HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006-06-15 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
Board of Directors
Regular Meeting
June 15, 2006
CALL TO ORDER: 7:04 p.m.
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth,
William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann
Directors Absent: Jeanette Hallman
Staff Present: General Manager Darin McCosker
Office Manager Linda Groth
Recording Secretary: Kathy Davidson
Scheduled Guests: Kathryn Charlton, Office of Economical Water Use
Roger Butler, Consultant
1. ROLL CALL.
Keith Tiemann, William L. Howe, John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
None.
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA
WAS POSTED.
General Manager McCosker stated that he received a request from a domestic water
customer who purchased a 3 acre parcel consisting of one house surrounded
by vineyard. He said the owner of the neighboring 20-acre vineyard has a
4” agricultural water service and that the neighboring rancher is willing to serve ag water to the homeowner if he receives a letter stating no objection, from the District.
The General Manager told the landowner that there are no available increases
to ag use or property. Director Howe mentioned that the General Manager should
check on the policy of RVCWD, as he believes that it does not allow the sharing of
water between landowners. It was decided that staff will handle the matter.
4. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
Financial Statement.
b-1. Bill Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
Item 4 is a carryover from last month and should be withheld from payment
until it is resolved.
Special Expenditure Fund Status Report.
District Activity.
Mail Log.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented, continuing
to withhold funds to Brelje & Race until #c. Item 4, in the amount of
$1,437.50, has been discussed with Brelje & Race.
Howe/Groth Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: William L. Howe, John W. Groth, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Jeanette Hallman
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED.
Minutes of Adjourned Regular Meeting of May 24, 2006 were presented.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes as presented.
Groth/Butow Discussion among the three attending Directors who were in attendance at the May 24, 2006 Meeting CARRIED
Ayes: John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: William L. Howe
Absent: Jeanette Hallman
6. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS
(AGENDA ITEM 7).
Resolution No. 2006-2, Authorizing Execution of AB 3616 Memorandum of
Understanding: Efficient Water Management Practices by Agricultural
Water Suppliers in California.
Kathryn Charlton, of the Agricultural Water Management Council, presented
the Board with the organization’s Annual Report and some printed materials and background about the statewide, voluntary organization funded entirely by
government grants. She also gave an oral presentation further explaining
the agency’s purpose and focus and stating that the Agency is funded for the
next 4 years. Membership in this Council obligates the member agencies to prepare and submit a water management plan, which is to be updated and submitted every 5 years. The Agricultural
Water Management Council will offer assistance in creating the plan. Ms. Charlton gave a very in-depth report and answered questions from the Directors. She further stated that attendance
is not mandatory at the quarterly meetings, which are held in Sacramento. They are always pleased to have member agencies in attendance.
Chairman Butow asked questions about the survey completion and process
which was answered by consultant Roger Butler, stating that part of his job
would be to handle that for the District.
MOTION: Approve Resolution NO. 2006-2, authorizing execution of the
AB 3616 Memorandum of Understanding.
Howe/Groth Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: William L. Howe, John W. Groth, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Jeanette Hallman
A copy of this information and the Resolution will be shared with the Russian
River Flood Control District and the Inland Water & Power Commission.
Kathryn Charlton left the Meeting at 7:41 p.m.
Draft of response to the Grand Jury Report, for the Board of Directors approval.
Page 3, Response 2: Director Groth suggested rewording this response, to include ”would be open to participating in a proposed Council”.
MOTION: Approve the draft of Response to the Grand Jury Report, with
rewording Page 3, Response 2 as discussed.
Groth/Howe: Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: John W. Groth, William L. Howe, Donald E. Butow, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Jeanette Hallman
c) Status of preparatory work on customer request for fire suppression service.
General Manager McCosker has heard nothing from the customer.
7. GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT (AGENDA ITEM #8).
a. Treatment Plant Status
Installing improvements to the potassium feed system per the capital budget.
Started purchasing material for the adjustable intake per the capital budget.
b. FEMA Activity
Received the final project list with approved estimated costs.
c. Transmission Line
Located two blow-offs slightly leaking; continuing to use our new equipment
to check suspect areas for leakage.
d. Surge Tank
Waiting for Rau & Associates to contact us regarding the surveying. Anticipate
moving forward in the second or third week in June.
e. Watershed Sanitary Survey (WSS)
All requested data for Brown & Caldwell has been submitted. The immense
amount of research by General Manager McCosker was placed in his newly created digital reports and spreadsheets. In the future all of the data will be in a format that can be e-mailed
easily when agencies request data.
f. D.H.S. Annual Report and Consumer Confidence Report (CCR)
The Department of Health Services Annual Report has been completed. At
some point prior to December 2004 the population of the District was reported
to D.H.S. as 3,696. Since we now exceed 3,300 population, we owe DHS and EPA two more documents: a Vulnerability Assessment Report and an Emergency Response Plan.
The Consumer Confidence Report is completed.
g. Maintenance Issues
General Manager McCosker will be training the crew and implementing a very comprehensive preventative maintenance program. It is an inexpensive program that he developed
in 1997.
h. Solar Project
General Manager McCosker contacted PG&E and spoke with several people about our project. Although last month the General Manager’s Report was discouraging, General Manager McCosker
is now encouraged with new information that is available. He, along with our account representative Martha Baeli, and Pete from Advanced Power will research a combination of efficiency
measures and project “payback” periods. PG&E granted the District a 30-day extension on our milestone timeframe.
i. District Website
We have received many inquiries about a website for the District. It is
becoming much more frequent that forms to be completed request our website
address. When contacted by the California Urban Water Conservation Council,
our District was the only one on the list without a website. It costs $15.00 annually for a domain name. Consultant Roger Butler is available to assist with creating the Website.
We can offer efficiency topics, and link to other websites such as drought-resistant landscaping, etc. It was the consensus of the Board to proceed with setting up such a website.
8. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION
TOPICS. (SEE AGENDA ITEM 6).
a) None.
Roger Butler left the Meeting at 8:00 p.m.
9. BUDGET UPDATE.
Due to only recently implementing a rate increase, experiencing two “wet” years in a
row, and only one or two nights of frost protection usage among other things, income
from Ag Usage may be a little less than was originally proposed. The General
Manager will submit a proposed budget at the next Regular Meeting reflecting figures
to the end of the fiscal year.
10. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION.
Report of attendance at IW&PC Meetings.
Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC.
Discussion and possible action on IW&PC topics.
Chairman Butow mentioned that RVCWD has paid the IW&PC a $25,000 check as a
one-fourth share of costs for the Dam Raising Feasibility Study. Director Groth reported on attendance at a recent IW&PC meeting, mentioning that Roland Sanford of the MCWA was in attendance.
He said the recent election may impact some Board of Supervisors decisions which will also impact County-wide water issues.
11. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER
CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT.
Report of attendance at MCRRFC&WCID meeting.
Consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID.
Letter dated June 6, 2006 from MCRRFC&WCID was discussed. It was the
consensus of the Board to send a copy of the letter to Paul Minasian so that
he is made aware of this latest correspondence.
A May 31, 2006 letter to Victoria Whitney was brought up for discussion.
Director Groth asked that Paul Minasian received a copy of the CD that has been distributed to other agencies along with the letter. He said the method proposed
does not promote conservation which is a concern.
c. Discussion and possible action on Flood Control District topics.
Director Groth suggested that the District should consider applying for membership into the MCRRFC&WCID. A conversation regarding going into a contract agreement with MCRRFC&WCID which
would remove the District from “surplus” status, and eventually lift the moratorium, was held. The new Board of Trustee’s of the RRFCD has asked RVCWD to participate as an ad hoc committee
for the purpose of meaningful discussions leading to a resolution of the supply needs of the District. Director Groth offered for himself and General Manager McCosker to serve as a
committee to meet with the RRFCD.
Chairman Butow offered an historical review of MCRRFC&WCID and this District, and expressed his appreciation for the hard work that has been done recently that has increased common goals.
Director Tiemann added that any action needs to include our Counsels comments. There was a consensus to share the information with Counsel and to meet with the RRFCD in ad-hoc committee
as this is an opportunity to go forward. General Manager McCosker stated it is in everybody’s best interest to work together.
8:35 p.m. Break
8:50 p.m. Reconvene
12. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY.
a. Consider any correspondence or reports concerning the Sonoma County
Water Agency.
b. Discussion and possible action on SCWA topics.
General Manager McCosker reported he has been keeping in touch with Chris
Murray via telephone.
13. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT.
The June 1, 2006 letter was discussed. Director Groth suggested that the issue
be discussed with Supervisor-elect John Pinches and get his input on it before the
District drops the project. A lengthy discussion ensued.
14. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT.
Any meeting with John Pinches will be reported to the Board.
15. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES.
a. Requests for Proposals have been mailed to several geological specialists
and the District is awaiting responses.
16. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT.
a. District response to SWRCB.
There is a potential that the application could be approved if we can supply
the areas with the water they can store.
17. STATUS REPORT OF PROGRESS BY LEGISLATIVE CONSULTANT.
Nothing to report.
18a. DISCUSS SUPPORT OF M.O.U. FOR ALL AGENCIES/HOPLAND STORAGE
PROJECT. (AGENDA ITEMS #18)
The Memorandum of Understanding was discussed. Counsel Minasian
had reviewed it and made his changes. Director Groth said he cannot vote to spend
a penny until the property owner provides a M.O.U. clarifying his intent and
understanding; this needs to be done before money is spent on surveys and studies.
Also, regarding Page 3, Item 6: The $90,000 commitment does not appear to
include engineering and other fees. General Manager McCosker said Counsel
advises these reports should cost far less than the figures mentioned. Chairman
Butow also supports obtaining a M.O.U. with the landowner, clarifying his intent
and requirements. General consensus was that after obtaining a M.O.U. with the
landowner, only minimum amounts of money should be spent first for
primary
engineering studies to see if it is even a viable project.
The General Manager was asked to forward these comments to the Project
Committee.
18b. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEIMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS,
CONFERENCES AS RECEIVED SINCE LAST MEETING. (AGENDA ITEM 22).
None.
19. CLOSED SESSION (AGENDA ITEM #18 d, e, f).
Director Butow asked questions before going into Closed Session regarding the
job description sheets included in the confidential file. The General Manager stated
that these job descriptions were just for the Directors to review to see if they
approved of the format and content. The Directors had no objections.
9:45 p.m.
The Recording Secretary left the Meeting, which immediately went into Closed Session.
d. Public Employee Performance Evaluation: Laborer-Water Treatment/
System Operator 1. – Government Code 54957 (e)
Director Groth and Office Manager Groth left the Meeting.
e. Public Employee Performance Evaluation: Office Manager - Government
Code 54957 (e)
General Manager McCosker left the Meeting.
Director Groth and Office Manager Groth returned to the Meeting.
f. Public Employee Performance Evaluation: General Manager - Government
Code 54957 (e)
OPEN SESSION 10:10 P.M.
Recording Secretary and General Manager returned to the Meeting
20. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION (AGENDA ITEM #19).
d. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Laborer-Water Treatment/
System Operator 1.
e. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, Office Manager.
f. Public Employee Performance Evaluation, General Manager.
Chairman Butow reported that the Directors heard and discussed performance evaluations for the above three employees.
21. CONSIDER PERFORMANCE MERIT INCREASE FOR LABORER-WATER
TREATMENT/SYSTEM OPERATOR 1 (AGENDA ITEM #20).
Howe/ Approve 8% performance merit increase, effective 7/8/06
Motion failed due to the lack of a 2nd.
MOTION: Approve Performance Merit Increase and, increase the base
pay by $1.00 per hour for the Laborer-Water Treatment/System Operator 1,
effective July 8, 2006.
Groth/Howe Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: John W. Groth, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: Jeanette Hallman
22. CONSIDER PERFORMANCE MERIT INCREASE FOR OFFICE MANAGER.
Director Groth recused himself from this Agenda Item.
Chairman Butow and Director Howe plan to meet with the Office Manager
regarding her future retirement plans and to discuss possible replacement
options.
MOTION: Approve a 5% Performance Merit Increase for the Office
Manager, retroactive to June 1, 2006.
Howe/Butow Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: William L. Howe, Donald E. Butow, Keith Tiemann
Noes: None
Abstain: John W. Groth
Absent: Jeanette Hallman
23. CONSIDER PERFORMANCE MERIT INCREASE FOR GENERAL MANAGER
(AGENDA ITEM #21).
General Manager Darin McCosker is licensed as a Water Treatment Operator
Grade 5 and a Water Distribution Operator Grade 3. It was noted that Mr.
McCosker has encountered a myriad of challenges over every spectrum, since
his employment began at the Water District. As each event has come up, he
has stepped up to the plate and has addressed each matter straight-on. He
communicates very well with the Board of Directors and Staff. In addition,
feedback indicates his communications and forward-thinking attitude with the
Flood Control District, the City of Ukiah and other agencies, is excellent, noting
it is a change from previous operations and he was thanked for it. General
Manager McCosker was further thanked for his excellent rapport and progress
with the Sonoma County Water Agency officials.
MOTION: Approve a $10,000.00 annual increase in salary, retroactive to
June 1, 2006.
GROTH/HOWE
Discussion followed. Director Tiemann suggested that someone with this
General Manager’s qualifications does demand this range of salaries, however
in small, rural water districts, the annual budget is lower than large water
districts and the earning power is less. Director Groth reported having recently
reviewed numerous General Manager solicitations noting that the wage scales of
the small, rural water districts also encompassed this pay range. General
Manager McCosker disagreed with Director Groth’s statement about those
solicitations and wage scales being for a General Manager; they were for Chief
Water Treatment Plant/Supervisor jobs. Director Groth agreed and corrected
his comments. He also clarified that he was definitely comparing the annual
income and budget information of those solicitations, and after having worked
on the District’s budget, he feels the District can handle this wage scale.
Chairman Butow again thanked General Manager McCosker for his good work
and stated that in his opinion, Mr. McCosker has earned this increase. The
vote was taken:
AYES: John W. Groth, William L. Howe, KeithTiemann, Donald E. Butow
NOES: None
ABSTAIN: None
ABSENT: Jeanette Hallman
MOTION CARRIED.
The Meeting ended at 10:31 p.m.
The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. on Thursday, July 20, 2006 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully submitted,
Kathy Davidson, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE:
SIGNED:
Secretary, Board of Directors