HomeMy WebLinkAbout2013-04-18 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley CA 95470
(707) 485-0679
MINUTES
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Regular Meeting
April 18, 2013
Directors Present: Jeanette Hallman, Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Jack Spilman, Ken Todd
Directors Absent: None
Staff Present: General Manager Bill Koehler
Recording Secretary: Linda Groth
Others Present: Will Carson/Millview CWD
CALL TO ORDER: 7:09 P.M.
1. ROLL CALL.
Jeanette Hallman, Board Vice -President
Jack Spilman, Director
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Ken Todd, Director
Granville Pool, Board President
2. HEARING OF COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM THE ATTENDING PUBLIC.
Nothing.
3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED.
Nothing.
4. ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA.
MOTION: Accept the Agenda as presented.
Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Todd, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
5. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR
a. Financial Statement.
b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting.
b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting.
c. Bills Payable.
d. District Activity.
The Consent Calendar was reviewed.
MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented.
Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Todd, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED
The Draft Minutes of March 21, 2013 were reviewed. There were some minor corrections.
MOTION: Accept the Minutes of March 21, 2013 with minor corrections.
Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Todd, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
7. DIRECTOR AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON -ACTION TOPICS.
a. Personnel Committee Report.
President Pool advised there is nothing to report.
b. Ad Hoc/Consolidation Committee Report.
GM Koehler reported that the Flood Control District has requested a Public Meeting with the full
Board of Directors of RVCWD and the full Board of Trustees of MCRRFC&WCID. They would like this
meeting to be held from 5:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. on Wednesday, May 15, 2013 at the Barra of Mendocino
facility (an overlapping area of both Districts). Although there was no fee required by the facility when our
two agencies held a meeting there a few years ago, the FCD Trustees approved a co -pay of up to $200 if
there is a facility fee required and the RV Directors should consider doing the same. There were no
objections.
President Pool encouraged the Directors to be available on this date and there was consensus. He
reiterated the purpose of the meeting is for the agency Board Members to get acquainted and discuss
common topics.
c. Discussion of rates.
Director Ricetti reported the committee was unable to meet due to illness.
GM Koehler referred to the FCD Update commentary put together by GM Sean White: This gives a good
overview of water use accounting between the FCD and the SWRCB (Permit 12947B/8,000 afy). Further,
2
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
the FCD filed an application for 6,000 afy in 2004 with the intention of serving RVCWD and the FCD has
responded to all Protests, spending most of its efforts dealing with the SCWA Protest. During these
negotiations it became apparent that the FCD, the SCWA and the RVCWD would benefit from a more
comprehensive `global solution' for which SCWA has strongly pushed as the best alternative for calming its
concerns. It was during these talks that the concept of consolidating the FCD and the RVCWD, took hold,
as both entities want to resolve the long-standing water supply issues in Redwood Valley. At the present
time the SCWA continues to be concerned that if a permanent water right was issued, would there be
enough yield in the reservoir to supply the demand of full build -out of agriculture; and more pointedly, build -
out of vineyards. GM Koehler commented that grapevines require less water than other crops, and if
vineyards were planted to replace other crops, the water consumption would actually decrease.
The Directors agreed that Sean's FCD Update commentary was well done. General discussion followed
about various scenario's and expenses and cap fees to consider when the Rate Study Committee meets.
President Pool asked the Directors to provide GM Koehler with questions or topics of discussion they
would like to discuss at the combined, informational meeting with our two Districts on May 15th. GM
Koehler will make sure the FCD receives this in time to prepare for the meeting.
8. GENERAL MANAGER'S REPORT.
8-A. District Operations.
The District is operating well. The SCADA problem reported at the last Board Meeting has been repaired.
The pricing is close to $7,000. The hardware and software is obsolete and we need to be prepared to
upgrade our system at some point.
8-B. General Manager Vacation.
GM Koehler will be gone for a week immediately following the May Board meeting.
8-C. District Staffing.
RV and Willow have agreed to cross train for an additional 20+/- hours beginning April 15th. At the end of
that period the General Managers will meet again and will face the decision to either terminate or to agree
to some form of contract with Willow. Such a contract would allow Willow to hire another employee. This
decision could lead to a complete field labor agreement with Willow. The FCD is also showing some
interest in sharing a meter reader and this might be something that works out for the benefit of several
Districts.
8-D. Lake Pump Station.
Pump #3 is running fine. As to pump #1, the motor has been repaired and balanced. The cost was
$9,700, which was as cheap as it could get. The controls don't work for pump #1, they are fried. One
option to get back to three perfectly functioning motors, pumps and controls is to have the boom truck pull
out pump #2 and at the same time we replace that spot with the repaired pump #1. Pump #2 is damaged
also and needs the same repairs pump #1 received, roughly $10,000. After we do that, we need to decide
when to also replace the controls and wires, at roughly $32,000.
President Pool noted that this expense does not address the communications link and that the Board
needs to decide whether it's a high priority to get 3 pumps reliably on-line or to get the communications link
working.
3
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
GM Koehler suggested that the Board throw out virtually the entire capital budget and consider this:
pump #2 is essentially $42,000, we've already spent $8,000 with Rau, we've spent $6,000 on the SCADA,
we're going to be spending $5,000 on the server, that's $61,000 which leaves a balance of $79,000. If we
do pump #1 for an additional $42,000, that leaves a balance of $37,000 in our existing capital budget which
probably is not quite enough to do the communications.
GM Koehler told the Board he recently obtained permission from the County Environmental Health
Department to put off the project of converting the single -wall tanks to double wall tanks, for another year.
After further discussion and consideration the Board directed GM Koehler to proceed with the following
capital expense projects: repair the Pump #2 Motor; repair the Communications Link; and, relocate the
Chemical Vault & Alarms.
8-E. Office Server.
The recommended Office Server has been ordered.
8-F. GPS Trackers.
The two trackers have been ordered. One is installed and the other will be installed in the next day or so
8-G. Pipeline Inspection.
We are still trying to locate a pipeline inspection firm that can handle the 20,000' distance between
insertion points; or even 10,000' if they do it separately from both ends. There is a company that can
handle 3,400 feet. President Pool suggests finding out how much it will cost so the Board can look at the
fiscal year budget. GM Koehler will report further next month.
8-H. School Way Bridge.
The official notification indicates that the School Way Bridge Project will go to bid December 2013 or
January 2014 for a Spring 2014 construction start.
8-I. Water Re -use.
The City of Ukiah is releasing a Public Draft Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration of the its
proposed recycled water project for irrigation and frost protection water. The public hearing will be held at
the City Council Chambers at 6:00 p.m. on May 15.
8-J. Audit Approval.
The Audit was reviewed.
MOTION: Approve the Audit as presented.
Hallman/Spilman Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Hallman, Spilman, Ricetti, Todd, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
8.K. Bank/Sinkina Fund.
The interest rates from the State Farm Bank were presented per the request of Director Ricetti
4
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
During discussion, Director Spilman urged the Board to consider that the Savings Bank of Mendocino
County is well -managed and very secure, it stood strong when other banks were failing. It provides several
services to the District and its customers, at no charge, for good will. He urged the Board to consider
leaving our funds `as -is'.
Director Ricetti agreed that none of the rates are fabulous although the State Farm Insurance Company
Bank rates are higher. "We are holding money for the public and we should get them all we can."
President Pool acknowledged that the Savings Bank is a local bank and he supports maintaining the
accounts that are established and to consider transferring only the sinking -fund monies.
Director Hallman mentioned the Local Agency Investment Fund in Sacramento which holds funds of
various Districts, and has held some of our District funds for many years.
It was agreed there will be no action now and this matter will be discussed again at a future meeting.
8-L. Election of Board Members.
There are two Directors whose Terms of Service end in November of this year. They are Director Jeanette
Hallman and Director Ken Todd. The final date to File for Election is July 3, 2013.
BREAK: 8:51 P.M.
RECONVENE: 9:03 P.M.
8-M. Allocations.
GM Koehler provided a verbal review of three specific large parcel owners who have multiple numbers of
allocations. These allocations were representative of what, decades ago, the property owners thought
would provide enough water for usage on the properties at that time and in the future. The monthly water
bills reflected actual usage plus the base rate x the number of allocations. The three property owners are
Ric Piffero and Partners, Barra of Mendocino (formerly Weibel Winery), and the Fetzer Family. This
situation had the potential to turn into a real can of worms and several years ago former General Manager
Darin McCosker conducted a survey of customers, requesting the number of homes on their property; and
then he used that number to change the number of allocations being billed.
The Piffero property was recently in escrow, but fell out of escrow and has not been sold. There are 10
allocations associated with that and Piffero wishes to retain the 10 allocations.
Barra of Mendocino originally started out with 33 allocations. He got dropped to 2 for the two houses and
plus the 2" service at the winery. In addition, Barra is one of the recipients of a water main extension
project under the Safe Drinking Water Bond Act loan, so Barra additionally pays back a monthly share
based on 33 allocations.
Fetzers have had 9 allocations since Darin's revamp but originally had 50 and at this time they would be
happy to settle for 25.
The Fetzer property billing will be somewhat of a struggle, because when the matriarch of the family
passed away, a good chunk of the property was divided up between 5 of the heirs. One of the heirs
recently sold his property to a buyer who is building a Family Winery, a Guest House, an Event Center, a
Barn and farm labor housing, so he wants the 5 allocations. The buyer has already obtained a Permit;
construction is taking place to build at least the winery and the house and to get water to the guest house.
When the County called GM Koehler about this property, GM Koehler told the County he is not willing at
the present time to provide a letter stating that this property has a water source from RVCWD.
GM Koehler said while he was reviewing the legal discussions of David Rapport and Paul Minasian, it
seemed that David was leaning toward the opinion that if it was an allocation that was paid for and listed in
active accounts prior to the moratorium, in theory it is part of the 1,350 customer cap that the Judge set.
5
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RY.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
President Pool added, But he also says elsewhere in that discussion, that that's only to provide water to the
existing structures on the property that are already receiving water.
President Pool also sees David's comment indicating that, if a single meter served 3 houses, and the
customer was paying for 3 allocations, that was o.k., but if the customer built a new house to receive an
unused allocation and put in a new meter to send water to it, that would be in violation of the Judgment.
President Pool mentioned David's report of the Judge being very displeased that the Rancheria was
upsized from a 3/" meter to a 2" meter and then they built all those houses.
GM Koehler explained that the original %" meter served a small house that existed at the time inside the
District boundary. Upsizing to a 2" meter did not increase the amount of water used and did not change
the net number of meters installed. But then the Rancheria built 30 more houses that we are serving water
to that are not within our Place of Use. Back at that time, the District prepared all the paperwork for
annexation with LAFCO. It's in our Service Area (LAFCO's term for where we could provide service). But
it's not within our Place of Use per the State Water Board (they have been in possession of the paperwork
for years).
Director Spilman suggested the District should do the right thing and offer a portion of the allocations back
to the customer. It's clearly a situation that was not explained to the customer when previous management
reduced the allocations. Of course, the customer would be billed for the difference of those allocations that
weren't billed in the interim.
President Pool stated that the District made a mistake and it needs to be rectified.
Director Hallman clarified that this discussion is about allocations and this does not affect the outstanding
Hardship Hookups.
Director Spilman led a recap of the Board decisions as discussed:
1. Correct the past error. Return all the allocations that were removed and bill the customer for allocation
fees for that look back period. Meters will be installed when requested and paid for. If the customer wants
just a portion of the original allocations, that's fine, but this is the final settlement. It's over. There will
never be another discussion about outstanding allocations.
2. A licensed contractor will do the installation, the District will inspect.
3. If we come to an agreement with allocations, they do not have to install meters for all the allocations
right away. They will pay the additional monthly allocation fee that is in effect with each current rate
schedule. When they do ask for meter installations, they will pay installation costs and cap fees existing at
that time in the future.
4. The Safe Drinking Water Bond construction loan billings stay in place as -is.
5. Cap fees will be required when they request a meter installation.
6. Cap fees collected will go into the Sinking Fund.
It was noted that all this discussion has been about domestic services. The agricultural cap fees are a
different amount.
GM Koehler was directed to speak with the Fetzer Family and with Barra Winery and get the final allocation
decisions and bring that information back to the Board next month for finalization.
6
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
10:00 p.m. Member of the public Will Carson left the Meeting during discussion of above.
9. FINANCIAL REPORT.
After a review of the Financial Report for April 18, 2013, a Motion was made.
MOTION: Accept the Financial Report as presented.
Spilman/Todd Discussion CARRIED
AYES: Spilman, Todd, Hallman, Ricetti, Pool
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
10. LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION OF MENDOCINO COUNTY — LAFCO
GM Koehler attended their April 1, 2013 Meeting. He was the sole member of the public in attendance.
There wasn't much of a turnout on their MSR request, as a result the contract with their consultant has
been extended to June, 2013. The District's contribution to the LAFCO budget will remain the same.
11. M. C. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION.
Director Hallman reported she and GM Koehler were both at the IW&PC Meeting. An All Boards Meeting
is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. on May 9, 2013 at the Ukiah Valley Conference Center. There are three items
on the agenda, mainly regarding FERC.
GM Koehler mentioned ACWA is having a conference in Sacramento on May 9th which is in direct conflict
with the scheduled IW&PC Meeting. He is particularly interested in this because the topic is Water District
Consolidation. Part 1: Nuts & Bolts of it. Part 2: Case Studies. He had asked Candace if the IW&PC
Meeting could be rescheduled, but they could only change the time. So he will be coming over from
Sacramento and will arrive a little bit late to the IW&PC Meeting.
The Directors suggested that since he is going to be in Sacramento all day, he does not need to drive to
Ukiah for this meeting.
GM Koehler reported that Congressman Thompson is working on legislation that will require the Corps of
Engineers to perform Quagga Mussel Inspection on all boats before they are allowed in the lakes.
The wording of the Russian River Compact is still being worked on.
The SCWA will Petition for `reduced outflow' based on low flows in Lake Pillsbury.
12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION
IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT,
The Two -Boards Meeting is planned for May 15, 5pm-7pm at the Barra Facility. Each agency to pay up to
$200 if a fee is collected.
Director Spilman reported:
The study from Hopland Extension to SCWA shows that with full build -out, there will be a 3,000 ac-
ft reduction every year.
7
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D,
April 18, 2013
Last year the FCD paid $28,000 in legal fees. This year they have paid $26,000 in legal fees so far.
They are checking on consolidation of meter reading with other Districts.
They are Petitioning to have the lake flows cut by May 15tn
13. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY.
Nothing to report.
14. REPORT OF ATTENDANCE AT AGENCY MEETINGS OF ANY OTHER ENTITY NOT LISTED
SEPARATELY HEREIN.
GM Koehler referenced the City of Ukiah Public Hearing at 6:00 p.m. on Wednesday, May 15tn regarding
the Draft of the Initial Neg Dec:
The Application for Extension of Time to put water to beneficial use is out and floating around. This is for
underflow, not groundwater. They have amended their application a couple of times since their Permit
expired in 2000 and they now want an 80-year extension to perfect the use of their water. Their Permit is
for 20 cf per second, maximum withdrawal rate, with no annual cap; but they don't need 20 cf per second.
They're using about 4,000 AF now, but they're claiming that they have an estimate of total diversion at full
build -out of 8,000 AF. Their Pre-1914 Right for 2,000 is untouchable. In 2011 they diverted 2,800 AF.
They are claiming that even if they are pumping underflow, there will be no reduction in flow of the river,
because Sonoma will have to make it up with discharges from the lake.
Flood Control's only Protest of their particular EIR was to stipulate that if Ukiah does buy water from the
FCD, it cannot be used outside the FCD's Place of Use.
It did list that essentially half of the inflow into Lake Mendocino is through the tunnel on an annual basis.
They said there is 90,000 ac-ft of water underneath the main portion of the Ukiah Valley in unconsolidated
alluvium so, it's possible. They also say that in the fringes of the Ukiah Valley there is an additional 45,000
ac-ft of water, and that even during the 76-77 drought, it was back, full, at the end of the '78 rainy season.
It also contains a map on page 222 put out by the USGS that shows where true groundwater exists in the
Ukiah Valley and it's obviously pretty wide down by the airport. And they are saying there is a narrow band
of Class 1 true groundwater up here, underneath the south boundary of the RV District, Class 1 means
that it is sufficient for municipal supply. They did not quantify how much is in that one little piece, it may be
limited by the perforations. In this draft EIR the City of Ukiah is claiming that their two new wells are
groundwater, therefore not subject to the jurisdiction. They said they are putting them in the Application
just in case the Dept. of Water Resources changes their mind one day, "we want to already have it." This
includes major chunks of Millview and Willow's Districts.
The Meeting ended at 11:04 P.M.
An All Boards Meeting of the M. C. Inland Water & Power Commission will be held at 7:00 P.M. on
Thursday, May 9, 2013 at the Ukiah Valley Conference Center,
A Full Boards Meeting with the Redwood Valley County Water District and the Mendocino County Russian
River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District will be held at 5:00 P.M. on Wednesday,
May 15, 2013 at the Barra of Mendocino facility, 7051 North State Street, Redwood Valley, California.
8
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013
The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, May 16, 2013 at the Water District
Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California.
Respectfully Submitted,
Linda Groth, Recording Secretary
APPROVED: Board of Directors
DATE APPROVED: June 20, 2013
SIGNED: Paula Berezay
Secretary, Board of Directors
Minutes, Regular Meeting
Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D.
April 18, 2013