HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016-04-21 RVCWD MinutesMINUTES
Redwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting Minutes
Thursday, April 21, 2016
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili, Mary Talso
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 6:05 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Mary Talso, Director
Ken Todd, Director
Absent:
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public for Items Not on the
Agenda
No attending public.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Talso
In favor: Unanimous
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
Dir Todd asks how sharing feel works with the consolidated work force. GM Koehler
says the only fuel that gets charged to Redwood is for his car. All other fuel is worked
into the charges for the field crew.
Motion: Approve the March consent calendar
Motion by Dir Talso, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
Motion: Accept the March Regular Meeting minutes as corrected.
Motion by Dir Talso, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
7. Action Items
1. Discussion and possible decision to proceed with MCC SCADA evaluation and
quote.
MCC did the work in the past and $80,000 to $100,000 should cover it. This is
much less than the quote we were given from another company that GM Koehler
wasn't happy about working with. For $6,000 to $7,000 MCC will come over and
do a thorough evaluation and deduct that from the overall cost if we decide to
have them do the new system. The only other option is the electrician who set up
the system at the Lake Mendocino pumps. But he did some work at the plant that
didn't do well at all. So he may be a cost saving, but it's not worth it. Dir Poole
also points out that a company like MCC will be around for a long time to offer
support.
The last time the SCADA system went down, we had to buy an old computer just
so it could run the software. This new system will use new everything, and while
it will be expensive, we'll be set for the next 10 years. Dir Poole asks if this
change will make us more compatible with the Millview system. GM Koehler
says that while it isn't the best match (Millview uses TelStar), it's a lot closer. Dir
Poole is interested in hearing from MCC about the compatibility of data between
our system and Millview's system, so that if we merge and want to run both
systems remotely, would it work? GM Koehler says it's rather a moot point since
you won't have one system reading another system. If you were a remote
operator, you would look at one system and then have another program that read
the other system. It wouldn't cause any problems.
Motion: Proceed with the MCC SCADA evaluation
Motion by Dir Talso, second by Dir Todd
In favor: unanimous
2. Discussion and possible approval of expenditure of $600 for SGMA
presentation.
Dave Redding with Willow knows an attorney who helped write the SGMA
legislation. For $2,400 he'll come up and give a presentation about this act. The
JPA approved this but they don't have any money, so the four partners to bring
this attorney around are Millview, Willow, RRFC, and Redwood. The County is
coming, the City declined, Farm Bureau accepted, the small agencies are coming,
and someone from the Hopland tribe will be there. It's going to be at the Willow
office.
2
Motion: Approve the $600 expenditure for the presentation
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Talso
In favor: unanimous
3. Discussion and possible action regarding formation of Ad Hoc committee
regarding allocations.
Dir Todd talks about the property in question. He worked with Mayfield to put in
a T-j unction to install pipes to that property. The new buyers asked for it knowing
that they would not get water anytime soon. GM Koehler says that this isn't a
good example. The house in the flat was bought by a house -flipper and that has
further complicated an already complicated situation. The point is, this is going to
start being more of a problem as time goes on and the moratorium is not lifted.
This Board needs to establish some kind of procedure to deal with this issue.
There is a table consensus to form this committee.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. District Operations
The older Rangers are not surplus yet, but maybe next month.
b. Asbestos Lawsuit
Our part is over; the people who needed information have come and gone. We are
not named as a party at this time. Mendocino County Counsel advised GM
Koehler to look at everything that they lawyers looked at, so he pulled a few guys
from Willow to help look through things. County Counsel's Kit Elliott did a
terrific job helping out and keeping things financially reasonable.
c. Tank Repair
The tank is filling right now and they did a wonderful job repairing it. It was the
first tank in the system and it's now like new.
d. Contract Operations
There's a clause in the contract that Willow is not responsible for deferred
maintenance. They cleaned up Millview and it cost about $15,000 dollars. There
was a lot of scrap metal to sell, the outdated chemicals are gone, and dead AC
pipe. It was all legally disposed of with chain -of -custody forms.
e. Lake Mendocino Diversions
In March we were able to divert 60 acre feet of our own. That also led to an
electrical bill which is basically $100/acre foot to move water over the hill. But
we didn't have to pay for the water.
f. Financial Evaluation of Contract Operations.
Before the maintenance contract, having two employees cost about $145,000 per
year (full burden cost). The cost of the 2.5 contract employees minus his contract
to Millview is about $150,000 per year. So it's pretty much a wash. Right now,
we're not getting 2.5 employees, but it will even out as soon as the treatment plant
starts running. Dir Poole asks if Dave Redding has hired anyone yet and GM
Koehler says he brings that up a few times a week. GM Redding has never
handled this many employees before, so the thought of adding even more is
daunting. But things will start picking up soon and a lack of personnel will
become more obvious.
Comparing this January, February, March to those months of previous years
shows that things are quite comparable. We aren't getting as much bang for the
buck as before, but that was expected and we expect things to pick up.
*Ben Henthorne from the Redwood Valley Rancheria arrives*
GM Koehler reminds the Board that representatives from the RV Rancheria came
in last month and really pushed to be included in letters and decisions to the State
Board. We agreed and GM Koehler has tried to work with the Tribe and hasn't
gotten anything back from them. So he's ready to send the letter this week if he
doesn't get any comments from the Tribe.
Redwood Valley has submitted two different petitions to the State for water
issues. The State lumped the two together and refuses to split them again until
Redwood agrees to reduce our water right from what we're allowed (4,900 acre
feet) to what we can prove that we use (300 acre -fee": Our attorney has said that
it's better to continue to pay $1,000 to keep the petitions going than to concede
any water. So we're going to just sit on this. That's where the Tribe comes in
since place of use is one of the issues with the State.
Ben says that he is here to listen and report to his bosses, so he can't really
comment on anything. GM Koehler says that's fine, but if there aren't any
comments by next week, he's going to send the letter. After some discussion, GM
Koehler asks that Ben send him an email asking about what was said at this
meeting so that GM Koehler can write a detailed response to present to the tribal
Council. Dir Todd asks about the water usage of RVR and GM Koehler says they
use less than the average for the rest of the valley.
Dir Talso asks about the County hiring a mediator for the SGMA. GM Koehler
says that they have done so and it will be addressed later.
9. Financial Report
Dir Poole asks about some costs related to the intertie and GM Koehler says that it was
for a spare, custom-made pump. Dir Poole asks if there is still some retention left for the
tank repair or if this is it. GM Koehler says he can't quite remember, but that he thinks
the full retention has been released.
Motion: Approve the March Financial Report
Motion by Dir Talso, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
SGMA is ruling our world these days. The big deal with this is about the integration of
ground and surface water. In the past, the Department of Water Resources has maintained
that the water in the Ukiah basin is ridgetop to ridgetop. Right now, a lot of focus is on
the Russian River, maybe because it has a relatively small watershed. They're trying to
work on inspection points to keep the mussels out of Lake Mendocino, but they only have
one and that's at the north boat ramp.
10. JPA— Upper Russian River Water Agency
Items already discussed.
11. Local Agency Formation Commission of Mendocino County (LAFCo)
Nothing to report.
12. Mendocino County Inland Water & Power Commission (IWPC)
Their latest meeting was on the 141h and Dir Ricetti wasn't able to make it to that. There
was some talk about a USGS driven interface between the groundwater and surface water
camps. At the last minute, Sean White was invited and Tamara heard about it and
dutifully informed the other water agencies. So they were the only ones from this area
who attended the meeting.
Farm Bureau -Dr. Eiler gave a presentation about the economic benefits of this area.
California is the lead in pulling the economy of America and the California recovery is
being led by the Bay Area. And when those people get out of the city, they come to
places like Mendocino County. So his talk didn't focus so much on water but on the
tourism potential and development of this area.
USGS Meeting -GM Koehler went to the USGS interface meeting and it's not the same as
SGMA. It's similar, but it's not the same. The biggest problem is that they are not
reaching out to the people who are to be affected by this. GM Koehler had to ask for an
invitation and even then, he almost missed the meeting as did any representative of
Mendocino County.
After that meeting, he met with Paul Minasian, our water rights lawyer. It'd be a good
idea to have a meeting with Redwood, Millview, and Paul together. The biggest concern
is that the Masonite diversion water right may not be worth anything. The next concern is
working with Masonite Well 6. It may not be able to be transferred to Redwood Valley
under the restrictions of what recharges Well 6. These are some of the things that the
SGMA is dealing with.
Something that is brought up related to a side comment is that GM Koehler and his
immediate staff have been putting in a lot more work because of the merging of
workforces. To this end, the Board needs to talk about pay. It is agreed to discuss this
next month.
13. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement
District (RRFC)
Dir Poole reports that Judi Hatch and Richard Shoemaker have left the RRFC Board.
*The recording ends here at approximately 7:28pm, likely due to batteries, cutting
off approximately 15 minutes of the meeting.*
14. Sonoma County Water Agency
Nothing to report.
15. Report of Attendance at Agency Meetings
Discussed earlier under Item 12.
16. State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB)
Discussed earlier under Item 12.
17. Status Report of Place of Use Issues
Discussed earlier under Item 12.
18. Status Report of 2800 acre-feet Storage Right.
Discussed earlier under Item 12.
19. Consider Attendance at Other
Nothing to report.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Talso, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 7:45 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved: Board of Directors
Date Approved: '` l
Signed: / F
6