Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-04-01 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT 2370 Webb Ranch Road P. O. Box 399 Redwood Valley, CA 95470 (707) 485-0679 MINUTES Board of Directors Regular Meeting April 1, 2004 CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 p.m. Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann. William L. Howe arrived at 7:25 p.m. Directors Absent: None Staff Present: David Wallen, Operations Manager; Linda Groth, Office Manager Recording Secretary : Kathy Davidson Guests: Nick Tibbetts, Consultant from Nicholas R. Tibbetts & Associates, Dallas Miller, Ross Mayfield of Recovery Operations Specialty Services Members of the Public: Roy and Barbara Beck, Dee Sutherland, Bob Anderson, Jessica Taaning of Redwood Riders, Inc. ROLL CALL: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann 2. HEAR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC. None. 3 CONSIDER CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF EXCESSIVE WATER CHARGES ON PINECREST DRIVE ACCOUNT FOR PERIOD OF 12/20/03-01/20/04. The District has tested and replaced the meter, as it was reading slowly. Property owners asked for some explanations for the high read, as they have found no leaks, made no repairs, and the usage now is back to normal. The Operations Manager checked with experts on the causes of meter misreads and was further reminded that when meters misread, they read slow. Internal gearing is plastic and if a dial breaks, the whole thing stops. The dial of this meter does turn, so, it is functioning properly. It appears the problem occurred past the District's meter therefore it’s not the District's responsibility. The property owners requested a forgiveness of some type. Director Tiemann stated that water sales are the revenue for the District and the metered water is the basis for those revenues. Since staff reports nothing justifies a conclusion of meter malfunction, other than a slow read, deny the request for relief. MOTION: Send the property owner a letter stating the Board of Directors is unable to justify waiving part of the water charge for this period, and to enclose an offered Payment Schedule form for a very lenient payment schedule. Groth/Tiemann CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: William L. Howe 4. CONSIDER CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF EXCESSIVE WATER CHARGES DUE TO A LEAK ON EAST ROAD ACCOUNT FOR PERIOD OF 12/20/03-01/20/04. Jessica Taaning, on behalf of the Redwood Riders, Inc. was present to plead the case for this horse association/arena property. It was stated that after the water bill was received, they finally discovered a break 2 feet under the ground. There had been heavy rains and no one saw the leak. By the time it was discovered the bill had reached over $800. The owners, a non-profit organization, were very concerned as they had no funds to pay this bill. On behalf of the association, she requested that they be responsible for only one-fourth of the billing and that the District forgive the balance of the charge. Director Tiemann said the District sets its rates for water, by the costs of delivery of that water. The District is non-profit; if this bill isn’t paid, the rest of the District’s customers will have to pay. MOTION: Direct Staff to work out a payment arrangement with Redwood Riders, Inc., wherein a small amount of the outstanding debt is added to each monthly billing. There will be no forgiveness of the usage charge. Groth/Parker CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: William L. Howe 5. CONSIDER CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF EXCESSIVE WATER CHARGES DUE TO A LEAK ON WEST ROAD ACCOUNT FOR PERIOD OF 01/20/04-02/20/04. The property owner asked for relief and forgiveness based on the fact that the property owner was expeditious in finding and repairing the leak. MOTION: There will be no forgiveness on the bill. Staff is directed to work out a payment schedule with the owner. Parker/Tiemann CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: William L. Howe 6. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED. Chairman Butow asked to discuss a letter from Director Robert F. Parker. MOTION: Include the Item on the Agenda. Groth/Tiemann CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: William L. Howe 7:25 p.m. William A. Howe arrived at the meeting. Chairman Butow read a letter from Robert F. Parker submitting his resignation due to personal reasons. After a discussion about the rules and regulation regarding resignations and replacements, Director Parker amended his resignation, indicating an effective date of April 10, 2004. MOTION: Accept the March 30, 2004 letter of resignation from Robert F. Parker effective April 10, 2004. Tiemann/Groth CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None Chairman Butow offered profuse appreciation to Director Parker for 4 years of dedicated service on the Board of Directors. He added that Director Parker has offered to volunteer a library for the District. Staff was directed to post and notify the public of the opening. 7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS. (AGENDA ITEM # 10A) a) Report of meeting with legislative counsel regarding Bureau of Reclamation loans. Nick Tibbetts, Consultant from Nicholas R. Tibbetts & Associates referenced the 2002 Board of Directors interest in finding some way for the government to forgive the Bureau of Reclamation loans that got this District started. In the late 1980’s, the U. S. Government forgave interest and penalties of many of these loans. In the 1990’s the Bureau of Reclamation determined that Redwood Valley County Water District didn’t have the ability to pay. Mr. Tibbetts reviewed the 20+ year history of the loan, and the District's attempts to get the loan forgiven and subsequent events. Mr. Tibbetts is considering approaching the Bureau of Reclamation on behalf of the District, at this time. He is offering to go to Washington, D. C. and interact with members of the senate appropriations committee and others. Tibbetts laid out the situation, the approximate costs, and how the process would work. He presented a fee for service agreement for 24 months at a cost of $15,000 for expenses for that period. If he is successful, a fee of $360,000 in cash would be due immediately upon the successful resolution of the retirement of the two Small Reclamation Projects Act loans, or any resolution that is acceptable to the District. Fifty percent of the above fee would be paid if, during the 2 year period of the contract, the District enters into either a successful renegotiation of its two loans, or a loan buy back agreement which ultimately yields a successful buy back of the District’s two loans. Mr. Tibbetts would like to return to the May 6, 2004 Regular Meeting with a formal proposal for the Board of Directors decision. He also gave the Board several options on how to approach the situation. Several questions were asked and answered. MOTION: Proceed on basis of presentation. Authorize Nicholas R. Tibbetts & Associates to make contacts in Washington, D.C., working on behalf of the District in an attempt to get the debt owed to the Bureau of Reclamation forgiven. The cap on expenses will be $15,000.00 over a 2-year period. Receipts will be submitted. The fee of $360,000 would be paid on a contingency basis; and 50% of the fee if during that time, the District finds another solution to the forgiveness. Parker/Howe CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None BREAK 8:30 p.m. Mr. Tibbetts left the Meeting at this time. RECONVENE: 8:47 p.m. 8. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR. (AGENDA ITEM # 7) a. Financial Statement. b.-1 Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting. b.-2 Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting. c. Bills Payable. d. Special Expenditure Fund status report. e. District Activity f. Mail Log. MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented. Parker/Groth CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 9. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 5,2004, FEBRUARY 16, 2004 AND MARCH 4, 2004 AS PRESENTED. (AGENDA ITEM #8) A Correction of the Minutes of March 4, 2004: Item 8 b.: The sentence should be clarified as Sonoma County Water Agency. MOTION: Approve the February 5, 2004, February 16, 2004 and March 4, 2004 Minutes with corrections on March 4, 2004 as listed above. Parker/Groth CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe Noes: None Abstain: Keith Tiemann abstained on the Feb. 16, 2004 Minutes, as he was not in attendance at that meeting. Absent: None 10. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION TOPICS. (AGENDA ITEM #9) a) Report of response to County Planning Department re: MS-10-2003. The response was read aloud. No further comments. b) Report of attendance at March 11, 2004 meeting of the Redwood Valley Improvement Association. The meeting was attended by Directors Parker, Butow and Tiemann. Director Tiemann brought to the group’s attention that a mechanism already exists for a Community Service District and that perhaps it would be to the group's advantage to check into it. Frank McMichael of LAFCO will attend the next meeting. c) Report of attendance at 2004 ACWA Legislative Symposium in Sacramento on March 30, 2004. Director Groth attended the symposium and reported on the Ortiz legislation regarding Special Districts and their procedures and operations and accountability. One suggestion that alerted Director Groth was the Ortiz bill's suggestion that auditors be changed every five years. His concern was that there is a scarcity of Special District qualified auditors in our area. The District presently enjoys a 3 year contract with a reduced rate, and this legislation could end up costing the District more money. He suggested that the District write a letter regarding these concerns and that if the bill passed without bringing this to their attention, this could present a financial burden to smaller districts. New regulations on percholate and several other areas regarding testing are in the works under the Clean Water Act. Workers compensation was discussed along with other matters pertaining to Special Districts. 11. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORT AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS. (AGENDA ITEM #10 b) SolarBee recommendations for upgrades. SolarBee technicians came out this week and staff went on-site with the SolarBee crew checking for clogging in the system. In conversations with consultant Sandy Walker, the Management Team has concluded that we should be running 24 hours a day to take care of the odor and taste problem. Some adjustments and suggestions were made regarding battery packs; Ms. Walker will be checking on other options such as an electrical kit, with a money back guarantee. They felt it would take about one season to make a difference and if it did not work, the District would get a refund. It is possible that installation could be accomplished by staff. Operations Manager Wallen will report further at the May meeting. Continued Business Items: 12. BUDGET, MONTHLY UPDATE. (AGENDA ITEM 11) Accepted as presented. 13. REVISIT THE DOMESTIC WATER SERVICE PRICING STRUCTURE IN THE RATIONING PLAN IN ORDER TO DISCOURAGE EXCESSIVE USAGE (AGENDA ITEM #12) Nothing to report; this is a continuing item. Director Parker has some historical information that he is going to pass on to Director Tiemann so it will be available as a resource. 14. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION ( AGENDA ITEM #13) a. Report of attendance at Inland Water & Power Commission Meetings. b. Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC. c. Discussion and possible action on IW&PC topics. Director Butow reported that Roland Sanford wants all agencies to participate in the dam modification. Mendocino County Water Agency will be the lead agency. IW&PC wants the proposal to get through, and has asked the Districts to agree to work together, with a bail out option if preferred. It was the consensus that the District wants to be supportive of the Inland Water & Power Commission, but that it is the feeling of the Board that the only agency that can promise more water is the Sonoma County Water Agency. The District will advise Inland Water & Power Commission that it wants to support them to show a united front, but that the District will not give any money to the project at this time. 15.. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. (AGENDA ITEM #14) a. Report of attendance at Flood Control District Meetings. b. Consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID. c. Discussion and possible action on Flood Control District topics. There was no meeting. Nothing reported. TIMED ITEM: 9:00 p.m. 16. CLOSED SESSION (AGENDA ITEM #15) No Closed Session a. Real Property Negotiations; Report of Negotiator, Donald Butow, in regard to progress or lack of progress in negotiations for access to Mill Creek water sources, rights of way, easements or interests in real property related to transmission and storage of water. No address available. Negotiations with County interests and other possibly effected landowners. Government Code Section 54956.8. b. Conference call with legal counsel re: Existing Litigation – Government Code Section 54956.9. Arbitration proceeding with Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District. OPEN SESSION: 17. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION (AGENDA ITEM NO. 16). There was no Closed Session. a. Negotiations. b. Existing Litigation/Arbitration. (Continued Business Items): 18. STATUS REPORT OF EEL RIVER PROJECT. (AGENDA ITEM #17) No action. 19. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT. (AGENDA ITEM #18). Roland Sanford of the Mendocino County Water Agency believes that a test well and a surface diversion will benefit the project. Mendocino County Supervisor Delbar has stated that he is not willing to do this, therefore Roland Sanford requested that the District write a letter to the Board of Supervisors asking for participation in the test well in Talmage. There was no objection from the Board for Chairman Butow to pen a letter to the Board of Supervisors. Operations Manager Wallen reported that all authorized funds have been expended to date, and the District is about at 80% annual budget. Potential cost sharing may be coming up with the County of Mendocino. A report from Roland Sanford is expected and Operations Manager Wallen would prefer to wait until the report comes before any more funds are expended. It is his suggestion that we authorize the funds and the Operations Manager can monitor the funds until we hear further from Mr. Sanford. MOTION: Authorize $12,000 for the Mill Creek Project. A report should be received from Recovery Operations Specialty Service (R.O.S.S.) and Operations Manager Wallen will monitor the project and give a report at the April 21, 2004 meeting. Groth/Howe CARRIED Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Noes: Keith Tiemann Abstain: None Absent: None The Meeting ended at 10:20 p.m. The next meeting will be a Continued Regular Meeting to be held at 7:00 P.M. on Wednesday, April 21, 2004, at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California. The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, May 6, 2004 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California. Respectfully submitted, Kathy Davidson Recording Secretary APPROVED: Board of Directors DATE: SIGNED: Secretary, Board of Directors