HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-03-04 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
Board of Directors
Regular Meeting
March 4, 2004
CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 P.M.
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann
Directors Excused: William L. Howe, John W. Groth
Staff Present: David Wallen, Operations Manager; Paula Berezay, Assistant Office Manager
Recording Secretary: Kathy Davidson
Members of the Public: Roy and Barbara Beck, Bob Anderson
1. ROLL CALL: Robert F. Parker, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
None .
3. CONSIDER PINECREST DRIVE CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF EXCESSIVE WATER CHARGES BETWEEN 12/20/03 – 01/20/04.
Defer to next meeting.
4. CONSIDER EAST ROAD CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF EXCESSIVE WATER CHARGES BETWEEN 12/20/03 – 01/20/04.
Defer to next meeting.
5. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
Staff was asked for an explanation of payment on Water Rights fee- Operations Manager Wallen explained that everyone who has a Water Rights Permit was assessed by the State Board of
Equalization.
Page 3, Item 6: Rental of copier:
Operations Manager Wallen explained that it was a loaner rental on the printer. Item 6 should be corrected to printer, not copier as listed.
Page 6, Item1: Director Tiemann stated that he did not believe staff had authorization from the Board to spend $200 for the April seminar in preparation for a D-2 Certification Review
Class. Tiemann expressed his frustration that the February Minutes were not available to support his recollection. He also questioned why the Minutes were late and unavailable for
review, and said he felt the turnaround time to get the Minutes to the Board is too long.
Chairman Butow asked the Operations Manager to place the matter of McBride’s authorization on the agenda for the next meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid As Approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
Items 4 & 5: These items showed numerous discussions with the RVCWD and other parties. Director Tiemann feels that he and the full Board should also be involved with those calls and
wonders if decisions are being made at this level. Operations Manager Wallen clarified that most of the calls were between himself and the subjects mentioned; routine status reports
are routed through the Operations Manager. No Board Members are particularly being cut out.
d. Special Expenditure Fund status report.
e. District Activity.
f. Mail Log.
MOTION: Approve Consent Calendar as Corrected on b-1, page 3, item 6.
Approval is withheld from b-1, page 6, item 1 regarding McBride
registration for Distribution Certification Review Class.
Parker/Tiemann CARRIED
Ayes: Parker, Butow, Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Howe, Groth
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF JANUARY 7, 2004 AS PRESENTED.
Director Tiemann objected to the wording regarding a failed motion under the Minutes Item #7, approving Consent Calendar without Section b-1. Director Tiemann does not remember making
a motion. It was suggested that the tapes be reviewed by Director Tiemann to ascertain if he made a motion or just a comment.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes as Corrected with a minor typographical error in the spelling of Brelje on page 7; with asking Staff for a clarification on the Minutes report of Agenda
Item #7, failed motion; and a report back to the Board of Directors on a response to the Planning & Building Department in the Minutes report of Agenda Item #21.
Parker/Tiemann CARRIED
Ayes: Parker, Butow, Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Howe, Groth
7. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
MOTION: Hear item regarding Progress Payment No. 1 to Jeffco Painting & Coating, Inc. as recommended by Brelje & Race engineers.
Parker/Tiemann CARRIED
Ayes: Parker, Tiemann, Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Howe, Groth
The District received Progress Billing #1 on March 2, 2004 for Clarifier #1 Project. Inspector Charlie Fisher feels the project was at 95% completion this past week; and as of today,
the project is complete. Brelje & Race recommends payment of Progress Billing #1 in the amount of $119,116.70, less the 10% retention of $11,911.67, which comes to $107,205.03. Both
Fisher and the Operations Manager were very pleased with the operation.
MOTION: Release funds for Progress Payment No. 1, in the amount of $107,205.03, to Jeffco Painting & Coating, Inc.
Parker/Tiemann CARRIED
Ayes: Parker, Tiemann, Butow,
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Howe, Groth
8. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION
TOPICS.
a) Request for submittal of Form(s) 700, due from Board members, as required by the County.
a) Reminder to the Board of Directors that the Forms are due and need to be submitted to the County Clerk’s office.
Director Parker reported the County Clerk’s office told him the directors do not have to submit a separate schedule for the director stipends.
b) Report regarding Prop 50 information @ Russian River public agency meeting.
Operations Manager Wallen reported on the Integrated Regional Improvement Plan, but no forms were available as yet. There is no guarantee that money is there. Guidelines are very broad
at this point and still being developed, but there will be ongoing efforts to band together various projects to become a regional project. Sonoma County says, give us anything along
the river, and we will make it regional.
9. STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS.
a) Status Report of Uva Drive Hardship Application.
The Hardship Water Service Installation is being planned at this time and will be done this upcoming month.
b) Status Report of West Road Railroad Crossing Project.
Nothing to Report
c) Status Report of Clarifier #1 Rehabilitation Project.
The project is at the point of completion. Refilling will be complete this week, and testing has been done.
d) Redwood Valley Improvement Association Meeting(s).
The Operations Manager was unable to attend, however Directors Parker and Tiemann were in attendance. The next meeting is March 11, 2004. Although it was an interesting meeting, it
seemed redundant. The purpose was to brainstorm and that was accomplished. There was a comment regarding water district easements on West Road. The Department of Transportation said
that those easements are specifically for certain functions and cannot be used for other things such as bike or horse trails. The main interests seem to be generally looking for city-type
amenities such as cable tv, natural gas, etc., but they wish to maintain the rural character of Redwood Valley. A small amount of grant money has been received and the group has hired
a professional firm from out of the area to hear comments and come out with a report.
e) Auditor attendance at April/May Regular Meeting.
Operations Manager Wallen spoke with Auditor Rick Bowers about his schedule for presenting the Year End Financial Report to the Board of Directors as requested. It looks like April
or May will be the timeframe for Mr. Bowers to attend a Board Meeting.
Continued Business Items:
10. BUDGET, MONTHLY UPDATE.
The monthly update was presented.
Director Tiemann commented on the fact that he felt the District had no business operating in a deficit budget. Chairman Butow explained that the uniqueness of the District and its search
for water, makes this situation a necessity. Major capitol funds are set aside for improvements and other needs of the District, so funding for the reserve is not in jeopardy. After
a discussion on how the budget was created and why the contingency fund contained Bureau of Reclamation funds, it was suggested that the Operations Manager speak with the Auditor regarding
the Bureau of Reclamation funding ‘set aside’ and how it should be classified to protect the reserve. In the past, a reserve amount of $245,000 was placed in the L.A.I.F. account on
an annual basis. Part of those reserve funds are now being used to improve the District’s equipment and facilities. Director Tiemann felt that since the rates charged during those
years was accrued from deliberately “low priced” water rates, that now is the time to consider raising water rates so that these funds will always be there and keep the reserve stable.
The
consensus was that the reserve funds are being spent right now for the survival of our District in its pursuit of developing water sources and also for maintenance of a 25-year old system.
We are on target.
11. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION.
a) Report of attendance at Inland Water & Power Commission Meetings.
Chairman Butow offered an overview, stating the IW&PC is in the throes of trying to determine how to work with the County Water Agency in regards to the issue of a dam-raising feasibility
study. The Corps of Engineers received $100,000 to have as a budget in matching funds to the community, which was originally going to be the 5-agency-member Inland Water & Power Commission.
However, the Board of Supervisors pulled the County Water Agency out of the IW&PC. As it turned out, the County Water Agency, the IW&PC and the Russian River Flood Control District
have each filed to be the lead agency in filing for the Feasibility Study.
Chairman Butow said that, “in trying to find water storage for 17,000 acre feet off the West Fork, and knowing all the space behind the dam as it exists today is not being used, we wondered
if Redwood Valley could ‘play in it’.” Chairman Butow and Dallas Miller talked to Mr. O’Hagen at the State Water Resources Control Board, who told them, No. He said only Russian River
and Sonoma County because they paid for the construction, etc., etc. Chairman Butow said he “asked this question because the Corps of Engineers recently told Redwood Valley and the
IW&PC that the chances of raising the dam are nil & none. For a lot of reasons, but the big one is, money, the chances of getting enough money to do it. The questions was, well if
we can’t raise the dam, can we use the Feasibility Study as to how we can access that extra 20-foot layer in the lake that’s never been used. Oh, yeah, we can do that, according to
the County Water Agency, according to Janet Pauli at the IW&PC, according to RRFCD. I said, wait a minute, there is something wrong with this picture. The only people that can play
in that lake is the RRFCD. Has anybody bothered to ask anybody else around here, if we spend this money, do we have the right to get water out of that lake or have access to storage
in that lake. Nobody could answer that question; they said it hadn’t occurred to them. I said, well this is what we are being told by officials in charge.”
Chairman Butow told them that before Redwood Valley spends any money or commits to infrastructure changes, or costs for the Feasibility Study he will check with our legal counsel for
his opinion. That opinion will be reviewed and discussed with the full Board of Directors.
Director Parker said that this District has already approved some money for the first year, and nobody is asking for approval beyond that amount of time.
Chairman Butow said at the recent IW&PC meeting and in several trial balloon MOU Agreements between the various agencies, IW&PC, RRFCD and MCWA, it would indicate that they’re getting
into a commitment situation where they will want us to go forward. He told Roland Sanford that he could not see how Redwood Valley could get involved in a feasibility study, with the
expenses RV is incurring to develop water. Should we be spending our money on this, if we’re not going to be getting any water out of it? We need to have a ruling; if they’re going
to give up on the idea of raising the dam and now they’re going to change the intent, then we want to take another look at it before we get committed.
Director Parker said the IW&PC, FCD and MCWA have filed as a joint lead agency for a dam raising feasibility study. There are four phases to the study – dredge the lake, raise water
level, change spillway, raise dam.
Attorney Minasian researched the issue and the District received a fax of his opinion today and the Board has not had a chance to review and discuss it.
Chairman Butow reported on the Special Meeting of the Board of Directors to consider funding litigation as a member of the IW&PC. Janet Pauli attended and Attorney Minasian participated
by phone, in a discussion regarding the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) decision regarding the Eel River diversion at Potter Valley. The meeting had to be called on President’s
Day as no other time was available. There was a question as to the validity of the meeting since it was held on a holiday. Attorney Minasian advised that it was appropriate to have
the meeting, considering the time restrictions. The vote was in support of IW&PC action in filing an appeal.
b) Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC.
None.
c) Consider Cost-share to Feasibility Study for Corps of Engineers.
Everything is on hold until the letter from counsel can be reviewed and discussed.
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT.
Report of Attendance at Flood Control District Meetings.
None.
b) Consider Any Correspondence Concerning the Flood Control District.
None.
c) Consider Letter of Inquiry to Flood Control District Regarding Their Desire to Offer RVCWD a Contract for Water under Current Provisions.
It was the consensus of the Board that there was no point to considering a letter to the RRFCD.
TIMED ITEM: 8:30 P.M.
13. CLOSED SESSION There was no closed session.
a) Real Property Negotiations - Government Code Section 54956.8.
Conference with Real Property Negotiators.
Address of Property: Water within Lake Mendocino available to Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District, Sonoma County Water Agency, Mendocino County
Water Agency or other water by substitution.
Action Proposed: No formal Action is anticipated.
Instructions will be provided to the Real Property Negotiators
consisting of the Attorney and Board of Directors representatives.
b) Real Property Negotiations; Report of Negotiator, Donald Butow, in regard to progress or lack of progress in negotiations for access to Mill Creek water sources, rights of way,
easements or interests in real property related to transmission and storage of water. No address available.
Negotiations with County interests and other possibly effected landowners.
Government Code Section 54956.8.
c. Conference call with legal counsel re: Existing Litigation - Government Code
Section 54956.9.
Arbitration proceeding with Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District.
14. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 13.
a) Real Property Negotiations.
b) Real Property Negotiations.
c) Existing Litigation/Arbitration.
No report; there was no Closed Session.
Break 8:43
Reconvene 8:57
Continued Business Items
15. STATUS REPORT OF EEL RIVER PROJECT.
Nothing to report.
16. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT.
The Operations Manager reported that Mr. Toy of the State Water Resources Control Board is now not accepting the maps that R.O.S.S. first presented. A request was made for an additional
$5000 for engineering and $5000 for consultants for the Mill Creek project to cover the new topo maps. The State wants different and more current maps.
MOTION: Approve $5000 for consultants and $5000 for engineering, on the Mill Creek project, for new topo maps that the State now requires.
Parker/
Motion Failed for lack of a second.
17. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT.
Some questions are being answered; things are going along well and under budget. There is about $16,000 available.
18. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES.
The maps have been received and a copy has been sent to counsel for further analysis and submission.
19. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT.
The District is waiting for Roland Sanford to complete an Operational Study. He has offered to take the District’s numbers and crunch them so that the District can
approach the State Water Resources Control Board with our updated data to modify our Permit to draw at a lower point. At this time there is no cost to the District, however it may cost
in the neighborhood of $1000 at some point.
20. APPOINT COMMITTEE TO REVIEW BY-LAWS AND SPECIAL DISTRICT HANDBOOK.
Directors Tiemann and Parker were appointed as a subcommittee to develop a Special District Board Member Handbook.
21. APPOINT DIRECTOR AS DELEGATE OF ACWA/JOINT POWERS INSURANCE AUTHORITY AND APPOINT STAFF AS ALTERNATE DELEGATE.
Appoint Director Keith Tiemann as Delegate and Operations Manager Wallen as the Alternate Delegate.
MOTION: Authorize Director Tiemann to attend the May 2004, ACWA/Joint Powers Insurance Authority Semi-Annual Meeting.
Parker/ Tiemann CARRIED
Ayes: Parker, Butow, Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Howe, Groth
New Business Items:
22. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS, CONFERENCES AS RECEIVED.
a) ACWA Region 1 Membership Meeting March 24, 2004 in Santa Rosa, California.
The Operations Manager will attend and if Director Tiemann is available he will also attend.
b) 2004 ACWA Legislative Symposium, March 29-30, 2004 in Sacramento, California.
MOTION: Authorize a Director, to be determined as available, to attend the
2004 ACWA Legislative Symposium,
March 29-30, 2004 in Sacramento, California.
Tiemann/ Parker CARRIED
Ayes: Tiemann, Parker, Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Howe, Groth
The Meeting ended at 9:32 p.m.
The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 PM on Thursday, April 1, 2004 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully submitted,
Kathy Davidson,
Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE:
SIGNED:
Secretary, Board of Directors