HomeMy WebLinkAbout2014-10-16 RVCWD MinutesRedwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, October 16, 2014
Directors Present: Granville Pool, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili
Directors Absent: Pamela Ricetti
Staff Present: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 7:00 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Granville Pool, President
Ken Todd, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public
None.
Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
There are consent calendars for September 18 and October 16. GM Koehler says that we
are down 45% in water use from this time last year.
Motion: Approve the consent calendar from September 18
Motion by Dir Basili, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
Motion: Approve the consent calendar from October 16
Motion by Dir Basili, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
Dir Pool has a few corrections and those are noted to be passed along to the Recording
Secretary.
Motion: Accept the September 18th minutes with the corrections specified.
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Ricetti
In favor: unanimous
7. Directors and Staff Reports and Discussion of Non -Action Topics
Items are either not relevant or will be discussed later.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. District Operations
GM Koehler passed someone going slowly on Rd D [legal passing area] and they
called and complained. The tank repair that was authorized last year has moved
forward and the tank guys came to look at it. They showed up, said "we can't do
that", and left. He will be talking with the field guy who said that they could do
the repairs and make some noise.
The main talking item is the high disinfection by-products (DBPs) at the tank on
Tomki (the North Tank). That water is the most aged water in the system, so that's
where the problem shows up. Dir Todd asks how long that water is in the system
and GM Koehler says it's about a 5-7 days. That sample was also taken during hot
weather and the tank is a dark color, all of which contribute to high DBP levels.
This is a problem every year, but since the sampling is a running annual average,
it's always been low enough to smooth over. This time, it was high enough to put
the average over the limit. Also, the chlorine used at the plant was also degraded
with time and that tank was black, contributing to the breakdown of the chlorine.
That problem has been fixed. The favorable way of dealing with high DBPs is
with an aerating pump. It involves taking water from the bottom of the tank and
spraying it to the top. This particular DBP is trichloromethane and it is the easiest
to mitigate with aeration, due to its volatility. There are probably enough solar
panels already to power the pump and we'll start by running it in day only so as to
avoid buying battery packs. The work can be done in-house, the only thing is to
make sure they're drinking water approved.
b. Meeting Time Change
Dir Basili has suggested making the meeting time earlier. It is decided to change
it to 6 p.m. and agreed upon by consensus.
c. District Engineer
Michelle Fredrick is leaving her job with CDPH to spend more time with her kids.
They will probably be bringing up someone in-house to fill that position.
d. Family Care Unit
There are already two houses on the property and there are two service
connections, both of which are paid up on. The plan with this one is to convert a
garage. Environmental Health has done a septic inspection and feel that the leach
field is adequate and believe that the unit will be required to be torn down when
the need for it is done. It is not a new meter. Water usage may be up a little bit,
but nothing significant.
Motion: Approve the family care unit as presented
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In Favor: Unanimous
e. Water Usage
RVCWD has contracted for 355 acre-feet and have used 278 of as of the end of
September. We're averageing around 35 of per month which means we should
make it into December. GM Koehler thinks that the pot growers are NOT having
much of an impact since it seems most of the larger grows are on wells or
trucking water in. Therefore, he is not expecting a large drop in water usage after
the harvest.
Dir Todd asks about the punishment of catching illegal water trucks and how it's
not a large fine since the value of the water is only about $30. GM Koehler
doesn't know anything about the penalties involved. It seems all they can be
charged with is petty theft, but Dix Todd thinks it can be upgraded to 'misuse of
public assets'.
In January, RRFC gets a new 8,000 of contract, but GM Koehler doesn't think that
we can get a contract with them if the intertie is up and running. If we have
another dry year, it's pretty irrelevant since this whole area will be hurting. But it
could be hard to get RRFC to sell us water. Mrs. Barra says they have to prove
beneficial use, but GM Koehler says they found a loophole in that they can say
their beneficial use is conservation. RRFC has done some very unpopular things
with its customers. We may be able to get enough water through the intertie to
support domestic use, but there wouldn't be anything for Ag users.
f. Election/Appointment
The issues have been straightened out with the County to make sure this problem
[missing the appointment of another Board member] won't happen again. As long
as a board has at least 3 people, that board is legal. GM Koehler didn't even ask
about the cost of special election, but the guess is about $10,000. It doesn't matter
for this particular problem, but this information (county codes and such) will be
saved for future reference.
g. Monitoring Well
The status has not changed. Samples have been taken and results are not in yet.
There was a single sampling event. Elevated levels of boron is a deal breaker. If
the chemical constituents are fine for drinking, then they will analyze the isotopes
to see if it's groundwater or surface water. The report should be available 4-6
weeks after the sampling event.
h. Intertie
We are about 80% ready. The building is built, the roof is on, and the pumps and
90% of the internal piping is in place. It will be surprising if it's not done by the
middle of November. Dir Pool asks about the issues with point -of -use but Tim
Bradley has been out sick all week, so nothing was answered.
i. School Way
The end of the construction season near the river is October 15 but they have
another month to do work further away from the river. A chunk of main needed to
be removed on the south side. It was leaking and threatened to tear up the hillside.
There has been some problems with MCM construction about access, but we have
backing from the Mendocino DOT. Work will be done in-house.
j. Audit
The audit is done and there is a contract for the next three audits with Mr.
Johnson. Dir Todd asks about cost increases, which are a few hundred bucks a
year.
Motion: Continue with Mr. Johnson for the neat three years for audits
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
k. CUWCC Membership
It will cost about $1,500 but with that aside, there isn't a lot of benefit in it. So for
right now it's a non -issue until it comes up again to qualify for something.
9. Financial Report
There are two financial reports, for September and October. Once again, more is going
out than coming in, but it's closer than previously. But the two big costs for the well are
coming back to us from the grant. Backflow testing is still being done by RH&Sons. Mrs.
Barra asks about the discrepancies between the monthly costs for health insurance for the
three field employees. GM Koehler makes a note to ask Paula about it. Mrs. Barra asks
about the effectiveness of the overage charges and GM Koehler says that for some people
it had a great effect and with others it didn't do anything except increase our cash flow.
GM Koehler is looking into a way to increase penalties or otherwise "get bigger teeth" to
penalize abusers.
Motion: Approve the September financial report
Motion by Dir Basili, second by Dir Todd
In favor: unanimous
Motion: Approve the October financial report
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
10. Local Agency Commission of Mendocino County (LAFCO)
GM Koehler did not attend the latest meeting. The paperwork that was handed out in the
special meeting outlines the way to proceed if things get past LAFCO.
11. Mendocino County Inland Water & Power Commission (IW&PC)
GM Koehler did not attend their latest meeting. Dir Ricetti did attend, but she is not at the
Board meeting.
12. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement
District (RRFC)
GM Koehler did attend as did Dir Basili. Dir Basili said that their list of discussion items
for the merger is very similar to ours. GM Koehler is rather unhappy with their response
in that they pretty much just went off of what GM Koehler had written, not really adding
anything of their own. Lee [Howard] and Judy were not at the meeting, for what it's
worth. RRFC proposed a joint meeting on either November 5th or 6th.
Dir Pool adds another talking point which is an open discussion about getting a
permanent contract. GM Koehler adds another would be talking more about the JPA. Sc
far, it has been made fairly clear to us that doing the annexation and the JPA together in
some way will not happen, but that seems to be the best way to go.
Discussion continues about how an annexation would affect RVCWD customers. Ag
water would be in a more perilous situation since it comes second to drinking water. Dir
Todd points out that the system RRFC uses right now where you pay for a certain amount
of water whether or not you use it is essentially buying insurance for the year. RRFC sells
Ag water to it's customers much, much more cheaply than RVCWD does, so it may be
better to work out a system where the grape growers buy directly from RRFC if they
annex RVCWD. Also, as Mrs. Barra points out, RRFC can legally only store about 1,400
of of Ag water and would that be enough to supply all the growers that it currently sells to
if all the RVCWD Ag customers switched to buying it directly. With the JPA, it wouldn't
change RRFC's area of use for Ag and it would provide them with a very reliable
customer base. So the JPA seems to be a win -win situation. All the districts would stay
under their current operating sections and wouldn't need more water than RRFC could
provide.
Another thing that came out of that meeting was that they voted to start video recording
their meetings and Judy has stated before that she will not allow herself to be
photographed.
GM Koehler asks if they want to proceed with a meeting in November and Dir Basili
says that it seems like nothing has moved forward with RRFC and that they aren't putting
anything forward from themselves. Dir Todd wants to get together with them to start
asking more questions and getting answers instead of just getting pushed aside. A plan is
made for a dual board meeting in about a week, tentatively planned for November 6th.
More discussion ensues about how the new rate system may work.
Again, RRFC does not want to be responsible for RVCWD's debt. If, for some reason,
RVCWD was annexed and then locked the door to the plant and walked away, RRFC
would be responsible for that debt. Also, in case of the annexation, Redwood Valley
would get precedence over contracts with RRFC since they are part of RRFC. So then it
doesn't make sense that Redwood Valley would have a contract, since aren't they the
same entity now? It doesn't make sense.
It also carve out in the meeting that RRFC does not own the water, the tax base that paid
for it owns the water and RRFC is just there to administer the water, not to throw their
weight around. Mrs. Barra asks if RRFC is like the Mendocino County Water Agency.
GM Koehler explains that before 1959 there was a larger regulatory agency that had
jurisdiction over all of Mendocino County. It morphed into MCWA and then there was a
spinoff known as RRFC which was only responsible for water past the Coyote Valley
Dam. There is an idea out there that the Board of Supervisors could dissolve RRFC and
take control of the 8,000 af, although there's no reason for them to want to.
13. Sonoma County Water Agency (SCWA)
Nothing.
14. Other Meetings
GM Koehler went to a meeting of the Eel/Russian River where they talked about the
State wanting to go after trespass grows. They're also expecting mussels to invade Clear
Lake next and any day now. There are too many points of entry and boats coming in from
all over the state. Operation of Lake Mendocino is also under scrutiny. Dir Todd states
that the solution to all our problems is how that lake is being handled.
The Upper Russian River Managers meeting also happened with the goal of having
PG&E to re -think their work on the tunnel from the Eel to Potter Valley. PG&E is under
no obligation to listen, but it's worth trying.
15. State Water Resources Control Board
We had an inspection by the State Water Board last week. Her visit was to see how we
handled the curtailment order even though we get our orders from RRFC. So GM
Koehler took her everywhere in our system. She also wanted to see the annexations of
RVCWD.
Items 16-18
Nothing to discuss at this time.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 9:20 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved:
Date Approved:
Signed:
Board of Directors