HomeMy WebLinkAbout2012-08-16 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Regular Meeting
August '16,2012
Directors Present: Jeanette Hallman, Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Jack Spilman
Directors Excused: Donald E. Butow
Staff Present: William L. Koehler, General Manager
Paula Berezay, Office Manager/Secretary to the Board of Directors
Others Present: County Supervisor John Pinches, Steven Gardner
CALL TO ORDER: 7:02 P.M.
1. ROLL CALL.
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeanette Hallman, Director
Jack Spilman, Director
Granville Pool, Board President
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
Is=
5 j I I I M I I I 1111 � I'M
MOTION: Accept the Agenda as presented.
Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
1BSENT: Butow
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012
5. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR.
a. Financial Statement.
b.4 Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. District Activity.
After review and comment, a Motion was made,
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: Butow
7:07 P.M. County Supervisor John Pinches arrived.
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED.
The Minutes of July 19, 2012 were presented.
MOTION: Approve the Minutes of July 19, 2012 as presented.
Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: Butow
a) Personnel Committee report,
This is a place -holder. Nothing to report at this time.
Director Spilman asked to discuss the radio system from the pump station to the water treatment plant.
The Board agreed to hear his comments under Agenda Item 8.a..
8. GENERAL MANAGER'S REPORT.
8-A. District Operations.
The District is operating well with no specific problems to report.
Director Spilman inquired whether the radio system has been purchased yet, wondering if there is a
possibility the District could get the same benefit by using wireless access.
GM Koehler confirmed that the radio system has not yet been purchased. He also explained that the
signal is constant, 24/7, from multiple sites and because of that, the charges for wireless would exceed the
charges for the radio system and therefore it didn't seem practical. However before purchasing anything,
our SCADA company, MCC, will come to Redwood Valley and perform a Radio Site Survey. At that time
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012
Vvo will discuss our vDti0Ds' dedicated fneOUeDCy, licensed n@di0' broad $peCbU[o radio or an alternative.,
such aswhat Director Spi|UO3Dis suggesting. Before purchasing Vve will look atcost- effectiveness, buy -in
costs, everything.
8-B. Vacation
GMKoehler will bm0Dvacation the third Thursday iDNovember, Regular Board Meeting date. The fourth
Thursday isThanksgiving Day. GK8Koehler suggests the Regular Board Meeting bescheduled for the fifth
Thursday iDNovember o0that hewill be able tvattend. This will bediscussed again iDOctober.
8-C. Linda Vacation.
The Directors thanked Office Manager Paula Berezay for taking notes at the Meeting tonight while
Recording Secretary Linda GnVthiaoOvacation.
GM Koehler reported that he met with field staff after receiving the July 19th draft Minutes which itemized
Board directives after coming out ofClosed Session. All field staff were verbally provided with that
information and then later field staff was provided the directives in written form, which they signed and
returned iothe GM.
As requested, GM Koehler changed his work schedule to 7e-3:30p' M-F. On nl0Uth|y Board Meeting day,
hewill arrive at7aand will stay until the Board Meeting isover. Hmwill not come towork the next day
(Friday). This change ofhours means hewill not beable toattend the evening monthly meetings nfthe
Flood Control District, the |VV&PC' and the Farm Bureau Water Committee. These are very important
nnmmUDgs and should bmattended byaDirector.
President Pool said Di[. BUtovvi8 designated to attend the FCD meetings, however ifhe cannot then Di[
Spi|[n8Disthe Alternate. President Pool asked 0[8pi|OO@DtVnotify him ifneither Don nor he can attend.
On the |VV&PC Dir. BUtoVV is the Commissioner and Di[ Ricetti isthe Alternate.
For the Farm Bureau Water Committee, Dave Knba|| from Fetzer Vineyards is the Chair and is very Up to
date ODwater issues. Also attending iearepresentative from the Sonoma County Water Committee,
providing updates uDfrost issues. President Pool requested that Director Ricettiattend the meetings and if
she is UD8b|e to attend o particular meeting, Director Hallman will bethe Alternate.
Director Hallman stated that next month she would like the Board ufDirectors to have a more in-depth
conversation ofpersonnel issues. |fanybody has any concerns 0[comments, they can bring itt0the
Board utthat time ifthey need to. She doesn't have @ preference astVwhether it's iUOpen Session u[
Closed Session. BK8Koehler will have this topic placed oUthe Agenda for next month.
Director Spilman asked if a chain of command has been set up as requested. GMKoehler stated that, 88
far aGfield VVO[k. he specifically assigned the job of Lead Person to Scott Norcross.
This item is informational.
8-F. Surge Tank Site.
Mrs. Benrazavi ietoo busy stthe moment tOdeal with the transfer and the easement.
Since GM Koehler has already obtained certain proof that the District OVVDs that pF0pedv, he is not pushing
her on this.
Director Hallman is not sure the District needs tosign over anything.
Minutmm, Regular Meeting
Board ofDirectors, RN.C.VV.D.
August 10.2O12
GM Koehler explained that the District has the ea .aerraent that covers the valve.; site. We want this formal,
recordable easement to the antennae site. We want the easerraent to protect us for access to everything
that the District has in the ground.
President Pool stated that: the alternative is to go back to the former tank site and put up a tower that would
meet our needs.
8®G. Conservation/Fishery Fund.
GM Koehler is meeting with Supervisor Carre Brown, as part of the Fishery Committee, on Monday. He
received an email from SCWA yesterday saying they agree on the amount, but they have deleted out their
water year 2010 because it falls outside the expiration of the original surplus water agreement. Until we
get the new surplus water agreement which presumably should be very soon, they don't want that
particular $5,600 included. However, they do want the balance transferred into the Fund, with the
exception of the $5,600, That's not to say it's going to be approved; it's going into the Fund as per the
agreement. There is also a stipulation in the original agreement that any funds that remain in the Fund that
have not been approved and, if the agreement is not renewed, those funds are still to be spent the same
way. It's just that we sidestep the Mendocino County Water Agency and go directly to SCWA for
permission to spend the money up here for the same eligible items. It's a little convoluted, but after we
move money into the account to get the full amount in, GM Koehler thinks they are poised at that point to
authorize the extension of the surplus agreement. Presumably this will be used as a stepping stone to get
a more permanent agreement with SCWA. GM Koehler would like to transfer the funds on Monday. Where
is basically $21,000 for educational. The biggest individual hit was the $9,000 we spent for the
Conservation Kits that we delivered to our customers free of charge. GM Koehler provided SCWA with
written memo that the result of distributing these free conservation kits was very positive. Also there is
about $7,500 which is our share of the cost of the USGS stream gauge; plus the $5,000 contribution to the
quagga/zebra initial hazard evaluation and the North Coast Consortium which is headed toward a
permanent inspection program. The balance is to be used for the 4" irrigation meter replacement program.
GM Koehler said he will talk with Supervisor Carre Brown then he will meet with Paula to get the monies
transferred into the Mendocino County Water Conservation and Fishery Advisory Board Fund. He will not
make any expenditures until he receives permission from SCWA.
ITI[IP1 IiMM
SigningiMussel, indicate our }.•program• allow us to be at
tablethe during discussion with the consultantsgoing tobe selected to•
evaluation and risk assessment. President Pool agrees there is a value to being at the table at the
beginning of process.
Director Spilman asked where the funding is coming from. GM Koehler responded that it comes from the
Conservation Fund as just talked}• previous Agenda Item. When we signbecom
a part of cons
Directori • where the money• from } _• r changes
GM Koehler stated that if someone changes their mind, the money doesn't come from the fund and the
money doesn't get paid, because we are not paying it until it's approved as a fund expenditure.
Director Hallman added, The MOU does not require it.
GM Koehler confirmed, The MOU does not require it. The MOU merely says, We think this is a good idea
President Pool .i•*o And we are • .• to be .. T table.
GM Koehler reminded the Board that there is no commitment tied to the MOU and also, there is a
mechanism for withdrawing from participation
4
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012
MOTION. President Pool will sign the Memorandum of Understanding with regard to
the zebra and quagga rn"sselsM.O.U.
Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Fool
NOES: None
ABSENT: But.ow
3.1. School Way Bridge Funding.
GM Koehler reported that, as suggested by County Supervisor Carre gown, he has spoken with
Assemblyman Wes Chesbro and also his local representative Ruth Valenzuela. Assemblyman Chesbro
said he would support Ruth's efforts to find funding on our behalf. Ruth phoned GM Koehler recently to
say that she has found absolutely nothing. It is a dead-end. She will keep this matter open in hopes of
finding something in the future.
County Supervisor John Pinches stated that Supv. Brown is out of town and before leaving, she asked him
to come to this Board Meeting to sit in on this issue and he hopes he can provide some insight. Before
doing so, he would like to hear the GM report on this issue.
GM Koehler stated we have the preliminary drawings from Rau & Associates. The decision was made to
do this as a continuing construction project with the primary contractor who is building the bridge because
we want to avoid any construction delays. They are going to build the new bridge and a crane will insert
the two water mains into the interior of the bridge along with the PG&E gas line, We'll have a 10" irrigation
water line and an 3" domestic water line with flexible earthquake fittings on both ends, 2000 lineal feet total.
Just taking the cost of the ductile iron pipe and not knowing what the cost of a crane operated installation
into a bridge is, we think the estimate of $200,000-$300,000 is fairly accurate. The County will select the
overall lowest bid, and we understand there is potential for huge cost overruns.
Supervisor Pinches stated: The bridge itself is designed to accommodate all utilities. The feds pay 80% of
the cost of all that. It's real clear that the water lines are not a part of that.
He continued: I spoke with Howard at DOT today and Howard said he would support an option for
RVCWD to have a separate M®U with the County if RV thought it would save some money.
Supervisor Pinches suggested that since the County is also retaining the original right-of-way after the
original bridge is removed, the Water District can simply string the domestic and irrigation water main lines
across the river without being involved with the new bridge.
Both GM Koehler and Director Spilman explained the critical need to protect the water mains by utilizing
ductile iron pipe. The suggested C900 pvc pipe will decompose over time if subjected to direct sunlight.
Also, if the ductile iron pipe were to be strung across the river without being involved with the new bridge, it
would have to be supported some way, similar to a suspension bridge.
GM Koehler reported his contacts and conversations with various agencies regarding their experiences
and expenses, and all that went into the Board decision to do this as a continuing construction project with
the primary contractor. It is painful for the District that this project is draining 25%®30% of its capital
reserves. Construction is scheduled to begin in May, 2013 and the fiscal impact will affect us next year.
Supervisor Pinches encouraged further conversation with Howard at DOT. GM Koehler and President
Pool will plan to meet with him.
5
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012
8--J. —Pyerlap Area,
Nothing. (This is a placeholder).
8-K. SCWA StAirPIUS contract.
Discussed previously in the Meeting. GM Koehler is in frequent contact with SCWA.
Supervisor Pinches left the Meeting at 8:07 P.M.
8-L. Archived material.
After approximately three weeks of research and going through historical materials from the storage locker,
GM Koehler was able to reduce the volume of material by 75%. He did find some valuable information:
some missing Resolutions; the surge tank site history; the details regarding early attempts to purchase
water from SCWA; the bad history in 1978 with the MCRRFC&WCID and subsequent costs to the District;
the original design of the pump station.
9. FINANCIAL REPORT.
The Financial Report of August 16, 2012 was reviewed and discussed. This is the first Report in the new
fiscal year and shows that we are slowly dwindling down our capital.
Director Ricetti asked if we are going to continue spending our capital or else are we going to consider
raising our rates. GM Koehler will have that matter listed on the Agenda for the September Board Meeting.
He urged the Directors that have not yet read John Dickerson's report, to please do so before the next
Meeting.
MOTION: Accept the Financial Report as presented,
Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: Butow
gl�ffgl W
GM Koehler reported he still has not been contacted by the person LAFCO has hired to finalize the
Municipal Service Reviews, but his conversations with Frank McMichael before Frank left LAFCO definitely
confirmed that he does not need anything from RVCWD regarding our MSR; mostly because our Sphere of
Influence is not looking to change.
�Mo
6
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012
11. M. G. INLAND WATER & POWER GOMMI,8�ION.
A lot of the discussion has taken place in previous meetings regarding Paige Poulos and the education
program that has been funded until now. Apparently it was agreed that there are probably sufficient funds
in the dues account to pay Paige for a year. The initial money was to get things rolling; they are exploring
the possibility of forming a 5013C under the umbrella of Fish Friendly Farming, so that they can go out
there and get tax-free donations, etc.
OM Koehler reported that Director I3utow told him that the only thing really worth reporting from the August
2012 IW&PC Meeting is that there was a great deal of consternation and discussion about whether it is
even legal to provide the money from the dues account to pay for this project. The Flood Control District
has apparently chosen to look into the legality issue. OM Koehler feels this is a bit strange because the
IW&PC was formed with the specific intent of protecting the project. The primary enemy to the project is
the "Friends of the Eel River". That group is determined to tear, the dams out, with no regard for the impact
that such an action will have on 600,000 people including 4,000 residents of Redwood Valley.
The Federal Energy & Regulatory Commission will be reviewing the licensing for the project in 10 years
from now, and it is a 20®year process.
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION
IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT.
GM Koehler reported that Director 13utow told him that the primary topic of interest at the FCD Meeting was
concern that there should be an investigation made into whether it's legal to extend the funds held in the
IW&PC dues account.
GM Koehler seems to recall that Judy Hatch, the FCD representative serving as a Commissioner on the
IW&PC, did vote in support of this.
Director Hallman added that she skimmed through the FCD Meeting Minutes. It was a very short meeting
and there was nothing that stood out.
13. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY.
Already discussed.
4 REPORT
OF ATTENDANCEA AGENCY SEPARATELY
• • • • • •
to help get Lake ounty, which includes ake Pillsbury, reengaged. There was discussion of fish -friendly
"block water" releases out of Lake Pillsbury during the spring rather than the fall. Spring releases would
encourage the • _
ing fish.
President Pool reported he & GM Koehler met with Chris Neary, Tim from Millview and Dave from the
Willow and Calpella Districts. GM Koehler added that since Millview and Willow are now sharing an office,
they are also doing cross -training in their water treatment processes of both well/groundwater and river
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012
water with direct filtration. There was some mention of having Redwood Valley field staff also cross -train
with the two agencies for distribution systern and related maintenance, etc.
15. STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD.
Chief Engineer Jay Jaspers, Tong with other representatives of the SWRCB, will be touring the entire
Russian River. These are people that are promulgating Rulings affecting the Russian River area and with
changes of personnel at the SWRCB over a period of time, most of them have never visited the area.
During the Upper Russian River and Lake Mendocino portion of the tour, GM Koehler and President Pool
will be meeting with the SWRCB representatives, along with the Flood Control District representatives, and
the Sonoma County Water Agency representatives. The tout, is being conducted this corning Wednesday,
August 22, 2012 and a report will be provided at the September Regular Board Meeting.
16. STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES.
Nothing new to report.
17. STATUS REPORT OF 2300 ACRE-FEET STORAGE RIGHT.
Nothing new to report.
The Meeting ended at 3:40 P.M.
The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, September 20, 2012 at the Water
District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully Submitted,
Linda Groth, Recording Secretary
A _ QED • of Directors
DATE APPROVED:September1
SIGNED:Paula Berezay
Secretary, Board of Directors
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
August 16, 2012