Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006-04-20 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT 2370 Webb Ranch Road P. O. Box 399 Redwood Valley, CA 95470 (707) 485-0679 MINUTES Board of Directors Regular Meeting April 20, 2006 CALL TO ORDER: 7:02 p.m. Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, William L. Howe, Keith Tiemann, Jeanette Hallman Directors Absent: None Staff Present: General Manager Darin McCosker, Office Manager Linda Groth Recording Secretary: Kathy Davidson Scheduled Guests: Attorney Paul Minasian by telephone conference Members of the Public: Hal Voege, Roy Beck, Nicholas Muniz, Evert Jacobson 1. ROLL CALL. Keith Tiemann, William L. Howe, Jeanette Hallman, John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow 2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC. None 3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED. None 4. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR. Financial Statement. b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting. b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting. c. Bills Payable. d. Special Expenditure Fund status report. e. District Activity. f. Mail Log. MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented. Howe/Hallman Discussion CARRIED Ayes: Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, Jeanette Hallman, William L. Howe Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED. The Minutes of March 16, 2006 were presented. There was a question from Director Hallman regarding reference to Counsel Paul Minasian sending a follow-up letter to the Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District. Director Hallman stated that the letter was not to come from Counsel, but from the District Staff. It was decided that Staff will review the Meeting tapes and follow up accordingly. MOTION: Approve Minutes of the Regular Meeting of March 16, 2006 as presented. Howe/Groth Discussion CARRIED Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, John W. Groth Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 6. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION TOPICS. a) Response to customer regarding allocations. General Manager McCosker presented correspondence between customer Nicholas Muniz and the District. Mr. Muniz, who was in attendance at this meeting, said he did not understand the letter and what the conclusion was. He asked for clarification as to his status regarding getting an additional water connection. General Manager McCosker explained the moratorium issue and the mandated rulings by County and State Agencies. Mr. Muniz advised the Board that he is in the process of creating a minor subdivision on his two acres and that he has been paying for two allocations since 1987. He wants to hook up a new service to the second home, using the second allocation, now. He also asked about what happens during drought time, and is there a possibility that he could eventually get a separate hook up. He said he is concerned that his allocation is going to be taken away from him. The Board assured Mr. Muniz that the District was not taking his allocation away, but instead that the District is bound by the County Superior Court-Ordered Moratorium, and the rulings of the State Health Department and the State Water Resources Control Board. Mr. Muniz was informed that once the moratorium is lifted, and all the terms and conditions existing at that time were met, he could use that allocation to apply for a second service hook-up to the same assessor’s parcel as that of the existing water service. Mr. Muniz left the Meeting at this time. b) Self-Generation Solar Project. General Manager McCosker presented a progress report on the development of a PG&E self-generation solar project. He reported that despite the efforts of himself and Pete at Advanced Power, PG&E was not convinced to allow the District to design a self-generation project larger than 84 Kw. PG&E is now ready to proceed, so the District has a 60-day turn-around period to get the project out to bid. The incentive amount supplied by PG&E is roughly 40% or $232,000. He feels because of the cost of construction, the District should acquire outside financing. If a private lender is used, it would only take the District 4-5 years to pay back a loan, as opposed to a Bond which could take 18-20 years to pay off. He added that legal counsel has contacts and he will also speak to Chris Murray. After a few specific questions and answers, the Board encouraged the General Manager to proceed. Watershed Sanitary Survey Update. General Manager McCosker informed the Directors that this WSS update is due every five years, to be in compliance with the Surface Water Treatment Rule. The costs are shared with the City of Ukiah and Millview County Water District because the three water purveyors have common watersheds and water supply sources. If the District were to tackle this survey on its own, the cost will be about $50,000. With sharing, the District will be responsible for 15% of the overall costs. It was noted that Calpella and Willow County Water Districts are not involved as they process ground water, not surface water. 7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS. a) Draft Concept Plan, Groundwater Investigation for the Greater Ukiah Valley. Director Butow reported on a recent meeting he and General Manager McCosker attended with other districts and agencies regarding a groundwater study and having each agency contribute to fund the study. It is hoped that the proposed study will provide sufficient information to identify locations within the Greater Ukiah Valley in which economically significant groundwater resources are most likely to be found. Evert Jacobson, General Manager of Hopland Public Utility District, explained that groundwater currently provides a significant portion of the total water consumptively used in the area, that it is apparently abundant and could supply a significant portion of any future water demands. He said it is typically much cheaper and easier and quicker to develop, from a regulatory perspective. General Manager McCosker reported that since there is no database that all purveyors can share and use, Roland Sanford of the Mendocino County Water Agency wants all of the agencies to participate in the proposed study, by supplying their data and some financial assistance, with the County paying 50% of the costs of the study and the perhaps 6 – 9 participating agencies sharing the balance of the costs, which could range from approximately $5,000 to $8,000 per agency, depending on number of participants. After a lengthy discussion, the consensus was that the General Manager would find out from Roland how many agencies he was able to involve in this project, and report that information to the Board of Directors. b) (See Agenda Item No. 18.b.): Real Property Negotiations; Report of Negotiator, Donald Butow, in regard to progress or lack of progress in negotiations for access to Mill Creek water sources, rights of way, easements or interests in real property related to transmission and storage of water. No address available. Negotiations with County interests and other possible effected landowners. Government Code Section 54956.8. This item was originally going to be held in Closed Session. It was established that at this point it was not necessary to have a Closed Session, so the matter was presented in Open Session. The discussion is an M. O. U. between water agencies. Chairman Butow reported that there was a recent meeting with six water agencies on the Russian River that was very positive. Hopland Public Utility District brought forward a location that could be used as a reservoir. The group at the meeting had concluded that the agencies attending the meeting wanted to work as one unit and to share the water. Director Groth and also the Chairman expressed their concerns about proceeding with the project without a written outline, a full report on how to proceed, an engineered study, a report by a geologist, and a letter from the landowner stating they are willing to participate in the project. It was noted that legal counsel advised the Directors to know before going in, that they can afford this. Evert Jacobson clarified that the Memorandum of Understanding is not a commitment to pay a $10,000 bill, but strictly a statement of agreement that all water agencies will work together and if the group approves of the project initially, that eventually they would commit to their equal share, not to exceed $10,000. Once signed, he can take this M.O.U. to the property owner. He further stated that the District is not obligated to stay in the group, and is not obligated for any financial contribution if they decide to remove themselves from the group. MOTION: Sign the Memorandum of Understanding with the understanding that the District will receive a complete written progress report of the project and what is to be done next. This is not approving payment of a dollar amount at this time. General Manager McCosker will be the agent on this project and a Director will also be appointed in the future. Groth/Howe Discussion CARRIED Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow, William L. Howe, John Groth Noes: None Abstain: None Absent: None 8:35 Break 8:52 Reconvene 8. GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT. a) Treatment Plant Status Annual outside treatment plant maintenance has been delayed due to the long rainy season. Still dealing with warranty issues on the broken shaft and seal on the flash mixer. b) Storm Damage and FEMA Activity Continued rain prevents District from beginning work on any projects and prevents other agencies we need to work with, from beginning their work. c) Transmission Line Very frustrating that many “as-built”, and “record drawings” do not match what is actually in the ground. An example being that the plans show three screens installed on the influent pipes to the caisson in Lake Mendocino. Actually, the third screen is not installed, but is sitting alongside of the access road. In another case, certain valves are shown on the plans but the valves do not exist. d) Surge Tank We contacted Tom Yokoi at Brelje & Race for his records on surveying, as the surge tank location had been planned to be fenced, but he advised that the final surveying had not been completed. He offered to complete the final surveying for $2,400 +. We are experiencing telemetry problems, probably due to the house built next to the tank. Plans are being made to raise the antennae and verify signal strength. e) District Mapping Tom Yokoi at Brelje & Race advises that none of their historical work was placed in digital files, they had only mylars and a few pdf files. This conflicts with records we’ve found, showing a filename ending in DWG. It is anticipated that new, digital mapping could be done over a one or two year period for an estimated cost of $7K-$10K. The updated mapping would allow us to be much more accurate in all aspects of the District operation. This estimated cost will be added to the proposed 06/07 capital budget. f) Maintenance Issues The three isolation valves for the pump effluent pipes at the Lake Mendocino pump station need to be exercised. They are inside the caisson roughly 30’ below, and staff has reported that one of the valves does not operate. It is believed to be a shaft problem at the valve. Since this is a “confined space” General Manager McCosker will not sign a permit to enter this confined space until he verifies that crew will be utilizing all of the safety equipment necessary to ensure they are not overcome by fumes or will not fall and become incapacitated in any way. That safety equipment will run between $2000 - $4000 to purchase, as we do not own any of it. To hire an outside company for this work we could quickly spend the money that we could have used for purchasing the equipment. 9. BUDGET UPDATE. General Manager McCosker presented the Budget, explaining some of his Budget concerns such as safety issues and other items. He is discovering some situations he was unaware of, that may end up costing the District money to correct, that were not part of the original Budget. As a result, the General Manager will ask the Board to modify policy or costs from time to time so he can operate the plant properly and safely. He assured the Board that he will always try to work within the parameters of the Budget but sometimes problems or issues come up that no one expects when running a water district, an example being outdated maps. The Board consensus was for the General Manager to get some quotes on surveying one specific parcel that involves a District tank so he could get a current map of the parcel. The Capital Budget on page 2 was also discussed. 10. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION. a) Report of attendance at IW&PC Meetings. b) Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC. c) Discussion and possible action of IW&PC topics. Director Groth reported on a Special Meeting of April 10, 2006. A repre- sentative from Wells Fargo Bank spoke on creative options of how to raise revenues for supporting the feasibility study or for raising the dam. Director Groth said that overall, it was a good presentation, but too early for these strategies. Director Groth further reported that the IW&PC is asking Redwood Valley to share in funding the feasibility study; however, there is no mention of making a share of water available to Redwood Valley County Water District. 11. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. Report of attendance at MCRRFC&WCID meetings. Consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID. Discussion and possible action on Flood Control District topics. Director Groth reported the Board of Trustee’s is reviewing the Revised Draft of the Feasibility Study and preparing comments to be included in the document. Chairman Butow expressed concern that when it comes time to perfect the application, each and every agency would have to share costs of several million dollars. Director Groth added that there is nothing in the federal budget for this project. On a different topic, Director Groth reported that the Flood Control District has agreed to provide the State with all of their information on their hydraulic modeling for State reports. Director Groth asked that a letter be sent by Paul Minasian to the State Water Resources Control Board telling them the District has complied with certain terms of the Cease and Desist Order (CDO). He also mentioned asking the State when the deadline is for the MCRRFC&WCID to submit their report on the meter readings, as stated in the Flood Control District’s CDO. OTHER ITEM General Manager McCosker mentioned that Hal Voege, Rudy Light, Tim Buckner, and he have been sharing information regarding the Baggett Meetings and what impact the Peregrine and Trout Unlimited and Audubon groups might have on the District. These groups’ non-publicized meetings give an appearance of secrecy. Mr. Voege reported to the Board that the District would not be impacted, and that these groups are targeting the State, not specific districts. He also explained that the groups’ reasoning for the petition that was submitted to the State, was only to get the State’s attention. He listed the six points of their position and goals and concerns as to unlicensed diversions, and stated that the State should have consequences if they just lally-gag and don’t standardize the process of licensing. There was a lengthy discussion. Chairman Butow said that there are other decisions being made that he feels will directly affect Redwood Valley, without any input from Redwood Valley, which could result in mandates brought down from the State. 12. SOMONA COUNTY WATER AGENCY. a) Consider any correspondence or reports concerning the Sonoma County Water Agency. b) Discussion and possible action on SCWA topics. The State Water Resources Control Board had some criticism of the District’s contract with the Sonoma County Water Agency. General Manager McCosker will provide comments from Alan Lilly when they are received. It did not seem to be insurmountable according to Chris Murray. 13. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT. No action to report. 14. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT. No action to report. 15. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES. Counsel Paul Minasian commented that if the District can find another source, all the better. 16. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT. General Manager McCosker will contact the hydro-geologist recommended by Rudy Light. He said Chris Murray is also included in these discussions. 17. STATUS OF RESPONSE TO RUDOLPH LIGHT LETTER OF NOVEMBER 1, 2005. The General Manager has been in communication with Mr. Light. He will provide Mr. Light with a letter informing him of the Motion to remove Mr. Light’s property from a Filing with the State. He will also provide a copy of the Minutes from the last meeting. Mr. Light has offered to be of assistance to the District in any way he can. 18. CLOSED SESSION There was no Closed Session. See Minutes Item #7.b. 19. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 18. There was no Closed Session. 20. STATUS OF PREPARATORY WORK ON CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR FIRE SUPPRESSION SERVICE. It has been established that the property is within District boundaries. The General Manager reported that, due to results of flow tests at that location, the California Department of Forestry changed some of its requirements. 21. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS, CONFERENCES AS RECEIVED SINCE LAST MEETING. The General Manager is sending all three operators to an Operation and Maintenance of Distribution Systems workshop in Ukiah next month. The Meeting ended at 10:20 p.m. The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. on Thursday, May 18, 2006 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley Water, California. Respectfully submitted, Kathy Davidson, Recording Secretary APPROVED: Board of Directors DATE: SIGNED: Secretary, Board of Directors