chairman Butow said Mr. Casebier wanted the District representatives to sign a non-disclosure statement if the District didn’t want to pursue his proposal so he would be able to market
it to others.
Attorney Rapport suggested the non-disclosure agreement will be added to the agenda as an urgency item tonight.
Chairman Butow asked Mr. Mayfield if there are any funding sources for the irrigation distribution system improvements. Mr. Mayfield said there are some funding possibilities,
but they are not ready just yet. He thinks he will know about funding sources by early next week. He is hoping to use a groundwater recharge program for the funding source. He set
up a meeting with Chairman Butow and Director Parker to meet with Steve Casebier at 12:00 noon at the Maple Café on February 12, 2002.
Director Dwight asked if any of Mr. Mayfield’s tribal contacts had plans for an unmet water need in the valley. He wants there to be a mutuality of need between the District and the
tribes.
Mr. Mayfield said that housing is limited on all the reservations and that they want to grow. He is suggesting that they support Redwood Valley Water District and its existing infrastructure
to provide their water needs rather then try to develop infrastructure and staff of their own to utilize their water supplies.
Tom Yokoi arrived at 7:28 during Mr. Mayfield’s presentation.
Agenda Item #4 – Presentation by Tom Yokoi of Brelje & Race on Irrigation Distribution System Improvements.
Chairman Butow stated for Tom Yokoi that the Board is trying to find funding for irrigation distribution system improvements and that a moratorium has been placed on irrigation system
connections until improvements can be made.
Mr.Yokoi said the irrigation system was originally designed for delivery of 18,000 gpm, but has actually used up to 22,000 gpm during recent frost events. He said the primary reason
the design is being exceeded is that some customers are able to take in excess of 500 gpm which detracts from what other customers are able to take. One solution talked about was to
restrict meter flow to 500 gpm with orifice plates. Each service structure is unique requiring different size orifice plates for each service which made the process difficult to implement.
His office has since developed a hydraulic model which can predict the size orifice plate needed when some sample flow rates are known from field tests on some services. He said his
office has also identified three bottlenecks in the irrigation distribution system which need to be eliminated in order to attain the design capacity of 18,000 gpm. He suggested enlarging
the pipeline bottlenecks first and then installing the orifice plates to limit users to 500 gpm so the available water is distributed more equitably.
Director Parker said he was under the impression that there was little or no economy of scale to doing all three bottleneck areas at one time and that they would have to be done in
stages to be able to afford them.
Mr. Yokoi explained that if the most effective bottleneck replacements were done, more water would suddenly be available to previously water starved areas to the detriment of high
elevation areas such as Road J which had previously enjoyed abundant water supply with the distribution system bottlenecks. Mr. Mayfield asked if this could be construed to be a water
conservation project, which could be in line for grant funding. Mr. Yokoi did not think it
could be thought of as a water conservation project. He also did not think it could be looked at as a groundwater recharge project.
Chairman Butow said that the decision has been made to go ahead with this improvement project and that Mr. Yokoi was invited to the meeting to advise the Board where they are with the
project and to be directed to move forward with it and get started.
Director Parker stated his belief again that the project will have to be completed in sections. Mr. Yokoi suggested that the improvements could be made in stages and put into service
for most of the year, but during frost protection season, the parallel line of the improvements would have to be valved off so there would not be detrimental repercussions to certain
portions of the distribution system.
Mr. Yokoi was asked to begin the design of the project for the bottleneck replacement and orifice plate installation while Mr. Mayfield continues to look for a funding source. He will
return to the meeting next month with a status report.
Chairman Butow advised Mr. Yokoi of the Board’s desires regarding the shop building and office expansion revised plans. Mr. Yokoi agreed to develop plans to incorporate their ideas
and report back with a status report at the next meeting.
Chairman Butow briefed Mr. Yokoi on the Gabrielli reservoir site and asked him to fine tune the estimate of yield so the Board can decide if they want to go further on it while Ross
Mayfield continues to look for a funding source.
Ross Mayfield and Tom Yokoi left at 8:13 P.M.
The Board took a break at 8:13 P.M.
The Board reconvened at 8:29 P.M.
Ray and Karen Gowan arrived at 8:01 P.M. during Mr. Yokoi’s presentation.
Agenda Item #15 – Consider Request from an irrigation system customer for a service size reduction.
Manager Tiemann reminded the Board that Mr. Gowan had written a letter requesting that his service size be reduced from 4 inch to 2 inch so he would not have to pay an annual minimum
for 6 acre-feet of water. He would prefer to have a nominal change in service size without changing the meter or pipe size. Manager Tiemann advised that without down-sizing the meter
to 2 inches, there would always be a 4 inch demand on the system that the District could have to instantaneously supply. Manager Tiemann advised putting in a 4 x 2 reducer and a 2
inch meter and charging Mr. Gowan at cost for those changes. That cost would be a one-time cost of about $1,000.00. It was discussed that Mr. Gowan would receive a buy back of that
investment from savings of 3 acre-feet in about 3 years. Mr. Gowan confirmed that he would have the option of changing it back to a 4 inch service sometime in the future.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Authorize modification of a 4 inch service to a 2 inch
service and install a 2 inch meter for Ray Gowan,
effective 12-15-01.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #20 – Request for adjustment of meter read from Robert Van Hoy.
Robert Van Hoy suggested that there was either a meter reading error or number transposition such that he received an over billing of $5.60. He showed the Board that he historically
has a minimum water use of 6,000 gallons per month and in December, 2001, he had 2,000 gallons usage followed by 10,000 gallons usage in January, 2002. He felt there was some kind
of error resulting in those disparate reads. He requested an adjustment of the 2,000 gallon read and the 10,000 gallon read to reflect usage each month of 6,000 gallons so he would
not incur the overage charge.
Manager Tiemann reported to the Board that he had checked the meter the day Mr. Van Hoy called on January 30, 2002 and found that there had been only 1,000 gallons usage in 1/3 of the
new month which was a pace of 3,000 gallons usage for the month. He pointed out that that was low usage again similar to that reported for December, 2001. He stated that there may
indeed have been a meter reader error, but without corroborating evidence it is all speculation. Manager Tiemann reminded the Board that it has over a $50,000.00 investment in meters
in the distribution system which it needs to rely on for its usage rather than relying on customers calling in to report how many gallons they used.
Director Dwight said for $5.60, he didn’t think we need to worry about it. He thinks the reading was in error, but there is no way to know. Director Butow agreed that it looks like
there was an error or that the meter is acting up.
Director Parker advised that Mr. Van Hoy be watching the meter for a similar anomaly to occur again.
Director Parker asked Manager Tiemann if the meters can malfunction. Manager Tiemann explained that a meter is a mechanical device, which can only move when water goes through it.
Furthermore, the meters lose accuracy with age such that they run slower. If a new meter is installed, it will be more accurate and record more usage.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Leave the billing as it is and watch for any more anomalies
to occur.
Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #7 – Directors’ reports and discussions of non-action topics.
Manager Tiemann advised the Board of the letter from the Mendocino County Employees Council requesting a speaker from the Board at their next regular meeting.
Chairman Butow said he has advised them that he will speak at their meeting.
Director Parker asked if an item on the correspondence log is a letter he has received. It was determined that he had received a copy of that letter.
Director Parker asked about the notice of exemption received from the County Clerk.
Attorney Rapport explained that was the posted notice of exemption for the irrigation moratorium process.
Director Parker asked if he could receive copies of letters addressed to the directors. Manager will do that in the future.
Chairman Butow suggested that personnel matters should not be listed on the correspondence log along with any private documents from the attorneys.
Manager Tiemann was directed to omit those types of correspondence along with catalogs and advertisements. Attorney Rapport concurred that could be done by directive.
Manager Tiemann passed out Attorney Rapport’s analysis of Nick Tibbetts’ proposal to resolve the Bureau of Reclamation loan obligation. The matter is for Board information for use later
when the proposal is on the agenda for action.
Manager Tiemann passed out the Form 700 Conflict of Interest forms to the four directors present.
Directors Ross’s form will be sent to him by certified mail by the time required.
Chairman Butow said that he filed the Form 700 at the County Clerk’s office that ACWA-USA had sent him. He was told that that form was to be returned to ACWA-USA for filing. Manger
Tiemann will attempt to get another form from ACWA-USA.
Manager Tiemann advised the Board of a public meeting by Sonoma County Water Agency on February 28, 2002 on the contract negotiation between Sonoma County Water Agency and the ten major
water contractors it serves.
Agenda Item #8 – Consider hearing of urgent items received since the agenda was posted.
Director Howe/Director Parker – The Board will hear the matter of a non-disclosure
statement that was received after the agenda was posted
and needs to be acted upon before the next regular
meeting.
The Motion was passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Chariman Butow be authorized to sign a non-disclosure
agreement regarding a water sale proposal from Steven
Casebier.
The Motion was passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Dwight/Director Howe: The Board will hear the matter of Director Ross’s
resignation from the Board of Directors that was received
after the agenda was posted and needs to be acted
upon before the next regular meeting.
The Motion was passed by a vote of 4-0.
Chairman Butow reported that Director Ross called him and verbally tendered his resignation from the Board of Directors. Chairman Butow told him he thought he needed something in writing
and that there is a procedure to be followed.
Attorney Rapport said the Board needs a written statement from Director Ross that can be acted upon at the next meeting to accept the resignation and appoint a new member.
Attorney Rapport will check the code to confirm the procedure and Chairman Butow will call Director Ross and ask him to submit a written resignation.
Agenda Item #9 – Approval of Change Order #3 and Progress Payment #4 for water storage tank rehabilitation contract.
Manager Tiemann explained the contract costs and change order cost due with the progress payment.
Director Howe/Director Dwight: Approve Change Order #3 to Olympus Painting and
Sandblasting in the amount of $1,244.43 for extra welding
on East Tank #1 of the storage tank rehabilitation contract.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Parker/Director Howe: Approve Progress Payment #4 to Olympus Painting &
Sandblasting in the amount of $30,846.99 for the storage
tank rehabilitation contract.
Agenda Item #10 – Report on status of repayment plan for Bel Arbres Mutual Water Company.
Attorney Rapport reported that Bel Abres Mutual Water Company sent out a survey to its customers and received thirteen responses which all chose the option of being billed for the surcharge
of $53.31 on each monthly water bill until the indebtedness is paid off. Attorney
Rapport presented a resolution for the Board to adopt to impose the surcharge of Bel Arbres customers.
Director Butow read the resolution for the record.
Attorney Rapport suggested that Manager Tiemann attach a list of affected accounts as Exhibit A.
Director Parker/Director Howe – Resolution 02-1 be accepted as presented and read.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Ross absent.
Agenda Item #11 – Review the District Conservation and Rationing Plan.
Manager Tiemann reminded the Board that it had asked him to produce the conservation and rationing plan of the District and have it reviewed by Attorney Minasian. It was then being
reviewed by Director Ross for a report to the Board if it was consistent with past and current policy of the Board. Manager Tiemann was asked to have it agendized for the next meeting
and for a copy to be included in the Board packet so the Board can act on it at the next meeting.
Agenda Item #12 – Request of reimbursement of expenses for Director Dwight and Manager Tiemann for attendance at seminar on Governing Together.
Manager Tiemann submitted expenses of $251.86 for two nights lodging and portions of per diem for three days. Manager Tiemann submitted expenses of $347.46 for Director Dwight for two
nights lodging, portions of per diem for three days and mileage at 32 cents per mile for 330 miles. Director Howe said the mileage had been changed to 35 cents per mile.
Director Howe/Director Parker: Manager Tiemann’s expenses of $251.86 and Directors
Dwight’s expenses of $347.46 plus the additional
difference between 32 cents per mile and 35 cents per mile
when figured be approved.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Director Dwight thanked the Board for allowing him to attend. Director Parker asked Director Dwight for copies of the seminar hand out and a report on the seminar.
Agenda Item #13 – Advise Board of meeting of water agency managers to discuss water issues.
Manager Tiemann reported on a phone call and fax from Evert Jacobson calling for a meeting of water agency managers in mid-February after all Boards have met and authorized their managers
to attend to discuss water issues.
Director Parker/Director Dwight: Manager Tiemann be authorized to attend a meeting of
of water agency managers and to make a written report
on the meeting to the Board.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #14 – Consider service contract renewal from Core Utilities.
Manager Tiemann reported that the first year of the new billing system has been completed and there was technical support offered as part of the warranty on the billing system. That
warranty period is now up and a service contract renewal is being offered by Core Utilities at $500.00 for 10 hours of technical support for the next year and fee software upgrades
for one year.
Director Parker/Director Howe – Authorize the service contract renewal with Core Utilities
for one year at $500.00.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda item #16 – Consider liquidating money market account for Fire Hydrant maintenance and rolling it into another account.
Manager Tiemann recommended rolling the fire hydrant maintenance money market account into the Bureau of Reclamation money market account. He explained further that one money market
account is required by the Bureau of Reclamation as a reserve account for emergencies to maintain their investments in the District infrastructure. The fire hydrant maintenance fund
is maintained to repair damaged fire hydrants. The account is added to only by funds generated by a fee on new hydrant installations as there is no income from the fire district which
chooses to not be charged for hydrant service. Since there are no new main extensions to generate income to this fund, the fund balance has fallen below the minimum to avoid a maintenance
fee. At present, the monthly maintenance fee exceeds the interest earned and the account is dwindling slowly to zero.
Director Dwight/Director Howe: The fire hydrant maintenance money market account
balance be liquidated and rolled over into the Bureau
of Reclamation Reserve money market account.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #17 – Consider Support payment for ACWA Region 1 representative to the 2002 DC Conference.
There was discussion that the support payment is sent every year, but the District never seems to get any benefit or even a report on the conference.
Director Dwight/Director Parker – Send a $100 support payment to ACWA Region 1
representative to the 2002 DC Conference.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Agenda Item #18 – Call for nominations from LAFCO for special district representatives seat.
Director Dwight asked if there were any issues coming before LAFCO that the District had a particular interest in.
Chairman Butow said he didn’t know of any issues before LAFCO especially affecting the District.
Manager Tiemann explained that there are two special district representatives on LAFCO and that Camille Rancher’s seat is up for appointment and she has indicated that she also wants
to continue to serve. There were no nominations offered.
Agenda Item #19 – Request for reimbursement of education expenses for Paula Berezay.
Manager Tiemann reported that Paula Berezay took courses on Quickbooks and on Word processing and is submitting requests for reimbursement of $154.28 for two text books and class registrations.
Director Howe/Director Parker – Paula Berezay be reimbursed $154.28 for text books and
registration fees for two courses on computer software
operation.
The Motion passed by a vote of 4-0.
Manager Tiemann asked if the text books should be retained in the office for reference books and the Board concurred.
The meeting was adjourned by Director Butow at 9:45 P.M. to reconvene on March 7, 2002 at 7:00 P.M. at the District Office, 8961 Colony Drive, Redwood Valley, California.
Approved: Board of Directors
DATE:___________________
_______________________________
Secretary, Board of Directors
Redwood Valley County Water District