HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-02-19 RVCWD MinutesRedwood Valley County Water District Approved B.O.D. 3/19/15
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, February 19, 2015
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 6:00 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Ken Todd, Director
Absent:
Jeff Basili, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public
None.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda with Item 8.e. moved up
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
Absent: Dir Basili
Presentation by Luhdorf & Scalmanini:
Bill Gustafson begins by introducing L&S who have been around since 1980 and does
groundwater projects. They've worked all over California on both large and small water projects.
They were contacted by GM Koehler to look for a groundwater source. They did the geophysical
investigation and followed it up with a test hole and a monitoring well. They are here tonight to
talk about the results of the groundwater tests and provide some recommendations as to subsequent
action.
Scott Lewis does a recap about the investigation. They started with a few suggestions for locations
from GM Koehler; the two main ones being down on East Road by Road A and on the other side
of the river behind the winery (Barra). Based on their review of the geology, they decided the
eastern site would be better to look at. One reason is that the site is more in the center of the
alluvium that runs through the valley and a thicker alluvium has better potential for water. A test
hole was drilled at the site to characterize the lithology and a monitoring well was designed based
on those findings.
He then hands out copies of the report and explains some of the figures. Some of the things he was
looking for was isolating clay layers and layers that would prevent river underflow from entering
into the well. They figured 500 feet deep was a good depth because anything deeper than that has
less chance of water. The monitoring well contains multiple separate 2-inch pipes in the same
borehole which allows collection of water for analysis from three different layers of water. The
shallow piezometer was above the confining clay layer to collect information on what river
underflow water looks like. The deeper didn't have favorable water quality with high TDS [total
dissolved solids], manganese, arsenic, and others that were too high to work with. The middle
zone, from about 182-230 feet down, had much more favorable water quality; a little bit of
manganese, but nothing else.
Before samples were taken, the well was developed by cleaning it with clean water and pulling
water in from the formation. During development of the deeper well, they found that it didn't
produce much water at all and never really cleared up. It stayed turbid [dirty] despite a lot of effort
to clear it. The middle layer cleaned up well and produced water much better. Dir Todd asks how
they would determine how much a well would produce at this site. He responds that they need to
construct a well and then test it. When the monitoring well was constructed, it was sealed with
concrete to prevent any contamination from the surface. It would be cheaper to drill a new well
and set it up for production than to convert the monitoring well to a production well. The
monitoring well would still be useful for monitoring how the production well is changing the water
table and collect samples. Dir Todd asks for a guess as to what a well like that would produce. Mr.
Lewis says that it's very variable and a lot of the data they have is old and varies a lot by season.
The report says from 100-200 gallons per minute (GPM), but it's very hard to tell.
Calpella's well is screened at the same interval (180-230 feet approximately) but he believes that
the radius of influence of a well in this area is very small.
Tom Ellison continues that this zone is separate from the river and is a groundwater source. It is
not ambiguous. The Masonite well has a clay layer at about 30 feet and that has already been
agreed upon as a barrier. So a clay layer even deeper at this site is a very good argument. This well
is not expected to perform as well as Masonite and may yield about 100 GPM, which is more
consistent with wells in this area. The idea may be to develop two or three wells and at 100 GPM
each, it would add up. And if you try to build a production well and it just doesn't produce, that
answers the question for sure about whether or not there is groundwater to be had in this area.
Dir Pool asks about trying another monitoring well on the Barra site. Mr. Ellison responds that the
best case in doing that would be another well like this one, but over there you probably wouldn't
have the well-defined clay layer to prove it's not underflow. So the best course of action is to
install a well here and see what yields can be had.
Some questions come up about Forsythe Creek and how it would flow through the area by Barra
and if that creek would help recharge an aquifer in that area. Mr. Ellison explains that the creek
flows through a narrow path and through largely impermeable layers that would prevent
accumulation of groundwater. The person asking the questions introduces herself as Emily
Luscombe and she is from the Coyote Valley Reservation and is interested since they are working
on a groundwater source and have both Forsythe Creek and the Russian River flowing through the
reservation.
The decision before the Board now is if to continue and install a test well. GM Koehler suggest the
first action is to turn the current well into a monitoring well. Dir Todd asks if there is funding for
these projects. GM Koehler says there was money from the Emergency Drought Fund, but we
haven't seen a nickel yet. Dir Pool asks if there is a possibility of putting two wells close together.
Discussion ensues and is answered when Mr. Ellison says that with low -yield wells like these, they
would ideally be one -quarter to one-half a mile apart since the radius of influence in so small. But
that largely depends of availability of space. The main problem will be boron in the water. The
limit is about 2-3 parts -per -million (ppm); the deep zone of this well was at 1.5 and the middle
zone is about 0.17. Emily asks about the boron since they're having problems with arsenic in their
water. They seem to be hitting it at 250-300 feet down.
If the water isn't good enough for potable water, it could be used on vineyards or pumped up to the
treatment plant. If there's a lot of iron and manganese, those are pretty standard for removal.
The Luhdorf & Scalmanini guys leave.
The talk moves to the test well and the Board favors the idea. Trying to add more wells to the
system later may be a problem since most people with land and a well on it would be very hesitant
to let another well be drilled on their property. But the Board will work on that when/if the test
well proves successful.
Emily speaks up about a recent report that is predicting a 40-year drought in California with us
being in the 4th year right now. If that's the case, it's best to get as many options as possible.
Sonoma County is working on new methods with small swales and such to catch water. Dir Pool
brings up the JPA and a possibility of a recharge area and/or additional water supply and lines.
Especially if the rain comes in short intervals every few years, getting that into the ground via
recharge wells would be very prudent.
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
Motion: Approve the consent calendar
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
Absent: Dir Basili
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
There were some corrections to the minutes by the staff but they were pretty quick because of the
time crunch. Dir Pool points out a few more typos.
Motion: Accept the January 15th Regular Meeting minutes as corrected.
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Ricetti
In favor: Unanimous
Absent: Dir Basili
7. Directors and Staff Reports and Discussion of Non -Action Topics
Items are either not relevant or will be discussed later.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. District Operations
We are doing pretty well and still adjusting to the new intertie.
b. Trucks
We'll be needing to buy new trucks soon. The only ones that are in decent shape are pretty
high mileage. The maintenance agreement with Willow may help. They aren't making Ford
Rangers anymore, but they are making improvements to the F-150. Dir Pool suggests the
Chevrolet Colorado. GM Koehler is just saying that this decision is coming up soon.
c. Election
Dirs Pool, Ricetti, and Basili are all up for election. GM Koehler will put out a sign for the
Director position. Dir Ricetti asks if Chuck Van will be applying again since he didn't file
on time last election.
d. Committee Appointments
GM Koehler runs through the various appointment positions. They decide to wait until Dir
Basih is present. Dir Pool says that in any case, he'll be going to meetings of Russian River
Flood Control and Willow.
e. Well Report
Already covered.
f. Coyote Valley Reservation
The bulk of this has been covered already and we're very excited to be working in
conjunction with the CVR to develop groundwater options. If they get a high -producing
well, they'd be able to sell some of that to RVCWD and then they would be able to get their
water through a "master meter" like the Redwood Valley Rancheria. Also, if they gave up
some of their services, would those be able to be used for other places in Redwood Valley.
But of course, all of this is speculation until they get water. Also, what if their well fails?
Emily clarifies that while the tribe would be willing to share water from a well, they would
not want to give up their services in case of a 40-year drought.
4
GM Koehler has also been talking with their engineers, LACO Associates, about the well
options. Emily says that the well is their main focus and then they will hopefully start
working with some kind of recycled water program.
g. Intertie
The intertie has been in operation since January 8. Since then, we've been drinking
Millview water. The pricing structure still hasn't been worked out, but it's rather irrelevant
since it's our only option right now. We're getting about 300 GPM from both interties. So,
it's working well and we're really happy with it.
In order to use this water in a non -emergency basis, Millview has to conclusively prove
that this is percolated groundwater. If they can do that, we can look at using this water on a
much longer timeline. There's also the Masonite property which can be used to recharge the
groundwater in times of rain. The Central Valley is already having problems with the
ground surface lowering because of all the water that is being pulled out.
h. EPA Climate Change Program
Their site visit is on the 4th and 5th and the presentation of the Upper Russian Managers
meeting is on the 5th, so they will be coming to that. Sonoma County has spent a large
amount of time and money studying the reliability of Lake Mendocino which is tied to
climate change. They won't be able to provide any new information, but having their
opinion to submit with grants would be very helpful.
i. JPA
The next JPA meeting is on the 5th, probably at 5pm. Dir Todd asks if there are any topics
that this Board wants to be discussed at the JPA meeting. GM Koehler says there will be a
lot of housekeeping stuff like elections. They will also talk about if they are going to
attempt the aggregate their contracts. They would all add together their anticipated
requirements and then come as one to RRFC and put in an "order". Then it can be used and
one entity could assist another if needed.
GM Koehler brings up the case were RVCWD is annexed into RRFC, which would allow
Redwood Valley residents to be voted onto the RRFC board. In order to sign a contract
with the JPA, the annexation would have to be done. And aggregation of water needs
probably isn't a good idea right now but should wait until the dust settles on negotiations
between RVCWD and RRFC.
j. Operations Contract with Willow
The meetings will begin next week to hammer out what it will look like. It's possible for
the JPA to take over operations at a later date with the way things are going.
k. Water Supply
At the latest meeting the RRFC board decided to lift their drought curtailment effective
February 21st. That means that on the 21st, RVCWD is back in business as a surplus
customer. We're going to fill our reservoir on Monday and our crew is going to go out and
test valves for functionality. It's important to make sure everything is working before the
frost season. We'll also be placing signs announcing that the Ag water is back on. Now we
have to work with the people to whom we owe water. Staff has calculated a roughly
$30,000 to $50,000 hit in the future.
10. LAFCO
There's still language in the annexation/dissolution that says that this action will lift the
moratorium. Sean White says he didn't put it in there, and GM Koehler sure didn't, so it is in the
rewriting process right now. There is a bigger push now for RRFC to put an actual amount on the
water that they will supply RVCWD. These issues with contracts and water amounts are coming to
the surface.
GM Koehler was on the phone with the Bureau of Reclamation where they discussed the main
questions of what counts as an event that would trigger repayment, can the debt be carried by the
zone of benefit, and what's the procedure for reevaluation of the debt. The triggering event is us
going to the BoR and saying that we want to repay the loan; they'll agree to pretty much anything.
They also said that the terms of the loan repayment are all negotiable but only after we have shown
ability to pay. The problem is that Redwood Valley hasn't increased its ability to pay at all since
the last evaluation. If this loan were to be paid off in 30 years, it would increase every domestic
customer's fee by about $20 per month and roughly double the meter fee for Ag customers. And
that's just not viable in this area. There would be a pretty significant reduction in overall payback
amount because of the lower interest rates today, though.
The biggest question that was asked was about what would trigger a repayment, and the answer is
that they would wait until we say we can pay.
12. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control
There was a lot of waffling around but it came down to a number of 600 acre-feet, based on the
assumption that they have 7,000 acre-feet under contract. So they're comfortable giving Redwood
a 600 of contract, holding 400 of in reserve, and most likely the City of Ukiah will roll over their
800 a£ So there could be as much as 1,400 acre-feet available.
One of the ways that they could free up more water is with a recycled water program. This would
save water because of the required dilution factor for release into the river and would make things
easier without having to deal with the state for water.
Another thing is the problem of the permit with the Division of Drinking Water. They can't control
Ag water and Ag is a big part of the financial stability of this district. Getting a new permit is
nearly impossible and we would lose our permit in the event of dissolution. All in all, this seemed
to shift discussion away from dissolution by pointing out all the ways it can't work.
Recently, the Rancheria has come to RVCWD saying that they are working for the money to drill a
well and don't like the idea of administrative action that may be taken against them. Specifically,
how the State would come to RVCWD and tell them to shirt the reservation off since they aren't a
part of our use area. The petition to change the place of use and the other petition where lumped
together by the State and it's been a losing battle to get them to separate them again. Dir Pool and
GM Koehler met with the State Water Board and they were offered a deal where RVCWD gets
122.8 acre feet on the license which has a face value of 4,900 acre feet, because that's the most that
was used before 2002 (when the petition expired). Then they will work on the change of place of
use if they agree to the first part. It may not be in the best interest for RVCWD to accept this offer.
If they don't, GM Koehler has just talked with the Rancheria and they agreed to try their channels
of influence to separate the petitions. Even then, it could be years before anything gets going.
Dir Pool brings up the fact he'd like to have some provisions of the permit changed since a lot of
the original ones were set up by Fish and Game. There is a lot of discussion about whether or not
to accept the State's offer and various possible implications. They decided to wait until they can
talk to their lawyer, Paul, about what may happen with this deal.
9. Financial Report
There is some talk about costs and savings for pumping water from Calpella rather than running
the plant. We will probably save money from not running the plant, but using more pumps does eat
up the electricity. Also, a check came from the state which covers about 60% of the cost of the
intertie. But the paperwork involved is horrendous.
Motion: Approve the financial report
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
10. Local Agency Commission of Mendocino County (LAFCO)
Already discussed.
11. Mendocino County Inland Water & Power Commission (IW&PC)
Dir Pool attended the meeting. One thing that came up was that Districts that maintain their own
websites need to either post the salary of officials or provide a link to the attorney general's site
that details what the salary is for officials. They're going to wait until better instructions come out
on who counts as an official. There also needs to be a better costibenefit analysis for the Lake so
that they can make it more of a priority. All talks with the Army Corps need to be transcribed as
soon as possible.
There was also talk about the new groundwater regulations that will be coming and the JPA would
be a good way to address that with all the Districts as one voice.
12. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement District
(RRFC)
Dir Pool and Dir Basili both attended this meeting. Judy Hatch is against the
dissolution/annexation as long as RVCWD is looking to be a part of the JPA. A lot of these things
were talked about earlier with regard to how dissolution just won't work out. Then the RRFC board
started throwing out conflicting numbers as to what they could sell to RVCWD that ranged from
600 to 1,400 acre feet. Shoemaker tried to offer 900 acre feet, but that got shot down, and then
Judy changed it to 500 acre-feet. The final motion was for 600 acre feet to Redwood Valley with
the expectation to increase to 1,400 acre feet and was approved by all except Judy, who came up
with that offer in the first place and Lee had gone home.
7
The 600 of isn't much at all and RVCWD still has the stipulated judgment which entitles them to
water that is not put to beneficial use - it has nothing to do with water that is under contract.
13. Sonoma County Water Agency (SCWA)
Nothing.
14. Other Meetings
Some of them went to the Board of Supervisors meeting but there's nothing to report from that.
The S WRCB has already been talked about. GM Koehler went to the Farm Bureau meeting a few
days ago. There will be a focus on the West Branch which serves a lot of Redwood Valley and
those areas, since they haven't been very involved so far.
There is also some talk about who will represent this area for the groundwater preservation talks.
The only agents that can do it are either RRFC or the County. And so far, neither one seems to be
interested in doing it.
Items 16-18
Ethics training is coming up soon for the Board.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 9:15 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved:
Date Approved:
Signed: