HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011-03-30 RVCWD Minutes SpecialMinutes, Special Meeting
Boards of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. & R.R.F.C.D.
March 30, 2011 Page 1
REDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
Minutes
Board of Directors, RVCWD & Board of Trustee’s, RRFCD
Special Meeting
Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Barra of Mendocino, Tasting Room
7051 North State Street, Redwood Valley CA
GM Koehler made introduction and thanked Barra of Mendocino for providing venue.
CALL TO ORDER: 8:00 A.M.
1. ROLL CALL FOR R.V.C.W.D.
Hal Voege, Director
Jeanette Hallman, Director
Merle Reuser, Director
Donald Butow, President
Staff Present: Bill Koehler, Paula Berezay
ROLL CALL FOR R.R.F.C.D.
Lee Howard, President
Judy Hatch, Vice President
Richard Shoemaker, Trustee
Al White, Trustee
Paul Zellman, Trustee
Staff Present: Sean White
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC FOR ITEMS
NOT ON AGENDA.
None
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
Urgent items can’t be considered at Special Meetings.
4. DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING POSSIBLE WATER RIGHTS PURCHASE
FROM SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY AND POSSIBLE MERGER WITH THE FLOOD
CONTROL DISTRICT.
Trustee Lee Howard opened the meeting introducing RRFCD GM Sean White to make a presentation to the
public.
RVCWD Vice-President Granville Pool arrived 8:10 A.M.
Minutes, Special Meeting
Boards of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. & R.R.F.C.D.
March 30, 2011 Page 2
GM Sean White stated Redwood Valley Water District is looking for alternatives for a water supply.
When RV’s contract expired, Sonoma County had several conditions. He explained by combining
the two districts it would maximize existing water rights. He stated this goal will be good
for all. RVCWD would have the same priority, liability, standing as SCWA & RRFCD. The RRFCD
application for 6,000 af would be abandoned. SCWA wants consolidation. SCWA has all new
Board members and manager.
Trustee Lee Howard asked the Board Members to state their questions and comments.
Director Don Butow explained to the public that four years ago RV got together with SCWA for
surplus water. It has been a constant search for water. He explained the reservoir property
availability, but the costs would be too expensive and it would not lift the moratorium. He stated
RV is presently pumping under its own rights for the first time for three months. He mentioned
Decision 1610 and the many issues between the Districts to overcome, but stated it could be doable
and we need to take the first steps.
Trustee Richard Shoemaker said this is a good move.
Director Jeanette Hallman said she feels this is a good move and stated that RVCWD needs a solid
source of water. She also mentioned annexations.
Trustee Al White said this was great.
Director Merle Reuser supported this and said it would give RV solid water rights.
Trustee Paul Zellman said this is an opportunity to correct mistakes made 25 years ago. A unified voice
would benefit the community and the State Board.
Director Hal Voege said it was a positive goal but he needs to know more about the details.
Trustee Judy Hatch said it took a long time coming, but she doesn’t want the existing RRFCD rate payers to
pay more.
GM Koehler replied the details are to be worked out. Neither side wants to pay an unreasonable share. He
mentioned a more complicated accounting process. RRFCD has no direct water customers. He mentioned the
moratorium and if it was lifted, would the annexation areas be allowed. RV goals are to be affordable for
primary Ag. customers. He questioned how much to offer SCWA for water and trying to keep the price down
to under $300.00 per af. For domestic customers it would be easier. Also the possibility of agriculture
changing in RV. He mentioned wine grapes using less water than other crops. We need to be
prepared for growth. RV will be having more meetings with the public. Several issues need to
be worked out and to keep costs as low as possible.
Trustee Lee Howard spoke about one entity, consolidation and annexation. No one wants to pay
for someone else’s water. Is tax accepted? He mentioned new customers and a participation
agreement. He stated the Ukiah Area Plan doesn’t even include Redwood Valley. RV only gets
surplus water and negotiations need to be done soon. The dollar amount will have to be worked out.
We need to hear from the public. He mentioned LAFCO and the time consuming process or the
possibility of State Legislation. He said RV has a judgment against RRFCD that would go away.
He mentioned the RV petition for Place of Use and the Bureau of Reclamation bill. A firm water supply
is an advantage for everyone.
Director Don Butow mentioned the Ad Hoc committee and how we need to get information to the public.
Would the moratorium be lifted if we get permanent water supply? He is concerned with working out
the details. Two different Districts, one is wholesale and one is retail. There are lots of issues in RV that
Minutes, Special Meeting
Boards of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. & R.R.F.C.D.
March 30, 2011 Page 3
FCD doesn’t have to deal with.
Director Jeanette Hallman asked if both Boards are going to SCWA.
Trustee Lee Howard stated Ad Hoc could go jointly to SCWA.
Director Jeanette Hallman stated someone should go from each Board.
Trustee Richard Shoemaker stated the process needs a lot of work. The first step is an official memorandum.
Develop a committee to work with SCWA and give regular reports to the Board. Have a M.O.A .
(Memorandum of Agreement) drawn up between the two agencies, and the group come up with a proposal to
SCWA. We have to have public input.
GM Sean White stated the biggest detail is to see if SCWA will say yes. He said this is the time
to do it, and the Boards should expedite this so we know if SCWA is a yes or no.
Director Don Butow agrees for the Boards to work up a possible M.O.A.
Director Hal Voege agrees with Richard Shoemaker and GM Sean White. Let’s look at the deal killers first. He
was curious about the SCWA offer to RRFCD. He was concerned if SCWA agrees, what the cost
might be.
Trustee Judy Hatch mentioned the Ad Hoc did a good job, and to keep the Boards informed. Both Boards
should be privy to information.
Trustee Lee Howard mentioned the 6,000 af.
Director Don Butow said RV went down to Santa Rosa about 1 ½ months ago and stated the renewal of
surplus water hasn’t gone forward. SCWA was interested to know if we wanted to purchase water
provided getting rid of 6,000 af (RRFCD’s not RVCWD’s). The opportunity is good now but he is
concerned about the costs.
Director Granville Pool stated SCWA seemed to express interest. Decision 1610 as well as changes in
structure will take time. SCWA expressed strongly the desire to only deal with one entity.
Trustee Lee Howard invited the members of the Public to offer their comments at this time.
Charlie Barra brought up the past and how hard they worked to organize the District. He mentioned
the Area of Origin Rights and challenging SCWA in court. It’s been done, Arizona sued Colorado.
We can show beneficial use now.
Will Carson applauded both entities and discussed joining forces. He asked whether RV would
be receiving a defined water amount and how it would have effect on other water districts joining.
GM Sean White stated if RV is paying for 3,500 af it will all go to be Redwood Valley. If over time RV doesn’t
need it they could sell it.
John McGowan said this is a 55 year old problem. We should have an M.O.A. before you talk
to SCWA.
Jack Spilman asked if there was a way the Ad Hoc committee can be put on a website.
Trustee Lee Howard stated the Ad Hoc meetings are not agendized or posted. We will try to better
communicate to the public. The M.O.A. has to be approved by both Boards.
Minutes, Special Meeting
Boards of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. & R.R.F.C.D.
March 30, 2011 Page 4
Charles Vau said no one wants lawsuits. He wants to be able to buy water for the least amount of money.
Mr. Van Vleet asked, “Should we give up the 6,000 af?” “Is 3,500 af enough?” RRFCD has already
used 8,000 af.
GM Sean White stated the 6,000 af is not based on demand. It is what is left over from reduction
to northern Sonoma County.
GM Koehler stated that RV has consumed 2,600 af on several occasions and that 3,500 af would allow for
reasonable growth. The amount we get we will have to pay for, whether we use it or not.
Trustee Lee Howard stated not everyone could apply for the 6,000 af.
Director Richard Shoemaker said 6,000 af is uncertain. Not guaranteed, everything is negotiable.
John McGowan asked,” If the agreement is intended to cover Redwood Valley, what is in it for
RRFCD?”
GM Sean White said it is not about advantage but about what we can do for the public. Several
entities such as RV have been underserved way too long.
Trustee Lee Howard said it benefits the entire watershed. RV has worked eighteen years trying to
find storage. The devil is in the details.
Jean Harman asked about the Eel River and Lake Pillsbury, and if we are going to be cut off.
She said to look at the larger picture. How much is Marin County paying for water?
Jack Cox asked if we would pay for the water whether we use it or not?
Trustee Lee Howard said SCWA sells from an appropriated water right to us. RRFCD also filed on 6,000 af.
Trustee Richard Shoemaker said RV would still have to pay the amount appropriated.
Director Merle Reuser stated we are not obligated to buy 3,500 af.
Debbie Vinson commented it is good merging the Boards and moving forward with SCWA for water rights.
MOTION: Ad Hoc to go forward with M.O.A. and talk to SCWA as one entity.
Hatch/White
AYES: Lee Howard, Judy Hatch, Richard Shoemaker, Al White, Paul Zellman
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Trustee Richard Shoemaker mentioned an initial M.O.A. to work together and agrees the Board members
will not independently have discussion with SCWA. Get an agreement and all exchange signatures.
Whether 3 months or 3 years we need an agreement in place.
Director Don Butow suggested Motion: RVCWD enter simple M.O.A. between the two Districts to approach
SCWA.
Director Hal Voege asked if it included the GM. The answer was yes.
Director Jeanette Hallman asked if the Ad Hoc committee will report to Board at the following meeting.
The answer was yes.
Minutes, Special Meeting
Boards of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. & R.R.F.C.D.
March 30, 2011 Page 5
MOTION: RVCWD enter simple M.O.A. between the two Districts to approach SCWA.
Pool/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Hallman, Reuser, Butow, Voege
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
GM Koehler asked, “Do you want discussion of the dollar amount involved?”
Director Jeanette Hallman said the amount is less than the recent survey amount.
GM Koehler will contact the Grange Hall folks and set up a public meeting at that location.
Director Don Butow stated it was premature. First enter into discussion as to how much
SCWA wants.
Director Reuser commented on the unknown dollar position of SCWA. See if SCWA will even talk to us.
Trustee Lee Howard asked the public if there are any more comments.
Charlie Barra discussed the Corps and raising the level of the Lake and moving the campground.
He questioned who will get the water?
GM Sean White explained that raising the water level does not increase the volume of water available.
It increases the carry over capacity for the following year.
Trustee Lee Howard stated only the community will make improvement happen.
The Meeting ended at 9:40 A.M.
The next RVCWD Regular Meeting is scheduled for April 21, 2011 at 7:00 P.M. at the Water District Office,
2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
The next RRFCD Regular Meeting is scheduled for April 11, 2011 at 6:00 P.M. at 151 Laws
Road, Suite D, Ukiah, California.
Submitted by: Paula Berezay, Acting Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE APPROVED: April 21, 2011
SIGNED: Linda Groth
Secretary, Board of Directors