HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-12-17 RVCWD MinutesRedwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, December 17, 2015
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili, Marvin Talso
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 6:00 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
Ken Todd, Director
Marvin Talso, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public for Items Not on the
Agenda
None.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
Dir Ricetti asks about item #4 on page 18 for the tank repair, and asks how far along they
are on this project. GM Koehler says that they're about halfway. The structural work is
done and the painting is about 2/3 done. They've also bought some metal trench plates.
Motion: Approve the May consent calendar
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
There are no revisions worth bringing up.
Motion: Accept the November Regular Meeting minutes.
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
7. Directors and Staff Reports and Discussion of Non -Action Topics
Everything will be included in the Managers Report.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
GM Koehler recommends starting with Item b since the customer is present.
b. Customer Issue
The customer is here about a billing issue. He bought a property over on Uva
Drive about 10 years ago. The property was sold with 2 connections available and
had two benefits: he would be able to get another connection to the district if the
moratorium is lifted and secondly, in a time of drought he would be able to have
two allocation amounts. GM Koehler speaks up to clarify that he only has one
meter right now. His complaint is that he didn't get double water during the recent
drought rationing. The customer's suggestion is that the meter fee for a second
connection such as what he has now be reduced from $20/month to something
more like $10/month.
The second thing is about the fines imposed last year. There wasn't much
information that he could find about the fines other than what they were. Also,
they were taken away without explanation. He had a leak last year of about 5,000
gallons that cost an extra $68 that he would like credited to his account since the
fines seemed arbitrarily instituted.
Dir Pool asks if there is only one house. The customer clarifies that there are two
residences on the one property. But he knows of other properties in the district
with two houses on one meter that only pay one meter fee. Dir Pool informs him
that he has three residences on his property and is paying three meter fees. The
customer says that Dir Pool should be interested in this, then. Dir Todd mentions
that the water ration was 50 gallons per person per day and therefore not based on
the number of meters. GM Koehler says that the first conservation from the State
was per residence back in 2007. That wasn't really working, so the State moved
on to rationing per capita. In Redwood Valley, most of the extra residences are
being charged a second meter fee. Also, when this customer accrued some late
fees from protesting payment of the fine, GM Koehler took $50 off of the bill.
The Board understands that he is paying for two meters while only one is in
service and that there are no drought benefits. Also,the Board understands that the
customer feels that it's not fair that he has to pay for two while there are other
2
property owners in the valley that have two houses on one property and only pay
one meter fee. The Board agrees that that isn't a good situation but that instead of
letting the second house pay a reduced fee, they should work on tracking down
owners that are in violation. Also, his paying a second meter fee reserves his place
in line should the moratorium be lifted in any way.
The customer says that the $50 credit to his bill was because he didn't pay the fine
for a few months out of protest because he didn't think it was fair. Dir Talso asks
if he has repaired the leak and he says that he has not but has shut off the part of
the line that leaks. The leak is too small for him to find. GM Koehler says the
customer not paying the fine has instituted more fines to compel him to pay. He
has had numerous conversations with this customer and even gave a $50
reduction to get him to go away and he has not, so this is coming to the Board.
The Board says one option for him is to give up the reservation, or he could
physically connect the houses and get a permit from the County saying that it's
now considered one residence. GM Koehler agrees with the customer that there
are multiple places in the valley where people have two houses on one meter and
we don't like it and there's nothing that can be done if people aren't willing to be
honest.
The bottom line is that the Board will not be making exceptions to the rules. The
customer thanks them and leaves.
a. District Operations
Nothing new to report. The reservoir at the plant is full and the pumps are off.
c. Contracts
The transition to being Willow employees went smoothly. One field tech made
the transition happily, the other did not. GM Koehler is now the GM for Millview
as well. He's been spending more than 50% of his time with them because their
moratorium was just lifted, but he expects things to taper off soon.
d. Sanitary Survey
These are done every 5 years and are a component of surface water licensing. The
last few times these have been done, we've done cost -sharing with the City of
Ukiah being the lead agent. The City is required to put this out to bid, which
drives the cost up and has brought a different consultant on board each time. GM
Koehler suggested that Redwood be the lead agency so we could just negotiate
directly with the last consultant instead of going to bid. Millview and the City of
Ukiah are both on board with this idea.
Dir Todd brings up that Redwood is now getting their water from wells in
Millview. GM Koehler agrees, but that this may be a temporary situation.
e. JPA
Dir Todd is covered under the insurance of the JPA to an amount of $2 million
with a $50,000 deductible. Each board member of the RVCWD board is covered
under a similar policy to protect against "errors and omissions".
f. IRWM Grant
This is the toilet rebate program (among other things). Humboldt County is the
recipient of the grant with the City of Ukiah being a sub -grantee and Redwood
being a sub -sub -grantee. GM Koehler has received another bit of paperwork that
needs to be signed changing the dates of implementation. The terms are the same,
just the dates have changed.
There's money available for 60-70 toilets and they think they have a plumber
willing to take on the work.
Motion: Sign the paperwork for the toilet rebate program.
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Talso
In favor: unanimous
g. Rosalind Peterson PRA
GM Koehler wants it in the permanent record the problems Rosalind is causing
and how we're trying to be cooperative. She keeps demanding information that
she could be finding online in simplified versions and refusing to let it be known
what she's looking for so that Redwood employees can help her instead of
wasting time.
9. Financial Report
There was a question last month about a charge and it's for Redwood's portion of the UC
Davis study that Redwood helped to pay for.
They asked about the water line break by the contractor at School Way Bridge and GM
Koehler says that it's probably best to let this one be.
Motion: Approve the Financial Report
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
10. JPA
Senate Bill 88 is a piece of legislation that (among other things) pushes consolidation of
failed water systems with successful water systems. They also like to work with
disadvantaged communities. So Redwood consolidating with other small districts is
exactly what this Bill is meant to do. All the individual boards are for the consolidation,
systems are already working, and no senior management is opposed to it. The problem
right now is how the water rights are set up. Bruce Burton of the Division of Drinking
13
Water is very interested in this process for Redwood Valley and he has the ability to talk
to the higher levels of the State Water Board to get the water rights figured out.
11. Local Agency Formation Commission of Mendocino County (LAFCO)
They are beginning to work on the spheres of influence of the various water districts.
Unfortunately, those are based on flawed reports that are written in stone. GM Koehler
has changed the SOI as best as can be done and hopefully also revised the population
estimate of Redwood.
12. Mendocino County Inland Water & Power Commission (IW&PC)
A facilitator has been appointed for the GSA. Ukiah is seeking the max grant amount for
the Purple Pipe Project. It is a lot of money for a little bit of water, so they may not get
the money. There's still quite a stigma with recycled water, so getting a good use for it
may be a challenge as well.
The (Potter Valley) tunnel is still closed for repairs and there isn't enough water available
for compensatory releases. We have to hope that there's some good rain in March to help
fill the lake.
There's some talk of the Army Corps of Engineers request for projects instead of raising
the dam and the study by Sonoma State monetizing the water loss, both of which have
been written in previous minutes.
13. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement
District (RRFC)
There was a lot of discussion about trying to have Sean White help them with the
transition to a new general manager and keep working on the requirements for licensing.
14. Sonoma County Water Agency
Nothing to report.
15. Report of Attendance at Agency Meetings
Willow: They're very much in support of consolidation. That hasn't always been the case
and now Dave Redding is vocally supporting consolidation.
Millview: The lifting of the moratorium is giving GM Koehler a lot of experience for
when/if Redwood's moratorium is lifted. There is some discussion about rates coming for
the water being sold to Redwood. GM Koehler's opinion is that we're still in an
emergency situation and will be until the Lake fills up again. Redwood is buying water
for less than Calpella right now, but they're under contract while Redwood is still under
an emergency agreement.
There's some more talk about how nice a consolidation would be in the greater Ukiah
Valley.
16-19
Nothing to report.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 7:40 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved:
Date Approved:
Signed:
C7.