HomeMy WebLinkAbout2012-07-19 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
%z
Regular Meeting
July 19, 2012
Directors Present- Donald E. Butow, Jeanette Hallman, Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Jack Spilman
Directors Absent: None
Staff Present: General Manager Bill Koehler
Recording Secretary: Linda Groth
Others Present: County Supervisor Carre Brown, Steven Gardner, unknown member of the public
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Donald Butow, Board Vice -President
Jeanette Hallman, Director
Jack Spilman, Director
Granville Pool, Board President
3
lam
Vice President Butow announced to the Board that although it won't be happening immediately, it is quite
likely that he will be moving outside the District boundary before the end of this year. His term of service
would ordinarily end in December 2013, which would be the culmination of 14 years of service on the
Board of Directors. Whomever the Board should Appoint to fill his vacancy will serve until the end of his
scheduled term and then will be subject to the election process.
President Pool stated he will be sorry to lose Director Butow but he understands and he appreciates the
early notice.
7:05 P.M. County Supervisor Carre Brown arrived.
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
MOTION: Accept the Agenda as presented.
Hallman/Butow Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Butow, Ricetti, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. District Activity.
The Consent Calendar was reviewed.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Butow/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Butow, Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
.413SEUT: Vote
President Pool asked the other Directors if they feel the Meeting Minutes should be required to be a word-
for-word transcript. The June Minutes were 55 pages long and that runs into longer hours to produce and
at a higher cost to the District.
Director Spilman said a 5-hour Meeting is too long.
Director Butow said he hopes the goal of the Board would be to do their job in fewer hours and hopefully
the Board Meeting would not extend beyond 10 — 10:30 P.M.
GM Koehler reminded the Board that the digital recording is transferred onto a removable hard drive for
permanent archiving, which would be easily available if there are any questions in the future.
President Pool mentioned that at least one of the other Special Districts doesn't even record their
Meetings, which surprised him to hear. He then asked Supervisor Brown if the County Minutes are
verbatim.
Supervisor Brown said there is a legal debate, but currently the Minutes are reflecting only the Actions
taken by the BOS. However, everything is backed up with Agenda Summaries, and they also have
Attachments for what the subjects were all about. There are other entities within the County that provide
Minutes with more details. Supv. Brown added, It's just whatever your policy is.
President Pool would like to see the District Minutes be detailed enough and copacetic enough to capture
the essence of what was discussed; and then of course, to reflect the Motions.
After further discussion, the Board agreed to go forward with receiving much shorter Minutes and also to
have the occasional 'time of meeting' posted within the Minutes.
NEW".]
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
UQ=1- I I OWN I I
M&L L51[TuLur NaMman T commem Me FIL 10 Say WaL UUM OU110ifla 1-011ILY afl,t 0lY11L He* r-1 III
same day.
MOTION: Accept the Minutes of June 21, 2012 with notation.
Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Butow, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
=*J;1VZW, a i ii i
b III
GM Koehler reported that as of today, the District's internet provider is Digital Path. It is the same cost but
it's 3 times faster than Hughesnet and is far and away a better product.
a) Personnel Committee report.
President Pool stated that the Personnel Committee did not meet. Director Spilman requested updated,
detailed listings showing the job descriptions and responsibilities. Both he and President Pool will receive
the information.
Director Ricetti said her IT programmer contact has provided a Compensation Analysis Format that can be
adapted to accommodate the District's needs and it will update automatically. GM Koehler has been
working with the programmer so that all the data we require will be shown.
President Pool mentioned he has requested that GM Koehler provide a printed hardcopy of the Dickerson
Report for reference. It is an actual analysis of all the water and sewer districts in the Russian River Basin
in Mendocino County and the proposals made over the years to consolidate them and why it hasn't
happened. President Pool feels that whether or not RVCWD wishes to consolidate with other Districts, this
Report provides some very useful guidelines.
GM Koehler reminded the Board that the report is also available at vvww.rrfc.org. He will provide each of
the Directors with a written path to follow at that website in order to find the Dickerson Report and the
Neary Report.
=0 rel= 01TTV NITI NUVWWW1 4110-1 V0 as]
The District is operating well with no specific problems to report.
M. I FA 0 1. �W -
Regarding ownership of the tank itself, Dr. Benrazavi has verbally agreed to send the $10.00 check at
which time GM Koehler will provide her with a receipt for the tank.
8-C. Former Surge Tank Location.
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
Jim Ronco has sent a note saying he hasn't had time to look into this matter yet. However GM Koehler has
continued to pour through old boxes of historical files, and has found what he feels is the answer. He said
there was a condemnation trial in 1981. The District actually purchased that site in 1981 at the value set by
the Judge, which was $15,000 for the 2/1 Oths of an acre the District needed. It was the best building site
for the District on that 33.80 acre parcel.
GM Koehler has in hand, the Memorandum of Intended Decision from 1981, and the subsequent 1981
Legal Judgment with a legal description of the site. He does not have a copy of the Complaint filed, but he
does have the Case No. of that Complaint, so he will go to the County Recorder and obtain a copy. He
suggests the Board of Directors, upon agreement with Dr. Benrazavi, get a satisfactory easement to that
portion of the project for which we do not have an easement. In exchange and for a very nominal fee, we
would then transfer the property back to her because it's useless to us and we can't sell it to anybody else,
and he doubts she is in any position to give the District any money for it.
President Pool wants to make sure the language we do end up with would let us go and do whatever is
necessary to dig up the conduit and replace it if needed. He also urges that at the end of the document, it
should include the wording "and appurtenances thereto".
GM Koehler suggested, as a courtesy to the property owner, we should make it as unrestrictive as
possible.
President Pool agreed, he just wants to make sure we don't shoot ourselves in the foot in the process,
especially since we're giving back something for which we paid quite a lot of money.
GM Koehler will take care of it.
The Board and GM Koehler continued general discussion and clarification of the physical layout including
the easement and antenna at the surge tank site, including the history of litigation, prejudgment, judgment
and legal description. The surge tank site is a legal survey.
The Adjusted Budget, as requested last month by the Board, was presented and discussed.
It was noted that the income was lower than expected. Also there are some numbers that GM Koehler will
review for the Directors.
GM Koehler stated that once the Budget is approved he will be able to go forward with the early survey
work and the valve exercising project.
MOTION: Approve the Budget in its final presentation by Staff so that they can go forward
with the budgeted expenses.
Butow/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Butow, Ricetti, Hallman, Pool
NOES: Spilman
ABSENT: None
President Pool clarified that the specific numbers the Board asked the GM to review do not affect the
1udget for this coming year.
As an aside, Director Spilman asked about our current standing with the State Water Board regarding the
mitigation monies the District paid.
GM Koehler reported that the District has received a formal letter from the State Water Board, with a cc to
J.R. Ashcraft at Rau & Associates, Inc., stating that there is nothing more expected from RVCWD. The
only thing the State needs is a final report from Rau & Associates. JR has replied to the State asking for
details of the type of report they require, i.e., an Executive Summary, or else a compilation of all the reports
he has sent them over the last couple of years. His estimate is anywhere between $500-$1,500,
4
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
depending on whether they want a few pages or a bound hundred -page book. Our letter from the State
Water Board says that Redwood Valley has paid. No more money required, no more surprises. All they
need is a Final Report, and the books on this are closed. The State is satisfied, and, the RCD has the
money.
8-E. Tank Maintenance.
GM Koehler advised that he doesn't feel the District needs to spend a lot of money this fiscal year on
professional tank maintenance. He has staff doing all the maintenance that can be done in-house this
year. The oldest tank in the system, built in 1978, does have structural damage by the vent that needs to
be taken care of.
President Pool feels an important point for the Board to absorb in this matter is the kind of expenditure the
Representative presented last month for the Tank Maintenance Agreements, and not only for the sake of
the tanks but for all of our infrastructure. The next big thing is all of our pipes and valves in the ground. So
when you look at that staggering huge expenditure the reality is that whether we spend it that way or we
plan for spending it some other way, such as our own maintenance and ultimately replacing the tanks or
whatever, it's probably some sort of an indication of the kind of money that we need to be figuring has to be
planned for and budgeted. The tanks are just one part of it. President Pool continued, Again I'll say, if you
read Dickerson's Report, you'll see a pretty good discussion of what all that means and why small water
districts nationwide tend to be heading for a train wreck because of trying to ignore this. Dickerson had
some guidelines about how you should be budgeting for capital, maintenance and depreciation, and if I
remember correctly his number was about 10% set -aside, which is a little more attractive than the 15%-
17% that the State is suggesting. He got these numbers from a nationwide survey.
President Pool urged all the Directors to read the Report.
GM Koehler said he feels there is nothing in the Budget that can be cut. In order to put 10% aside we need
to either sell a lot more water or else we'll need to raise the rates.
President Pool referred back to a discussion the Board had regarding the base rate which is ostensibly for
capital. It seems that maybe the Budget should be structured so that the money that is taken in that is
supposed to be for capital, would go into a separate capital account and all capital expenditures then would
be budgeted to come from and would be drawn from that account. We would have an operating budget
and a capital budget that are accounted for separately and discreetly. There probably will be times of
exceptional circumstances when funds would have to be transferred from one account to another, but that
is the way it should be structured.
Supervisor Carre Brown agreed and mentioned that the County is structured that way.
Director Ricetti asked GM Koehler what his feelings are about how much of this can be done in-house or
what is too dangerous for staff to do.
GM Koehler said the tank needs some serious work, the exterior coating could be done by staff. The valve
vault, the control valve, a lot of that can be done in-house. As to the interior, he is having trouble obtaining
budgetary quotes on tank coating. The contractors that have responded are requesting photographs
because they don't want to travel this distance to see the structures. So once we obtain 2 or 3 budgetary
5
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
quotes and have some sort of ballpark figure, we'll put that together and send it to Brelje & Race and they
will put together a Bid Package.
8-F. Rate Increase Discussion.
GM Koehler referred back to the committee discussion of a rate increase being carried entirely by
residential customers and he realizes that the Board needs to rethink that because the transmission
pipeline inspection and any repair of the transmission pipeline is 2/3's agricultural. Also the bridge crossing
is 50-50 ag and domestic.
President Pool added that the Board needs to be looking at maintaining and depreciating and ultimately
repairing and replacing all of our pipelines and all of our valves and so on.
GM Koehler offered an example, adding $10 to the domestic (treated water) base rate, and based on our
current consumption, translates into a $400 per acre-foot increase in revenue. He noted that Redwood
Valley consumes approximately 90 gallons per person per day, which is less than the California low
average of 125 gallons per person per day. The California high average is 250 gallons per person per day.
The untreated water typically represents an 18% share. Carrying that out, 18% is in the range of $65-$75
per acre-foot.
GM Koehler reported that Kevin Barnes from Utility Services Company came by to check in with us after
his presentation to the Board last month. He told GM Koehler that he was sitting in a vendor booth at a
water industry show and he met a guy there who inspects undersea pipelines. GM Koehler said, Obviously
for someone like that, a 4.5 mile pipeline would be 'nothing'. Perhaps it's possible that our lines could be
inspected without digging up the mains and installing access points.
President Pool referred to the Dickerson Report: A full cost rate structure is not only planning properly for
depreciation and capital expenses, but also providing clear, understandable information to your customers
so that they can understand what those costs are and why they are, and why, for their long term availability
of their water supply, they are necessary.
President Pool mentioned the matter of how we value our fixed assets and he suggested that before we
hire an engineering firm to do this perhaps we could have a discussion with the County Auditor or Chief
Auditor -Appraiser regarding the approach of the County for personal property taxation. He asked
Supervisor Carre Brown if she thought a couple of people from RVCWD could go in and talk to that person.
Supervisor Brown agreed to assist the District in contacting County personnel
8-G. Consumer Confidence Report.
The annual CCR has been mailed to most customers and hand delivered to the mobile home parks and
other combined customers. There were no violations to report. The CCR is also posted on our web site so
any Directors who are not domestic water customers may either request a copy for their records or may
prefer to look it up on the website.
F;a I WMET, IT, 17 M I =0
The Directors reviewed the annual audit included in their Board Packets.
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
MOTION: Approve the Annual Audit as presented.
Hallman/Butow Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Butow, Ricetti, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
GM Koehler offered the Board the standard engagement letter with Rick Bowers CPA. He asked the
Directors if they still wish to issue an RFP soliciting other auditors.
(8:26 p.m.)
President Pool said the consensus is to approve an RFP for a new auditor, and certainly Mr. Bowers can
also submit a Proposal for Services. President Pool still needs to take a little more critical look at things
such as the way building improvements and water rights and source of supply are valued. He has never
been really satisfied with the way those numbers are derived. He suggested this review be done at staff
level and with whatever support is needed from the Board. He also wants to look at the value of land and
of right-of-way. After further discussion and clarification of concerns stated by President Pool, GM Koehler
stated it would be advantageous to have the abbreviated RFP ask for experience with small public entities,
preferably water districts.
8:30P.M. Unknown member of the public left the Meeting
millpiz--Tip.rsv_*Im
Director Spilman expressed hope that the Water District could expand its customer base by making a
transfer of Redwood Valley customers in the southern area, which is overlapped by both the Water District
and the Russian River Flood Control, to the Flood Control District. This would allow the Redwood Valley
District to add new services in the remainder of the Water District's place of use. He feels doing so would
generate more income by adding more services and selling more water, which we need to do very badly.
He asked, Is there a problem with doing that?
GM Koehler suggested that the first decision that should be made by the Board of Directors is whether or
not the Board wishes to renew the Surplus Water Contract with Sonoma County Water Agency. If it is
renewed, the contract will contain the same language as before: No new services.
Director Spilman replied that he feels we should tell SCWA that we want to lift the moratorium we have on
the ag hookups even though we still need their water.
GM Koehler explained that he has already asked SCWA if a renewal of the Contract will allow any changes
to the customer service area. Their reply was clear: SCWA will require both Appendix A (list of domestic
service addresses) and Appendix B (list of agricultural service addresses) to remain intact and unchanged
as part of the Surplus Water Agreement.
GM Koehler referred to the Board Packet chart showing the amount of water we pumped under the SCWA
Contract, saying, Without that Surplus Agreement we would have pumped zero water during those months.
Another chart shows approximately 400 acre-feet pumped when Flood Control said, "we're out of water".
So we had to pump under the SCWA Contract and then later Flood Control came back and said, "it turns
out we did have water'. In the past, this was a chronic occurrence with FCD saying we have no water to
sell you, then we'd pump under the Surplus Agreement with SCWA, then FCD would later say, turns out
we did have water, pay us.
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
President Pool commented, If I understand what Jack is looking for, it's specifically to acquire new
customers in the overlapped area that are not actually our customers but are RRFCD customers and we
would be wheeling the water to them, right?
Director Spilman answered, That's one method of doing it, yes.
GM Koehler said he was under the impression that Director Spilman was asking to take the 8 ag services
and 43 domestic services that are in the overlap area and remove them off the Water District rolls and add
8 and 43 into the area north of the overlap.
Director Spilman said, That would allow us to wheel water into that area and also create the opportunity of
taking on more customers.
GM Koehler explained that the Stipulated Judgment lists "the number of customers". But the Surplus
Agreement with SCWA lists "the specific service address", with the wording that not only can you not add
new addresses but you cannot increase the volume.
Director Spilman repeated his idea to pick up the 8 ag and the 43 domestic accounts and relocate them
into the District and then be able to service people within the District that are without service, and then also
wheel FCD water into the overlap section.
President Pool remarked, Clearly that would be a violation of the Surplus Agreement. He asked GM
Koehler, Have you gone to SCWA and told them this? And have your received a reaction from them?
GM Koehler said Yes. He had spelled it out to Todd Schram and Don Seymour, the Engineers he deals
with, and they follow the directive of Pam Jeane and Grant Davis. GM Koehler continued, And, Yes I got a
reaction. The reaction was: No.
GIVI Koehler explained, I believe what happened that derailed the Renewal of the Surplus Agreement in the
first place, was that I asked for changes. This discussion tonight is for a far more significant change than
what I had approached them with. GIVI Koehler continued, You will note that there are several pages in the
renewal package that say, No changes to Appendix A and No changes to Appendix B.
Director Spilman asked what SCWA's reasoning is for that restriction.
GIVI Koehler said it puts more water into the District system and it changes the Addresses. It also is not
guaranteed that we're not just cutting off our own noses to spite our face in terms of access to Flood
Control water. We're chipping away at our own surplus with the FCD. These are decisions the Board has
to make; I will do what you direct me to do.
President Pool said, Given what you've spelled out tonight which is clearer to me now than it was
previously, I have to say I'm not terribly enthusiastic about the idea of going back again to SCWA on this
matter.
Director Spilman remarked, What we're doing right now is that we're having to force ourselves into a
budget situation that we're letting a Surplus Agreement with Sonoma County control. The District is not
growing, we're just sitting here stagnant and if you sit stagnant long enough I can tell you which way you're
going to go. You're going to raise your prices, you're going to put the District in a corner and you're going
to use less water. Somehow or another we've got to get away from that. We've got just one window and
we can't just let Sonoma County dictate to us exactly what we can do and what we can't. We've got to get
past that.
8
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
Director Butow stated that the original negotiators for the Surplus Water Agreement with Sonoma County
were himself and two other Board Members. We went down there and met with Randy Pool. Why?
Because Russian River Flood Control put us through the wringer. They would commit the amount of water
to the users in their District, and then offer Redwood a small balance. And then, they would go to the State
Water Resources Control Board and say Redwood isn't pumping our water, we don't know whose water
they're pumping. The State would then send Redwood a letter asking who we're getting water from. Then
we'd go to our Water Rights Attorney and he would respond to the State that RR Flood had no meters, they
were relying specifically on contracts and don't really know who is taking what amount of water. He
continued, That issue went away after our years of approaching SCWA trying to get a contract and finally
getting that Surplus Water Agreement. They were cooperative with us. SCWA is not the bad guy.
However, RR Flood still goes through the exercise of telling us they have no surplus water to sell us, so
now we are able to pump under our SCWA Surplus Agreement. But then later in the year RR Flood says,
Well we ended up with surplus water, so you need to pay us instead of paying Sonoma County.
Director Butow continued, Now, what you're saying is exactly true Jack, this District because of the
moratorium has been placed in a situation where there are fewer customers than the system can handle,
and those fewer customers are responsible for supporting our infrastructure. So we're stuck; we'd like to
have more customers and we'd like to sell more water.
Further discussion continued.
�M
GM Koehler mentioned that the change he would like to make with the SCWA contract is to allow Redwood
to withdraw from the Urban Water Conservation Council which is really for large water agencies. He
added, We are such a small entity and our lower usage is a conservation mode of itself and we're likely to
stay at the same per capita and same usage per day.
During general discussion, Director Ricetti said she feels we shouldn't jeopardize the Surplus Agreement.
GM Koehler commented that for the past four years SCWA has been our savior.
Supervisor Carre Brown mentioned as a point of interest that at a SCWA-BOS Meeting a couple of years
ago, they projected out that they won't have enough water to supply the population after the year 2025
unless they get access to the Lake Sonoma water.
Director Hallman requested we postpone further conversation on this particular matter for three months.
Since we've been waiting three years for the surplus water agreement renewal, she would like to see if we
actually do have a signed Contract in three months or if we might be able to pursue other things.
Director Ricetti wondered if that would make SCWA mad.
GM Koehler repeated his conviction that we would have had a renewed contract if we had not requested
any changes to the Contract at that time. If we would have said Yes we want to re-sign that Contract, then
we would have just re -signed the Contract and it would have been done.
Supervisor Carre Brown mentioned that the five-year Contract was signed in 2005 and it expired in
November, 2010 and GM Koehler repeated he felt it wasn't renewed at that time because he had
requested a change in it.
As part of that Contract, the Mendocino County Water Conservation and Fishery Advisory Board was
created. Originally it was comprised of Supervisor Carre Brown, RVCWD General Manager Bill Koehler
and MCWA Director Roland Sanford. There is $95,000 sitting and waiting to go into the account.
GM Koehler will place this topic on the Agenda again in three months as requested.
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
9:05 P.M. BREAK
Supervisor Carre Brown left the Meeting during the Break.
9:21 P.M. RECONVENE
8-J. SCWA.
Discussed previously in the Meeting.
10
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
MOTION: Take the reimbursement, the stream gauge, the water meters and the quagga
mussel proposals to the Committee and once they are approved and the funds released, G
Koehler will pay them. None of the money comes out of the general fund, it comes out of t
Conservation Funds. If the Committee approves the quagga program support right away,
those funds may be distributed right away.
Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Butow, Spilman, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
CSDA's Special District Leadership Academy Courses are coming up on August 8 & 9, 2012 in Pleasanton,
California. This is directly related to the GASB34 accounting. The first day is "Board's Role in Finance &
Fiscal Accountability". The second day is "Board's Role in Human Resources". If any Board Members
wish to attend, please contact GM Koehler.
8-M. Sick Time Accrual.
The employee handbook states that "sick time accrues at one day per month (12 per year)..."
There is no distinction as to how to differentiate accrual between the different hours in our 4 different
hourly/weekly structures.
President Pool suggests GM Koehler contact the County to peruse their standard of accrual for this same
situation. The Board consensus is to also establish an End Cap to sick leave accruals.
8-N. Neary Proposal/Ukiah Valley Sanitation District evaluation.
Previously discussed in Meeting.
President Pool and GM Koehler urge every Director to read the documents.
9:50 p.m. Steven Gardner left the Meeting at this time.
Upcoming Meetings -- GM Koehler plans to attend and the Directors are welcome to also attend:
July 30, 2012 - The Eel Russian River Commission will meet in Eureka.
November 2, 2012 - The Russian River Watershed Symposium 2012 will be held in Cloverdale.
The Financial Report of July 19, 2012 was reviewed and discussed.
MOTION: Accept the Financial Report as presented.
Ricetti/Butow Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Ricetti, Butow, Hallman, Spilman, Pool
11
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
FAI " M�M JIL,
51ill'ilill � iiisi� c 1 11
LAFCO is going ahead with the Municipal Service Review (MSR).
(9:57 p.m.)
They are pushing hard for all the Commissioners to submit information for what their Board Members feel
is reasonable for an hourly rate for management services. Also the COE is claiming that the IW&PC owes
$90,000 to the COE, and IW&PC is wondering if they can prove time spent as an in -kind amount of money.
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION
IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT.
Apparently the FCD's Legal Counsel Mark Del Piero is close to getting elected to Supervisor in his home
county, so the FCD is in a search for his replacement.
Already discussed.
Closed Session, Section 54957 (b) (1) Evaluation of performance: General Manager.
GM Koehler confirmed that pursuant to Section 54957, he was given the formal notification 24-hours prior
to this meeting and as is his legal option, he chooses to go into Closed Session.
10:01 p.m. Recording Secretary left the Meeting.
19. Evaluation of performance: General Manager, William Koehler.
No specific complaints or charges will be considered. Government Code Section 54957(b)(1).
GM Koehler was directed to divert sufficient emphasis from local political involvement in order to effectively
direct the plant and field supervision and to improve District operations. Specifics include:
Increased direct supervision of field and treatment plant activities.
12
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012
Development of effective hierarchy of authority and responsibility with field crew including assigned
crew leader.
Improved capital and maintenance project planning, scheduling and completion.
Review operational scheduling with a goal of reducing overtime. Consider staggered schedule to
provide weekend coverage.
Improved public perception of District efficiency.
Keep the work environment professional — no blow-ups, vulgar language, etc.
Improved communication with Board of Directors.
The Meeting ended at 11:35 P.M
The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, August 16, 2012 at theflater District
Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully Submitted,
Linda Groth, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
SIGNED: Paula Berezay
Secretary, Board of Directors
13
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
July 19, 2012