HomeMy WebLinkAbout2010-09-16 RVCWD MeetingREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
P. O. Box 399
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
September 16, 2010
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, Jeanette Hallman, Granville Pool, Merle D. Reuser
Directors Excused: Hal Voege
Staff Present: General Manager William L. Koehler
Office Manager/Secretary to the Board of Directors Linda Groth
Others in Attendance: Roy Beck
CALLED TO ORDER: 7:02 P.M.
1. ROLL CALL.
Granville Pool, Merle D. Reuser, Jeanette Hallman, Donald Butow
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
None
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
GM Koehler asked the Board to hear an urgent item concerning a Resolution proposed by the Russian River Flood Control District.
MOTION: Hear the urgent item.
Hallman/Pool
AYES: Hallman, Pool, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
GM Koehler said the proposed resolution is tied in with the discussion of the recent All Boards Meeting as well as Russian River Flood Control District, so we can wait until we get
to that point in the meeting, but he wanted to establish that an action item not on the posted Agenda will be heard later.
The Board of Directors agreed that the urgent item will be heard later in the meeting.
4. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. District Activity.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Hallman/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Pool, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED.
The Minutes of July 15, 2010 were presented.
Director Pool noted some clarification needed on Page 5, under Pinecrest Well: the word ‘percolated” should be inserted to make the sentence end with: the water coming out of the well
is percolated groundwater.
Also at bottom of that same item, the discussion about Lake Pillsbury, gist of it will have been, there should be less of a problem with siltation in the future.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes of July 15, 2010 as corrected.
Pool/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Hallman, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
The Minutes of July 22, 2010 were presented.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes of July 22, 2010 as presented.
Hallman/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Pool, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
The Minutes of August 19, 2010 were presented.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes of August 19, 2010.
Pool/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Hallman, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
6. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION TOPICS.
Nothing submitted
7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS OTHER THAN THOSE LISTED IN GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT.
ACTION ITEMS.
a. Conservation, other than GM Report.
GM Koehler reported he and Director Voege attended the August 31st Irrigation Pond Liner presentation at Parducci Winery. There were about 30 people in attendance. Ken Seckora spoke
about why ponds leak and about the latest techniques to stop them from leaking or keep them from leaking. He also advised that if you can find a spot in the vineyard where there is
clay and it doesn’t drain, you should pull out your vines at that spot and build your pond there. Tim Thornhill gave a presentation of safety considerations, including leaving some
unlined areas around the pond where wildlife can escape if it has fallen into the pond. Carol Mandel of AWEP, (Agricultural Water Enhancement Program), spoke of how AWEP funds can
provide matching funds to help you pay for improving your pond if you meet
certain criteria. These Wine Country AWEP funds are for watersheds in Mendocino, Sonoma and Napa Counties and the funding priority for 2010 will be given to applications in the Russian
River and Navarro River Watersheds.
b. GM Koehler informed the Board that he will not be available for the November Board Meeting due to vacation scheduling.
8. GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT AND ACTION ITEMS, SEPTEMBER, 2010.
District Operations.
The District is operating well with no problems to report at the treatment plant.
One of our operators cut his hand and was on light duty for a few days but did not lose any time.
Also, when we do our service line repairs throughout the year, we routinely fill the pavement cuts with cold patch and then about once a year, we have all the cold patches replaced with
asphalt. We have received a price of $6,000 to repave all of last year’s patches from leak repair jobs, so that amount will be showing up in a future expense report.
B. R.C.H.D.C.
Things are not moving ahead very fast on the housing project. We won’t spend much time on this until Calpella CWD resolves their problems with the project, as Dave Redding wants to
clear up the wastewater and water tanks storage issues before we proceed. Millview will also need to resolve whether or not they can produce the water. It is confirmed that we have
plenty of elevation gain from our tanks to allow gravity flow into the Calpella tanks.
C. Pinecrest Well.
Nothing new to report.
D. New Employee.
A candidate has been hired to begin on September 27, 2010. He is T-2, D-2 certified and will eventually be able to share in the on-call duties.
E. Recovery Operations Specialty Services.
The State has requested a couple of photographs that might eliminate the need for them to come out for a site visit. Ross Mayfield’s secretary has told GM Koehler that all the CalEMA
employees are in Southern California covering emergency events. Things are winding down, but nothing will be released until the State of California actually gets a budget.
F. Surge Tank.
Jack Spilman is doing the work for the property owner. He is also working for another property owner who wants the tank. GM Koehler has provided the tank drawings to Jack for his
review. In addition, the new owner stripped the vegetation from the site, leaving loose dirt everywhere. Director Reuser expressed concern about potential washout of the topsoil
and wonders what remediation the owner has done, because when it rains, this mud is going to end up in the drainage the District just spent $150,000 mitigating. GM Koehler said the
owner is planning to have Jack Spilman do the hydro-seeding. GM Koehler reported that he and an engineer from George Rau’s office and Cecille Morris walked down the site and they
told Ms. Morris, This is the District’s drainage, and this is the confluence with their drainage, and you notice that right now this is clean. It is absolutely spotless; there has
been no rain. So, we have documented it with the Regional Water Quality Control Board. If we start seeing turbidity come roiling down the hill, we are going to come to this spot
and we are going to point our finger at the top of that hill.
G. Lake Pump Road.
The pump road is clear and drivable. The culverts are plugged primarily with sand. Kevin at the Corps of Engineers is planning to meet with GM Koehler to inspect the
culverts. Kevin’s initial indication is that it is the Corps’ responsibility because the culverts belong to the Corps even though we enlarged them at the request of the Corps. It
was agreed that a whole lot of time and money won’t be spent improving or removing the road until such a time as the Corps and SCWA make some kind of determination. If indeed the
Lake is going to be operated at anything over 750’ then we’ve got to start moving up the hill with 2 sections of road. If they are
thinking about raising the lake another 30-feet, there will be no campground anywhere and there is no land- based recreation area. We’ll have to put in an entirely new road from the
wastewater plant out to our pump station.
Action Item 1. Fetzer Allocation Issue.
Fetzer has two 2-inch meters set, one at the end of Bel Arbres Road and the other at Uva Drive & Smith Lane. Both meters were installed before the moratorium, one in 1980 and the other
in 1987. At some time before the moratorium, it was district policy to contact the customers and ask them how many allocations they would like to have on their meters, and Fetzer asked
for 51 allocations. Their rate was modified to pay the monthly minimum for 51 allocations and they paid that fee until 2006. They were not overpaying because at that time 8,000 gallons
of water was included in with each minimum rate and they were typically using 500,000 gallons to 700,000 gallons a month at the compound. They weren’t overpaying for anything. But
in 2006 both Attorney David Rapport and Attorney Paul Minasian said that allocations are bad. So in an attempt to regularize the whole allocation system, General Manager McCosker contacted
the domestic customers including the secretary at Fetzer’s and asked how many houses they actually have and she said 9 houses. As a result, they were bumped down to 9 allocations from
51. So there is some confusion there. Again, they are still not overpaying because they are paying 9 monthly fees and they have been paying 9 monthly fees since 2006, plus they pay
for their water usage. They are still using consistently between 500,000 and 700,000 gallons per month for the 4 or 5 wineries, 8 or 9 houses, farm labor buildings, etc., it’s a huge
compound over there. Everything functions off the 2 meters, and the 2 meters are intertied, so it’s really one looped water line with 2 meters on it, and both of them have double-check
valves on them which prevents any backflow. At this point, the property is divided amongst the families. A potential buyer of a certain parcel decided to back out of negotiations
when it was determined the Water District cannot guarantee a source of drinking water for that parcel because it is located at the end of the Fetzer’s private line loop off of Smith
Lane. Even though this is within the District boundary and not an annexed area, the District does not have a distribution main at that location. The ‘bottom line’ after a tremendous
amount of research, is that there is not a whole lot we can do to help them. They can go ahead and apply for a building permit and Planning will contact the District and ask if there
is water availability and we will respond, There is a water service line to that property being provided by the Fetzer Family. At this point in the meeting, it was suggested that the
Fetzer’s should have their legal team assist with sorting this out. GM Koehler should be available in the future after some matters are cleared up. It is obvious the Fetzers have
always tried to do the right thing with the District. The District must work within the guidelines placed upon it.
9. FINANCIAL REPORT.
The Financial Report was reviewed. It was noted that water sales are still sluggish. It was further noted that this has been a very mild summer, possibly one of the mildest summers
in the past two or three decades.
MOTION: Accept the Financial Report as presented.
Pool/Reuser Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Reuser, Hallman, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
10. LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION OF MENDOCINO COUNTY - LAFCO.
Nothing to report.
11. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION. COMBINED WITH:
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT
DISTRICT.
An All Boards Meeting of the Boards of the IW&PC member agencies was held on Thursday, September 9, 2010 in Ukiah for the purpose of holding a public discussion with the Corps of Engineers
on the Coyote Dam Feasibility Study. The member agencies are County of Mendocino, City of Ukiah, Potter Valley Irrigation District, Russian River Flood Control, and the Redwood Valley
County Water District.
Directors Butow and Pool and GM Koehler were in attendance for Redwood Valley. GM Koehler referred to the Dam Safety Review 2005, Screen Portfolio Risk Assessment (SPRA) which gives
Coyote Dam a Safety Rating of “3”, with “1” indicating Disaster and “5” indicating Safe. They are prohibited by Law from raising a dam that is anything other than “5”. The issues
making Coyote Dam a “3” is a strong suspicion that there is something wrong – either seepage, or seismic, or overtopping (which would indicate that the spillway is inadequate). If
the reservoir is close to full, and a major storm occurs, they won’t be able to dump water fast enough to prevent overtopping. The minute you overtop an earthen dam, it is very dangerous.
Mike Dillabough said there are 350 dams within their system and they cannot get the funding for dams rated “1”, much less for dams rated “3”. His estimate was if they got a billion
dollars a year, it would take 30 years to get around to the Coyote Dam, and he stated in no uncertain terms, it is going to take many millions of dollars to get Coyote Dam converted
to a DSAT “5”. Ultimately, in order to combine the Seismic Study portion of the Feasibility Study with the Dam Safety Study, they would do an Issue Evaluation Study. They finally
agreed that the Scope of Work to decide what the Study would look like, would only cost $16,000 instead of $100,000, but the Study itself would cost $1,000,000. They think that it’s
still a year off, even if they started tomorrow, and they can’t start tomorrow because they don’t have any money. So the result of all of this, is that Flood Control has proposed a
Resolution to be signed by all affected parties and by taking a stack of these signed documents - from Potter Valley and points north and all the way down to Marin - to Congressman
Thompson and Senator Feinstein, it is hoped that they would go to Congress and plead for money. At this point it’s a very simple resolution, asking congress to act on this and support
this project.
Resolution No. 2010-2, Resolution of the Board of Directors of RVCWD Regarding Needed Improvements to Coyote Dam and Lake Mendocino, was presented.
The Board agreed that the affected parties should speak with one voice, and this Resolution will do that.
MOTION: Approve Resolution No. 2010-2 as presented.
Hallman/Reuser Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Reuser, Pool, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: Voege
ABSTAIN: None
13. REPORT OF ATTENDANCE AT AGENCY MEETINGS, I.E. CITY OF UKIAH, COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS, ETC., NOT LISTED SEPARATELY HEREIN.
It was noted that no City Council members were in attendance at the All Boards Meeting. The City Manager was there, but no City Council people.
14. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY.
a. Consider any correspondence or reports concerning the Sonoma County Water Agency.
b. Discussion and possible action on SCWA topics; water audits, conservation, etc.
General Manager Koehler reported he spoke with Pam Jeane at SCWA yesterday. Due to budgetary problems in Mendocino County, the Supervisors are closing out the Mendocino County Water
Agency as of October 1st, so Pam is reaching out directly to GM Koehler. She asked him to create a paper document for their files showing justification of the expenditures Mendocino
is incurring with the Conservation Fund, i.e., this is how the gauge works, how it helps, etc.
15. STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD.
a. Updates and possible action.
As of October 1st there are changes in assignment of management at the SWRCB. The result is that Victoria Whitney has been transferred from Division of Water Rights, to the Division
of Water Quality.
The new Division Chief for Water Rights is Barbara Evoy.
Other changes are Darrin Polhemus to Division of Administrative Services and Esteban Almanza to Division of Financial Assistance.
BREAK: 8:43 P.M.
Member of the public, Mr. Beck left the Meeting during Break.
RECONVENE: 8:53 P.M.
CLOSED SESSION: 8:54 P.M.
16. CLOSED SESSION (Agenda Item No. 19)
a. Real Property Negotiations - Government Code Section 54956.8.
Conference with Real Property negotiators.
Address of Property: Water within Lake Mendocino available to Russian River Flood Control
& Water Conservation Improvement District, Sonoma County Water Agency,
Mendocino County Water Agency or other water by substitution.
Action Proposed: No formal Action is anticipated.
Action will be provided to the Real Property Negotiators consisting of the Attorney
and Board of Directors representatives.
b. Real Property Negotiations; Report of Negotiator, Donald Butow, in regard to progress or lack of progress in negotiations for access to water sources, rights of way, easements
or
interests in real property related to transmission and storage of water. No address available.
Negotiations with County interests and other possibly effected landowners. Government
Code Section 54956.8.
c. Conference call with legal counsel re: Existing Litigation - Government Code Section 54956.9.
Complaint by SWRCB regarding Redwood Valley County Water District utilization of water
from Lake Mendocino. Arbitration and Cease & Desist Order and Proceeding before the SWRCB.
Action Proposed: The Board will not take action but instead provide guidance and direction
to staff.
OPEN SESSION: 9:23 P.M.
17. REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 17. (Agenda Item No. 20)
President Butow stated the Closed Session was for information only. No action was taken.
The Meeting ended at 9:25 P.M.
The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, October 21, 2010 at the Water District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE APPROVED:
SIGNED:
Secretary, Board of Directors