Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-06-15 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT 2370 Webb Ranch Road P. O. Box 399 Redwood Valley CA 95740 (707) 485-0679 MINUTES Board of Directors Continued Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 15, 2004 CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 P.M. Directors Present: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow Staff Present: David Wallen, Operations Manager Linda Groth, Office Manager Public Present: Rick Bowers, CPA 1. ROLL CALL: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann Donald E. Butow 2. HEAR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC. None in attendance at this time. 3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED. This Item to be considered later in the Meeting. 7:05 p.m. Other Members of the Public arrived: Rich Respini, Rosalind Peterson, Ross Mayfield and Dallas Miller of Recovery Operations Specialty Services 4. AUDITOR PRESENTATION OF JUNE 30, 2003 FINANCIAL STATEMENT. Auditor Rick Bowers said he is here to assist the Directors in understanding the audit in its required new format and to answer any questions from the Board Members that may have arisen during their individual review of the document. He said although the format is different, the numbers are pretty consistent. Some clarifications were offered in answer to questions that were asked, and a couple of corrections were pointed out and confirmed. Also, it was noted that in the future reports, cross-referencing will be provided. Mr. Bowers said this brand new format is required of all Special Districts and will become more familiar to everyone in the coming years. MOTION: Approve financial statement with modifications as discussed. Anderson/Howe Discussion: None MOTION CARRIED Ayes: Anderson, Groth, Butow, Howe, Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 7:24 P.M. Mr. Bowers was thanked for attending and he left the Meeting at this time. 5. HEAR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC (Agenda Item #2) Member of the public, Rich Respini questioned the unpleasant taste and odor of the water. Chairman Butow said the Board agrees this is not the usual time of year for the taste and odor problem. He said that at the last Board Meeting, Staff was directed to seek out possible solutions to the problem. Operations Manager Wallen provided an overview of the historical taste and odor issues; and the decisions of previous Board’s to not seek an expensive permanent solution to a temporary problem. He further reported that the Engineer’s Report for dealing with the taste and odor problem will be ready for the July Regular Meeting and will be considered at that time. Member of the public, Rosalind Peterson asked if the State Health Department is aware of the taste and odor issue. Chairman Butow responded that Staff had previously been directed to seek out possible solutions to the problem, which included contacting the State Health Department to discuss the situation. He added that one of the Directors had also contacted the State Health Department and he then asked Director Tiemann why he felt he had to call the Department after Staff had already been directed to do so. Director Tiemann responded that he wanted to find out if there was anything that the State can do about this matter. Chairman Butow said that Staff had been directed to make contacts and research ways to address the matter, and that it was highly inappropriate for a Director to take it upon himself to go behind the directive of the Board. Rosalind Peterson said that she also called the State Health Department and they told her they would speak with the District and maybe offer some direction. She wondered if Mr. Burton had addressed the issue with the District. Operations Manager Wallen reported his call from the State Health Department office representative and the discussion of the District’s procedures, with which the State Health Department is satisfied. He said the State reiterated this is not a health issue. He further reported that he is looking at several possibilities and although the taste and odor problem is disappearing, tests are ongoing. It is possible that as Lake Mendocino is managed differently, this issue may be happening more frequently. Director Tiemann mentioned that Clearlake is experiencing the same problem and suggested that Staff should contact the water district at Clearlake. Director Groth interjected at this point, to Operations Manager Wallen: Yes or No: Have you called Clearlake to learn how they’ve dealt with the problem? Operations Manager Wallen responded: Yes. Director Groth said, Twenty-five years is long enough to put up with this problem; let’s move ahead. Member of the public Respini asked, Is it the Board’s consensus that they want a permanent solution? To which the Board responded, Yes. Director Tiemann added that when previous Boards of Directors were presented with the problem and costs to provide a solution to the taste and odor, they chose to not spend the money for a short-term problem. Director Howe asked Director Tiemann, What is the solution? Director Tiemann replied, Two granulated activated carbon towers. This Item is continued to the July Regular Meeting. 6. DIRECTOR AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION TOPICS. (Agenda Item # 5) Director Howe reported that the committee is working on the employee handbook update and in a couple more meetings will have something to present to the Board. 7. DIRECTOR AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS. (Agenda Item #6) a. Staffing, Operations. Operations Manager Wallen reported he has placed two ads, one for an Operations Manager, and, one for a Water Treatment Plant Operator 3. He has received some résumé’s for the committee to consider before bringing to the Board. b. Staffing, Clerical. Office Manager Groth reported that ads were placed for the vacancy of Clerical Support Staff and that as of Monday, June 14, 2004 the vacancy was filled. The new employee is Elizabeth Markowski. c. Operations Manager Wallen reported receiving a letter from the County Administrative Office concerning Grant Applications for local governmental agencies. MOTION: Hear Item. Howe/Anderson Operations Manager Wallen reported the Grant applications, which require sponsorship from local tribes, must be submitted by June 24, 2004. He is requesting the Board to authorize funding for Recovery Operations Specialty Services to assist the District in the proper submittal of the grant applications. Ross Mayfield said all the applicants write to the tribe asking them to support the projects listed. Requests are evaluated by the county, the tribe, etc, and they will rule on the grant and on who will benefit from the grant. MOTION: Authorize expenditure of up to $1,500.00 for Recovery Operations Specialty Services to prepare the Grant Applications. Anderson/Howe Discussion ensued. AYES: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, William L. Howe, Donald E. Butow NOES: Keith Tiemann ABSTAIN: None ABSENT: None 8. BUDGET, MONTHLY UPDATE (Agenda Item #7) Item was reported at the June 3 Regular Meeting. 9. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION (Agenda Item #8) a. Report of attendance at IW&PC meetings. Reported at last meeting. b. Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC. None c) Discussion and possible action on IW&PC topics, including SCWA topics such as previously discussed. Chairman Butow reported on the Draft Agreement for Sale of Surplus Water to Redwood Valley County Water District. He said Randy Poole of the Sonoma County Water Agency has been in discussion with the IW&PC over along period of time with the intent to present a sale of surplus water to the RVCWD. He further reported that it seems the IW&PC has asked Mr. Poole to not attend its June 17, 2004 meeting. Roland Sanford has been asked to be the go-between and set up a meeting at the MCWA office between Redwood Valley CWD and Mr. Poole, after which they would attend the IW&PC meeting. The Draft Agreement has been prepared by the SCWA Counsel and a copy has been forwarded to RVCWD Counsel for review and comments. Copies are available for the public and the matter will be agendized for the next Regular Meeting. Chairman Butow reported the standing order of Sonoma County Water Agency has been to not talk with individual small water agencies. Redwood Valley CWD has strongly supported the Mendocino County Water Agency, and it has been acting as facilitator for discussion. He said this Draft is a result. d) Consider Invoice No. 20043 from the IW&PC. Chairman Butow said the question is, does RVCWD wish to continue to support the appeal process regarding FERC? Operations Manager Wallen reported Mr. Poole says the Sonoma County Water Agency prefers to sit-back at this time. Chairman Butow said the consideration is, now that RVCWD has the draft agreement, what is the decision to support the costs of the appeal? Director Groth said that since attending the Flood Control Meeting last night, he would like to report on that meeting and it would work hand-in-hand with discussion of both agencies. He reported that as far as cost-sharing, Roland Sanford said the Board of Supervisors will meet on July 27, 2004. Also, 1. if you don’t appeal, it’s over and done with. 2. if you appeal and they decline it, there is no more money involved. Director Anderson said you probably could further appeal it to Superior Court and that would cost more. Director Howe suggests waiting on that decision until the July Meeting to learn more about the County’s participation. Chairman Butow said that since the payment was approved at a previous meeting, no motion is required at this point. He said that four members of the IW&PC continue to pursue the goal of raising the dam. He further reported that the Corps of Engineers said raising the dam won’t happen; however, reconfiguring the existing dam might happen. The issue is that Sonoma County Water Agency owns the water in the pool. Chairman Butow reported he asked Randy Poole, if there is an effort to study infrastructure modification, would it have to be worked through the Sonoma County Water Agency? He said that Randy Poole responded, that is absolutely true. Chairman Butow concluded, for Redwood Valley to get involved with studies, without Sonoma County Water Agency involvement and cooperation, would result in spending a lot of money for nothing. The question is, does Redwood Valley continue to participate in this project, or pull out? Director Howe wondered if there is a reason why Redwood Valley, Sonoma County Water Agency and Mendocino County Water Agency could not get together and why the Flood Control District won’t deal with those two agencies. Director Groth reminded the Board that Attorney Minasian says that unless Sonoma County Water Agency is a participant, Redwood Valley won’t get anywhere with this project. Director Groth said that the lake is designed to hold 122,000 acre-feet and the Flood Control District has 8,000 a-f with a contingency for 6,000 a-f. He suggests considering 1. partner with Sonoma County Water Agency 2. set a limitation, change infrastructure before raising the dam 3. once Draft is signed, Redwood Valley should be willing to talk. Ross Mayfield mentioned that for the past several months the Inland Water & Power Commissioners have had the opportunity to talk with Randy Poole and get something accomplished. He said it is remarkably sad that the Commissioners have given Randy Poole the cold shoulder. 8:45 p.m. Break 9:00 p.m. Reconvene Chairman Butow asked, what would the Board like me to do Thursday night? support the IW&PC as lead agency, or not? They have to have a letter to the Corps by July 1st. Director Howe commented, say no, because they are not allowing Sonoma County Water Agency to be involved. Director Groth said he agrees. Counsel says paying money without SCWA is paying money with no guarantee of water. Director Groth also said he doesn’t like tying two issues to the same money, reconfiguration or raising the dam. There is too much infighting amongst the agencies involved and he feels they have slapped SCWA in the face. Director Anderson asked, what is the implication to Redwood Valley, to vote against IW&PC being the lead agency? Chairman Butow said, none. It was the consensus of the Board that a Motion isn’t necessary at this time. Chairman Butow will tell the IW&PC that Redwood Valley CWD is interested in a guarantee of water and that the Flood Control District cannot sell water it doesn’t own. 10. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. (Agenda Item #9). a. Report of attendance at Flood Control District meetings. b. Consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID. c. Discussion and possible action of Flood Control District topics. Comments included in above discussion combining IW&PC and RRFCD. 11. ADOPT RESOLUTION AND UPDATE OF BANK SIGNATURE CARDS. (Agenda Item #15) Office Manager Groth explained that any time there is a signature change on the bank accounts, a Resolution is required. MOTION: Adopt Resolution No. 04-1, updating the bank signature cards. Anderson/Howe Discussion ensued. Ayes: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 12. ADOPT RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR EXECUTION OF PAYMENT OF INVOICES FOR OPERATIONAL PURPOSES. (Agenda Item #16). Matter carried to July Regular Meeting. 13. ASSIGN COMMITTEE MEMBERS TO REPLACE VACANCY ON COMMITTEES (DUE TO DIRECTOR RESIGNATION). (Agenda Item #17). Matter carried to July Regular Meeting. 14. DISCUSS NOTICE OF PREPARATION SUPPLEMENTAL EIR FROM THE SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY. (Agenda Item #18). It was noted this document is for information only. Public input period has closed. 15. CONSIDER ISSUE OF SMALL WATER SYSTEMS BY DEVELOPERS WITHIN DISTRICT BOUNDARIES AS REFERENCED BY PLANNING DEPARTMENT. (Agenda Item #19). Operations Manager Wallen reported the Planning Commission is trying to give the Board of Supervisors some direction on this type of issue, so it is soliciting general information from this District. What are ramifications if small water systems can no longer supply water? How does Redwood Valley feel about this - can it offer some guidelines for them to take to the Board of Supervisors? Discussion ensued. Matter continued to the July Regular Meeting. 16. AUTHORIZE STAFF TO REQUEST OPINION OF ATTORNEY MINASIAN IN REGARD TO REDWOOD VALLEY RANCHERIA WATER SERVICE IN TIMES OF RATIONING. (Agenda Item #20) Chairman Butow expressed concern about serving this account during times of rationing. MOTION: Have Staff request opinion of Attorney Minasian in regard to Redwood Valley Rancheria water service in times of rationing. Anderson/Howe Discussion ensued. Ayes: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 17. CONSIDER CHANGE OF POLICY ON CHARGES FOR COPIES OF CERTAIN DOCUMENTS. (Agenda Item #21) Director Groth presented his reasons and suggestion that the Board consider waiving charges for copies of either the Board Meeting Agenda or the Board Meeting Minutes, if a request for copies is submitted within 30 days of the meeting. If the request is for copies of documents beyond a 30-day period, the usual copy fees will apply. This does not include the Board Meeting Packet, for which the usual copy fees will apply. MOTION: No charge for copies of Board of Directors Agenda or Meeting Minutes if the request is within 30 days of such meeting. If request is also for mailing the document, the costs associated with mailing are not charged to the requestor. Anderson/Howe Discussion ensued. AYES: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann NOES: None ABSTAIN: None ABSENT: None 18. CONSIDER SOLARBEE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR UPGRADES. (Agenda Item #22). Matter carried to July Regular Meeting. 19. STATUS REPORT OF EEL RIVER PROJECT. (Agenda Item #23). Matter carried to July Regular Meeting. 20. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT. (Agenda Item #24). Ross Mayfield reported that the Preliminary Report from the County says water is there for Redwood Valley County Water District. He distributed copies of a 1977 hydraulic analysis for review. Discussion followed. This Matter is continued to the July Regular Meeting. 21. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT. (Agenda Item #25). Dallas Miller and Ross Mayfield provided an update to the habitat and hydrologic studies completed and steps necessary to proceed. EIP Consulting Services is prepared to provide its services to the District, through Recovery Operations Specialty Services, for furthering the studies, etc. This would be an additional $17,800.00. Director Groth said he recalls Roland Sanford was going to contact people, with whom he has previously worked, to do this; and also that MCWA had indicated they were going to share the costs of the fish studies. Chairman Butow added that Roland Sanford had said the EIP would do a very satisfactory job and that at this point, the County was going to step in and share some costs. Dallas Miller said that Roland Sanford had indicated very clearly to Recovery Operations Specialty Services that the County is not going to participate in costs. Mr. Miller had thought Mr. Sanford had already talked to Redwood Valley about this. Operations Manager Wallen was asked to contact Mr. Sanford to find out about this decision that none of the Directors knew about. Director Groth also asked R.O.S.S. if the County might have the maps that are needed. Mr. Mayfield said that the maps R.O.S.S. originally submitted are correct and also that Brelje & Race engineers agrees. This matter is continued to the July Regular Meeting. 22. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES. (Agenda Item #26) Matter carried to the July Regular Meeting. 23. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT. (Agenda Item #27) Mendocino County Water Agency is doing some number crunching on the operation of the dam. The agency hasn’t asked Redwood Valley for any information yet. Matter carried to the July Regular Meeting. 24. REVISIT THE DOMESTIC WATER SERVICE PRICING STRUCTURE IN THE RATIONING PLAN IN ORDER TO DISCOURAGE EXCESSIVE USAGE. (Agenda Item #28). Matter Carried to the July Regular Meeting. 25. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS, CONFERENCES AS RECEIVED. (Agenda Item #29). Matter carried to the July Regular Meeting. Break 10:00 p.m. Reconvene 10:10 p.m. Meeting reconvened and immediately went into Closed Session. 10:11 p.m. 26. CLOSED SESSION: (Agenda Item #10) a. Real Property Negotiations - Government Code Section 54956.8. Conference with Real Property negotiators. Address of Property: Water within Lake Mendocino available to Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District, Sonoma County Water Agency, Mendocino County Water Agency or other water by substitution. Action Proposed: No formal Action is anticipated. Action will be provided to the Real Property Negotiators consisting of the Attorney and Board of Directors representatives. b. Real Property Negotiations; Report of Negotiator, Donald Butow, in regard to progress or lack of progress in negotiations for access to Mill Creek water sources, rights of way, easements or interests in real property related to transmission and storage of water. No address available. Negotiations with County interests and other possibly effected landowners. Government Code Section 54956.8. c. Conference call with legal counsel re: Existing Litigation - Government Code Section 54956.9. Arbitration proceeding with Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District. d. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Operations Manager – Government Code 54957(e). Director Groth left the Meeting in Closed Session before the evaluation of the Office Manager. e. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Office Manager - Government Code 54957(e). Director Groth returned to the Meeting in Closed Session to participate in the evaluation of the Laborer. f. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Laborer - Government Code 54957(e) OPEN SESSION: 10:25 p.m. 27. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 26. (Agenda Item #11) a. Negotiations, Real Property b. Negotiations, Real Property c. Negotiations, Existing Litigation d. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Operations Manager e. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Office Manager f. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Laborer. Chairman Butow reported that discussions in Closed Session were only in regard to the Public Employee Performance Evaluations and none regarding negotiations. 28. CONSIDER MERIT INCREASE FOR OPERATIONS MANAGER. (Agenda Item #12) Matter was preempted by Letter of Resignation. Director Groth left the Meeting. 29. CONSIDER MERIT INCREASE FOR OFFICE MANAGER. (Agenda Item #13) It was determined that the old Merit Increase procedure is still in effect, 0% to 5% cap. MOTION: Based upon Public Employee Performance Evaluation, award 5% merit increase to Linda Groth, Office Manager. Anderson/Howe Discussion: None AYES: Robert L. Anderson, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe NOES: Keith Tiemann ABSTAIN: None ABSENT: John W. Groth Director Groth returned to the Meeting. 30. CONSIDER MERIT INCREASE FOR LABORER. (Agenda Item #14) MOTION: Based upon Public Employee Performance Evaluation, award 5% merit increase to Scott Norcross, Laborer. Howe/Groth Discussion ensued. AYES: Robert L. Anderson, John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann NOES: None ABSTAIN: None ABSENT: None The Meeting ended at 10:30 p.m. The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. on Thursday, July 1, 2004 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California. APPROVED: Board of Directors DATE: SIGNED: Secretary, Board of Directors