HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-04-16 RVCWD MinutesRedwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, April 16, 2015
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 7:00 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
Ken Todd, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public for Items Not on the
Agenda
No public in attendance.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
The Board asked about the charges for the door handles on two of the work trucks. GM
Koehler has nothing to add. Then they asked about the charges for Calpella wheeling the
water and GM Koehler says that it is and that it's a'real bargain'. He also says that they're
going to be getting a bill from Millview and that it will be about $300 per acre foot
opposed to over $600 per acre foot to buy it and treat it.
Motion: Approve the consent calendar
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
Dir Pool points out a few more typos. They are noted and will be corrected. Dir Ricetti
asked about the estimate of 250,000 cubic yards of soil that could slough off the bluff
behind the Coyote Valley Rancheria. GM Koehler says that it's a conservative estimate
that could be as high as 1,000,000 cubic yards with the potential to dam the river and
flood the vineyard to the east and block East Road. Unfortunately, the Rancheria doesn't
have the money to stabilize the slope and could lose about half of their housing. The
Army Corps only offered to help move their houses. A tentative idea is to auger in earth
anchors to stabilize the slope. But it'll be $80,000 to even get a study done that can be
presented for serious aid. GM Koehler has tried to convince agencies that it will greatly
affect the fish and water quality for agencies downstream.
Motion: Accept the Regular Meeting minutes as corrected.
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
7. Directors and Staff Reports and Discussion of Non -Action Topics
Everything will be included in the Managers Report.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. Groundwater Sustainability Act
Nobody is really stepping up yet, as discussed at the last meeting. Carre Brown is
looking for each district to say what they'd like to do to be involved. Dir Todd
says it makes the most sense for the County to step up and take charge. GM
Koehler agrees and says if they don't want to do the actual field work, to contract
with someone like the RCD, and that's about as neutral as you can get. RRFC still
won't declare themselves. There's about a half -dozen wells being monitored in
Redwood Valley and RVCWD could volunteer and ask to be trained to do it the
way they want.
Motion: RVCWD takes the position that Mendocino County should be
responsible
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
GM Koehler clarifies that they can hire whomever they would like to do the
monitoring.
b. District Operations
In turning on the Ag meters, they've found some that need replacement and that's
what the field crew is doing right now. They've also received a lot of new meters
and are replacing several that are hard to read or not very accurate. They're
2
Badger meters that are easily integrated to existing systems. GM Koehler said
they're already seeing a difference in usage now that there are meters that will
register the lower flows that the old meters missed.
c. Watershed Sanitary Survey
These are done every five years and that information is shared with the City and is
in proportion to the water usage. So last time, we paid $9,000 for a $35,000 study.
The Survey is a report on potential polluting activities like spilled hazardous
wastes. The best idea is to join with the other water districts in this area to keep
the price down.
Motion: Join the other water districts in the area for a Joint WSS
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
d. Ag Water Reimbursements
Staff has recommended that instead of trying to keep track of who has what credit
and when they've used it, just reimburse all the Ag users who paid for what they
hadn't received and start from zero.
Motion: Adjust to just charging meter fees in times of lack of water and reset
the credit status
Motion by Dir Basili, second by Dir Todd
In favor: unanimous
e. Tank Repair
The latest price is $90,000 for not even the whole job. Superior Pump hasn't
responded to anything. He also contacted Spiess who gave him a more specific
answer. They think the problem is from inadequate ventilation in the tank. They
will do a complete repair and fix the structural deficiencies for about $120K and
to reapply the enamel on the tank and upgrade the anti -climb device will about a
little over $200K. The combined price is about $205K since they wouldn't have to
charge twice for a mobilization/demobilization cost. The life expectancy of a
welded -steel tank is 100 years (with maintenance) and this one was built in 1978.
Also, a new tank is about $1 per gallon; $500,000 in this case.
Motion: Approve complete tank repair with Spiess
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
f. Filter pumps
PG&E has a sub -contractor that comes out and does pump -efficiency tests.
Fortunately, the lake pumps are about as efficient as they can get. There are four
filter pumps, two of which are never used (the two smaller ones). Unfortunately,
they only had the company test the two 60 HP pumps instead of the 40 HP. If
we're looking for some sort of rebate, we should report the worse of the pumps
and the reason we stopped using the 40 HP is that they're so inefficient. Dir Pool
points out that here at the plant we're on solar power and therefore probably not
eligible for an energy saving rebate. GM Koehler agrees and says that he will
check into the potential for a rebate before asking for action by the Board.
g. School Way Bridge
Work is starting on the bridge again soon. There are two meters that need to be
moved by RVCWD on the south side of the bridge. As they begin to move the
main water line, invoices will start coming in and it's going to cost about
$400,000. It'll hurt the bank account, but...
h. Intertie Grant
...there is reimbursement coming in from the intertie and the monitoring well. The
intertie money is almost here as the paperwork has been sent in yet again and
they're running out of things to find wrong with it.
i. Mini Excavator
We have spent $22,000 in the past two years on excavator rentals; it's time to buy
one. The budget is about $50,000 but could go up to about $80,000 for a new
tractor and trailer and much less for one with 1,000 hours on it. Some talk ensues
about various brand attributes. GM Koehler says that for small municipalities, a
dealer would do something called a'municipal lease' which ends with a change in
ownership. Dir Ricetti asks if the JPA would end up owning it. It would be
basically that each district in the JPA would'rent' it from the JPA, paying for
usage. For a used excavator and a new trailer, it would cost about $1,200 - 1,500
per month on a five-year lease. At current usage rates, a new unit would last a
very long time. And GM Koehler vouches for Steven's skill as an operator.
The Board wants him to continue his research of new machines vs buying a used
one.
j. Operations Contract
Willow, Calpella/Millview, and Redwood Valley will all split the $6,000 fee to
get this process going. Even before this gets approved, GM Koehler is going to
get some Millview/Willow employees over to the plant to practice running it.
k. Dissolution/Annexation
Last month the Board reached a consensus that this process will not move ahead
until RRFC addresses the permit issue. After some back -and -forth at their
meeting, RRFC agreed to work on the permit issue. So they would like Richard
Shoemaker from their board to get together with Dir Pool to work the permit
process.
Milliview has a long-standing request for more water that they put in before their
Masonite well was online. So if they do decide to take that water, Redwood
Valley could be cut off again. But, if they do take the water, it would be hard for
4
them to put it to beneficial use, opening the door for a water audit that would most
likely pass the water back to RVCWD. It's complicated and there are a lot of
options. They will claim that having water under contract is beneficial use, but
they've been busted before by Sonoma County Water Agency for bad accounting
by not including other water rights.
There's a lot of other discussion about who's doing what and what problems there
are. It's all been brought up at previous meetings and it all comes down to that the
D/A process is on hold until the permit issue is worked out.
k. Drought
We're all seeing how the Governor can call for mandatory reductions, but how do
you enforce it? How do you make sure some people only water two days a week?
GM Koehler and Dir Pool have a discussion that highlights how poorly the rules
are written and who has to reduce usage and by what amount. It changes as the
months go by. Larger districts may have to limit days of use, but a small district
like this can make a plan on how they can get the same reduction by other means.
Ukiah did something where they allowed people with an even numbered address
to water on one day and odd numbered addresses on the next day. In this valley, it
would be easiest to split it for people on the east side and west sides of the
Russian River. GM Koehler says that method still leaves too many holes since
there are too many people out at the ends of the system who would never be
caught breaking the rules. He says that we'll have to do the same thing as last year
(if it gets to that point) where you get charged for overuse.
in. Customer Mailer
GM Koehler will send out a mailer to all the customers about what the State is
starting to regulate and to the Ag customers about the potential for them to be cut
off again. Last year, RRFC used the State's instructions to lower withdrawal from
the river by 25% to cut off Redwood Valley Ag water (leaving 2,000 acre-feet in
the Lake pointed out by Dir Ricetti).
Another thing is that people need to check their meters regularly to make sure
they don't have a leak.
n. Place of Use
Paul got back to GM Koehler confirming that they should leave the reservations
alone and not try to push either way.
o. New well
They have estimated the cost of a new domestic water supply at $73,000 and a
new pump station at $60,000. It'd be a different type of casing, well screen, and
other things pushing the price higher. They all agree that it seems like too much
money and other bidders should be considered. The big problem here is that some
water agencies that 'got' money in first round of grants and spent a lot on upgrades
still have not been reimbursed by the State and are in danger of defaulting on
bank loans. RVCWD went about the first well with the knowledge the money
may not come through and it will survive if the money never comes. But doing
another well won't be a safe bet. Dir Ricetti seems to remember them quoting
about $25,000 for the well. It'll be smaller, too, as they only are looking for about
100 gallons per minute.
p. Election
Pretty much all of the Board is up for election plus the vacancy. Paula has put
together a packet for each of them.
9. Financial Report
There are some surprises about the total amount of fee income since the system was first
implemented by the previous general manager. GM Koehler says that the only way to get
a lot of people to reduce water usage is via the pocketbook. There was also a problem
with the computer system looking at a tank level instead of the reservoir level, so it
would automatically turn the pump on and overflow the reservoir. They got it worked
out, but there was a larger charge from the lake pumps from trying to fill the wrong thing.
Motion: Approve the Financial Report
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
10. LAFCO
Nothing has been put forward on the plan for services. Sean White finally got together an
invoice, so that's been paid by RVCWD.
11. Mendocino County IW&PC
Looks like nobody can apply for the grant for the Quagga Mussels Program because
nobody is the owner. So there's nothing to try to get rid of those invasive clams. PG&E is
going to close down the tunnel next year for more repairs.
IWPC is still pushing for raising the dam at Lake Mendocino. It's the most logical thing
and is pretty much all ready to go.
12. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control
Already discussed.
13. Sonoma County Water Agency (SCWA)
Sonoma will file an emergency change petition to reduce the outflow from Lake
Mendocino.
14-18
Nothing to report.
Side note: GM Koehler will be out for medical reasons starting the last week of May for
4-5 weeks. He will keep the Board updated as much as possible but is expected to miss
the whole month of June.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 8:30 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved: Board of Directors
Date Approved:
Signed:
4 hours