HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011-12-15 RVCWD Minutes—draft --
REDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
237OWebb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley CA9547O
(707)485-0879
MINUTES
BOARD OFDIRECTORS
Regular Meeting
Thursdoy, December15. 2011
Directors Present: Donald E. Butovv Jeanette HaUman, Granville Poo, Pamela Ricetti, Jaok8pi|man
Directors Absent: None
Staff Present: William L. Koehler, General Manager
Linda Gnoth, Qffioa Manager, Secretary tothe Board of Directors
Others present County SupervisorCornu Brovvn, Will Cnrson/yWi||viewCVVD. K. Tiamonn
7:OO P.M.
County Supervisor Carre Brown asked if any of the three recently elected Directors have already been Sworn -in and
signed their Oath cfOffice. Director Pamela Ricettihas done so. Atthis time Supervisor Brown performed the
Swearing -in with Oath of Office for both Director Granville Pool and Director Jack Spilman.
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Granville Pool, Board Vice -President
Jack Spi|man.Director
Jeanette Hallman, Director
Donald Butovv, Board President
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
Mm
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
As a matter of general information, President Butow stated the Board will follow the procedures it has used at several
previous Meetings with new Directors, that is, the election of Board Officers will be held at the January Board
Meeting.
4.APPROVAL {}FCONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b,1. Bills Paid since those approved edlast Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid asapproved stprevious Meeting.
C. Bills Payable.
d. District Activity.
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board ufDirectors, R.vCxxo.
After review and clarifications, a Motion was made.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Pool/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Minutes of the November 17, 2011 Regular Meeting were presented.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes of the November 17, 2011 Regular Meeting as presented.
Hallman/Spilman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Spilman, Ricetti, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: Pool
6. DIRECTOR AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON -ACTION TOPICS.
Nothing submitted.
7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTSOTHER THAN THOSE• IN GENERALPO
ACTION
a. Conservation, other than in GM Report.
Today GM Bill Koehler along with GM Tim Bradley of Millview and GM Dave Redding of the Calpella and Willow
County Water Districts met with a representative of the RCD. The request was that we offer support for the RCD
applying for a Conservation Grant. The RCD is going to approach Sonoma County Water Agency for matching funds
to apply for the Grant, which will be for conservation. GM Koehler requested that, if this were to come about, and
since we (Redwood Valley) have already spent $30,000-$40,000 on conservation measures for our domestic
customers, that it would be appropriate to possibly look into gauges or other helpful tools for our agricultural
customers. The RCD will meet with each of the District's Board of Directors, as the RCD cannot apply for grants
directly themselves, they have to be sponsored by some agencies. A presentation will be made to the RVCWD
Board of Directors next month
b. Election results.
The newly elected Directors, Granville Pool (incumbent), Pamela Ricetti and Jack Spilman are now serving on the
Board of Directors. President Butow thanked County Supervisor Carre Brown for being in attendance tonight and
performing the Swearing -In and Oath of Office before the Meeting began.
e. Water Main marking.
Director Spilman expressed concern about the potential of unmarked, or mismarked, water mains being damaged
and the resulting added expenses possibly being placed upon the District.
GM Koehler said his research shows that very few water mains are located outside the county road right-of-way.
The District has only Engineered Drawings, not As-builts, and unfortunately they are not always accurate, such as
the area of School Way where the lines were actually located 6' away from where they were shown on the drawings.
Fortunately, in the five years that he has worked for the District, there has been only one (1) time that someone hit
our main. Director Spilman said he experienced the same thing with line markings on his property several years ago;
Minutes, Regular Meeting 2
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
December 15, 2011
the lines were actually located some distance from the markings. GM Koehler informed the new Directors that the
District is in the process of having its whole system incorporated into a GPS system. And with that information, the
general consensus of the Board was that the GPS system will resolve the issue.
f. Safety issues regarding operators and heavy equipment.
Director Spilman reported a recent situation where he heard quite a few comments from throughout the community
about an obviously inexperienced field crew personnel operating some track -steered heavy equipment. The risk of
injury was a concern, and also costs to the District if an injury should occur. GM Koehler informed the Directors that
he also heard, and this was taken very seriously. After an in-house safety meeting the next morning, that employee
was relegated to lower level tasks until further notice and further training. Safety meetings are ongoing.
1ggp's. • a
A. District Operations.
The level of water in Lake Mendocino is well below the conservation pool level, and will remain that way unless we
get some rain. Fortunately the demand last month was very low.
B. Redwood Valley Community Church.
This project is being done by the customer. The Water District is not responsible for the design. District personnel
will supervise, and the District will be named as Additional Insured. There is no expense to the District with this
project.
C. Watershed Sanitary Survey.
The draft Watershed Sanitary Survey was received today. GM Koehler has not had time yet to thoroughly read the
document.
Member of the public, Keith Tiemann informed the Directors that the Broad Band Alliance meeting scheduled for
January 6th has been changed to January 13th and they will be formulating their next presentation to the Board of
Supervisors. He hopes a representative from the Water District can attend and report back to the Board of Directors.
In addition, he urged that the Internet Availability Survey be completed and returned.
County Supervisor Carre Brown stated that the Availability Survey is very important. These surveys are sent to
Washington D.C. and they give the testimony from our citizens showing that there is very little coverage in our rural
community. There will be no Grant funding available to communities where their maps show that they are mostly
covered; and as it stands now, the federal maps show, inaccurately, that the rural communities around here are
already mostly covered!
E. Conservation Ordinance.
GM Koehler brought attention to the lack of rain so far, and the potential that we may need to implement our
Conservation Ordinance. After having the Ordinance in effect for a period of time it is apparent that there are a few
sections of the Ordinance that need to be revised. For instance, the tiers need to be changeable upon discretion of
the Board Action or notices from various Agencies of Authority, and not limited to the lake level and dates.
The Directors held a general discussion for the benefit of the new directors, including information that a general
pattern of conservation throughout the system has overall reduced not only the consumption of water but the income
level to support the District. Proposition 218 requires public hearings so that the customers are given opportunities
to participate and to understand why, if the water usage drops, the rates must increase in order to cover the costs of
operation and maintenance; or else the District has to build some combination of rates/reserves into the regular rate
structure. The Water Code requires us to provide water for, 1st, human consumption, 2"d, human sanitation and 3rd
fire protection. There are special provisions for medical institutions and schools.
It was agreed that GM Koehler will bring something for discussion during the January Meeting and if it appears we
are facing an emergency before the January Meeting, a Special Meeting can be called.
Minutes, Regular Meeting 3
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
December 15. 2011
County Supervisor Carre Brown left the Meeting at 8:18 P.M. at which time the Directors again thanked her for being
here to Swear -in the Directors and to participate in the Meeting.
After review and discussion, a Motion was made.
®"PION: Accept the Financial Report as presented.
Pool/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
10. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS OTHER THAN THOSE LISTED IN GENERAL MANAGER'S REPORT.
ACTION ITEMS. (AGENDA ITEM NO. 7.C. AND NO. 7.,D., (Continued)
a. Resolution No. 2011-3 and Bank Signature Cards. Agenda Item 7.c
MOTION: Approve Resolution No. 2011-3 and Bank Signature Cards.
Hallman/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Pool, Ricetti, Spilman, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
b. Resolution No. 2011-4 and Signatures. Agenda Item 7.d.
MOTION: Approve Resolution No. 2011-4 and Signatures.
Hallman/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Pool, Ricetti, Spilman, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
11. M. C. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION.
a. Report of attendance at IW&PC Meetings.
b. Consider any correspondence concerning the IW&PC.
c. Discussion and possible action on IW&PC topics.
President Butow, Director Pool and GM Koehler attended the IW&PC Meeting at which Consultant Paige Poulos
provided a progress report on efforts in getting the word out up and down the Russian River, for the importance of
protecting the Eel River Diversion.
The COE Report listed nine deficiencies that resulted in the Coyote Dam rating as a 3. Most of the deficiencies can
be corrected; the deficiency that cannot be corrected is the proximity of an earthquake fault next to the existing Dam.
The SCWA has agreed that the water level behind the dam can be raised, but since the dam is a flood control
facility, releases continue to be made. Any increase in the water level depends on what time of the year that we
receive substantial rains.
The IW&PC is still talking about supporting the installation of alarms up and down the Russian River in case of dam
failure. Judy Hatch continues to express concern that pouring more money into efforts to get the dam raised, is a
`lost cause'. She is thinking that an All Boards Meeting is needed, perhaps in February after Sean White collects
some more information.
Minutes, Regular Meeting 4
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
December 15, 2011
The next Eel/Russian River Commission meeting will be held in Ukiah at the City Council Chambers on February 9,
2012, and Sonoma County Supervisor Efren Carrillo will be in attendance. The Commission will be discussing the
Biological Opinion.
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT
DISTRICT.
a. Report of attendance at MCRRFC&WCID meetings.
b. Consider any correspondence concerning the MCRRFC&WCID.
c. Discussion and possible action on Flood Control District topics.
Director Pool reported the FCD seems to finally have their GIS mapping completed. The original map submitted to
the State Board was created with fairly primitive technology (clinometer and hand drafting) and were inaccurate. The
GIS mapping technology revealed a huge difference in the actual acreage from what the mapping was supposed to
show in the first place. The State Boards calculation from the original map was 12,000 + acres; the GIS calculation
reveals that it is 16,000+ acres. The FCD submitted the GIS mapping as a correction, hoping the State will accept it.
If the State does not accept it as a correction, the FCD will have to do a Protest.
There was also comment that they need to try to get SCWA to lift its Protest. Director Pool also reported that Sean
White said something about needing to set up another meeting to research that, but it was not clear with whom the
meeting would be held.
GM Koehler added that he did not attend the FCD meeting, but he did read the Minutes of the previous meeting, and
then he read the GM Report for this meeting. He thinks Sean was saying that the next step would be for Sean to
attempt to have a meeting with SCWA first, regarding the 6,000 A-F. Then following the meeting regarding the
6,000 A-F, it is Sean's general feeling that it would be time to kick-start the FCD-RVCWD ad hoc committee
meetings again.
13. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY.
GM Koehler reported that he attended a meeting with Pam Jeane, Grant Davis and Jay Jasperse at the SCWA
headquarters in Santa Rosa last Friday, December 2, 2011. The meeting was held at his request and there were a
number of topics for discussion.
On Monday, December 5, GM Koehler phoned Sean White and gave him a full report of the meeting. The primary
topic was to discuss getting the Surplus Water Agreement reauthorized, as it has been expired for two years.
Complementary to that, is to get release of funds that are still being held in the account - including the $64,000,
including the $22,000 that we've already spent, including the $10,000 that we owe on the stream gauge. It rapidly
segued into a discussion of the 6,000 A-F; of the founding ordinance of Sonoma County Water Agency (which
prohibits, for all practical purposes, the sale of a water right); the 7500 A-F; the conservation efforts; the whole can of
worms.
GM Koehler continued, he set up the meeting hoping to take care of a whole lot, but what he did get was a better
understanding of what they want from us in order to make this process go forward. In the past, we have been
approaching it from the angle of, how can we make them release the 6,000 AF, and what would we do with it.
Instead, what SCWA wants is, rather than backing in to the 6,000 AF, they want us to figure out what we really need.
The way the additional 6,000 is currently projected is actually two applications, one for 2600 and one for 3400, and
has a point of diversion as our pumps. It's kind of complicated because it's unlikely that we would need 6,000 A-F in
Redwood Valley, unless something dramatic changes (such as a population explosion).
So that complicates the issue in that before, when we were discussing the 6,000 A-F, the 6,000 would be available
pretty much at any point of diversion anywhere within the merged FCD & RV Districts, thereby increasing the water
supply pretty much anywhere in those areas. The homework that we were sent back, was that we need to get real
about a) how to merge the Districts b) define a future with a coordinated approach — essentially, they want a white
paper or a roadmap so to speak, that includes how to stretch a limited supply, get rid of the uncertainty of the surplus
agreement. Sonoma would like to see Redwood, at least, approach it from two different tiers: what would we need in
order to relieve the uncertainty that we have, and without increasing supply. And how much would we need if we
were actually able to increase supply.
GM Koehler
So, we have some work to do. What do we think our projected demand at build -out is going to be? The new
Directors have both said they have been approached by people who want to get onto the Ag System. We need to
Minutes, Regular Meeting 5
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
December 15, 2011
look atmaps ofthe distribution system and see ifvvecould physically serve them now, orifAgMain Extensions
would need tobebuilt. The Agdistribution system does not cross the freeway,although the Domestic distribution
does; but there ispotential for new ogcustomers, onthe west side. VVealso need tolook atthe domestic side. We
have o 'waiting list' of potential applicants. The2OO5 Census states there ana25OO homes in this zip code; we serve
135Oofthose homes (this includes the mobile home parks) This figure does not include any granny units, for
example, that have been added to customer properties but haven't been registered with us. VVedonot serve the
Black Bart Trail area of Redwood Valley, or the Baker's Creek area off Tomki Road, etc., etc. The maximum
amount of water that we have delivered in a year is 2600 A-171- we currently are delivering about 1350 A-F. If we
expand our service areas, that would involve the Annexation process and then could involve installing booster
pumps along with the Main Line Extensions, etc.
One of the discussions that came up during our many ad hoc meetings, was some reluctance on the part of the
alleged new district, toget involved inthe annexing additional new areas. Nodoubt itiesuch apain towork with the
State Board onannexing, itioomulti-year process. However, vveneed tostart with figuring out how much water vve
actually will need.
During general discussion, GM Koehler provided that adding another filter, at another $250,000, is 400 more houses
onthe system. That's all vvareally need toupgrade the water treatment plant. The clarifiers are big enough and vve
have surplus water storage in the field, on far as the tanks. Another topic to decide will be the Capital Improvement
Fee (Cap Fee) for each new service.
Discussion ofvarious scenarios continued. |nthat vein GK8Koehler stated, ifvvecan get the moratorium lifted, vve
will be able to develop additional ways to serve our customers'water needs.
And tying intoProp 21O.vvewill need hnget anengineering firm inhere toperform areal Rate Study/Cap Fee Study.
|fvvebring inCo|-Runa|.they will doitfor free. That's agood starting place.
It is assumed that the 2800 AF for storage is gone, we don't have that storage. |fthe restriction onour ability to
divert water during frost season,
Back tothe SCVVAmeeting, the money hsnot being released sdthis time. GK8Koehler did discuss the $S4.0OO
expenditure with them and they do agree the expenditures do qus|ify, but they are not releasing funds piecemeal.
They are refusing hobeinthe drivers' seat. They are telling uathat vveneed hobeinthe drivers' seat. VVeneed to
tell them the integrated package including what political form we're going to tsho, what we've got to offer, what
pieces vvewant tokeep, how vveare going tostretch the supply. Because part ofthe premise vveand FCDwent to
SCWA with a couple of years ago was, you know, if we could quit squabbling, there probably is enough water.
President Butow mentioned that the SCWA founding ordinance states that Water Rights cannot be sold (except by
fairly prohibitive measurem).but it also states that the water can besold under permanent contract (such as
Hea|dsburg.etnj Therefore Mendocino could purchase also.
GM Koehler stated that 6 months ago they told us that in order to come up with that number, D1 610 has to be
neoo|vad, because until D1G1O is resolved, they can't model how much water might be available.
During discussion, member of the public, Will Carson left the meeting at 9:43 P.M.
It was agreed the District will discuss all these facets further, and proceed with doing its homework.
The Meeting ended at 9:55 P.M.
The next Regular Meeting will be at 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, January 19, 2012 at the Water District Office, 2370
Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Minutes S
Board ufDirectors, R.vCxxo.
Respectfully Submitted,
Linda Groth, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
SIGNED:
Secretary, Board of Directors
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
December 15, 2011