Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2013-02-21 RVCWD MinutesREDWOOD VALLEY COUNTY WATER DISTRICT 237DWebb Ranch Road Redwood Valley CA85470 MINUTES BOARD OF DIRECTORS Regular Meeting February 21'2U13 Directors Present: Jeanette Hallman, Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Jack Spilman, Ken Todd Directors Absent: None Staff Present: General Manager Bill Koehler Recording Secretary: Linda Broth Others Present: Will Ca[n¢D/K8i||Vievv CVVD CALL TOORDER: 7:00P.M. 1. ROLL CALL. Pamela F|icotti' Director Ken Todd, Director JaCkSpi|n13M. Director Jeanette HoUOnaO, Director Granville Pool, Board President 3. CONSIDER HEARING OF URGENT ITEMS RECEIVED SINCE THE AGENDA WAS POSTED. MOTION: Accept the Agenda as presented. Ricetti/Spilman Discussion CARRIED AYES: Ricetti, Spilman, Hallman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None Minutes, Regular Meeting Board ofDirectors, RN.C.WD. February 21.3O13 r ,wi. APPROVAL C9)h CONSENT C;AI-fm a. Financial Statement. b.-1. Bills Paid since those approved at last Meeting. b.-2. Bills Paid as approved at previous Meeting. c. Bills Payable. d. District Activity. The Consent Calendar was reviewed. MOTION: Approve the Consent Calendar as presented. Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None 6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AS PRESENTED. The Draft Minutes of January 17, 2013 were reviewed. MOTION: Approve the Minutes of January 17, 2013. Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None 7. DIRECTOR AND STAFF REPORTS AND DISCUSSION OF NON -ACTION TOPICS. 7.a. Personnel Committee Report. Director Spilman reported the Personnel Committee, made up of Pool, Spilman and Koehler, discussed trying to utilize one field crew employee to swap back and forth between Redwood Valley and Willow, as needed. He referred the Board to Item C in the General Manager's Report later in the meeting. Item C provides more details and an update. President Pool agreed with Director Spilman and deferred to the GM Report in this matter. He also mentioned for the benefit of the new Directors that it is important for the Board Members to receive a verbal report at the Board Meetings after each committee or ad hoc meeting so that the whole Board is kept informed and updated in various matters. GM Koehler reported that the Ad Hoc/Consolidation Committee met two weeks ago. Those in attendance were himself and Granville Pool, Chris Neary, Tim Bradley and Dave Redding. The Flood Control District was invited to attend, however they had no one available at that time. The general consensus is that rather than pursuing a monster merger, the best approach at this time is to pursue small steps that would lead to large steps. It was acknowledged that at the end of the large steps, there would be several General Managers looking for titles. There is also concern as to how the retirement of any Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 tU[neOtGIVIwould be @fOCtOd. There are other concerns, for (",Xa|npleWillow is justifiably m)Dce[U�('] about the, amount 0fdebt Redwood Valley owes. GW1Koehler said there will beanother meeting onMonday. The Flood Control District, the Sanitation District and the City of Ukiah are also invited, There will be no Board Members, it will be Staff only. The direction isthat there will be reports back tVthe individual Boards and sometime, iUthe future there will be@DAll Boards Meeting. President Pool mentioned that the Sanitation District has ahUrn0OgOUs debt and they are not paying it d0vvU. He had been tinder the impression that their very large rate increase was paying down the debt. After general conversation, GM Koehler stated that the 120 page MSR is now published. 7.o. 0soUsai0O of rates. Director RiCekistated that the District isfacing some major expmnseoaDdtheyc@Dn0tbei8Uoped. She suggested appointing acommittee. Ageneral discussion followed. /Vthe multiple Public Hearings held for the last rate increase, and although the increase would be considered modest, there were only two registered Objections. The don)eSticrate structure vvo$ changed t0have o $10 Base Rate' plus tiered [gteofo[vVGte' Usage. Ideally, the Base Rate goes for operation and maintenance and the Usage Rate goes for the production of safe drinking water.*SEE NOTATION at end of paragraph. Some points made by the new District Auditor were discussed; the Audit is now showing G Sinking Fund. It has been 12 years since Brelje & Race Engineers did a Rate Study for the District although its model was used for interim [ate increases. *NOTATION: During approval 0fthe Minutes, the Directors agreed that the statement was made, ao $hoVVD' however the statement is incorrect. Correction: The Base Rate is to cover capital costs and the Usage Rate iot0cover the cost ofoperations. Will Ca[anO/K8i||vievvCVVO said it had also been 12 years since W1i||Viem/had consultants prepare a Rate StUdy, however the new, [enoDt Rate Study has been completed. He offered to share some of Mi||Viem/'s strategies and outcomes and benefits oftheir recent Rate Study. GM Koehler told the Board that he has the electronic form of the K8i||vieVV Rate Study and can share it with anyone who asks. President Pool suggested asking BpeUe&F<GceEngineers t0provide a scientific basis for replacing capital ite[DoiDthe future. He cautioned about'putting inplace arate increase that everybody thinks will provide for the District for several years, only to find out in two or three years that it wasn't adequate at all. He also referred to the Dickerson Report with admonition to properly maintain the facilities that are serving our various Districts. President Pool suggested we ask Brelje & Race to provide us with an idea of what type of Rate Study we might need, and some rough idea 8Stowhat that might cost. GK8Koehler said that the last Rate Study provided two variations oDRate Logic: one with paying back the monster debt and one without paying back the monster debt. He continued, Atthis time VVeare 'that much older' and VVe have stuff falling apart. President Pool asked how thorough the last Rate Study was oDaddressing Capital replacement. He added. If we do a StUdV, this has got to be g top concern. GIVI Koehler said that Auditor Bob Johnson developed the Sinking Fund to address just that issue. 3 Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D. February 21.2Oi3 Director Ricetti added, By not moving forward, we are not doing ourselves or the people in this valley, any favors. We have some major expenses coming down the road, things we need to take care of. Director Hallman mentioned that in discussions three years ago for the last rate increase, the Board talked about putting 10% of the sales away; it didn't happen and it was not reflected in the Minutes, but there was a great deal of discussion about putting it away. She personally would feel more comfortable in putting something away at this time if three years ago the Board had taken that little baby -step and told the customers what we're facing. President Pool remarked that he thinks part of the reason the 10% set aside didn't: happen was because we were having to do a rate increase at a time we were coming out of the drought. Since everybody [lad to cut back their usage so much during the drought, we were in a difficult situation of trying to figure out what projected usage should be, to base our rates on. It turns out that our rate increase was based on a somewhat optimistic level of usage which we still haven't realized. If we had realized that level of usage, we would have had a lot better chance of putting aside that 10%. GM Koehler pointed out that our sales dropped over 40% and it's real hard to put money in the bank under those circumstances. After further discussion of the District's challenges, the consensus of the Board is that GM Koehler will contact Drelje & Race without spending any money and will bring that information back to the Board. Director Todd asked about finding out what other agencies in the area are charging. GM Koehler said, That is a good question but a classic mistake. If you look at what the City of Ukiah did, they paid a lot of money for a Study and the consultant came in with a recommendation. The City then decided they didn't want to charge their customers what the consultant recommended, but they wanted to look at what their neighbors are charging. This is truly an apples -and -oranges situation, groundwater vs. surface water and the entire infrastructure. Director Spilman urged the Board to study and evaluate the Audit Report very carefully before spending more money. President Pool also supports studying the Auditor's Report. He did caution the Board that although it appears to have good information for doing rates, the Board must consider that the way an accountant looks at capitalization is pretty simplistic compared to the way an engineer would look at it. In a sense, the audit is just sort of a guess and for accounting purposes that works just fine; but the auditor's report doesn't really tell you what it's going to cost to replace deteriorating facilities. A Rate Study Committee will most likely be appointed next month. 8. GENERAL MANAGER'S REPORT. 8-A. District Operations. GM Koehler reported finding out that the pressure transducer isn't working. He contacted the manufacturer and they replaced it, but the replacement didn't work either. We are awaiting the arrival of a second replacement transducer; and we are temporarily monitoring representative sites throughout the system. GM Koehler also reported that his District Vehicle was actually hit by a horse as it unexpectedly sidestepped against the vehicle. It does not appear the horse was injured; however, since the District's Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 Honda FIT is such a lightweight little car, there was some damage to the vehicle. The owner of 'the, horse paid the District $1800 to (,over the cost of repair and Bill will take the, vehicle to the repair shop to be, repaired during his two -week vacation, This (Aid not require an insurance claim and the insurance company was not involved. Other Business: Three Resolutions were presented for the purpose of updating authorized signatories on each of the Bank Accounts and on the, L.A.I.F. Account in Sacramento. Resolution No. 2013-11 Aclreementall accounts. To Remove Signature of: Donald E. Butow. To Add Signature of: Ken Todd. MOTION. Approve Resolution No. 2013-1, to remove the name of Donald E. Butow and to add the narne of Ken Todd. Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None Resolution No. 2013-2, Local Agency pLSignatories. To Remove Signature of: Donald E. Butow. To Add Signature of: Ken Todd. MOTION- Approve Resolution No. 2013-2 to remove the name of Donald E. Butow and to add the name of Ken Todd. Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None Resolution No. 2013 3 Savings Bank of Mendocino County' Creating and Establishing a Money Market Account for-Qe�reciation: Sinking Fund. After intensive research and scrutiny, our new accountant has recommended that every month we set aside funds in the amount of $22,000 to be held in a Sinking Fund. It is understood that this action will slowly make our other accounts get smaller and smaller. It will be listed in the Financial Report and will allow the Board to see a true financial picture, The full amount of $22,000 is not `locked in' and if the Board looks at the Financial Report and feels the District doesn't have that amount to set aside that month, a different amount can be determined. This could mean that operating funds will be taken out of the L.A.I.F. and/or Savings Bank accounts. This action does not make up for past years in which monies were not set aside, but it is a start. MOTION: Approve Resolution No. 2013-3, Creating and Establishing a Money Market Account for Depreciation: Sinking Fund. Ricetti/Todd Discussion CARRIED AYES: Ricetti, Todd, Hallman, Spilman, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None The following Motion is not a part of Resolution No. 2013-3, but, it is A -3. W Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 MOTION. Norge of the money in the Sinking Frind is to fie spent witho"t Board approval. Tallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None President Pool announced that these Resolutions require each Director to provide a signature at several sections on each document. We will take a Break at this time; each of the Directors will have an opportunity to sign the documents during Break. 3:25 P.M. BREAK Will Carson/Millview CWD left the Meeting during Break. 6:50 P.M. RECONVENE General Manager's Report and Action Items February 21 2013 Continued, 6-B. Lake PumD Repair. Rump No. 2 is still torn apart. Kudo's to Steven for steadfastly working on this and keeping us limping along for a year and a half. However, the number of man-hours put into this is unacceptable and we must turn this over to an electrical contractor. Also since the controls do not work, the communication link that allows the pumps to be turned on remotely also does not work. We are getting two estimates for Pump 2, (the pumps are 500 h.p.). We expect it to cost around $30,000 to replace and modernize the 1976 configuration which is now obsolete and to upgrade the communication link. This work will be assigned to the Approved Capital Budget under items: SCADA and WTP Upgrades. Pump No. 3 was upgraded several years ago is working well. Director Spilman is concerned that we are stepping into something without enough working knowledge. GM Koehler said he is enforcing the Lock Out/Tag Out safety procedures and will hire a professional electrician for any work on the 500 horsepower circuits. Also, GM Koehler and Steven have received tentative permission to tour the Sonoma County Water Agency facilities (two pump stations) near Forestville. The idea is to learn from that before any money is spent. Sonoma has a very similar application, only much bigger. We continue to operate with only two field employees. If one employee is assigned to certain work in the field and the other employee is assigned to work in the water treatment plant, it falls on the General Manager to carry out routine tasks such as work orders and lock offs. The net result is that the General Manager is pulled away from his time available for higher level administrative duties, As a follow up, GM Koehler has spoken with Dave Redding at Willow about cross -training and sharing a water treatment plant operator who has job experience and has received his T-3, D-3. The fully burdened cost to RVCWD would be $32.92 per hour and Redwood would expect to utilize this employee approximately 10 hours per week. Willow CWD is willing to work this out, but since this same employee is Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 also cross training with Millview CWD, it is foreseeable that Willow will be shorthanded from tirrie to tiru0. So in return, Willow expects to be able to call on RVCWD for field crew assistance when needed. GM Koehler asked the Board to give him directive in this matter. Director Spilman asked if there is any expectation of cross -training for field workers between Districts. CM Koehler said that, presently, that doesn't seem to be an option. CM Koehler reported he met with a Ukiah {--sigh School job placement advisor who had stated she has one student who is interested in water treatment as a career. It was arranged for the student to come to RVCWD and get acquainted and to shadow Scott in the field for approximately three hours. Both CM Koehler and Scott had the impression that the High School job placement advisor was rnore interested in this opportunity than is the student. CM Koehler encouraged the student to take advantage of online classes and several other related sources pertaining to a career in this field; it's a possibility that the student will come back showing a real desire to pursue this opportunity. After general discussion, the Board returned to the Willow employee -share possibility. It was agreed that the hourly cost is reasonable. The Willow condition of quid pro quo is a problem because RVCWD is trying to backfill a shorthanded staff situation. Director Ricetti asked what the point is for getting the Willow employee if we have to give a Redwood employee away and GM Koehler said the difference is that the Willow employee has chosen to become a Treatment Plant Operator, that's his goal. GM Koehler continued, One of the things I've been looking at is the possibility of what the end game looks like. In 3-5 years if all the Districts, that is, the Flood Control District, the Sanitation District, the City of Ukiah and the Water Districts have managed to come to an agreement and all of ras are at least somewhat merged in one Upper Russian Water Authority or whatever we want to call it, then we would have a number of qualified treatment plant operators in addition to laborers, meter readers, etc. So far, this fellow at Willow is the most promising person that GM Koehler has seen. President Pool said he is in favor and Director Ricetti agreed. The burden of providing quid pro quo, if that proves to be onerous, then the Board will have to give a higher priority to doing something about our labor situation. Consensus of the Board is that the Willow employee -sharing option is a good place to start and a good step to take at this time. Last month the Board of Directors asked GM Koehler to coordinate with Sean White at the FCD to ask the Inland Water & Power Commission to consider meeting every other month, at least temporarily. After a discussion, Sean and Bill agreed the best approach is for them to contact the IW&PC Secretary (Candace) and request that this topic be placed on the Agenda. Candace has confirmed it will be on the February Agenda. th The Regular Meeting has been postponed to February 28 GM Koehler referred to the Notice from the Association of California Water Agencies stating that there is proposed legislation to move the California Department of Public Health over to the control of the State Water Resources Control Board. Traditionally, if an agency has a technical problem they contact the CDPH and they come up and help you solve your problem. Conversely, if an agency calls the State Water Board with a problem, the SWRCB slaps a Fine on the agency, and doesn't help it. Most of the drinking water purveyors in Lake and Mendocino Counties are opposed to this proposal. Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 During discussion, the Directors agreed that this proposed legislation is Awful. The staff of a majority of districts have agreed to send a letter to the legislators but will wait to see what AGWA, CSDA, GRWA, and SGWA propose. If appropriate, RVCWD will ride the coat tails of the larger agencies or else will draft a complementary letter. A status report will be provided at the March Hoard Meeting. B.F. Appointment of President and Vice President (A, enda Item No. 3.G) MOTION: Nominate Granville Pool to continue serving as President of the Hoard. Hallman/Ricetti Discussion CARRIED AYES: Hallman, Ricetti, Spilman, Todd NOES: None ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: Pool MOTION. Nominate Jeanette Hallman to serve as Vice -President of the Board. Ricetti/Pool: Discussion CARRIED AYES: Ricetti, Pool, Spilman, Todd NOES: None ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: Hallman 3.Q. Audit Report. (Agenda Item No. 85.) The Audit Report will be discussed at the March 21, 2013 Regular Meeting. 9. FINANCIAL REPORT. After a review of the Financial Report for February 21, 2013, a Motion was made. MOTION: Accept the Financial Report as presented. Ricetti/Hallman Discussion CARRIED AYES: Ricetti, Hallman, Spilman, Todd, Pool NOES: None ABSENT: None *R �. another Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, R.V.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 11. M. C. INLAND WATER & POWER COMMISSION. The Regular Monthly Meeting was rescheduled to February 28tr, . 12. MENDOCINO COUNTY RUSSIAN RIVER FLOOD CONTROL & WATER CONSERVATION IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. Director Hallman reported she attended the Meeting at 5:00 p.m. and they went into Closed Session. She returned a number of times and they were always still in Closed Session. Finally at 7:45 p.m. when she returned and learned they were still in Closed Session, she went home. It was later learned that they were in Closed Session until 8:30 p.r-n. 13. SONOMA COUNTY WATER AGENCY. There is no movement yet, on anything. 14. REPORT OF ATTENDANCE AT AGENCY MEETINGS OF ANY OTHER ENTITY NOT LISTED SEPARATELY HEREIN. Nothing to report. 15. STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD. Discussed as Agenda Item No. 8.E. 16, STATUS REPORT OF PLACE OF USE ISSUES. As to our two Petitions, legal counsel advises to allow these to just fade away. It's better to pay the State the annual fee and let the Petitions sit on the back of a desk somewhere, than it is to have the State actually process them and turn them down. i 001111191011��K � � ii 1� .� � ii 151 H Wn"Irr-M1. 18. CONSIDER ATTENDANCE AT SEMINARS, TRAINING EVENTS, CONFERENCES AS RECEIVE SINCE LAST MEETING. 100 The Meeting ended at 10:06 P.M. Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D. February 21, 2013 The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for 7:00 P.M. on Thursday, March 21, 2013 at the Water District Office, 2370 Webb Ranch Road, Redwood Valley, California. Respectfully Submitted, Linda Oroth, Recording Secretary Correction: See NOTATION at end of the first paragraph in Item 7.c. to correct a statement made during the Meeting. The correct statement should be, The Base Rate is to cover capital costs and the Usage Rate is to cover the cost of operations. APPROVED AS CORRECTED: Board of Directors DATE APPROVED: March 21 2013 SIGNED: Paula Be gez Secretary, Board of Directors 10 Minutes, Regular Meeting Board of Directors, RN.C.W.D. February 21, 2013