HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011-06-16RVCWD Minutes
MINUTES
Regular Meeting
Board of Directors
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Directors Present: Donald E. Butow, Jeanette Hallman, Hal Voege, Granville Pool, Merle D. Reuser
Staff Present: William L. Koehler, General Manager
Linda Groth. Office Manager/Secretary, Board of Directors
Others Present: Keith Tiemann
CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 P.M.
1. ROLL CALL.
Hal Voege, Director
Granville Pool, Vice President
Merle Reuser, Director
Jeanette Hallman, Director
Donald Butow, President
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
None.
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
Nothing submitted.
4. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. District Activity.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Pool/Voege Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Pool, Voege, Hallman, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED.
The draft Minutes of May 21, 2011 were presented.
MOTION: Approve the draft as the Final Minutes of May 21, 2011.
Voege/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Voege, Pool, Hallman, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
As a courtesy to a member of the public, the Directors will hear Agenda Item No. 8.H. at this time.
6. GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT AND ACTION ITEMS - H. (Agenda Item No. 8.H.)
H. Broadband Internet.
President Butow introduced member of the public, Keith Tiemann, to offer his presentation representing the Broadband Alliance of Mendocino County. Keith Tiemann explained that this
is an ad hoc committee, a brand new committee of the Board of Supervisors and he is their unofficial representative tonight because they are so new that they don’t have any committee’s
formed yet. The Alliance is composed of some very impressive professionals from different backgrounds county-wide and is recognized by the Board of Supervisors in a resolution of strong
support and encouragement to proceed, copy of which was submitted in the Board Packet. He explained that statistically, 52% of internet users in Mendocino County only have internet
access by dial-up. Unfortunately, dial-up performs very poorly and leaves a lot to be desired. Many of those people find it necessary to drive into town to a public location with
broadband access in order to conduct their personal matters/business from that location. He has personally been searching for something that is reliable, faster and affordable in Redwood
Valley, but he hasn’t found anything encouraging. He asked GM Koehler how the satellite internet is performing at the Water District. GM Koehler answered that the satellite internet
outperforms the T-One the District used previously; and although the satellite is subject to weather conditions in Kansas which is where the satellite downloads, it is marginally better.
He finds that the large download applications sometimes get frozen in the middle of downloading. Director Pool mentioned that another problem with satellite broadband is that it’s
only one direction, it is download only. President Butow mentioned he is on Comcast in Redwood Valley and hasn’t been able to find anything available that is faster at this time.
Keith Tiemann continued, stating that the Community Foundation has issued a ‘challenge grant’ to the Broadband Alliance, meaning that when the Alliance raises an initial $40,000 the
Foundation will match it with another $40,000. This will provide the initial funding the Alliance needs in order to proceed with their efforts to acquire information and to develop
broadband accessibility in various areas in the county.
Director Voege commented that another item of benefit that should be mentioned is that broadband accessibility is an inducement to new businesses.
Director Pool remarked that, although the presentation and paperwork submitted clearly state how nice and convenient it would be to have broadband access out here, there is nothing specific
on how to go about it. He has trouble supporting something that is so vague. Keith offered another sheet of talking points and a work plan. President Butow is wondering if it is
doable in this mountainous country. Director Voege stated that AT&T is very reluctant to extend the carrier, and he wonders how this group would do that. Keith responded that it would
begin with extensive surveys. The results would be given to the consultants who would compile all the data and then approach the carriers. After further discussion, during which he
clarified that the committee has been focusing on ‘fiber optic’ rather than cell tower type of expansion, and recognizing the need for more details, Keith said the Alliance is approaching
agencies and private businesses, trying to get going with this. He encouraged any of the Board Members and GM Koehler to attend the committee meetings in Ukiah and meet the membership.
Keith Tiemann asked the Board of Directors to provide financial support and a resolution of support, taking it on faith at this point.
Director Reuser stated that he appreciates Keith’s passion for the subject, but we are a Water Board and we are in a fairly serious financial situation right now.
Keith responded that since Redwood Valley is an unincorporated area outside of Ukiah, he sees the Water District as a public agency that has an opportunity to serve the people of Redwood
Valley and provide a public service to them above and beyond what a water agency provides. He thinks it would be a great gesture on the part of the Board to do this for the sake of
the residents of Redwood Valley.
Director Reuser remarked that the Water District is not in the position to make financial contributions as gestures.
Keith Tiemann responded that he thinks the District could be in that position; he said the latent powers of the District’s Charter is wide ranging and has a huge scope and enables the
District to – Director Reuser continued, stating that he didn’t say the District doesn’t have the authority or the power to do so, he said that it doesn’t have the money to contribute.
He is all for signing something that says the Board agrees to it and it’s a wonderful project, but as far as spending any
District money on it, no. We don’t have any money for pet projects. How would we bring this to our customers the next time we have to talk about a rate increase? The people of Redwood
Valley look to us for water and that is a very time consuming, energy, all-encompassing thing, just to tend to the matters of the Water District. As a Water District Director, he is
not interested in spending further energy at this time on the broadband issue.
Director Voege suggested that the Alliance committee should find out how other communities have handled this very issue in the past; such information would be very helpful when the time
comes to bring the matter back again.
Keith Tiemann again requested that the Board issue a Pledge of a Future Contribution in order to support the Alliance.
President Butow asked the Directors their feelings on the matter.
Director Hallman thinks it is very ambitious and she needs more information. She agrees with Director Reuser’s comments about it not being appropriate for the Water District at this
time.
Director Pool is troubled by the County Board of Supervisors not considering it a high enough priority that it can put money toward it. He agrees that the county is in bad shape monetarily,
but the need to draw more businesses to the County, and all the other benefits, and yet no money toward it indicates that it may be an idea before its time. He feels the County, the
Chamber of Commerce, the Employer’s Council are the kinds of agencies that should be behind this and supporting it.
President Butow told Keith that he offered a very good presentation with the information he had to work with, however he hasn’t yet been provided with all the tools needed to answer
all the questions and concerns. He encourages that this go forward.
Director Pool added that he is interested in this, but he is not sure that it is an appropriate matter for the Water District to consider other than a small way in regard to its own
business.
Director Hallman reiterated the financial concerns and emergency projects that the District is facing.
Director Voege added that he supports the idea of broadband coverage but at this point he cannot support a financial commitment to the project.
President Butow spoke of the $750,000 project the District is facing in the near future with relocating the water mains because of the County Department of Transportation bridge relocation
project in Redwood Valley.
SEE NOTATION AT END OF THIS DOCUMENT.
It was agreed that the matter is tabled for the time-being.
Director Pool remarked that although the District response might have seemed like a ‘downer’, he wanted to
congratulate Keith on getting involved in trying to represent the people of Redwood Valley that were otherwise unrepresented.
Keith again offered GM Koehler and others to attend the Friday morning meetings.
Keith Tiemann left the meeting at 8:02 p.m.
7. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON-ACTION TOPICS.
(Agenda Item No. 6)
Director Voege reported that he attended the Board of Supervisors meeting on Tuesday and the good news is, on a 4-1 vote, the B.O.S. agreed that the former Masonite property will remain
an industrial site and that the Lover’s Lane area will remain agricultural.
Additionally, there appears to be a group of business people in Mendocino County who are seriously thinking about buying the former Masonite property as an industrial park and they are
already talking to the County about the details.
8. DIRECTORS AND STAFF REPORTS OTHER THAN THOSE LISTED IN GENERAL MANAGER’S
REPORT. ACTION ITEMS. (Agenda Item No. 7)
Conservation, other than in GM Report.
Nothing new submitted.
9. GENERAL MANAGER’S REPORT AND ACTION ITEMS, JUNE, 2011. (Agenda Item No. 8.)
A. District Operations.
The District is operating normally with no problems to report.
GM Koehler told the Board that he will have the Budget ready by July 1st and he wonders if the Board wishes to Order a Special Meeting to discuss the Budget. Otherwise the Board will
hear the topic at the July Regular Meeting. Consensus is that the July Regular Meeting date is acceptable.
As of today, GM Koehler has received the Preliminary 65% Engineering Plans for the School Way Bridge relocation project. D.O.T. wants a response by July 22 in terms of how we expect
to do relocation, easement, right of ways, everything. GM Koehler spoke with Engineer George Rau today and his rough guesstimate for design work is $15,000. There will be some relocations,
as we’ve got an ag main on the south side of School Way and a domestic main on the north side. We need to get them both on the same side. We have to provide a lot of information including
how we will keep our customers in-service during the construction phase. Also it looks like the bridge abutment foundation on the west side is on top of our water main, and we will
also have to deal with that.
Further details and discussion followed. Again GM Koehler reminded the Board that D.O.T. wants a response by July 22nd and if Rau & Associates, Inc. is acceptable without conflict of
interest, GM Koehler would like to have them start the design work. If the Board prefers to go out to bid, which has been preferential in the past, we will have to hire somebody to
put together the bid package, and the timeline is extremely tight. It is almost certain that we will have to bear the full $250,000 to engineer the lines.
MOTION: Move that we contract with Rau & Associates, Inc., if they have concluded there is no conflict of interest, to do the design so discussed.
Voege/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Voege, Pool, Reuser, Butow
NOES: Hallman
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
B. Surge Tank Insurance Settlement.
Fish and Game has assigned a new person to the surge tank overflow issue. Our District, our insurance company, our engineering firm, and Granite Construction have all been operating
on the assumption that the cleanup we did at the abandoned dump site in the affected watershed was the mitigation and as such, complied with the penalty requirements. Despite the fact
that no responsible party was ever identified, we will now have to meet with Fish and Game to try to sort this out.
C. Watershed Sanitary Survey.
The City of Ukiah sent out RFP’s for the Watershed Sanitary Survey update. Two engineering firms with extensive experience preparing this type of document submitted proposals, one
in the amount of $37K and one in the amount of $40K. Each proposal asked for exceptions to the language of the contract. The City, as lead agent, will review the request for changes.
The RVCWD share of costs is 17% (based on potable water production) and our costs will be in the $6-7,000 range unless there is cost overrun. In order to not cause a delay once the
agreement is prepared, we should have a Motion approving the signature of President Butow on the contract agreement.
MOTION: Approve the signature of President Butow on the contract agreement for the Watershed Sanitary Survey update.
Voege/Reuser Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Voege, Reuser, Hallman, Pool, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
D. Merger/ad hoc.
The Redwood Valley County Water District ad hoc committee and General Manager Koehler met with the Russian River Flood Control District ad hoc committee and General Manager White on
June 8, 2011.
President Butow reported that he told the RRFlood ad hoc committee that RVWater is concerned whether or not it is legal for the two agencies to merge, since RR Flood was created through
legislation and Redwood Valley Water was simply the formation of a District through election with boilerplate wording for a Special District. They responded that they could go back
to the legislature and put another bill together. Frank McMichael at LAFCO had offered that procedure as one of the options. His other suggestion was a Community Services District
(CSD), the advantage is that a CSD has latent powers to provide both wholesale and retail water as well as waste water, power generation, and other services.
President Butow said there were other topics discussed, and he pushed for the idea that if/when we merge, there would be a Board of perhaps seven (7) instead of five (5) members so that
we could be assured that Redwood Valley would have people on the Board. But that didn’t seem to go over too well. He reported further discussion and added, to be fair to everybody
on their side of the table, this is all just discussion; everything is in a state of flux. That’s why he urged them to first find out if it is possible for our two agencies to merge.
Then we can discuss all this other stuff.
Director Pool added that when the meeting started, the ad hoc committee and GM Koehler all understood that Frank McMichael at LAFCO had steered us toward the Community Services District
as the logical and sensible and reasonable thing to do. However at this joint ad hoc committee meeting, the Flood Control District ad hoc committee members had a completely different
understanding of what Frank had said; so, Sean White called Frank and convinced him to come join our meeting and sort that out. Director Pool continued, to my amazement, according
to Frank that’s not what he said at all! He feels if we were to dissolve and reform as a CSD, the process is very involved, very costly, very difficult, and a big ordeal. A simpler
way would be for one District to just absorb the other. Director Pool continued, it’s clear the RRFCD has no interest in doing anything but absorbing RVCWD. He said he raised the
point then, that if everything looks good going in, and the people of Redwood Valley think this sounds good, and everything checks out in terms of cost and benefits and it goes through
the approval process and it’s all well and good, and then after the fact, there is no RVCWD water board to specifically represent and protect the people of Redwood Valley in this,
and then if things start getting by the Flood Control Board and the people of Redwood Valley aren’t happy about it, what recourse do they have? He thinks it was Lee (Howard) who made
the point that they can put forward candidates from Redwood Valley for members of the Flood Control Board in the next election. So that is basically their solution.
GM Koehler said that he agrees that when our ad hoc group met with Frank earlier, it was different than Frank’s comments on June 8th and it was fortunate Sean was able to get him to
the room so we could all hear the same thing at the same time. The process of dissolving two districts into one district is a lot more expensive and a lot more time consuming process
than a legislative reformation. Essentially, Flood Control would change its name. What we got from Sean as far as their primary enactment was actually that it would be an amendment
of the Water Agency Act, Appendix 54 of the California Water Code. It would be amended by forming an Improvement District on top of the Water Conservation & Flood Control District,
which they were originally formed under. In theory they have all the latent powers that we need. They can do water/wastewater/recycle/raw water/ag water.
Director Reuser stated, I may be oversimplifying the matter, but as it stands right now, if we give Sonoma County $3 million dollars, which is the number already given to them by Sean
when he and Bill went to SCWA, and we dissolve the District, and from that we get what - the right to purchase 3500 acre-feet?
GM Koehler clarified, No, it’s that we have purchased 3500 acre-feet that is exclusively for use north of Highway 20. Basically, it is transferred from Water Right A to Water Right
B, and then the folks north of Highway 20, as the zone of benefit on the debt service on that $3 million dollars have exclusive right to the 3500 acre-feet including the stipulation
that if any of that water is sold south of Highway 20, that water will be sold at the true cost of that water and not at the contract price that is currently in existence with the Flood
Control District.
After further discussion, including mention of the Beneficial Use issue and the RRFCD’s 30-Day Maximum Storage issue to be discussed, it was apparent there is so very much to be worked
out. GM Koehler concluded that it will take time, and expense, however: It Can Be Done.
Director Pool mentioned that another meeting with Sonoma County Water Agency is tentatively scheduled for mid-July.
President Butow suggested that the current MOA between RVCWD and the RRFCD should be extended another three months, to the 1st of October.
MOTION: The Memorandum of Agreement be extended another 90 days.
Voege/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Voege, Pool, Hallman, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Further discussion followed, during which Director Pool said that he is in accord with Director Hallman’s stated intention to follow the will of the people of Redwood Valley in this
matter. He isn’t speaking of the 30 or so people who attend meetings to speak, but by an election process or however we get a response from all the populace. If this is the will of
the people, then it is what he wants as a member of this Board and as a citizen of Redwood Valley.
GM Koehler stated that during his phone conversation this morning with our legal counsel Paul Minasian, Paul indicated he is open to a conference call meeting with the RV ad hoc committee
to discuss the legal maneuverings, recommendations, etc. Yes, his opinion is that it can be done; it has to be done right, there have to be protections in place to resolve the issues.
E. FEMA CalEMA.
After five years, we finally received the final check from the state and federal offices for the emergency repairs. The total cost for all the work was $1,120,000. The total of non-reimbursed
expenses is approximately $100,000.
F. Insurance Costs.
Matter carried to next meeting.
G. Restricted Funds.
GM Koehler has researched all our records and Minutes and found that during five specific meetings discussing the rate increase, Director Hallman had asked that we establish a separate
account to begin building a reserve for future projects and loan repayments. GM Koehler stated that all the Minutes reflect that there were extensive discussions and although the various
Directors agreed that this would a good plan, a Motion was never made. After completing his research, GM Koehler then contacted our Auditor who advised we can either set aside funds
in the existing bank account or create a separate account, and we can call it a restricted account but unless some other agency requires repayment with a restricted account, the funds
will actually be reported as unrestricted. Director Hallman thanked GM Koehler for his time and effort to research this matter. President Butow stated that we will be going into Budget
discussions next month and all this will be discussed at that time.
H. Broadband Internet.
Discussed previously in the Meeting.
I. IW&PC Annual Dues.
Consider approval of the invoice for $2,000, IW&PC Annual Dues.
President Butow reported that Judy Hatch felt the Commission should set aside an additional amount for a war chest for fighting the big cause on the Eel River Diversion when it comes
up for licensing in 2022. She suggested that if everybody were to start putting aside an additional $1000, in other words, raise the annual dues to $3,000 instead of $2,000, there would
be some money available when it comes time to fight the big fight. She also brought the same issue to her Board at the Flood Control District meeting.
Director Reuser said he is concerned that $1,000 additional is too small a figure. The war chest wouldn’t build-up fast enough between now and 2022 at that rate. He would prefer $5,000
per year + the $2,000 as a more realistic amount to fight that fight.
MOTION: Pay the $2,000 invoice.
Reuser/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Reuser, Pool, Hallman, Voege, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
J. Xeriscape Plan.
The Board of Directors had already approved payment of $500 for a xeriscape design/plant plan. We were thinking lots of rocks, lots of bark, etc., etc. So we received the completed
plan and we paid the $500.
GM Koehler is disappointed and displeased, because the plan we received basically has every square inch covered with some kind of plant. He had repeatedly told the designer that we
want something generic that we can pass on to our customers. This is clearly not what was discussed and not what was expected and is not the xeriscape message we want to sell. GM
Koehler will talk to the designer again.
10. FINANCIAL REPORT. (Agenda Item No. 9)
a. The Financial Report was reviewed.
MOTION: Approve the Financial Report as presented.
Voege/Pool Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Voege, Pool, Hallman, Reuser, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
b. The Auditor’s Packet, year ended June 30, 2010 was reviewed. Director Voege referred to the Operating, Income, Loss (in the middle of page 6: Budget, Actual, Difference) There
was no entry for the Difference. We will ask the Auditor to correct/complete the information.
MOTION: Approve the Auditor’s Packet with correction as stated.
Hallman/Reuser Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Reuser, Voege, Pool, Butow
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
11. LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION OF MENDOCINO COUNTY – LAFCO. (Agenda Item No.
10).
Nothing to report other than Frank McMichael’s attendance at the joint ad hoc committee meeting as reported earlier in this Meeting.
12. M. C. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION. (Agenda Item No. 11)
President Butow reported on his attendance at the IW&PC Meeting of June 9, 2011:
1. The Corps of Engineers has reported that all the campgrounds at Lake. Mendocino are open.
2. County Supervisor Carre Brown stated that No EIR in the Groundwater Monitoring was reported at the BOS Meeting on Tuesday June 14th.
3. They discussed establishing a war chest for legal fees for relicensing of the Eel River, with possibly $1,000 additional from each of the agencies with members serving on the Inland
Water & Power Commission.
4. Sean White reported that regarding the frost protection reasonable use issue before the SWRCB, the Farm Bureau requested an extension of the comment period.
5. Supervisor Carre Brown reported on the Eel River public effort and the hiring of a consultant. The consultant requested insurance information on IW&PC and it turns out, there is
none. Candace Horsley has been asked to contact the JPIA and it is possible that member dues will need to be increased to cover an insurance premium.
6. Tentatively, the Eel-Russian River Commission meeting will be held at the Conference Center in Ukiah on July 29, 2011.
13. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION
IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. (Agenda Item No. 12)
President Butow reported on his attendance at the Flood Control District Meeting of June 13, 2011:
1. The in-stream flow is approved to be dropped to 125 cfs.
2. They are down to 2 meters left to install. The cost of all the meters so far, is $150,000.
3. New email address: rrfc.net
4. Licensing process is down to map, draft and letter. The draft has been submitted.
5. State Water Board held closed session on the Millview CWD issue on June 21, 2011.
6. RRFCD is discussing the revised water contracts, they are still working on the use-it or lose-it portion.
7. Judy reported on the IW&PC meeting in regards to the lack of insurance for their new consultant; and also the proposal to contribute $1,000 a year towards the war chest for Relicensing
the Eel River in 2022.
14. REPORT OF ATTENDANCE AT AGENCY MEETINGS, OTHER THAN THOSE LISTED PREVIOUSLY.
(Agenda Item No. 13)
GM Koehler reported: Regarding the September 23, 2009 Protest that we filed in order to have Standing, in the Petition for the changes to the minimum instream flow requirements, they
have filed for an extension because they received 400 Protests and they have to respond to each one of those. As a result, the Draft EIR is scheduled to be released in July, 2012.
The Final EIR is scheduled to be Certified in September, 2013.
The Meeting ended at 9:55 P.M.
The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for 7:00 P.M., Thursday, July 22, 2011 at the Water District Office,
2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California
NOTATION: Let the record show that the expense of $750,000
so stated during the Meeting was not corrected at the time, however, the actual figure for the project is $250,000.
APPROVED AS NOTED: Board of Directors
DATE APPROVED: July 21, 2011
SIGNED: Linda Groth
Secretary, Board of Directors