HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006-03-16 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
P. O. Box 399
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
Board of Directors
Regular Meeting
March 16, 2006
CALL TO ORDER: 7:02 p.m.
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth, William L. Howe,
Keith Tiemann, Jeanette Hallman
Directors Absent: None
Staff Present: General Manager Darin McCosker
Officer Manager Linda Groth
Recording Secretary: Kathy Davidson
Scheduled Guests: Attorney Paul Minasian by telephone conference
Members of the Public: Rudolph Light, Chris Woida, Hal Voege
1. ROLL CALL.
All Directors were Present.
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
None.
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
None.
4. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. Special Expenditure Fund status report.
e. District Activity.
f. Mail Log.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Howe/Groth Discussion. CARRIED
Ayes: Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow, Jeanette Hallman,
William L. Howe, John W. Groth
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED.
The January 26, 2006 Minutes were reviewed. The following corrections are to be a part
of the motion to accept the Minutes:
Page 3, Item 8a: Change first line to: “Risk Management Plan”, and change second line
to: “Normal Hazardous Material Business Plan”.
Change the fourth sentence to read: “We save $300 in fee’s by not having chlorine gas.”
Page 4, Item 8b: Replace “Laptop” with “Automated”.
MOTION: Approve the January 26, 2006 Minutes with corrections.
Groth/Howe Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow,
John W. Groth, William L. Howe
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
The February 16, 2006 Minutes were reviewed. The following corrections are to be a part
of the motion to accept the Minutes:
Page 2: Second paragraph, second sentence-change to read-“each lab is processing different types of tests.”
Page 2: Third paragraph: end the second sentence at the word: “coliform”. End third sentence at the word: “tests”.
Page 6, Item 11 c: Replace “Senator” with “Congressman”.
MOTION: Approve with the February 16, 2006 Minutes with corrections.
Howe/Groth Discussion. CARRIED
Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow,
William L. Howe, John W. Groth
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
6. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION
TOPICS.
a) None
7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF ACTION TOPICS.
Financial Statement 6/30/06 Completed.
The second payment to the Auditor was paid on schedule according to contract.
Regarding Page 4, Item H4 on the Financial Statement: Director Hallman noticed a small
error, and the General Manager will correct it. (The correction will not cause a change in the figures).
The 3-year contract with Rick Bowers CPA, CMA has concluded. It was noted that
Mr. Bowers offered to continue providing his services at the same rate without signing
another contract if the Directors prefer. After a discussion, the General Manager was
instructed to send out RFP’s to three additional accountants and see what responses and
rate quotes are received for comparison and consideration.
PG&E has changed its criteria for the power savings/solar program. The District submitted
the required $1600.00 payment with its application, and there is still more paperwork to complete. More information will be forthcoming.
8. GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT.
The General Manager presented his report to the Board.
a. Treatment Plant Status
Continuing steps to upgrade the water treatment plant: The primary coagulant feed system
has recently been converted over to the new pumps and day tank system. When groundwater
levels recede, automated sludge valves for better controlling the sludge withdrawals will be
integrated.
b. Storm Damage and FEMA Activity.
A great deal of time was expended meeting and dealing with Recovery Operations Specialty
Services and FEMA representatives examining storm related damages. So far approximately
$85,000.00 in repairs has been identified, and submittals are being prepared for FEMA
assistance.
c. PG&E Self-Generation Project.
A required payment of ½ of 1% has been submitted within the 30 day period timeframe.
9. BUDGET UPDATE.
The Budget was discussed and reviewed.
10. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION.
a. Report of attendance at IW&PC Meetings.
b. Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC.
c. Discussion and possible action on IW&PC topics.
Director Groth reported that there has been a series of meetings between Arthur Baggett, a
commissioner at the State Water Resources Control Board, Randy Poole of
the Sonoma County Water Agency, Roland Sanford of the Mendocino County Water Agency
and a few select others. These are being referred to as the Baggett Meetings.
There have been protests from a large number of environmental groups who have joined
together to protest all water filings in the State, and who have requested the State have prior
approval from these groups, before any of the filings are approved.
It appears that Mr. Baggett has a desire to keep things very secretive, resulting in no reports or
communications to the water districts or other agencies that would be impacted. There have
been four meetings and yet there has been no reporting to the water agencies.
Member of the public, Rudy Light, mentioned that Timothy Buckner has been attending these
meetings and he thinks Mr. Buckner could provide a thorough report.
In regard to the F.E.R.C. Hearing, oral arguments at the 9th Circuit Court are scheduled for
April 5, 2006 in San Francisco.
11. HEAR AND CONSIDER CUSTOMER REQUEST FOR FIRE SUPPRESSION SERVICE.
(AGENDA ITEM #21)
It was noted that District’s Counsel, Paul Minasian has advised the District that providing
a fire suppression service would not violate either the moratorium or the SCWA Agreement.
Chris Woida, owner of Arrow Fencing, has purchased property on Laughlin Way behind the
old Cookie Factory. He is building a large shop and is hoping a water main extension with
hydrant for CDF purposes, can be provided. Director Tiemann who knew some history
about the area, asked the customer if all of the parcel was within the District boundary. It is
known that the house is, but the question is if the entire parcel is within the District boundary.
General Manager McCosker will get boundary assurances. Director Tiemann also
indicated that an engineered flow analysis, to see if the Districts’ system can handle
the addition, needs to be performed. Once the questions and data are received the
Board can continue their review of the request.
Mr. Woida left the Meeting at 7:51 p.m.
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER
CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. (AGENDA ITEM #11)
a. Report of attendance at MCRRFC&WCID Meetings.
b. Consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID.
c. Discussion and possible action on Flood Control District topics.
Director Groth reported he and General Manager McCosker met on March 10th with the
FCD ad hoc committee members Richard Shoemaker, Barbara Spazek and
Judy Hatch to discuss past water billings that remain unpaid by Redwood Valley
County Water District for several reasons including potential litigation, and many
questions on the Profit & Loss Statement figures that the Flood Control
District used as a basis for their charges. Director Groth said the meeting flowed
well and those in attendance hammered out a very good agreement, with a savings of
50% of the interest previously charged and approximately $10,000.00 removed
from their previous billings, for an ending total of $102,746.94. Director Groth added that he
and General Manager McCosker did a lot of homework in preparation for the committee
meeting including his conversations with the former Counselor for the Flood Control District,
Tom Johnson, and also Redwood Valley’s former Director Robert Anderson and received their
perspectives. He also reminded the Directors that clearing this debt to the Russian River Flood
Control District satisfies a term of the CDO issued by the SWRCB.
Director Groth further clarified that this figure covers all past billings and usage, up to
June 30, 2005, and that the committee recommends that the District accept it and go forward.
MOTION: Approve payment to Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control
& Water Conservation Improvement District, the sum of $102,746.94.
Howe/Hallman Discussion
General Manager McCosker distributed copies of a Letter of Agreement received today
from Judy Hatch, President of Russian River Flood Control District’s Board of Trustee’s. The letter reports formal action of that Board which, on March 13, 2006, voted unanimously
to accept a check in the amount of $102,746.94 for all past water used by Redwood Valley and such letter concludes that this satisfies outstanding obligations. Said letter is to
be co-signed by Chairman Butow of Redwood Valley County Water District’s Board of Directors.
Director Tiemann said we hired Paul Minasian as a water attorney to deal with the
Flood Control District and he wants to hear what Counsel Minasian has to say about
paying the invoices, before the Board approves payment, so that the Board is aware
of all the repercussions of this action. Chairman Butow reported a phone discussion with
Counsel Minasian recently. Chairman Butow added, it is more of a political issue and it’s getting in the way of other collaborative efforts with other agencies that can
assist the District. The public does not like the fact that the District has not paid the bill. The District customers have voiced their disapproval to individual Board members
and the situation has resulted in an
unpleasant perception of the District, and he recommends we pay as the committee
recommends, and go forward.
Director Hallman expressed her concern about using Attorney Minasian exclusively. The
General Manager reminded her of the Cease and Desist Order and other issues that require
legal counsel. Director Hallman said she understands the District needs legal counsel but that perhaps the water rights attorney could be used less for general counsel.
Chairman Butow offered a history of the time when Mr. Minasian was our water rights
attorney and David Rapport was our legal counsel for general matters. When Mr. Rapport
resigned, we solicited the services of several local attorney’s and not one was available for
services to RVCWD. We then asked Mr. Minasian if his firm could provide general
services in addition to water rights services, and he agreed.
It was agreed to contact Attorney Minasian after the Break to ask his opinion on the payment
approval and also to discuss the Rudy Light letter.
BREAK 8:22 p.m.
RECONVENE 8:41 p.m.
Counsel Paul Minasian was contacted by conference phone in Open Session at 8:42 p.m.
Chairman Butow introduced some of the issues to be discussed.
1) LETTER OF AGREEMENT AND PAYMENT TO MCRRFC&WCID. (AGENDA ITEM #11)
Attorney Minasian was brought current with discussions earlier in the meeting and an open
Motion to pay the RRFCD. Mr. Minasian expressed his concern that the District cannot be assured that the future amounts charged by MCRRFC&WCID will be accurate. Director Groth said
this payment is for past billings, it was negotiated well and, also, that the RRFCD is not contesting Redwood Valley’s readings.
General Manager McCosker suggested that the Cease and Desist Order would force the
MCRRFC&WCID to keep accurate records as per the State’s requirement.
Members of the Board asked questions about their legal rights with MCRRFC&WCID
and the different scenarios of how to further negotiate assurance that MCRRFC&WCID
water is accurately metered and reported to the State on a monthly basis so that it is very clear whether the MCRRFC&WCID has used their surplus water.
STATUS OF RESPONSE TO RUDOLPH LIGHT LETTER OF NOVEMBER 1, 2005.
(AGENDA ITEM #18)
During this conference call, Mr. Light spoke to Mr. Minasian regarding the application that
affects his property. Mr. Minasian explained the technical aspects of amending an Application
to remove points of diversion.
MOTION: Drop the Rudolph Light property and the Ford Property (Points of Diversion
#1 and #2), from the West Fork application with the State Water Resources Control
Board as soon as practically possible. It is not the District’s intent to use those points of diversion.
Tiemann/Howe Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: John W. Groth, Jeanette Hallman, Donald E. Butow,
Keith Tiemann, William L. Howe
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
It was agreed that a letter confirming the above action would be sent to Mr. Light.
3) STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES. (AGENDA ITEM #15)
Counsel Minasian advised that an amendment needs to be filed with the State for all four
Place of Use areas. He said that when the SWRCB approved Order 79-15, the interpretation was on the boundaries that existed in 1979 which included the two earlier annexed areas but
not the two later annexed areas.
Discussion ensued as to measures that could be taken to resolve this issue.
Counsel Minasian suggested that a hydrologist, experienced in fractured rock, be hired to
determine whether or not there is groundwater in Redwood Valley. If groundwater is
not available, another alternative will have to be considered. Several names were offered
and Mr. Light also offered the name of a water geologist he could recommend.
The Board directed Mr. Minasian to write a letter to the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs
encouraging them to write a letter to the State Water Resources Control Board regarding
the annexation issue.
STATUS OF EEL RIVER PROJECT INVOICE. (AGENDA ITEM #17)
The Board expressed concern about penalties and interest accruing and asked if the
outstanding invoice could just be paid. Counsel Minasian said if the Board wanted
to pay the bill they could and that would be a reasonable thing to do. He explained his
reason for not paying the fee was that he felt that it was not a legitimate fee, but he
had no objection if the District decides to pay the fee at this time.
The Conference Call with Counsel Minasian ended at 10:29 p.m.
MOTION: Pay the State Board of Equalization invoice of October 20, 2005.
Groth/Howe Discussion CARRIED
Ayes: Jeanette Hallman, Keith Tiemann, Donald E. Butow, John W. Groth,
William L. Howe
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
At this time the matter of paying the MCRRFC&WCID was brought up again for
discussion (Agenda Item #11). Each Board member and members of the public
made comments about how the payment and Agreement could be worded and how
to proceed.
The Motion that had been tabled before the Conference Call earlier in the Meeting was
made with the following amendment to read:
MOTION: Approve payment to MCRRFC&WCID the sum of $102,746.94 now.
Counsel Minasian will compose a follow-up letter stating Redwood Valley’s expectation
and encouragement that future billings of water usage will conform to the Cease and
Desist Order by the State. Attorney Minasian will submit his draft letter to the Directors
for review before sending it to the Russian River Flood Control District.
The makers of the Motion approved the amendment to the Motion.
Howe/Hallman CARRIED
Ayes: John W. Groth, Donald E. Butow, Keith Tiemann, William L. Howe,
Jeanette Hallman
Noes: None
Abstain: None
Absent: None
13. STATUS REPORT OF MILL CREEK PROJECT.
This item was discussed during the conference call with Attorney Minasian.
14. STATUS REPORT OF WEST FORK PROJECT.
This item was discussed during the conference call with Attorney Minasian.
15. STATUS REPORT OF 2800 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT. (AGENDA ITEM #16)
Letter from State Water Resources Control Board.
This item was discussed during the conference call with Attorney Minasian.
The Meeting ended at 10:50 p.m.
The next Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. on Thursday,
April 20, 2006 at the District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully submitted,
Kathy Davidson, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE:
SIGNED: