HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006-09-21 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
Board of Directors
Regular Meeting
September 21, 2006
CALL TO ORDER: 7:04 p.m.
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann, Jeanette Hallman
Directors Excused: John W. Groth
Staff Present: General Manager Darin McCosker, Office Manager Linda Groth
Recording Secretary: Kathy Davidson
Members of the Public: Myron Sawicki, Susan Stacey-Henwood, Richard Henwood
1. ROLL CALL.
Keith Tiemann, William L. Howe, Jeanette Hallman, Donald E. Butow
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
No public in attendance
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS
POSTED.
None
4. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as Approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. Special Expenditure Fund status report.
e. District Activity.
f. Mail Log.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Howe/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: William L. Howe, Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: John W. Groth
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED.
The Minutes of August 17, 2006 were presented.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes of August 17, 2006 as presented.
Hallman/Tiemann Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: William L. Howe
Absent: John W. Groth
Chairman Butow acknowledged members of the public that arrived after the Meeting began.
Attorney Myron Sawicki said he and his associates are attending this Board of Directors Meeting to discuss the concerns of the owners of the property identified in the All Agencies M.O.U./Hopland
Storage Project.
The Board of Directors agreed to hear the matter at this time as a courtesy to the public, but stated any Board action would be made later in the Meeting when they reach Agenda Item
20 in consecutive order.
6. STATUS REPORT OF M.O.U. FOR ALL AGENCIES/HOPLAND STORAGE PROJECT. (AGENDA ITEM #20, part 1)
Attorney Myron Sawicki said he represents the owner of a property located in Hopland that is identified in the M.O.U. as having been offered for a water storage site. Mr. Sawicki read
a portion of a report he had obtained, identifying his clients property as a storage location. He said this is wrong, that his client has never consented to offering his property,
and his client never would consent to such a proposal.
Chairman Butow responded that no one on this Board of Directors had seen the document Mr. Sawicki held, naming a specific site. He further clarified the reason for creating a multi-agency
M.O.U. for finding and developing a water storage site, was to make it affordable and beneficial to several agencies.
Director Hallman stated that although Director Groth couldn’t attend this meeting, she wants to make sure there is a matter of record that he has totally withheld his support of signing
the multi-agency M.O.U. in the past, because he has not seen a signed M.O.U. with the property owner.
Attorney Sawicki responded that he knew that, and that he appreciates it.
General Manager McCosker stated that this Board of Directors has agreed to sign the M.O.U., but has not yet done so.
Director Tiemann reminded Mr. Sawicki that the M.O.U. was not created by Redwood Valley County Water District. He added that this District cannot re-word the M.O.U., but we can make
the coalition aware of these points.
Chairman Butow offered that this District will not sign the M.O.U. as presently worded. He said when the agencies meet, the language will probably be changed to remove any mention of
the owners name or property location and to state that all potential sites will be explored.
Attorney Sawicki said that changing the language as proposed would take care of the matter.
At this time, Mr. Sawicki and associates left the Meeting.
7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION TOPICS.
(Agenda Item #6)
None
8. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS.
(Agenda Item #7).
a) Hear customer request for evaluation and modification of charges, continued.
General Manager McCosker reported to the Board in detail, all the tests and evaluations he had done to ascertain if this is a situation of an actual leak, or actual usage or if there
was a meter malfunction.
Director Tiemann said that the property owner lives on Road L and that the meter is on Road K which requires a long line to get the water to Road L. He stated that meters are installed
to record usage and if the water was misused, the District is asking its other water users to pay for the water that passed through the meter. He did not feel it was justified.
Chairman Butow said he agrees that meters are used to record usage but as stated previously, there is no evidence of usage on this volume of water in a 30-day period.
General Manager McCosker added that tests of the new meter vs. the old meter reflected a 5% loss through the old meter. He cannot prove the District lost that volume of water and
cannot prove that we have a basis for charging all the District customers for that volume.
Director Howe commented that this meter is very old. He said he would prefer to err on the side of the public in this circumstance.
General Manager McCosker stated that in his years of experience, he has actually seen a whole register just click-over. He added that he has spoken with several other water district
managers about this type of situation and they offer some type of discount to those customers.
Director Hallman stated that she has seen machinery do strange things on rare occasions and that in view of the investigation so far, she is not comfortable charging this customer
such a sizable sum of money in this circumstance.
MOTION: Modify the charges to the historical normal summer usage for the month of July.
Hallman/Howe Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, William L. Howe, Donald E. Butow
Noes: Keith Tiemann
Abstain: None
Absent: John W. Groth
b) Hear customer request for continuing water service.
Nothing submitted.
c) Review and respond to Request for comments, County Planning, MS-17-2006.
Applicant indicates intention to drill a well. District response will be that due to the moratorium, should this well fail, the District is unable to provide a water service
to this property.
d) Review and respond to Request for comments, County Planning, MS-16-2006.
Applicant indicates intention to drill a well. District response continues to be a cautionary statement indicating that should this well fail, the District is unable to provide
a water service to this property, due to the moratorium.
e) Statement of Economic Interest/Biennial Review Code Notice;
Resolution No. 2006-4, Amending Appendix to the Conflict of Interest Code.
The Political Reform Act of 1974 requires every local government agency to review its conflict-of-interest code, biennially, in even-numbered years and to submit any amendments
by way of District Resolution.
MOTION: Adopt Resolution No. 2006-4 amending the appendix to the Conflict of Interest code.
Howe/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
A Roll Call Vote was taken.
Ayes: Keith Tiemann, William L. Howe, Jeanette Hallman, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: John W. Groth
f) Notice of Resignation, Distribution Operator II.
The Distribution Operator II has resigned. Applications are being reviewed.
9. COUNTY OF MENDOCINO PLANNING TEAM/HOUSING ELEMENT.
(Agenda Item #8)
The County Planning Team will be holding an informational meeting. General Manager McCosker will attend. The District will protest the Planning Department desire to offer reduced
fees, as the District is under a moratorium and cannot consider any of these requests.
10. GENERAL MANAGERS REPORT. (Agenda Item #9)
a. Treatment Plant Status.
b. FEMA Activity.
The leak has been patched but there is ground movement on each side of the pipe. FEMA paperwork is being processed and we are looking for a engineering expert.
c. Solar Project.
Paperwork has been submitted.
d. Groundwater Study.
11. BUDGET UPDATE. (Agenda Item #10)
a. Memorandum
b. Revenue, expense 00 to 06
c. Operating Budget 06 to 07
d. Capital Budget
Chairman Butow expressed his support for this budget submittal and encouraged no more delay which could affect upcoming or emergency projects.
General Manager McCosker mentioned that we have a lot of assets that are approaching their lifespan and we have to make some plans for improvements before they become emergency situations.
He added that this budget incorporates all the Board of Directors recommendations and concerns.
MOTION: Approve Budget as presented.
Howe/
Director Hallman expressed her interest in hearing Director Groth’s opinion before voting on this matter. Director Tiemann concurred.
The Motion failed for the lack of a second.
12. LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION OF MENDOCINO COUNTY-LAFCO.
(Agenda Item #11))
Discussion and possible action on LAFCO topics.
Election of Special District Member – Call for Nominations.
Request for nominations and the ballot process by mail. Gov”t Code
Section 56332 (c) (1).
No action taken.
13. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION. (Agenda Item #12)
Report of attendance at IW&PC Meetings.
Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC.
Discussion and possible action on IW&PC topics.
No report since Director Groth is ill and not in attendance tonight.
14. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER
CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. (Agenda Item #13)
Report of attendance at MCRRFC&WCID Meetings.
consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID.
Discussion and possible action on Flood Control District topics.
No report since Director Groth is ill and not in attendance tonight.
15. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY. (Agenda Item #14)
Consider any correspondence or reports concerning the Sonoma County Water
Agency.
Discussion and possible action on SCWA topics.
Nothing to report.
16. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT. (Agenda Item #15)
Notice of Preparation of a Draft Environmental Impact Report and request for
agency input.
Chairman Butow related his recent conversation with Roland Sanford of the MCWA,
offering anything that RVCWD has that might be useful. Mr. Sanford said there might be something to discuss in a month or so.
Director Howe commented that if the dams are removed and not replaced, as indicated in the Report, that it would be such a loss, both with fire protection and with recreation.
17. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT. (Agenda Item #16)
Nothing to report.
18. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES. (Agenda Item #17)
Nothing to report.
19. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT. (Agenda Item #18)
Nothing to report.
20. STATUS REPORT OF PROGRESS BY LEGISLATIVE CONSULTANT. (Agenda Item #19)
Chairman Butow is encouraged by Mr. Tibbetts’ report that the District’s legislative consultants are in contact with and receiving support from various governmental departments in
the Senate and the House. Mr. Tibbetts is expecting to attend the
October Board of Directors Meeting and will update his report at that time.
21. STATUS REPORT OF M.O.U. FOR ALL AGENCIES/HOPLAND STORAGE PROJECT.
(Agenda Item #20 continued)
A discussion was held regarding the attendance of Myron Sawicki earlier in this
Meeting. Director Hallman expressed her surprise and concern that this M.O.U.
was presented to the Board as an agreed deal and now the property owner has an
attorney stating there is nothing agreed upon. It was Board consensus that Director Groth’s emphasis of obtaining a signed M.O.U. with the property owner before proceeding, must
be the approach in the future.
MOTION: District representatives on the coalition will recommend modification of the M.O.U. by eliminating a property owner name and a specific site location.
Howe/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: William L. Howe, Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: John W. Groth
22. CLOSED SESSION (Agenda Item#21)
There was no closed session.
23. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS, CONFERENCES
AS RECEIVED SINCE LAST MEETING.
Nothing submitted.
The Meeting ended at 8:20 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Kathy Davidson, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors_____
DATE:_____________________________
SIGNED:___________________________
Secretary, Board of Directors