HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-11-19 RVCWD MinutesRedwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, November 19, 2015
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 6:00 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
Ken Todd, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public
None. Only GM Koehler and Mary Talso are in attendance.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
Dir Pool points out an item on page 4 listed as "blow gun". It is explained to his
satisfaction.
Motion: Approve the current consent calendar
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
There are a few minor changes to be made. Item J in the minutes seems a little muddled,
but GM Koehler says that the gist of the conversation was recorded.
Motion: Accept the October Regular Meeting minutes as corrected.
Motion by Dir Basili, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
7. Directors and Staff Reports and Discussion of Non -Action Topics
Everything will be included in the Managers Report.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. District Operations
As of November 19, we have about 125 acre-feet left. It won't all be used but
that's a small price to pay to keep the Ag water secure for the customers.
b. School Way Bridge
The second payment has been made. The contractor that was installing the
guardrails punched a hole in the Ag main at the bridge. Fortunately it was the Ag
line and not the domestic. GM Koehler met with the County DOT on the site and
took a lot of pictures. The contractor is trying to blame Redwood for not marking
the water line even though we did and the water line was installed as part of the
bridge project and was installed according to plans. The contractor was very upset
and wanted Steven to mark the pavement again with "No water line", which
obviously he wouldn't. So there's about a day and a half for Redwood and Wipf,
and then MCS had to repair the drainage. GM Koehler is leaning toward that if
Redwood doesn't get a bill for the drainage repair and Wipf s time, that we just
walk away and absorb Steven and Scott's time. Dir Ricetti asks why we don't bill
them and GM Koehler says that they'll fight it really hard. Dir Basili reminds him
that there's a 2-foot margin around any marks on the ground; that if you're
digging within 2-feet, you should hand -dig. GM Koehler agrees and says that the
guardrail contractor says there was no mark in the first place. If there's no mark
where you asked for marking, they should call up the utility and complain, not
just dig anyway. There was a lot of talking and blaming at the site, so we'll have
to wait and see.
The repair is straight -forward and since it's an Ag line, no services needed to be
shut off. The repairs would come to a few thousand, but we'd spend that much on
lawyers. GM Koehler says that if they try to blame us for the environmental
damage, we'll fight it. So he took a lot of pictures of the site.
c. Domestic Fire Service
All new construction requires a'/4" meter with domestic fire sprinklers which is
larger than our usual meters. The options are to have a tank and pump from a well
or to have a connection with Redwood for fire protection ONLY. So it will be the
2
same for the church where there is a stand-alone fire meter. Ag water won't really
work because of debris in the water that would plug up sprinklers or a filter,
cutting down on reliability.
The question is, will we allow this? And at what cost? A regular meter is
$20/month, so he recommends $10/month. This meter will be read monthly and if
there are any problems, there will be major repercussions.
Motion: Agree to domestic fire services at $10/month; owners pay
installation cost including backflow device
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
d. Toilet Rebate Program
We agree to a certain monetary amount to support this program. They finally
came up with the money (allegedly). There wasn't much interest from the public
on this one and it's been even less from qualified plumbers who are willing to go
through the government paperwork required for reimbursement. The only one so
far is out of San Mateo.
GM Koehler has started to think that this would be a good program to back out of
because of the lack of response. Now, though, backing out will be a signal to
government that Redwood is not interested in conservation which will affect
requests for future funding. Ukiah and Redwood are still in it, but it seems that
Russian River Flood Control has backed out. In light of this, Redwood decides to
stay in the program.
e. Intertie Grant
The money still hasn't quite come through. GM Koehler has sat down with Jarod
Thiele with the City of Ukiah about trying to get the money. Redwood has spent
$130,000 so far and those receipts have been submitted with any remainder going
to Millview since they've put a lot of money in relation to this grant as well.
f. Rosalind Peterson
GM Koehler has found something in the Public Information Act that allows him
to bill for time spent copying information. She has been refusing to pay for his
time to make the copies.
g. Tiered Rates
A recent lawsuit has said that you cannot charge tiered rates for conservation
purposes even though the State of California wants agencies to do that. So we
may have to do away with tiered rates in the future. In that event, a rate study will
have to be performed to make sure Redwood can sustain new rates. Redwood may
be able to keep the tiered rates since we don't have a firm water right.
h. Willow Contract
This contract will be in effect on December 1st. We have also agreed to pay
$24,000 for a new vehicle or part of a new vehicle if they want something bigger.
So we're going in with a new truck, a Ranger, and the F-350 stays here and if it
leaves, it gets billed.
Dir Ricetti asks how Steven and Scott feel about this. Scott is happy about it and
will start on December I" but Steven wasn't offered a position right now. GM
Koehler is working on this and trying to help him out in how to deal with people.
The deal is that Steven has one month to have a change in attitude and if he does
start sharing his vast knowledge and expertise, GM Koehler will ask Dave
Redding to reconsider his decision. Steven has a lot of knowledge and talent and
has worked here for 10 years. But the final decision is Dave's.
i. Millview Contract
The Board needs to rescind 2015-2 because of a disagreement about what the
duties of the GM are. So some language was added that seemed to satisfy them
which is now 2015-3. This vote needs to be done by roll call.
Motion: Rescind 2015-2
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
Dir Ricetti: Aye
Dir Basili: Aye
Dir Todd: Aye
President Pool: Aye
Motion: Approve 2015-3
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
Dir Ricetti: Aye
Dir Basili: Aye
Dir Todd: Aye
President Pool: Aye
j. Sustainable Groundwater Act (SGA)
The latest meeting was on October 19. The decision was to obtain a facilitator.
The only thing people have been able to agree on is that they don't want someone
else to run things. So far it's still pointing toward the County. This will be
discussed more later.
k.LAFCO
Angela Silver is the LAFCO alternate and the Calpella representative to the JPA.
The MSRs are being discussed and the current information is inaccurate but
people are using them anyway to determine the spheres of influence of water
districts.
The other LAFCO issue is that they want a letter from us regarding the annexation
of Redwood with RRFC. There is a letter present for the Board to approve. RRFC
4
is waiting for a new general manager before they start work on an REP. So GM
Koehler drafted this letter to send to ask if they want us to keep spending their
money in pre -application work. The letter is looked over by the Board and no
problems are noted.
Motion: Approve the letter to LAFCO
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
1. REP for Debt Process
RRFC has talked about having another dual board meeting to talk about the
annexation. This will be discussed more later.
in. Consolidation with CWDs
Senate Bill 88 is quite a grab bag. The big thing is that Ag users are being
required to monitor and report their water usage hourly; financially impossible for
most. They also want to consolidate failed water districts and Redwood qualifies
for that. The State would really like to have some successful consolidations.
They're trying to force wealthy communities to match with poor ones and of
course they fight that. They really like disadvantaged communities and ones
without much water. So this could be a great opportunity for all the little districts
around this valley to come together. We may be able to get them to help pay for
this and the nice thing is that if the State is forcing it, no CEQA process. GMs
Koehler and Dave Redding are starting to do some meetings with higher-ups to
see what we can get done.
Ag water systems are not included. Since Ag water is a huge part of Redwood
being sustainable, they won't take away that ability. If the water districts around
here were able to consolidate, they would consolidate their water rights and that
would be quite a thing.
9. Financial Report
Dir Pool asks about an item for Professional Fees — Engineering. GM Koehler doesn't
know off the top of his head, but he will find out. Another item for RRFC is for our half
of the RFP that went nowhere.
Motion: Approve the Financial Report
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
Since the last Board meeting, GM Koehler has been to 10 evening meetings of various
agencies.
GSA:
The facilitator will help with decisions about who can vote. Ag cannot right now but
everyone says they need to have a voice. Sonoma County was there and is demanding the
right to be a spectator, which they're allowed to do. The City of Ukiah is still undecided
and if they decide to form their own GSA, things will get messy. Whether or not that is
allowed is in question. There should be only one to keep things smooth and if one breaks
off, more may follow.
Ag representation has been present at these meetings.
JPA:
They met on the 4 h and Dir Todd was there. They all agreed that the final goal of the JPA
is consolidation. They are ready to start collecting money and have a bank account.
They've also contacted Redwood's accountant to start keeping the financial books so the
JPA is ready when issues come up.
RRFC:
They're not doing so well right now. There's dissent between some of the board
members. Lee Howard has turned against the annexation and is fighting it. They had no
responses to their RFP because it's too small to bother with. They had 12 applicants for
the general manager position, most from northern California. They're working on hiring a
couple of people for office help and meter reading. They haven't done any more work on
licensing from the State and lost their only contact when their previous GM left.
Willow:
The handbook has been approved and that was the last step toward moving ahead with
the contract.
Upper Russian River Managers Meeting:
There will be virtually no inflow into Lake Mendocino until March 1st because PG&E is
working on the tunnel. SCWA is looking into doing another change petition by January
1st. The heavy rains are expected in January and February. City of Ukiah has announced
they're going to try for money for the Purple Pipe Project. It's a $55 million project for
only 1,600 acre-feet per year.
Janet did a presentation for the ACOE that was a bunch of smaller projects that would
produce as much water as raising the dam so that ACOE could have a comparison to
make the dam expansion look better. Rau and Associates came up with a plan for a
desalination plant in Fort Bragg with the water being trucked over to Lake Mendocino for
$2 billion dollars and a purchase price of $2,000 per acre foot.
FIRO Act: (Forecast Improved Reservation Operations)
This is amazingly a sensible process. However, the ACOE won't accept the IWPC study
and will have to do their own study, but there's a good chance that they will use the other
studies to back their own.
IW&PC was canceled.
Farm Bureau:
They've done a report that shows how loss of Ag water will affect the economy. Pears
are a minor issue, livestock has been dropped, and grapes are the main driver. It would be
$7 million dollars per 100 acre feet of lost water. It may be too high, but is based on all of
Mendocino County. This number also covers the loss in tax revenue to the County.
Sonoma County is going to be the lead agency for their GSA and the water agency will
be the partner; it seems like a good system.
Millview:
They had their moratorium lifted. Of the 800 people who were waiting, they got 58
responses. They have 298 openings and more may come, but they can only get 20% of
their existing amount without going through more regulatory hoops. The cap fee for new
'/4" meters is $7,900 not including installation and that's the smallest that is allowed now.
Millview is also on board with trying to get everyone together in the valley and working
together. Dir Pool says that they will see improvement working with Redwood. Before
Tim Bradley was GM there for 14 years, they had 10 GMs in 10 years. Dir Pool suggests
that one other person from the Redwood Board start attending the Millview meeting,
because he has a previous, ongoing commitment at that time. Dir Basili says that he
would be able to do it.
GM Koehler was at the last meeting at the City of Ukiah and thanked them for donating
their water to Redwood.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 7:45 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved:
Date Approved:
Signed:
Board of Directors