HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016-03-17 RVCWD MinutesRedwood Valley County Water District
2370 Webb Ranch Road
Redwood Valley, CA 95470
(707)485-0679
Minutes
Board of Directors - Regular Meeting
Thursday, March 17, 2016
Directors: Granville Pool, Pamela Ricetti, Ken Todd, Jeff Basili, Mary Talso
Staff: General Manager Bill Koehler
Call To Order: 6:05 P.M.
1. Roll Call
Present:
Granville Pool, President
Pamela Ricetti, Director
Jeff Basili, Director
Mary Talso, Director
Ken Todd, Director
2. Hearing of Comments or Questions from the Attending Public for Items Not on the
Agenda
Someone from the public asks about what are action items and if we will be discussing
Item 17. The Board confirms that they will be touching on it and will move that item up
for her convenience.
3. Consider Hearing of Urgent Items Received Since the Agenda Was Posted
None.
4. Acceptance of Agenda
Motion: Accept the agenda and move Item 17 to the front
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
17. Status Report of Place of Use Issue
GM Koehler has provided a letter to the Board from Darin Tran from the State Water
Board. We've been talking with him to work on the place of use and they have said they
won't unless they can work with it and the petition for the change of time of beneficial
use along with a reference to the highest water use Redwood has had (which is lower than
our potential). It wasn't a good deal, so we've walked away from it for the time being.
*Tamara Alaniz, the new general manager for Russian River Flood Control joins the
meeting*
So Darin has reached out to Redwood to ask about the status of things. GM Koehler
reached out to Paul Minasian, our water rights attorney, to find out what to do with this.
Paul responded with a draft of the letter now presented to the Board. GM Koehler is
asking the Board for permission to send this letter.
The place of use and time of beneficial use are two different issues, submitted at different
times, and with different petition numbers assigned to them. Dir Todd asks why the State
wants to lump them together and GM Koehler says he doesn't really know. Dir Ricetti
speculates that it's bureaucracy. GM Koehler says that we wouldn't be there at all if
Redwood Rancheria wasn't in danger because of the place of use issue, as the State has
sent letters to Redwood before telling them to shut off the Rancheria. Dir Ricetti asks if
Chris Burg, someone who knows about SB 88, would be helpful in this situation. GM
Koehler says that probably nobody could help in this case. This letter basically tells the
State that if they want to sit on their hands on this one, go for it.
A member of the public speaks up and says that Indian Health Service (IHS) is the
responsible federal agency but they do not speak for the R.V. Rancheria nor do they
make decisions for the tribe. The tribe has asked for follow-up information and the only
thing they've got is that they should just let it sit. But they want this issue resolved as the
tribe is concerned that at any time they could be cut off. They also want some funds for
test drilling for a well and they want it clear that it would be a supplemental water source.
She would like to make it clear that speaking with IHS is not the same as dealing with the
tribe. Dir Ricetti asks if she disagrees with the letter. The woman responds that she
doesn't necessarily disagree, but that the tribe needs to be in on this discussion since it
greatly impacts them. GM Koehler suggests that he start to deal directly with the tribe on
this issue. The Board agrees. She agrees and says that they have a tribal meeting on
Sunday and they'll discuss the letter at that time. It's agreed by all parties and the tribal
representatives leave.
There's more talk about why the State is making things so hard. LAFCo has set the
Redwood district boundaries and the State disagrees.
5. Approval of Consent Calendar
Dir Ricetti has a question about payroll: since we're sharing now, are the work guys
breaking out how much time they spend in each district? GM Koehler says that they do
not. They want to keep the paperwork low, so they created a flat payment system.
Yesterday, they had all six guys loading tip the filter and other days they only have one
guy for a few hours. Dir Todd asks how those rates were figured and GM Koehler says
it's based on averages from many years. Right now, we may not be getting as much time
as other districts but when/if the plant starts operating in June, that will change quickly.
The other districts are having a problem figuring this out, too, so he'll have to sit down
with Dave Redding to get more details figured out. Right now, Redwood is paying
$19,000 to Willow minus the $6,500 that Millview is paying for GM Koehler's time.
Right now, Willow is making money out of this deal. That's not a problem if they realize
that they're building a buffer for when more time is spent elsewhere and that they plan on
hiring a new person. The plan has been to get a few months into this maintenance
2
agreement and then look at things and see how they're working. Dir Pool agrees on that
plan and adds that even a few months may not be enough. He also adds that if Willow
doesn't hire and the workload increases, they'd lose that extra money paying overtime.
Dir Ricetti says that she thinks there could be a system that will track their time at each
districts' facilities. A lot of times with these kinds of systems, people can get unhappy.
GM Koehler says that the lines of communication are good enough that it probably won't
happen. Dir Pool agrees. Dir Todd notices that we pumped 12 acre-feet in February. He
was wondering if we can do more. GM Koehler says we have a limit on what we can take
and when. Even with the massive flows in the river, it's hard to remove water under our
right because "not enough" water is flowing.
Motion: Approve the February consent calendar
Motion by Dir Todd, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
6. Approval of Minutes as Presented
Dir Pool points out a few typos. On the last page, Millview is the one working on buying
part of the Masonite property. Dir Talso asks if valve exercising is a requirement and GM
Koehler says that it is and has been for some time, though most small districts don't do it.
Having a machine will put us in compliance and also motivate Willow to hire another
person. Dir Basili says that good valves are wonderful in the event of a leak where you
need to shut down the water flow quickly. Dir Pool adds that if questions come up while
moving though the minutes, this is a good time to talk about them.
Motion: Accept the February Regular Meeting minutes as corrected.
Motion by Dir Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
7. Directors and Staff Reports and Discussion of Non -Action Topics
This item has been a place -holder for some time and it is probably time to remove it.
8. General Manager's Report and Action Items
a. District Operations
Things are going wonderfully. We've had several comments from people who
have noticed the consolidation and no complaints.
b.SCADA
The new system is $200,000 and TelStar is going to provide a more detailed
proposal soon. Obviously, it will be much cheaper to do the change -over while
the plant is off.
c. Pipe Inspection
GM Koehler contacted Sonoma County Water Agency, who uses the same pipe
that we use. The acoustic evaluation would look at 10 sites for $15,000, which
isn't much good at all, since it would only look 20 feet up- and down -stream from
each site: (SCWA would have to spend $400,000 to inspect their pipes). It's
much cheaper to just fix leaks as they happen than to survey the whole system.
Dir Basili says the City of Ukiah uses a unit like this and it works really well. GM
Koehler says that it would work well in town, where there are lots of valves. Our
pipeline in question is 5-miles without a valve. It's been broken twice so far and
both of those were under extreme circumstances.
e. Tank Repair
The tank is done as of this morning. They'll be coming back for a final inspection
and if they find anything, they'll do a touch-up. GM Koehler says they did a
really nice job of not only fixing the problem but making sure it won't happen
again.
Action Item
1. Allocation Refund Request
The Vineyard Oaks property has sold and it has six meters allocated to it. They've
been paying a monthly fee on meters that were never installed because of the
moratorium. Most people who have allocations are just holding on to them, but on
this one, the time is up since he sold the property. So now the previous owner
wants to be paid back for the money he spent keeping those meters in reserve.
Since 1989, this has come to about $10,000. The previous owner had planned on
subdividing the lot and since he couldn't, he had to sell the property at a loss.
There are a lot of other situations like this out there, so we need to be careful
about what kind of precedent we set. He's also decided that he doesn't want to
take action on this item tonight, since he doesn't have all the information he needs
to make a good decision. This has been a bad situation for 30 years and various
GMs have tried to straighten things out.
Dir Ricetti asks if the moratorium is a good defense in this case. GM Koehler says
that this is a bigger discussion than what we can have here tonight.
9. Financial Report
Dir Todd asks about the insurance. GM Koehler says he doesn't have the answer yet, but
he had planned to have it ready tonight. He'll get it by next month, along with a total
evaluation of how things have changed with the overall staff changes. There is some
website talk.
Motion: Approve the February Financial Report
Motion by Dir Talso, second by Dir Todd
In favor: Unanimous
10. JPA — Upper Russian River Water Agency
There was no meeting this month.
11. Local Agency Formation Commission of Mendocino County (LAFCo)
Nothing to report.
4
12. Mendocino County Inland Water & Power Commission (IWPC)
Dir Basili went to this meeting and there isn't much to report. It looks like the state over-
promised the SGMA grant money, so they probably won't be able pay for a facilitator.
They may be able to get a little bit, but there are no promises. The program for fighting
the mussels is moving along. A few years ago, Sonoma County and Russian River Flood
Control both filed for grants to fight the mussels, but they were denied because the Army
Corps is the owner and they don't file for grants. So it just fizzled away.
Dir. Todd questioned RRFC GM Alaniz regarding frost water use reporting.
Now, you're supposed to report 6pm the night before if you anticipate the need for frost
water. Dir Todd asks why this is required; it doesn't have any effect on anything. GM
Alaniz agrees that it doesn't help anything. She also says that the State is trying to stop
any effects on the river that decrease the river level by 0.1 feet over an undisclosed time
period, which is arbitrary and could happen naturally anyway. GM Koehler says that a
vineyard owner created a large report that showed how frost events actually raise the
level of the river in the west branch and that report was promptly buried by the regulatory
agencies.
13. Mendocino County Russian River Flood Control & Water Conservation Improvement
District (RRFC)
RRFC has 7,045 acre-feet of water under contract which is a little better than last year.
Unless something drastic happens, we'll do what we did last year where we run drinking
water through the intertie and Ag water from the Lake. GM Koehler also liked Tamara's
mission statement and other goals, specifically in the way RRFC will work with
Redwood. Redwood is a very good customer to RRFC in bringing them income. She also
had the goals of consolidating the local water agencies, which is a good goal but RRFC
won't be the one facilitating it or controlling it. Dir Todd asks how much water was used
last year under RRFC contracts. She says she doesn't have the numbers yet, but she's
working on it. Dir Todd asks her about the 800 of we got from Ukiah last year and if that
could work out again this year. GM Koehler responds that we actually got 400af.
currently there's nothing in the works so far, but they'd have to wait for July until it
would come up. He also asks her if she can do a mid -year analysis of how much water
has been used and if there can be some adjustments at that point, such as if someone
doesn't use frost water in the spring. She says that this a more of an umbrella question as
to how the contracts are managed, that is, how does RRFC decide if contracts are
reasonable or if someone is hoarding water. It would be a long process to make any
changes since some contracts are over very long terms but it's something that will need to
be and will be addressed in the coming years. It's hard because Sonoma County Water
Agency and the Army Corps control the release of water from the Lake, not RRFC.
GM Koehler explains that Redwood has asked questions about water usage policies by
RRFC in the past and RRFC has not been willing to talk about it. He hopes things can
change and Tamara says that she agrees that things need to change. She says there is
some ambiguity with the tenure of two of their members and they're hoping for
5
appointments from the remaining Board members because a special election is very
expensive.
Tamara is also putting forward a system for bringing in Board members for RRFC. A few
names are brought up for potential replacements of the RRFC Board and there are some
good prospects.
14. Sonoma County Water Agency
Nothing to report.
15. Report of Attendance at Agency Meetings
Nothing to report.
16. State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB)
Covered earlier under Item 17.
17. Status Report of Place of Use Issues
Discussed earlier.
18. Status Report of 2800 acre-feet Storage Right.
Discussed earlier under Item 17.
19. Consider Attendance at Other Meetings
There was a training on the Brown Act. Some of the Board members attended and some
didn't need to. So it seems that everyone is current. There's another training that covers
Special District laws and the Brown Act, so it'd be good for people to attend the legal
part.
Unrelated to training, this asbestos litigation stuff is not going away. Today they
rescheduled for next Tuesday, `they' being the three law firms involved. Kit Elliott with
County Counsel will be working with Redwood on this and she's setting the rules for the
meeting. She is being paid for her time, so it will cost Redwood something, but it's a
whole lot better than any private attorney.
Motion to adjourn.
Motion by Ricetti, second by Dir Basili
In favor: Unanimous
Meeting adjourned at 7:30 pm.
Minutes submitted by Jeanette Wise
Approved:
Date Approved
Signed: