HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004-02-05 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
Board of Directors
Regular Meeting
February 5, 2004
CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 p.m.
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker,
William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Staff Present: David Wallen, Operations Manager; Linda Groth, Office Manager
Recording Secretary : Kathy Davidson
Members of the Public: Irma Turner, Roy and Barbara Beck
ROLL CALL: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
APPOINTMENTS TO COMMITTEES AND COMMISSIONS
Appoint commissioner and alternate commissioner to ACWA/Utility Services Agency.
On January 7, 2004, Director Tiemann and Operations Manager Wallen were appointed with a request for staff to find out whether Staff or Director should be the lead delegate. Staff reported
that the organization (ACWA/Utility Services Agency) has dissolved, and so the question no longer applies. Therefore Director Tiemann and Operations Manager Wallen were removed officially
in District records from the appointed commission.
Appointment of representatives and alternate representatives to North Coast Joint Power Authority Executive Committee.
On January 7, 2004, Operations Manager Wallen and Director Tiemann were appointed with a request for staff to find out whether Staff or Director should be the lead delegate. Staff reported
that it does not matter and that the previous delegate was Staff. This agency is also planned to be dissolved concurrently with ACWA/USA since the anticipated savings are not being
realized. However,
it was suggested that the District make the appointment, in order to be included in the voting process regarding dissolution of the agency. Therefore Operations Manager Wallen will
remain the Representative and Director Tiemann will remain the Alternate Representative.
Appointment of delegate and alternate delegate to ACWA/Joint Powers Insurance Authority. Staff was directed to find out whether Staff or Director should be the lead delegate. Staff
reported that it does not matter therefore Operations Manager David Wallen was appointed as lead delegate with Director Tiemann as alternate delegate.
HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
Member of the public, Roy Beck asked the Board what prevents increasing water levels at Lake Mendocino Dam and asked for additional information about a newspaper article regarding reducing
flows in Potter Valley. Discussion followed.
APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
Financial Statement
b-1) Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting
Director Tiemann recommended that a payroll item on Consent Calendar b-1 should show the break-out of the Operations Manager and Office Manager earnings. There was a consensus by the
Board to include a break-out in future Consent Calendar reports.
b-2) Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting
c) Bills Payable
It was determined that Item #7 should be corrected to indicate West Fork, not West Road.
Director Tiemann questioned the stipend increments and amount, and specifically Chairman Butow’s expense report listing a two hour meeting with Irma Turner, candidate for Board of Supervisors.
Chairman Butow offered his reasons for submitting the item.
Director Tiemann questioned the Board’s interpretation of the rules regarding stipend per day/per meeting. He also did not feel that individual Board members should meet with individuals
or at special meetings without the entire Board’s awareness, presence or prior approval. The Chairman and other Board members related that many of the meetings they have attended had
little notice and it was unlikely that they would have ample time to call and conduct a special meeting to ask approval to attend a short-noticed meeting . Tiemann felt a salaried person
should be the one who attends these meetings so that the Board does not charge the District for their attendance.
Chairman Butow said that the Directors are working very hard to acquire water and it is important that Directors also attend, in addition to the Operations Manager.
Director Groth commented that he had a concern at a recent meeting where he and another member were the designated representatives. A third Director also attended, which was not a problem,
but the third Director spoke on behalf of the District and so in accordance with the Brown Act, Director Groth felt he could not bring his prepared issues to the meeting. He requested
that any attending Board member, not designated as a representative, refrain from speaking at the meeting to avoid this problem in the future. After discussion, Staff was directed
by the Chairman to contact District Counsel with a request to make a determination regarding two or more Board members representing the District in a meeting.
d) Special Expenditure Fund Status Report
e) District Activity
f) Mail Log
MOTION: Contact Attorney to obtain a legal opinion on the Brown Act as to what constitutes a conflict when two or more Board members are attending and speaking at a meeting.
Tiemann/Howe CARRIED
Ayes: William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker
Abstain: None
Absent: None
Director Tiemann asked why Michael McBride did not appear before the Board to report what he had learned at a recent workshop. Chairman Butow stated that this workshop was standard
staff training. Whether or not it is necessary for staff who attend training to report directly to the Board at a meeting, was a decision made by the Operations Manager. Director
Tiemann requested that the following be part of the Minutes. “The Board does not wish to hear a verbal report.” Chairman Butow said the Board authorized his attendance, and is satisfied.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as Corrected on Consent Calendar C, Item 7.
Howe/Parker CARRIED
Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent:
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF JANUARY 7, 2004
No minutes were presented for approval.
6. 6. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
Director Parker advised the Board of a Notice, Section 7 Draft biological assessment which he had obtained a copy of, at no cost. It is available to any of the Directors for review.
He said there will be a meeting in Sonoma County tomorrow and later in Mendocino County.
7. 7. DIRECTOR AND STAFF REPORTS OF NON-ACTION TOPICS
a) Report of SolarBee recommendations.
SolarBee gave the District an “Action List” for modifications
Changes in hose levels (this would be at no cost to the District)
A solar panel for 24 hours per day operation. Operations Manager will review those costs in the upcoming budget year.
Also, a valve was opened on the west side of the pond, to avoid any chance of operating two pumps with only one valve open.
b) Staff Certification update.
Over the last 1-1/2 months, Michael McBride, Maintenance Supervisor, completed basic math and water courses and is now applying for a D-2 exam.
Operations Manager Wallen now has a Grade 2 Certification.
Operations Manager Wallen has recently completed his Associate of Arts Degree.
c) Director Tiemann said he received a copy of the Special District Handbook and
has several areas he would like to discuss for consideration.
Director Parker stated that the Board has been awaiting the seating of the new
Board members, so a committee can be appointed to review and update these
documents.
Chairman Butow instructed staff to place this matter on the next meeting agenda.
8. 8. STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS
Status report of Uva Drive Hardship Application: The Operations Manager and the property owner will meet tomorrow afternoon.
Status report of West Road railroad crossing project: Mendocino County may possibly schedule this project in 2004-2005. The Operations Manager is checking monthly to see if there are
any changes.
Status report of Filter rehabilitation project: # 2 filter is complete and back on line. Even though there was a cost increase which was approved by Directors Groth and Butow, repairs
were done below budget projections, and excess costs still came in below budget.
Status report of Clarifier #1 rehabilitation project: Project is about 90% complete and we expect inspection next week.
Update on search for fireproof filing cabinets: After checking three sources, for a 4 drawer fireproof file cabinet with a one-hour burn, the two lowest bids were $1271 and $1500 delivered
and set up. Board consensus was to hold off for a few months to review again.
Consider any changes in the Agenda format: A Board consensus was to put items for discussion or action (where there would likely be public in attendance) earlier in the agenda as a
courtesy to the public. Also to move Closed Session closer to the end of the agenda as a courtesy to the public.
Auditor attendance at March 4, 2004 Regular Meeting: Office Manager Groth informed the Board that the Auditor is planning to attend the March 4, 2004 Regular meeting.
Break: 8:30 p.m.
Reconvene: 8:45 p.m.
Continued Business Items:
BUDGET MONTHLY UPDATE
Monthly update was presented.
Director Tiemann commented on the Budget format, water rates and potential rate increases.
INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION
Report of attendance at Inland Water & Power Commission Meetings:
Consider any correspondence concerning the Inland Water & Power Commission:
Chairman Butow reported that IW&PC meetings have been contentious, with the main issue being who will be the lead agency for the Feasibility Study. Mendocino County, the Russian River
Flood Control District and the Inland Water & Power Commission have all filed.
Last January Janet Pauli wrote a letter suggesting that all three agencies work together and co-file as co-lead/co-sponsors for the Feasibility Study, to
preserve the funds currently available. Now the three agencies have to work out how to carry this forward. Redwood Valley has agreed to participate, but only its share of IW&PC .
Director Groth reported Chairman Butow was voted as Vice-Chair of the IW&PC. Director Parker reported he is acting as a member of the IW&PC subcommittee.
Randy Poole is looking to find some surplus water for the District for a short period of time and will have something drawn up to present to the Board. Decision 1610 is still in place
and whatever is received from the Sonoma County Water Agency will be carefully reviewed by the District.
Consider cost-share to Feasibility Study for Corps of Engineers:
An incomplete draft was received from Roland Sanford and given to the Board for review and comments. Details of the agreement and the District’s financial obligations were discussed.
Director Groth mentioned the Board should find out who will administer the money. Director Tiemann suggested that the agreement be reviewed by legal counsel before anything is submitted
to the Inland Water & Power Commission.
Participation in Russian River Watershed Association:
Dues are $5,000.00 per agency. The District has paid $1,000.00 of a 5-way split as members of the IW&PC . The City of Ukiah also paid $5,000.00.
Director Tiemann reported his attendance at last month’s meeting which was mostly a discussion of upcoming annual budget. Also, identification of historical sites on the Eel River were
discussed and Scotts Dam (over 100 years old) will be added to the project to protect that area.
MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT.
Report of attendance at Flood Control District meetings:
Director Groth reported discussion of FERC report, historical preservation review and fish count. Biological study from Sonoma County should be available in early February.
Director Groth further reported the Flood Control District voted and signed three letters regarding the Feasibility Study:
If the County doesn’t go along with Janet Pauli’s request for cooperation on the lead agency issue, the Flood Control District would go along with her request.
2) A letter of support of the IW&PC .
3) If necessary, the Flood Control District would drop out of the running
and allow the Inland Water & Power Commission to be the lead
agency.
b) Consider any correspondence from the Russian River Flood Control & Water
Conservation Improvement District: The billing issue is still under review and
was discussed. Operations Manager computed the billing discrepancies
where the Flood Control District added all legal and engineering firm
expenses. District counsel confirms that there are real questions concerning
the billing of 2002- 2003 as to what charges are appropriate.
CLOSED SESSION
There is nothing to be discussed in Closed Session at this time.
Since there was no Closed Session there was no action taken.
14. STATUS REPORT OF EEL RIVER PROJECT
Operations Manager Wallen reported the District has a permit which was filed prior to June, 2003, which is the retroactive date for increased fee rates of $10.00 per acre-foot. The
fee of $0.03 per acre foot was in effect when our permit was filed. We will have to wait and see what we are actually billed.
15. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT
Operations Manager Wallen reported the State does not recognize the topo maps from the original engineer with the Federal Bureau of Dams. After Dallas Miller goes to Sacramento and
puts ruler to the State records and gets further documentation, Brelje & Race will provide a current map and have it signed by one of its engineers. At that point the State should
be able to sign off the map. Ross Mayfield feels there could be many months delay due to the State budget crunch.
16. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT
Recovery Operations Specialty Services is answering questions as they are requested by the State.
17. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES
Brelje & Race was given documents last month and after information is provided for one specific location they will develop a map for Attorney Minasian to send to the State. It should
go smoothly after that.
18. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT
The Board of Supervisors has authorized Mendocino County Water Agency to go ahead with the reservoir operation study. Roland Sanford will have some numbers crunched for parameters for
lowering the draw point in the conservation pool and adjusting the flows in the river based upon a lower flow of the river. This should allow Redwood Valley to change its permit so
that we can get into the lake sooner.
19. a) Adopt policy that Bylaws and/or Handbook be reviewed annually and
suggested modifications be identified.
b) Set a month for reporting the review results to the Board, and for Board action.
c) Hear and consider recommended changes from the Employee Handbook Review Committee.
It was discussed and agreed that this Agenda Item will be for the Employee Handbook only.
MOTION: Have the Employee Handbook reviewed by June of each year and reported the following month.
Howe/Parker CARRIED
Ayes: Donald E. Butow, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: John W. Groth
Absent: None
New Business Items:
20. COMPENSATION FOR MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
Director Tiemann wondered how the wording of Resolution No. 03-03 was formulated. He was informed that legal counsel provided information as to the State Water Code and the Board of
Directors considered a remuneration amount that was appropriate. Director Tiemann introduced his request that the Resolution be changed to the exact wording of California Water Code
#30507 as follows: “Each director shall receive compensation in an amount not to exceed one hundred dollars ($100) per day, for each day’s attendance at meetings of the board or for
each day’s service rendered as a director by request of the board, not exceeding a total of six days in any calendar month, together with any
expenses incurred in the performance of his duties required or authorized by the board.”
Director Parker said, “Our Resolution doesn’t limit the number of meetings as long as we don’t exceed $600.00 per month.”
Director Howe asked Director Tiemann if he is limiting remuneration or limiting the number of days going to meetings.
Director Tiemann said, “It maxes out at $600.00, you can go to 30 meetings a month.”
Director Howe asked “OK, your concern is just for the dollars per month?”
Director Tiemann confirmed.
Chairman Butow said, “Well, fine, I’m not exceeding $100.00 per day, ever.”
Director Howe said, “Our existing Resolution says this level of compensation is too large.”
Director Tiemann said, “Right. What I’m proposing is the compensation be made $100.00 for each meeting and for each committee meeting, not to exceed 6 days per month.”
Chairman Butow said, “There is a difference between days and a meeting. Are you saying that a 15 minute meeting counts as a day?”
Director Tiemann said, “No, I am saying that you may go to 2 or 3 or 10 meetings in a day. A day is a day, regardless of how many meetings.”
Director Howe said, “”And you get paid $100 -.”
Director Tiemann said, “For that day.”
Director Groth asked, “So you want to increase the Stipend to $100.00?”
Director Tiemann said, “Yes.”
Chairman Butow said, “Alright, make a motion for what you want to say.”
Director Tiemann said, “My motion would be that we adopt the compensation rule in the California Water Code 30507 in the amount of $100.00, at a maximum of 6 days.”
MOTION: Adopt the Compensation Rule in the California Water Code 30607 in the amount of $100.00 per day, not exceeding a total of 6 days per month, together with expenses as authorized.
Tiemann/
Chairman Butow said, “So, I could easily be compensated at $600.00 per month for the amount of meetings I attend instead of the $147.00 I’ve gotten so far. This question came up before
and we decided $25.00 per meeting was sufficient.”
Director Groth said that local District’s were polled and it was found that compen- sation ranged from $15.00 to $75.00 per meeting in our County.
Chairman Butow said, “OK, we have a Motion on the table. Will anyone second the Motion?”
Director Groth said he would Second the Motion for the sake of conversation.
Tiemann/Groth
No further discussion.
Ayes: Keith Tiemann
Noes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe
Abstain: None
Absent: None
The Motion failed.
21. CONSIDER CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF EXCESSIVE WATER
CHARGES RESULTING FROM BREAK ON CUSTOMER PRIVATE LINE.
An explanation by Operations Manager Wallen was made to the Board and a discussion of the situation followed.
MOTION: Deny request for forgiveness of 1/3 charge. Return the check to the property owner and allow them the offered payment schedule.
Howe/Parker CARRIED
Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
22. APPROVE AGREEMENT FOR SPECIAL SERVICES EMPLOYMENT UPDATE BY
LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE.
MOTION: Approve Agreement for Special Services Employment update.
Howe/Groth CARRIED
Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
23. APPROVE SIGNORS FOR UPDATED BANK ACCOUNT SIGNATURE CARDS.
MOTION: Approve the following Signors for Bank Accounts: Donald E. Butow, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann, Linda Groth, David Wallen. Only one staff member may sign
on any check.
Howe/Parker CARRIED
Ayes: Donald E. Butow, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: John W. Groth
Absent: None
24. CONSIDER VERBAL INVITATION TO ATTEND THE NEXT MEETING OF THE
REDWOOD VALLEY IMPROVEMENT ASSOCIATION SCHEDULED FOR 7:00
P.M., WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 2004 AT REDWOOD VALLEY CELLARS.
This was an invitation to the Board of Directors and an open invitation to any resident of the valley. Operations Manager Wallen will be there to represent the District.
25. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS,CONFERENCES
AS RECEIVED SINCE THE LAST MEETING.
Operations Manager Wallen reported that Michael McBride is preparing for the Distribution 2 Test. The California Rural Water Association (CRWA) is sponsoring a two-day seminar in Sonoma,
California on April 7-8, 2004, to prepare applicants for taking the test, at a cost of $200.00 for the seminar, plus an overnight stay and mileage. Operations Manager Wallen feels
this Distribution Exam Preparation Seminar is valuable and he would like to send Mike McBride.
General discussion ensued.
Director Tiemann requested a verbal report from McBride, adding that he thinks it is important and necessary that the Board gets a report from anybody who goes to a seminar, spending
District money. He said, “The Board should know what the attendee is getting out of that. It’s very important. This is before the fact;
everybody knows it up-front. I’d like to have a report.”
Director Parker said, “Well at the same time I would too, and I’m sure we’ll get it, but I’m perfectly happy to get said report from Dave Wallen rather than McBride having to come up
to the Meeting.”
After further discussion, Director Groth offered, “McBride could just give a quick synopsis and present it to Dave Wallen to give to the Board, we don’t need McBride at the Meeting in
person.”
Director Parker said, “Dave Wallen is the one that found this meeting and who elected to send McBride.”
Chairman Butow added, “He’s also responsible for the training of the employees.”
Director Parker said, “Yes.”
Director Howe said, “Yes.”
MOTION: Authorize sending Mike McBride to the 2-day Seminar. The
decision of overnight accommodations to be made by the Operations
Manager. A synopsis report from McBride to the Operations Manager,
either verbal or written, and the Operations Manager will report to
the Board.
Groth/Howe CARRIED
Ayes: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Robert F. Parker, William L. Howe
Noes: Keith Tiemann
Abstain: None
Absent: None
The Meeting ended at 10:41 p.m.
The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 P.M.
on Thursday, March 4, 2004 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road,
Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully submitted,
Kathy Davidson, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE :
SIGNED:
Secretary, Board of Directors