HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016-07-21 RVCWD MinutesMINUTES
Redwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, July 21, 2016
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti; Ken Todd, Jeff Basili, Mary Talso
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 6:00 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Ken Todd, Director
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
Absent:
Mary Talso, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public for Items Not on the
Agenda
Nothing.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None from staff. Dir Ricetti asked about someone who approached her about their bill for
$140 for backflow while it was supposed to be $40; there were no repairs involved. GM
Koehler asked her to come to him with the information and he'd look into it.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
Domestic sales are up and irrigation sales are down. Dir Ricetti asks if the State -
mandated conservation measures are still in place. GM Koehler says that the measures
are no longer in place if the water provider has enough water for three years. Whatever
that means.
Dir Todd asks about the labor contract with Willow and that it's higher than he thought it
would be. GM Koehler says that this amount is correct and this item will be discussed
further at a later point in this meeting.
Motion: Approve the June consent calendar
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
Motion: Accept the June Regular Meeting minutes
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
7. Action Items
1. Cesar Toxqui Winery — Place holder for possible action
Cesar comes forward and reiterates his request to increase the size of the meter on
his property. He says that he was asked for some data that he doesn't think he can
provide yet and asks about service to a couple of other wineries. GM Koehler
reiterates that he cannot allow more meters under the moratorium, but he can
increase the size of a meter. At the last meeting, Cesar was going to work with
some local engineers to show how little water he will use at his winery. Cesar
agrees and says that he is looking for information for a comparison. He says that
he will be producing a tenth of what Graziano does. Dir Ricetti says that where
the District has had problems before is how much that use has increased years
down the line. Her concern is the opening for legal trouble. GM Koehler again
brings up the idea using a 50,000 gallon tank and letting the %" meter run 24-7.
He also likes Dir Ricetti's idea of getting a legal opinion.
Cesar also asks about the cost of the upgrade so he can compare it to a tank. Also,
he is using another method to make his wine that won't use as much water, so
maybe he doesn't need the upgrade. GM Koehler says that it will be expensive
based on $5,000 for a'/4" meter installed under the "hardship criteria". So a 2"
meter would run around $20,000. Dir Ricetti says that would buy a really nice
tank. Dir Pool points out that he'll probably need water at set points instead of
continuous, so a tank would be better.
Cesar asks about drilling a well and the Board says they have no problem with
that but it's an expensive gamble. He has a neighbor with a well and Dir Ricetti
suggests that he try asking them. GM Koehler says that his proximity to Forsythe
Creek may be helpful. He suggests that Cesar should check all his options before
making a decision. Also, in 2014 he had to have the vineyards shut down because
of the drought. His next question has to do with having a tasting room. GM
Koehler says that things get sticky when you involve two buildings, so they need
to try to keep everything in one building.
2
GM Koehler tells Cesar that right now, people are using 70-90 gallons per person
per day. Another person in the audience asks when it was increased from the
conservation of 50 gpppd. GM Koehler tells her that they haven't penalized
people for the last two years. She says she never got that memo and GM Koehler
says they sent a mailer to every customer saying that the overuse penalty is over
but they urge people to continue to conserve. Back to Cesar, GM Koehler again
tells him that he needs to bring in some good numbers as to proposed use and that
he get those numbers from another small winery. The Board throws out a lot of
suggestions.
2. Management Contract with Millview - Discussion and possible approval of
Amendment 1 to the Management Contract with Millview.
There was a meeting on Tuesday and that was two meetings since the last
Redwood meeting. He has been spending a disproportionate amount of time
working on Millview issues. In second to last Milliview meeting, he talked with
the Board and thought they had reached a consensus that they like what he was
doing and that they would be 2/3 of his proposed raise. In the latest meeting, it
was like that other conversation had never happened and they started all over
again. Two of the members flipped on their position and Dir Mack implied that if
Redwood starts paying more for the water they're getting from Millview, they'll
give him the raise.
So right now, they're willing to pay Redwood 2/3 of his raise. He has the papers
here with him. The original contract is that Millview pays Redwood a certain
amount a year for management services, valued at $78,000 per year which
includes his insurance, retirement, care, etc. He is asking for a raise of $20,000
per year, of which Millview will be paying 2/3. He hasn't had a raise in six years
and the last time there was an opportunity, the field guys got the raise because
they were really poorly paid. Dir Pool and Ricetti agree that this large of a raise is
reasonable based on his knowledge and experience. Dir Basili says that based on
his credentials and education, he would be making more pretty much anywhere
else.
Motion: Accept that Millivew will increase their payment under Amendment 1
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
3. General Manager Salary Increase - Discussion and possible approval of salary
increase for GM.
He is asking for an increase in his salary from $100,000 per year to $120,000 per
year. He has two years left and those two years are going to be packed in trying to
get the water districts together — a deal 30 years in the malting. A few years ago,
he and his wife were all ready for his retirement but he decided to stay on to get
the water districts consolidated. The Board agrees that GM Koehler is well worth
the money.
Motion: Approve the raise for GM Koehler, effective August 1, 2016
Motion by Dir Basili, second by Dir Todd
In favor: unanimous
4. Water Sale to Calpella — Review and possible approval of charge for water
supply to Calpella.
We are currently transferring water to Calpella. Moore Street Bridge is shut down
right now, so water can't go across the Russian River. So some people in Calpella
are upset because they say we're buying water cheaper from Millview than they
are, so you're getting cheap water and then selling it back to us on the other side
of the bridge. Dir Todd suggests a trade, but it is pointed out that Calpella doesn't
produce any water. GM Koehler says that he is currently running the treatment
plant because we're running off of only one intertie. There's a lot of expense
associated with running the plant. So his solution is to charge them the same rate
Millview charges us. There really is an issue in that Redwood already pays less
for water from Millview than Calpella does.
Motion: Sell water to Calpella at the same rate they currently pay Millview
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
In favor: unanimous
5. Budget — Review and possible approval of 2016-17 Budget.
We've been putting money aside to fully fund our depreciation. Before that,
things were looking better, but this is a more accurate representation of how the
District is doing. There was about $440,000 for the bridge and $250,000 for the
tank repairs and that put a dent in our finances. Since 2008 when the first drought
hit, water usage has dropped and income along with it. And that has not changed.
This will eventually cause rates to go up. Dir Pool asks about any more capital
improvements and GM Koehler says that it will be the SCADA upgrade. Dir Pool
asks about the valve -exercising machine and how much it has been used on the
Redwood infrastructure. GM Koehler says that it hasn't been used as much as
he'd like but that's due to a lack of manpower, not that one district is hogging it.
What it's been telling us is that the valves that get exercised start working again.
Dir Ricetti asks about the tanks and GM Koehler says that every few years, the
insurance company comes up with all the districts to go over the infrastructure. So
GM Koehler has been out with them and with GM Redding to look over the
systems. Millview has some tank problems and they're watching the City of
Ukiah deal with their tanks to see how it goes. Our tanks are looking good.
Motion: Accept the Budget
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Todd
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. District Operations
Most of it has been covered. The plant has been running, just cleaning up Ag
water, and it's been great working the plant without worrying about any
regulations because the water was not for human consumption. Scott has been
rd
doing great and really taking advantage of his freedom from a previous coworker.
He's been training the other guys on running the plant and is really stepping up to
the plate. He has also been given a raise and is a lot happier.
There is nothing in the district right now in desperate need of repair. Last year, we
had a discussion about upgrading the SCADA. TelStar gave a quote of about
$200,000 with a complete replacement. MCC, however, just did a few upgrades,
so they can't say the whole system is junk, only that it needs some tweaking. But
they are hard to get ahold of and don't seem to care about such a small job. GM
Koehler is going to Forestville to hear about a new system that is cloud based.
This company, XiO, hasn't done anything this size yet, but they are working on
similar districts.
b. District Consolidation
We did have plans to consolidate the offices in early August, but one of the office
staff is having some physical issues that require us to wait. It's not a problem.
c. Watershed Sanitary Survey
Things are going forward. We're only looking for 25 pages to talk about any
changes in the watershed. GM Koehler went to the same guys that did this for us
years ago and they wanted to redo the whole thing, which is much more
expensive. The sanitary survey needs to include any possible sources of
contamination included drainages, marijuana grows, airports, fires, and anything
else. So Luhdorff & Scalmanini is doing a new one for $20,000 which can be
simply added to every 5 years. On August 4, GM Koehler is taking L&S on a tour
of the district and the significant parts of the watershed.
9. Financial Report
Motion: Approve the March Financial Report
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
10. JPA — Upper Russian River Water Agency
Not a lot happened at the last meeting. The main thing is that the JPA decided to forgo
having insurance since they don't have anything to insure and the money can be used
elsewhere.
11. Local Agency Formation Commission of Mendocino County (LAFCo)
Nothing to report.
12. Mendocino County Inland Water & Power Commission (IWPC)
There were two interesting things at this meeting. Kevin Doble is the representative from
the City of Ukiah at the IWPC. This time, as well, Sage was there and they said they
needed help with the Sanitation District. Their position is that they need help in dealing
with the SD because things between them are devolving and it puts their Purple Pipe
Project funding in jeopardy. The big question is, who were they trying to get help from
on this? The members of the IWPC don't have any influence over the SD and wouldn't
want to get involved anyway.
The other interesting thing was that they're paying attention to the JPA. In this meeting,
Paul Zellman told him that RRFC is joining the JPA. So it appears that RRFC really is
going to join. It seems to be coming about because RRFC is finally asking the questions
of themselves that Redwood has been asking of them for a long time.
13. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement
District (RRFC)
Things have been changing in the RRFC. They're actually making progress at going to
license. The surprising thing is that they actually were having an honest discussion on
consolidating the water districts in this area and they see the JPA as a possible vehicle to
that end. They aren't going to join yet, but the fact that they're actually thinking about it
is a huge step forward. Dir Pool adds that when they were talking about it, there were no
dissenting opinions. They also talked about the contracts they have and how they account
for their water allocations.
Al White, from the RRFC Board, came in to the JPA meeting saying that the JPA is a
waste and just another layer of bureaucracy. But it seems that he has been partially
convinced. Rogina Water and the City of Ukiah are out of it, but the other districts in the
valley will all benefit from coming together.
14. Sonoma County Water Agency
Nothing to report.
15. Report of Attendance at Agency Meetings
SGMA: Everyone has agreed that there will be a single GSA. Toward the end of the
second facilitation they had a list of who can be the GSA. The options are the County or a
JPA of some kind. The County and the IWPC have been eliminated, as has the water
district JPA because there isn't balanced representation. The County may not be lead, but
they need to be closely involved. So they're looking to set up a new JPA. So they're
going to form a technical workshop to form this JPA, and GM Koehler volunteered.
Sam Sandoval has been doing mapping for the districts. He's a professor from UC Davis
and has graduate students doing studies for him for various scenarios. They demonstrated
that to have reliable water in Lake Mendocino we need to raise the dam and keep the
Potter Valley Project. We all knew that already, but now we have a very credible source
that backs up the opinion. His other graduate student is looking at the demand side of all
the valley. And we get all these studies for free.
Millview: We're still working on the backflow problems. Our guy has bailed on us and it
turns out that Millview and Willow are looking for backflow programs. Some local guys,
though, are upset that they don't get to do things the way they want to anymore. So we're
looking to get one program for all the districts. We don't have to go to bid, but it may be
a good idea.
Millview is also having an issue with railroad crossings. It may seem to be their problem,
but we have three places in our district where there are conflicts with the railroad tracks.
Right now, the railroad is saying they want $65/lineal foot where putting the pipe in the
road is only about $25/lineal foot for the paving and traffic control part. So that means
the railroad is not offering fair market value. So Millview is going to be opening up that
can of worms.
Willow: The big topic of conversation with them has been the conflict with the 83
services and the City of Ukiah. It has been detached from Willow's sphere -of -influence.
The big deal is that McCowen wants to force the transfer to take place. The same
situation may arise on the north end of Ukiah, where Millview serves the houses. And the
development down on Ford Rd may also be impacted in the future.
16. State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB)
Nothing to report.
17. Status Report of Place of Use Issues
Nothing to report.
18. Status Report of 2800 acre-feet Storage Right.
Nothing to report.
19. Consider Attendance at Other
Nothing to report.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 8:30 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved: Board of Directors
Date Approved:
Signed: