Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-01-28 Packet - Special Meeting - Councilmember ANominationPage 1 of 2 City Council Special Meeting AGENDA The Ukiah City Council Regular Meeting will be held virtually at: https://attendee.gotowebinar.com/register/3920990818524399888 After registering, you will receive a confirmation email containing information about joining  the webinar. Alternatively, you may view the meeting (without participating) by clicking on the  name of the meeting at www.cityofukiah.com/meetings.  January 28, 2021 ­ 6:00 PM 1. ROLL CALL AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE     2. AUDIENCE COMMENTS ON NON­AGENDA ITEMS       The City Council welcomes input from the audience. If there is a matter of business on the agenda that you are interested in,  you may address the Council when this matter is considered. If you wish to speak on a matter that is not on this agenda, you  may do so at this time. In order for everyone to be heard, please limit your comments to three (3) minutes per person and not  more than ten (10) minutes per subject. The Brown Act regulations do not allow action to be taken on audience comments in  which the subject is not listed on the agenda.     3. NEW BUSINESS      3.a. Discussion and Possible Action to Fill the Vacant Council Seat for the Unexpired Term of  Departed Councilmember Maureen Mulheren.    Recommended Action: Review the applications received, hold  a discussion and question  applicants if necessary, nominate and appoint one of the applicants to fill the unexpired term of  former Councilmember Maureen Mulheren.      Attachments:  1.Application of Mari Rodin 2.Application of Joel Veikko Soinila 3.Application of Stephen G. Scalmanini 4.Application of Jason Howard 5.Application of Michelle Johnson 6.Application of Jeff Trouette 7.Application of Susan Sher 8.Application of Cameron Ramos       Page 1 of 141 Page 2 of 2 4. ADJOURNMENT     Please be advised that the City needs to be notified 72 hours in advance of a meeting if any specific  accommodations or interpreter services are needed in order for you to attend.  The City complies with ADA  requirements and will attempt to reasonably accommodate individuals with disabilities upon request.  Materials  related to an item on this Agenda submitted to the City Council after distribution of the agenda packet are available  for public inspection at the front counter at the Ukiah Civic Center, 300 Seminary Avenue, Ukiah, CA  95482, during  normal business hours, Monday through Friday, 8:00 am to 5:00 pm.   I hereby certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing agenda was  posted on the bulletin board at the main entrance of the City of Ukiah City Hall, located at 300 Seminary Avenue,  Ukiah, California, not less than 24 hours prior to the meeting set forth on this agenda.  Kristine Lawler, City Clerk Dated: 1/21/2021  Page 2 of 141 Page 1 of 3 Agenda Item No: 3.a. MEETING DATE/TIME: 1/28/2021 ITEM NO: 2021-675 AGENDA SUMMARY REPORT SUBJECT: Discussion and Possible Action to Fill the Vacant Council Seat for the Unexpired Term of Departed Councilmember Maureen Mulheren. DEPARTMENT: City Clerk PREPARED BY: Kristine Lawler, City Clerk PRESENTER: ATTACHMENTS: 1. Application of Mari Rodin 2. Application of Joel Veikko Soinila 3. Application of Stephen G. Scalmanini 4. Application of Jason Howard 5. Application of Michelle Johnson 6. Application of Jeff Trouette 7. Application of Susan Sher 8. Application of Cameron Ramos 9. Correspondence Received - Lisa Hillegas - Support for Mari Rodin 10. Correspondence Received - Tom Liden - Support for Jeff Trouette 11. Correspondence Received - Susan Baird Kanaan - Support for Mari Rodin 12. Correspondence Received - Susan Gordon - Support for Mari Rodin 13. Correspondence Received - Armand Brint - Support for Mari Rodin 14. Correspondence Received - James Flaherty - Support for Mari Rodin 15. Correspondence Received - Mary Gustafson - Support for Mari Rodin 16. Correspondence Received - Marya Heath - Support for Mari Rodin 17. Correspondence Received - Paula Martin - Support for Mari Rodin 18. Correspondence Received - Laura Fogg - Support for Mari Rodin 19. Correspondence Received - Rick Ryan - Support for Joel Soinila 20. Correspondence Received - Helen Sizemore - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini 21. Correspondence Received - Katherine McElwee - Support for Mari Rodin 22. Correspondence Received - Marvin Trotter - Support for Mari Rodin 23. Correspondence Received - Martha Barra - Support for Mari Rodin 24. Correspondence Received - Carol Misseldine - Support for Mari Rodin 25. Correspondence Received - Crispin Hollinshead - Support for Steve Scalmanini 26. Correspondence Received - Terry Poplawski - Support for Steve Scalmanini 27. Correspondence Received - David Taxis - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini 28. Correspondence Received - Hafsa Steward - Support for Steve Scalmanini 29. Correspondence Received - Bill Fisette - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini 30. Correspondence Received - Trudy Morgan - Support for Steve Scalmanini and Susan Sher 31. Correspondence Received - Peggy Backup - Support for Steve Scalmanini 32. Correspondence Received - Tony Marsh - Support for Steve Scalmanini 33. Correspondence Received - Lorna Maslenikov - Support for Steve Scalmanini 34. Correspondence Received - Robin Sunbeam - Support for Steve Scalmanini 35. Correspondence Received - Marvin Kramer - Support for Susan Sher 36. Correspondence Received - Sharon Kiichli - Support for Joel Soinila Page 3 of 141 Page 2 of 3 37. Correspondence Received - Karen Lee - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini 38. Correspondence Received - Adina Merenlender - Support for Mari Rodin 39. Correspondence Received - Joann Rosen - Support for Steve Scalmanini 40. Correspondence Received - Bill Taylor - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini 41. Correspondence Received - Judy Luria - Support for Steve Scalmanini, Mari Rodin, and Susan Sher- updated 1-27-21 42. Correspondence Received - Larry Sheehy - Support for Susan Sher 43. Correspondence Received - Jim Robbins - Support for Michelle Johnson 44. Correspondence Received - Nora Sanchez - Support for Mari Rodin 45. Correspondence Received - Rhea Hollis - Support for Michelle Johnson 46. Correspondence Received - Deb Attaway - Support for Mari Rodin 47. Correspondence Received - Ede Morris - Support for Steve Scalmanini 48. Correspondence Received - Ruth Van Antwerp - Support for Steve Scalmanini 49. Correspondence Received - Leslie Kirkpatrick - Support for Susan Sher 50. Correspondence Received - Charlene Light - Support for Steve Scalmanini 51. Correspondence Received - David & Wendy Cram-Beth Thompson-Margee Wesott-Susan Cox - Support for Steve Scalmanini 52. Correspondence Received - Lauren Simmonds - Support for Michelle Johnson 53. Correspondence Received - Rick Seanor - Support for Michelle Johnson 54. Correspondence Received - Sarah Marshall - Support for Mari Rodin 55. Correspondence Received - Cynthia Coale - Support for Mari Rodin 56. Correspondence Received - Jamie Connerton - Support for Jeff Trouette 57. Correspondence Received - Kathy James - Support for Susan Sher 58. Correspondence Received - Jonah Walsh - Support for Michele Johnson 59. Correspondence Received - Chris Wilkes - Support for Michele Johnson 60. Correspondence Received - Pinky Kushner - Support for Steve Scalmanini 61. Correspondence Received - Chuck Williams - Support for Susan Sher 62. Correspondence Received - Andrea Davis - Support for Mari Rodin 63. Correspondence Received - Dorothy Gayle Haas - Support for Susan Sher 64. Correspondence Received - Russell Green - Support for Michelle Johnson 65. Correspondence Received - Jacqueline Lee - Support for Steve Scalmanini 66. Correspondence Received - Linda Helland - Support for Steve Scalmanini 67. Correspondence Received - Kerry Levin - Support for Mari Rodin 68. Correspondence Received - Stephen Groff - Support for Rodin and Scalmanini 69. Correspondence Received - Kathleen Thomas and Luca Szabo - Support for Susan Sher 70. Correspondence Received - Eileen Mitro - Support for Steve Scalmanini and Mari Rodin and Susan Sher 71. Correspondence Received - Cathy Anello - Support for Michelle Johnson Summary: Council members will review the applications received, hold a discussion and question the applicants if necessary, and possibly nominate and appoint one of the applicants to fill the unexpired term of former Councilmember Maureen Mulheren. Background: In December, 2020, Maureen Mulheren submitted her resignation on the City Council in order to take her new position on the Mendocino County Board of Supervisors, effective January 4, 2021. On December 16, 2021, the remaining Councilmembers directed the City Clerk’s office to notice the vacancy and accept applications to be reviewed at a special council meeting on January 28, 2021. The Clerk’s office received eight applications from Mari Rodin, Joel Veikko Soinila, Stephen G. Scalmanini, Jason Howard, Michelle Johnson, Jeff Trouette, Susan Sher, and Cameron Ramos (Attachments 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 , and 8 respectively). Discussion: A special city council meeting will be held virtually on January 28, 2021, at 6:00 p.m. for the Council to review the applications and interview the candidates. The Mayor will provide each candidate the opportunity to make a three minute opening statement. At the Page 4 of 141 Page 3 of 3 conclusion of all the statements, Council can hold a discussion, which may include specific follow up questions directed to any of the candidates. Subsequent to the discussion a nomination can be made and seconded, to which the Council can hold a vote for appointment. The successfully appointed candidate will be administered an Oath of Office and take seat at the beginning of the February 3, 2021, City Council meeting. The newly appointed Councilmember will fill the unexpired term of former Councilmember Mulheren, with the term expiring with the General Municipal election in 2022. Recommended Action: Review the applications received, hold a discussion and question applicants if necessary, nominate and appoint one of the applicants to fill the unexpired term of former Councilmember Maureen Mulheren. BUDGET AMENDMENT REQUIRED: N/A CURRENT BUDGET AMOUNT: N/A PROPOSED BUDGET AMOUNT: N/A FINANCING SOURCE: N/A PREVIOUS CONTRACT/PURCHASE ORDER NO.: N/A COORDINATED WITH: N/A Page 5 of 141 ATTACHMENT 1 Page 6 of 141 Page 7 of 141 Page 8 of 141 Page 9 of 141 Page 10 of 141 Page 11 of 141 Page 12 of 141 Page 13 of 141 Page 14 of 141 ATTACHMENT 2 Page 15 of 141 Page 16 of 141 Page 17 of 141 Page 18 of 141 Page 19 of 141 Page 20 of 141 Page 21 of 141 Page 22 of 141 ATTACHMENT 3 Page 23 of 141 Page 24 of 141 Page 25 of 141 Page 26 of 141 Page 27 of 141 Page 28 of 141 Page 29 of 141 Jason Howard January 20, 2021 Kristine Lawler City Clerk City Of Ukiah 300 Seminary Ave. Ukiah, CA 95482707 Kristine & City Council members, I am applying for the Ukiah City Council position left vacant due to Mo Mulheren winning a seat on the Mendocino County Board Of Supervisors. I have lived and worked in Ukiah since 1992. I moved here for a job at a local radio station, 103.3 KUKI. I am currently the Program Director for 94.5 K-WiNE and 93.5 MAX radio stations. Through my near three decades in local Mendocino County radio, I have had the pleasure of meeting many residents and business owners. I’ve listened to many different opinions about life in Ukiah, covering topics of recreation, quality of life, education, economics, housing, local government and more. My wife, Judy, and I also own a local business, SHAG Salon & Beauty Supply at 633 South Main Street in Ukiah. There we have had the pleasure of meeting many of our fellow Ukiah residents. We have sponsored local community events and fundraisers of all kinds while attempting to make a living. During my years in local radio, I have been a part of local fundraisers and events supporting a variety of local non-profits. I created, organized and ran a Warm Winter Coat Drive, in conjunction with the local McDonald’s restaurants, for several years during the 1990s. We gathered near one thousand coats each winter, all of which were distributed to local families, homeless, and anyone in need. I’ve worked with the local CHP to bring awareness to the dangers of drinking and driving. Through both, the radio stations I have worked for, as well as my wife’s business, I have organized promotional events raising money, and other donations, for several local organizations. I have also spent several years selling advertising, and putting together marketing campaigns for local businesses. This has given me the opportunity to hear what other business owners are feeling, in regard to doing business in Ukiah. It is all these years of interactions with a broad swath of local residents and business owners that, I believe, gives me a unique perspective of our community. Too often, people only see what is in front of them; what directly affects them and their families. I’ve had the privilege of seeing beyond my own backyard, so to speak. I also pride myself on being open minded, always willing to have that uncomfortable conversation that many will not. I want to hear different opinions. I want to be challenged. This is how we grow and become better people. This mindset and the previously mentioned experiences I have had living in Ukiah, make me an ideal candidate for a seat on the Ukiah City Council. Thank you for your time and consideration. Kind regards, Jason Howard ATTACHMENT 4 Page 30 of 141 Office of the City Clerk 6HPLQDU\$YHQXH 8NLDK,CA9 APPLICATION FOR VACANT CITY COUNCIL POSITION (Application must be submitted by Noon on -DQXDU\, 20) NAME: Last First Middle STREET ADDRESS: CITY: STATE: ZIP CODE: Contact Information: PHONE: Home Work/Cell E-mail 1. Attach a resume outlining your educational background and experience. 2.Attach an applicant statement (400-500 words) describing why you should be selected to fill this vacant position. Yes No +DYH\RXHYHUVHUYHGRQDSXEOLFSULYDWHRUQRQSURILW%RDUG&RPPLWWHH &RPPLVVLRQRU7DVN)RUFH",I\HVSOHDVHVSHFLI\EHORZ Name Length of Service Using no more than the space provided, highlight your relevant knowledge or skills that you will bring to the City CouQFLO  &RPSOHWHDOOTXHVWLRQVRQWKLVDSSOLFDWLRQ 4BMBSZQFSNPOUI)FBMUI#FOFGJUTQFSNPOUI &TUJNBUFE.POUIMZ5JNF$PNNJUUNFOUIPVST Howard Jason William Ukiah CA 95482 As a local radio personality since 1992, I have been in direct contact with members of the community daily, hearing opinions, meeting and seeing the diversity amongst us, and generally getting to know residents. I believe this has given me at least some insight as to what the community wants and needs. As a local business owner, I also experience both the good and bad in community policy that directly affects small business owners. ✔ Page 31 of 141 Office of the City Clerk Application for Vacant City Council Position City Council Appointment Applicant Questionnaire Please Limit Your Answers to the Following Questions to no more than 250 words 1.:KDWGR\RXEHOLHYHLVWKHUROHRIWKH&LW\&RXQFLODQGWKHGXWLHVRI&RXQFLOPHPEHUV" 2. What do you consider to be the top 3 to 5 significant issues/priorities currently facing the City of 8NLDK and why are they the most significant? What are your thoughts abouthow to address these issues? 3. Name a specific City of 8NLDK issue of special interest to you (other than the issue described in your response to question #2. Tell us what suggestions you have for addressing it. The City Council is, to some extent, the legislative body of the city, setting policy, overseeing budgets and the city's administrative officers. It is the City Councils job to look out for the best interests of the city as a whole, and its residents. The individual council members contribute their unique and individual experience and perspective to the overall council, helping make decisions and set policy that represents the diversity of the community members. The homeless situation: we need to evaluate the services being provided to see where changes are needed. We need to more closely regulate who has access to these services as well. We also need more affordable housing for low and middle income individuals and families. Economic growth: many small businesses are struggling due to the pandemic. We need to look at ways to ease the financial burdens on small businesses. Disaster/Fire preparedness: with fires devastating communities/forests in recent years, we need to take extra steps to be prepared, including pushing residents co clean up properties littered with junk that is a fire hazard, as well as an obstacle to combat a fire, if one occurs. We also need a community wide evacuation plan, just in case the unthinkable happens. The streets of Ukiah are crumbling and in horrible shape. We need to look at the budget and monies available to repair our roads. Where are the tax dollars from measures Y being spent, and can they be better managed to achieve the goal they were meant for. Page 32 of 141 4. What do you believe is the most important contribution you can make as a member of the City Council? What strength do you think you would bring to the City Council team? 5. Give an example of how you would resolve a situation where your personal philosophy is at odds with what is best for the City. 6. Please share your thoughts on the following topics related to the City of 8NLDK: a. Public Safety b. City Infrastructure Each council member brings their unique experience and perspective to the table, and I believe my experience as a voice of the community for the last 29 years, brings a valuable perspective, that has been influenced by decades of interaction and communication with a broad range of the population. As far as strengths, I am a very open minded, yet direct, no-nonsense moderate looking to bring more balance to the council. This country was founded on the premise of being governed by the people, for the people. "For the people" is key. As a public servant, I believe it is absolutely imperative to not let personal philosophy dictate public policy. I will always speak my mind, and share my opinion, but ultimately, all decisions must be made with the City and its residents, all of its residents, in mind. I'm not interested in vanity projects, or trying to force my will on anyone.Forme,itis about representing other like minded citizens, but always doing what is right for the greater good of the whole community. I think the largest detriment to Public Safety in Ukiah is the homeless situation and the related drug and crime problems that go along with it (ie.: needles left on the ground, overdoses, theft, etc.). I know this an ongoing issue that has been addressed in a variety of ways; yet the problem is just getting worse. I think the City is in a good place, for the most part, other than our roadways. Page 33 of 141 c. Economic Development d. Quality of Life Factors e. City Finances f. Sustainability/Smart Growth Supporting small businesses is the key. I am aware that there are already programs in place to support small business and promote shopping local, but I think we need to dig deeper, so to speak, and find new ways to really connect with the younger Ukiah residents and get them focused on supporting local business. This is one of my favorite aspects of living in Ukiah. Quality of life is good here, however, we really need more affordable housing. And not just low income, but for middle class families as well. Anything close to affordable, is usually dumpy; and anything nice, costs a fortune. There does not seem to be a happy medium here. We need to cut the fluff, tighten our belts and make sure every dollar is accounted for and well spent. Nurturing small businesses, adopting green technology, and well structured growth are the keys. Page 34 of 141 7.,VWKHUHDQ\WKLQJWKDW\RXZRXOGOLNHWRDGG" I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that I am a resident of the City of 8NLDK California, registered to vote in the City of 8NLDK, and that all information stated in this application and all attached pages are true, correct and complete. I also acknowledge that if appointed, I will be subject to filing a Form 700 Statement of Economic Interest. Signature of Applicant Date  Please submit this application and supporting documentation to the 8NLDK City Clerk’s Office by noon on 7KXUVGD\,-DQXDU\, 20. Applications received by the City will become publicrecords thDWZLOO be subject to public disclosure. Except for the name of the applicant, the City will treat applications as confidential to the extent allowed by law until the close of the application deadline. &LW\RI8NLDK $771 &LW\&OHUN 6HPLQDU\$YH 8NLDK,CA9 For office use only: Staff has verified that the applicant is a registered voter in the City of 8NLDK 'XHWR&29,'UHVWULFWLRQVSOHDVHGURSDSSOLFDWLRQRIIDWWKHGURSER[ORFDWHGDW&OD\6W,I\RXKDYH DQ\TXHVWLRQV\RXPD\FDOOWKH&LW\&OHUN.ULVWLQH/DZOHUDWRUHPDLONODZOHU#FLW\RIXNLDKFRP I love the idea of being involved with local government to help guide Ukiah to a strong, healthy future for all who live here. Digitally signed by Jason Howard Date: 2021.01.19 12:13:37 -08'00'01/20/2021 Page 35 of 141 JASON HOWARD I have over 30 years experience in Radio Broadcasting, Audio Production, and Sales & Marketing. WORK EXPERIENCE Program Director/On-Air Personality 05 /2012 to Present Broadcasting Corporation Of Mendocino County 110 Hastings Road, Suite B, Ukiah, CA 95482 I am the Morning Drive on-air personality and Program Director overseeing/managing all on-air personalities, production, music selection, and I am generally responsible for anything and everything that goes on-air at the radio station. I am also the Production Director responsible for all audio/commercial ad production, including managing/directing staff involved with production. I handle all Public Service Announcements, too. I am responsible for a variety of documentation and record keeping to meet all programming requirements for the FCC. Sales Manager 04 /2004 to 04/2012 Flashfire Advertising Ukiah, CA Radio, television, and print advertising sales and production. Responsible for all sales and creative for advertising campaigns for local businesses. Script writing, print ad/graphic design, and audio and video production of ads. Promotions Director/On-Air Personality 04 /1992 to 04/2004 Ukiah Broadcasting Corporation 1400 KUKI Lane, Ukiah, CA 95482 Responsible for creating, implementing, and managing on and off air promotions for the radio station with an emphasis on generating customer exposure and revenue for both the station and all sponsors. Responsible for station branding and promotion of brand. Managing staff for promotional events and fundraisers. Audio production. SKILLS Promotions & Marketing -10+ years Event Management -10+ years Effective Communication -10+ years Page 36 of 141 EDUCATION National Broadcasting School Broadcasting/Audio Production Sacramento, CA 1989 to 1989 Sierra College General Education Roseville, CA 08 /1987 to 06/1989 Page 37 of 141 Applicant Statement City of Ukiah Council Member 2021 My name is Michelle Johnson, and I have been an active community member within the City of Ukiah for over 13 years. I have had the opportunity to engage with the community from the perspective of a mother, coach, volunteer, board/committee member, student, spin instructor, waitress, tasting room manager, event hostess, and, most recently, a public servant. I educated myself as a single mom of five active children while working three jobs on a mission to obtain the knowledge I needed to leave this planet better than I found it and demonstrate to my children I could do it. I ultimately graduated with a double major in Economics and Land Use Planning and have had the opportunity to use my education as a Land Use Planner for the City of Ukiah, City of Novato, and the City of Willits. I left my career in the wine industry because I felt a void that I was not doing my part to make our world a better place to live for my children. I became an Urban Planner because it was a tool I could use to create the change needed to build better, sustainable communities. It didn't take long before realizing the power behind the change didn't come from city staff. It came from the direction of our elected officials. That is why I am running for City Council, so as a member, I can have the privilege of working on behalf of my community to listen, collaborate, problem-solve, communicate and deliver the change needed to enhance the quality of life for all of the community and leave the community better than when I started. ATTACHMENT 5 Page 38 of 141 Office of the City Clerk 300 Seminary Avenue Ukiah, CA 95482 APPLICATION FOR VACANT CITY COUNCIL POSITION (Application must be submitted by Noon on January 21, 2021) NAME: Last First Middle STREET ADDRESS: CITY: STATE: ZIP CODE: Contact Information: PHONE: Home Work/Cell E-mail 1.Attach a resume outlining your educational background and experience. 2.Attach an applicant statement (400-500 words) describing why you should be selected to fill this vacant position. Yes No Have you ever served on a public, private, or non-profit Board, Committee, Commission, or Task Force? If yes, please specify below: Name Length of Service Using no more than the space provided, highlight your relevant knowledge or skills that you will bring to the City Council. 3. Complete all questions on this application. Salary: $490 per month; Health Benefits: $837 per month Estimated Monthly Time Committment: 25-35 hours Page 39 of 141 Office of the City Clerk Application for Vacant City Council Position City Council Appointment Applicant Questionnaire Please Limit Your Answers to the Following Questions to no more than 250 words 1.What do you believe is the role of the City Council, and the duties of Councilmembers? 2.What do you consider to be the top 3 to 5 significant issues/priorities currently facing the City of Ukiah and why are they the most significant? What are your thoughts about how to address these issues? 3.Name a specific City of Ukiah issue of special interest to you (other than the issue described in your response to question #2. Tell us what suggestions you have for addressing it. Page 40 of 141 4.What do you believe is the most important contribution you can make as a member of the City Council? What strength do you think you would bring to the City Council team? 5.Give an example of how you would resolve a situation where your personal philosophy is at odds with what is best for the City. 6.Please share your thoughts on the following topics related to the City of Ukiah: a.Public Safety b.City Infrastructure Page 41 of 141 c.Economic Development d.Quality of Life Factors e.City Finances f.Sustainability/Smart Growth Page 42 of 141 7.Is there anything that you would like to add? I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that I am a resident of the City of Ukiah California, registered to vote in the City of Ukiah, and that all information stated in this application and all attached pages are true, correct and complete. I also acknowledge that if appointed, I will be subject to filing a Form 700 Statement of Economic Interest. Signature of Applicant Date Please submit this application and supporting documentation to the Ukiah City Clerk’s Office* by noon on Thursday, January 21, 2020. Applications received by the City will become public recordsthat will be subject to public disclosure. Except for the name of the applicant, the City will treatapplications as confidential to the extent allowed by law until the close of the application deadline. City of Ukiah ATTN: City Clerk 300 Seminary Ave Ukiah, CA 95482 For office use only: Staff has verified that the applicant is a registered voter in the City of Ukiah *Due to COVID restrictions, please drop application off at the drop box located at 411 Clay St. If you have any questions, you may call the City Clerk, Kristine Lawler, at 707-463-6217, or email klawler@cityofukiah.com Page 43 of 141 MICHELLE JOHNSON Phone: Ukiah, CA 95482 Email: Graduate of Sonoma State University with a double major in land use planning and economics with more than six years’ of experience assisting professionals and the community in complex land use and environmental planning projects. In addition to six years of experience in land use and environmental planning, also have experience in the private sector marketing, branding and increasing brand awareness and product sales in the wine industry. Experienced in project management, CEQA and land use practices with the ability to navigate internal and external politics to achieve department goals and objectives. Team leader with demonstrated success multi -tasking, prioritizing work, and managing time to meet deadlines. Skilled at cultivating exceptional working relationships. Seek to obtain assistant management position where I can contribute to the success of an organization through excellent service, innovation, experience and teamwork. Areas of Expertise ▪Report Generation ▪Document Management ▪Public Hearing Coordination ▪Public Inquiries Resolution ▪Budgeting ▪Plan Review ▪City Planning Principles ▪Customer Service ▪Statistical Reports/Analysis ▪Administrative Planning ▪Current & Long Range Planning ▪Client Communication ▪Public Outreach ▪Land Use Development ▪Sales ▪Discretionary Permitting ▪Community Liaison ▪Marketing ▪Feasibility Studies ▪Presentations ▪Social Media ▪Cannabis Permitting Professional Experience CITY OF WILLITS, WILLITS, CA 2018 – Present ASSISTANT PLANNER •Performs a variety of professional current and long range planning duties, including day to day administration of planning ordinances, project environmental review, and preparation of technical reports; performs skilled work in the investigation, inspection and enforcement of City codes; performs related work as assigned. Identify the elements of project design and construction likely to produce constructability issues and plan coordination problems prior to beginning construction of the project. Research, analyze and interpret social, economic, population and land use data and trends; prepare written reports on various planning matters and elements of the general plan. ▪Review development proposals and other requests made to the Community Development Department for conformance with appropriate regulations; prepare reports and make recommendations. ▪Prepares planning reports and develops agenda material for Planning Commission and City Council meetings. ▪Collects and records land use data, and prepares base maps, zoning maps, charts, and graphs. ▪Conducts follow-up procedures including the preparation of additional correspondence, site visits, communication with complainants, attorneys, and property owners involved in code violation cases. ▪Prepares required documentation for legal actions and conducts follow-up once legal activities have been initiated; appears in court as a City representative. ▪Confers with planning, building, and other staff, and the City Attorney regarding complaints to clarify interpretation of the law and procedures to be followed, particularly those referred for prosecution. ▪Manages Cannabis Activity Permits from submittal to approval, maintenance of the annual requirements. ▪Interpret and explain plans and contract terms to administrative staff, subcontractors, andPage 44 of 141 clients. ▪ Coordinate the efforts of all parties involved in the project, which include clients, architects, consultants, subcontractors and laborers. ▪ Maintain strict adherence to the budgetary guidelines, quality and safety standards. ▪ Daily inspection of construction site to monitor compliance with building and safety codes, and other applicable regulations. ▪ Manage Business Licenses ▪ Update State Annual Housing Report CITY OF NOVATO, NOVATO, CA 2017 – 2018 PLANNER ll Work involves responsibility for the application of professional knowledge and skills to various municipal planning problems and projects. Responsibilities include the preparation of specific reports and plans with opportunity for independent judgment in planning work details and making technical determinations. Research, analyze and interpret social, economic, population and land use data and trends; prepare written reports on various planning matters and elements of the general plan. ▪ Prepare initial studies and assist in preparing or reviewing environmental impact reports. ▪ Compile information and make recommendations on special studies; prepare planning reports. ▪ Review development proposals and work with developers to reach agreement on acceptable site plans; review various development applications for compliance with appropriate regulations and policies, and prepare reports of recommendations. ▪ Prepare and present staff reports for the Planning Commission, various committees and advisory boards as directed. ▪ Check commercial, industrial and residential development plans for issuance of zone clearance; process permit applications; review permit applications, business licenses and home occupation permits. ▪ Inspect properties and structures for compliance with current City zoning codes and regulations; recommend improvements; identify corrective actions to be taken by owner. ▪ Research and draft ordinances for review. ▪ Confer with and advise architects, builders, attorneys, contractors, engineers, and the general public regarding City development policies and standards. ▪ Respond to and resolve difficult citizen inquiries and complaints regarding the City's planning function. CITY OF UKIAH, UKIAH, CA 2016 – 2016 ASSOCIATE PLANNER Under general direction of the Director of Planning, the Associate Planner performs both current and long-range planning duties, including project review and zoning administration, as well as General Plan implementation; assists the public in matters pertaining to planning in the City of Ukiah; and performs related work as assigned. ▪ Respond to public inquiries received by telephone or personal contact in matters pertaining to planning, zoning, and related policies. ▪ Interpret and apply the City Zoning Ordinances in reviewing and analyzing development proposals and in replying to public inquiries. ▪ Assist the City's Code Enforcement Officer in interpreting the Zoning Code and recognizing and resolving code violations in the field. ▪ Process current planning applications, and evaluate plans and projects for code compliance and design considerations. ▪ Prepare planning reports and develop agenda material for Planning Commission meetings. ▪ Conduct Initial Studies and prepare basic environmental documents (Exemptions, Negative Declarations, etc.) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). ▪ Collect and record land use data and prepare base maps, zoning maps, charts, and graphs. ▪ Make oral presentations to the Planning Commission on a routine basis regarding planning matters and projects, and occasionally address planning issues or projects at City Council meetings. ▪ Coordinate with other City departments and other governmental agencies on planning issues and projects. Page 45 of 141 CITY OF UKIAH, UKIAH, CA 2014 – 2016 ASSISTANT PLANNER Performs a variety of duties related to the collection, analysis, interpretation, and presentation of technical land use, environmental, zoning and other City planning data; ensures compliance with the City’s development standards that include the following: ▪ Process current planning applications, and evaluate plans and projects for code compliance and design considerations. ▪ Prepare planning reports and develop agenda material for Planning Commission meetings. ▪ Conduct Initial Studies and prepare basic environmental documents (Exemptions, Negative Declarations, etc.) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). ▪ Conduct land use studies and compile data and information pertaining to planning as needed. ▪ Develop and implement systems and procedures to ensure the proper processing of permit applications and the issuance of use permits, variances, zone changes, and architectural reviews. USDA FARM SERVICE AGENCY, UKIAH, CA 2014 – 2014 PROGRAM TECHNICIAN This position responded to questions regarding program requirements and procedures, reviews nation al issuances and drafts notices, analyzes a variety of program reports, allocates and monitors program funds, and assists in resolving automated application problems. Insure all clerical operations are completed and in compliance with FSA procedures. Responsibilities include directing and managing programs, and administrative operations that require the following: ▪ Environmental assessment, GIS and field visits. ▪ Interpretation and explanation of procedures, program regulations and forms to producers and othe r agency personnel. CITY OF UKIAH, UKIAH, CA 2011 – 2014 PLANNING INTERN Serve as a planning intern with varied responsibilities, but primarily accountable for reviewing development proposals and site plans to ensure conformance with city codes, plans, and regulations. Draft and presents detailed statistical reports on development proposals to government bodies. Evaluate rezoning’s, ordinance amendments, site plans, special use permits, variances, and other proposals. Conduct field evaluations and assessments. ▪ Manage projects from inception to completion, ensuring accurate and thorough application review, site plan analysis, CEQA determination, correspondence, noticing, staff report, and presentation to Zoning Administrator, Planning Commission, and Design Review Board. ▪ Developed an electronic database in Access for paperless project files COUNTY OF MENDOCINO, UKIAH, CA 2013 – 2014 STAFF ASSISTANT III Support office and fiscal operations for the county by performing key administrative, l ogistical, and clerical duties. Main responsibilities include the following: ▪ Public noticing of meetings and drafting packets, agendas, and minutes for board members, staff, and groups. ▪ Preparing memos, letters, charts, labels, reports, contracts, legal do cuments, and other correspondence ▪ Compile, and assemble, and analyze information from department files, public records, and regulations in response to inquiries for general or technical requests. ▪ Answer and direct phone calls accordingly as well as respond to questions. Page 46 of 141 Career Note: Saucy, Ukiah, CA, Server, 2012 – 2013 Downtown Wine, Ukiah, CA, Tasting Room Manager, 2011 Nelson Family Vineyards, Ukiah, CA, Marketing Director/Event Coordinator, 2008 – 2009 Mendocino Wine Company, Ukiah, CA, Branding/Event Marketing, 2006 – 2008 Education Bachelor in Economics & Land Use Planning, Sonoma State University, Rohnert Park, CA, August 2013 Awards & Distinctions Appointed Treasurer Babe Ruth Baseball League 2017| Participated in Leadership Mendocino Class of XXIII | Contributed to Initial Study for Sonoma County Airport Expansion | Developed policies for update of Sebastopol General Plan | Received the 2011 Women Opportunity Award from the Ukiah Chapter Soroptomist Club. Page 47 of 141 Page 48 of 141 ATTACHMENT 6 Page 49 of 141 Page 50 of 141 Page 51 of 141 Page 52 of 141 Page 53 of 141 Page 54 of 141 Page 55 of 141 ATTACHMENT 7 Page 56 of 141 Page 57 of 141 Page 58 of 141 Page 59 of 141 Page 60 of 141 Page 61 of 141 Page 62 of 141 Page 63 of 141 Page 64 of 141 Page 65 of 141 Page 66 of 141 CAMERON RAMOS ATTACHMENT 8 Page 67 of 141 Page 68 of 141 Page 69 of 141 Page 70 of 141 Page 71 of 141 Page 72 of 141 Page 73 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Lisa Hillegas RE: Support for Mari Rodin From: Lisa Hillegas <lisahillegas@gmail.com>   Sent: Friday, January 22, 2021 11:17 AM  To: Meeting <meeting@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Endorsement of Mari Rodin for City Council vacancy  Dear Council Members: I encourage you to select Mari Rodin to fill the vacancy on the City Council for many reasons, including: 1) Mari has proven her commitment over and over to our local community through the vast variety of volunteer work and her participation on critical boards and committees that serve all residents of Ukiah and our County. She is thorough, fair, intelligent, well-informed, reasoned and always prepared to address the issues at hand. Unlike many of the other candidates who have applied for this position, she is unbiased and committed to addressing the needs of everyone in our community and does not bring a political agenda to the council. 2) When Mari was on the City Council, I was an advocate for low income families from 2001-2011 and worked closely with the city planning department, city manager and the city council primarily on issues related to homelessness and affordable housing, advocating for policies in the General Plan, Ukiah's Housing Element and the eventual adoption of the city's Mobile Home Rent Stabilization ordinance. In my multiple presentations to the city council during those years, I found Mari to be reasoned and concerned about these issues while also focused on making sure that she had all the information before making a formal decision as a city council member. In my estimation, the City of Ukiah has demonstrated over the past 20 years that it is dedicated to protecting low income residents and improving the availability and quality of housing that is affordable to low income people. I know that Mari also holds this as a core value and also recognizes that housing is needed for all income levels as demonstrated in her voting record on these important issues. 3) I believe it is important to have diversity and balance on the city council and the appointment of another woman to the council will help maintain that balance. By selecting Mari to fill the vacant seat on the City Council, there will be no need for "catch up" or extra time to educate her on the important and currently dire issues facing the council. She is smart, accessible and committed to being fair and reasoned in her decision- making. Out of all the potential candidates before you, Mari is the only one with a proven track record of being able to work well and efficiently with the city and other council members. She is a community builder and would be a valuable asset to the City Council and our community. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Lisa H. Hillegas Law Offices of Lisa H. Hillegas 106 N. School Street Ukiah, CA 95482 (707) 376-8592 fax: (855) 450-0985 Page 74 of 141 2 This email is from the Law Offices of Lisa H. Hillegas, and may contain information that is confidential or privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, do not read, copy or distribute the email or any attachments. Instead, please notify the sender and delete the email and any attachments. Thank you. Page 75 of 141 Kristine Lawler CityClerk City of Ukiah 300 Seminary Ave. Ukiah, CA 95482 Dear City Council Members, I would like to express my support for Jeff Trouett, applicant for the vacant City Council position. Jeff grew up in Ukiah and has been involved with City activities from a young age. As a volunteer planting sidewalk trees and maintaining curbside plantings to restoring Anton Stadium and helping on numerous non profit fundraisers, Jeff knows this community and the City workings from the inside out. As a plumber by trade, he is well aware of the City’s infrastructure and has worked with many City departments. Jeff has followed City Council meetings for years and as a dedicated community member, small business owner and landlord, is compelled to find solutions to problems. He offers a fresh mature perspective and approach to Ukiah’s needs. Respectfully, signature sized.jpg ¬ Tom Liden Ukiah, CA.  Page 76 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Susan Baird Kanaan - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Susan Baird Kanaan <susanbairdkanaan@yahoo.com>   Sent: Saturday, January 23, 2021 5:31 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Supporting the appointment of Mari Rodin to the vacant Ukiah City Council seat  Dear Mayor Orozco and Council members Brown, Dueños, and Crane, I am writing to encourage you to appoint Mari Rodin to the City Council seat vacated by Maureen Mulheren. I know Mari well, not only because she was a colleague of my husband, Benj Thomas, on the Council, but because I've worked with her on other projects to promote community health and well-being. As you well know, the City of Ukiah faces unprecedented challenges. I feel strongly that Mari's judgment, intelligence, and depth of experience make her uniquely suited to hit the ground running as a fully contributing Council member from day one. Thank you for your consideration. Best regards, Susan Baird Kanaan Page 77 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Marya Heath - Support for Mari Rodin From: susan o gordon <sogordon44@gmail.com>   Sent: Sunday, January 24, 2021 9:51 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Mari for city council seat vacated by Mo  Mari is more than qualified to be on the city council as she sat on it for 11 years. did an outstanding job of understanding what the city and its citizens needed to move forward. Please consider Mari Rodin for our new city council member. thank you, -- Page 78 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Armand Brint - Support for Mari Rodin From: armando@pacific.net <armando@pacific.net>   Sent: Saturday, January 23, 2021 1:56 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Mari Rodin letter of support‐‐please distribute to all council members  January 23, 2021 Dear Mayor Orozco and Council Members Brown, Duenos and Crane, I am writing this letter to support Mari Rodin to fill the vacancy left by Councilwoman Mulhern. I have known Mari for 25 years as a friend and colleague. And over this period, I have come to appreciate her dedication, intelligence and integrity. Mari, of course, has previously served on the Ukiah City Council as well as presiding as Mayor. She has a firm grasp of city government and a genuine interest in providing the kind of leadership and collaboration that will elevate responsive and effective city services. And given her experience, she could hit the ground running. If Mari Rodin were appointed to a seat on the Council, it would be a real boon to the citizens of Ukiah. Thank you. Sincerely, Armand Brint, Ukiah Page 79 of 141 2 Page 80 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - James Flaherty - Support for Mari Rodin   From: James Flaherty <jflaher1@att.net>   Sent: Sunday, January 24, 2021 9:25 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Submission RE: Vacant City Council Seat  Dear Mayor Juan Orozco, and Council Members Jim Brown, Josephina Dueños, and Doug Crane, As you know, Mari has been an elected City Council Member and served as Mayor in the past. In addition to her service in City government, she and her business partner were long-term grant writers for our City and County including many communities other than Ukiah. She has a wealth of knowledge and a proven success in getting resources for our citizens. This success is based on a strong foundation of understanding of the issues and doing the research necessary to get the funding for vital and important services--more than a hundred million dollars of funding over 20 years achieved! Her experience and success as Council member, Mayor, and successful grant writer has been exceptional. No other applicant for the vacant City Council position has this demonstrated level of experience and performance in local government. In my opinion, Mari is the preferable choice. Jim Flaherty, MD Jim Flaherty 5 Highland Dr. Ukiah CA 95482-4637 Home (707) 462-6157 Cell (707) 391-9631 Page 81 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Mary Gustafson - Support for Mari Rodin   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Mary Gustafson <marygus@pacific.net>   Sent: Sunday, January 24, 2021 10:33 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Appointment to City Council    [EXTERNAL EMAIL] DO NOT CLICK links or attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.    January 24, 2021    To the Ukiah City Council    We would like to express our support of Mari Rodin to fill the Ukiah City Council position vacated by Mo Mulhern.  We  feel very strongly that Mari would be an experienced asset to the council. In addition her appointment would increase  the number of women on the council.  Mari has a proven track record of effectively promoting the best interests of our  community.    Robert and Mary Gustafson    346 N Barnes Street, Ukiah    (707) 489‐0260    Page 82 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Marya Heath - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Marya Heath <aquakay6@gmail.com>   Sent: Sunday, January 24, 2021 9:23 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Appointment of Mari Rodin to Ukiah City Council  Dear members of the Ukiah City Council: Mayor Juan Orozco, Jim Brown, Josephina Duenos, Doug Crane This letter is to give my support to Mari Rodin as a friend and public servant that I have known for 15 years. Mari is an experienced representative, given her past experience on the City Council as well as her many years in grant writing and work with non-profits in the Ukiah area. I am an enthusiastic supporter of Mari, given her energy and ability to listen to and work with many diverse members of our community. Thank you all for representing our town and valuing the experience of interested applicants. We need steady and smart representatives. Mari will be that person. Marya Kay Heath 1141 W. Standley St. Ukiah, CA Page 83 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Paula Martin - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Paula Martin <paulamartinukiah@gmail.com>   Sent: Saturday, January 23, 2021 1:22 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Mari Rodin for City Council opening  I strongly support Mari Rodin for the opening with Ukiah City Council. I have known Mari personally for over 25 years. She is hard-working, smart, a team player, lknowledgeable and responsive to community concerns. Having served previously on the city Council and as mayor Mari has the knowledge and expertise to fill this position. If you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact me. Paula Martin Retired Former Associate Superintendent MCOE Page 84 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Laura Fogg - Support for Mari Rodin ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Laura Fogg <fogg.laura@gmail.com>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 11:22 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Letter in support of Mari Rodin    Dear Mayor Juan Orozco, Jim Brown, Josephina Dueños, and Doug Crane,    I would like to voice my support for the selection of Mari Rodin to fill Maureen Mulheren’s empty seat on the City  Council. Mari has plenty of experience, having previously served for a number of years on the Council, so she would be  able to hit the ground running as opposed to needing months of on‐the‐job‐training. She also has an established record  as a person who can listen to others, bring people together and find creative ways to bring much‐need grant funding to  our city. Last, but not least, Mari’s appointment would improve the ratio of women to men on the council, which I  believe is critically important in representative democratic government.    Thank you,    Laura Fogg  1143 W Church St, Ukiah      Sent from my iPad  Page 85 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Rick Ryan - Support for Joel Soinila   From: ricbob <ricbob@comcast.net>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 12:57 PM  To: Meeting <meeting@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Joel Sonlia  I am strongly supporting Joel Sonlia for City council. His new and fresh approach to City government goes beyond words. I feel confident that he will act in the people's best interests when it come to the betterment of Ukiah. Thank you,   Rick Ryan, Retired Fire Chief RVCFD, Retired Fire Captain, Cal Fire. Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone Page 86 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini   From: Helen Sizemore <helensize@gmail.com>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 11:56 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Council Appointment  To: Mayor Juan Orozco, Councilman Jim Brown, Councilman, Doug Crane, Councilwoman Josephina Duenos I urge you to select a candidate with experience, a commitment to service and a record of integrity. Mari Rodin and Steve Scalminini are elevated by these qualifications. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely yours, Helen Sizemore 989 North Oak Street Page 87 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Katherine McElwee - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Katherine McElwee <kmcelwee@pacific.net>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 7:35 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: To the Members of the City Council  I am writing to express my wholehearted support for Mari Rodin in her bid to replace Mo Mulheren on the City Council. She has the necessary knowledge and experience and can be “up and running” upon her selection and swearing in. She stands above the rest of the applicants. She is smart, competent, caring and committed to Ukiah. Please do the right thing and select Mari. Thank you. Katherine McElwee Page 88 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Marvin Trotter - Support for Mari Rodin   From: marvin trotter <marvin.trotter@gmail.com>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 6:08 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City council members  Dear council members...Orozco, Brown , Duenas and Crane Please consider experience, intelligence , accomplishments , ability to work with others, AND to be able to make workable solutions!! , in your choice of candidates for the city council. Please choose Mari Rodin, because she has all those qualities. Thanks for all you do for the City of Ukiah!!! sincerely, Marvin Trotter Page 89 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Martha Barra - Support for Mari Rodin Attachments:Mari Rodin Endorsement 2021.docx   From: Martha Barra <rvv@pacific.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 8:57 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Appointment of Mari Rodin to vacant seat on Council    Dear Ms. Lawler,    Would you please see that this letter is received by all Council members as well as other pertinent City staff?    Thank you for your assistance.  (And could you please acknowledge that you received this letter?)    Martha Barra  (707)489‐3085 (cell)  (707)485‐8771 (office)    www.barraofmendocino.com  www.girasolevineyards.com    Page 90 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Carol Misseldine - Support for Mari Rodin   From: CAROL MISSELDINE <cmisseldine@comcast.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 9:38 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Please appoint Mari Rodin to the Ukiah City Council  Dear Ukiah Mayor Juan Orozco and Council members Jim Brown, Josephina Dueñas and Doug Crane, Many sincere thanks to all of you for your service to our community. I am writing to urge you to appoint Mari Rodin as City Council member to fill the seat vacated by Mo Mulheren. Mari's previous experience as a member of the Ukiah City Council will serve her well in this position. Furthermore, Mari is extremely intelligent and thoughtful and she clearly loves and cares for this community deeply. We would be well served if Mari received this appointment to the City Council. Thank you for your consideration, Carol Carol Misseldine Ukiah, CA 301-892-1185 cmisseldine@comcast.net Page 91 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Crispin Hollinshead - Support for Steve Scalmanini ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Crispin B. Hollinshead <cbhollinshead@bigriverlines.com>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 11:50 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Support for Steve Scalmanini for open council seat    Mayor Orozco, Council members Brown, Dueñas, and Crane,    I am writing in support of Steve Scalmanini for the open council seat.  With years of experience on the council, he can be  productive immediately.  He has demonstrated his commitment to the job by his thorough investigation of issues, even  when they are not popular.  I am concerned about emergency power resilience, and this is an issue important to Steve  as well.    Thank your for your consideration,    Crispin B. Hollinshead  Page 92 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Terry Poplawski - Support for Steve Scalmanini   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Terry Poplawski <tpop@pacific.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 1:08 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City Council vacancy    Dear Ukiah City Council members,    I am writing to urge you to appoint Steve Scalmanini to the open seat on the Council.  Steve has a number of years of  experience on the Council and was fourth in what was a close race for the second seat in the last election.  He  represents my interests in seeing growth in our valley being controlled in order to protect as much of our small town  character as possible and seeing the energy needs of our community being meet by sustainable means as much as  possible.    Terry Poplawski  612 Walnut Avenue  Ukiah  Page 93 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - David Taxis - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini   From: DAVID TAXIS <youngrey@comcast.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 12:53 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: letter of support  City Council: I support your choice to select the next council member, rather than spend money to go to the polls. One end of the political spectrum is well represented with council members Crane and Brown. I believe Mr. Orosco and the newest member are moderates, judging by their voting records and public words. Since 40% of our population is Latino, I praise the insight of our voters to choose Josephina and Juan. So, I would recommend both progressives of your applicants, for their service to the community and being long-time Ukiahans. Both Mr. Scalmanini and Ms. Rodin have vast experience in serving on boards and committees and councils. They've shown that they pay attention to the issues, rather than allow their minds to wander to personal matters. For greatest balance, Ms. Rodin would be the best choice so that there are two women serving on the council. Our community is in need of many things and I wish you all a very productive year. Sincerely, David Taxis, Ukiah Page 94 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Hafsa Steward - Support for Steve Scalmanini From: Hafsa Stewart <hafsastewart@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 12:18 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Applicants for City Council seat  Dear City Council members, I am writing in support of Steve Scalmanini for City Council. He has, as you know, served on the Council for years. He is knowledgeable and would understand all levels of our City issues and personnel. He cares deeply about the community and is tireless in his service. He has done his best to address environmental issues which would help us keep our small town the delightful place it is now, while recognizing the need to support businesses that meet our needs as well as employing our citizens. Steve is always congenial and helpful. He is surprisingly willing to entertain any questions when stopped downtown and if he doesn't have time or needs to research the question, he will get back to you with the information. Mostly, he has the knowledge to "hit the ground running". In the time of Covid, we need all the support we can get to maximize the orderly distribution of vaccines, which is still pretty much a word-of-mouth and race there as fast as possible scenario. Call a doctor, they don't know. Often the Hospital doesn't know. Perhaps, City Council could coordinate with Public Health and others to help keep us informed. I believe Steve would be excellent at that. Last, he is the most perfect Santa we have ever had. Hafsa Stewart hafsastewart@gmail.com Page 95 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Bill Fisette - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Bill Fisette <wfisette@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 1:35 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City council appt.    To Juan Orozco, Jim Brown, Josefina Dueñas, Doug Crane,        I urge you to appoint Mari Rodin or Steve Scalmanini to the city council. Experience in the job is of utmost  importance, and these candidates both have the experience necessary to complement yourselves on the city council. I  have found them both to be eagerly  accessible to me, and helpful when I have reached out to them on issues that are of  importance to me. This is an important decision, please choose one of these candidates to fill the seat on the Ukiah City  Council. Thank you, William Fisette      Sent from my iPad  Page 96 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Trudy Morgan - Support for Steve Scalmanini and Susan Sher   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Trudy Morgan <morganmiller@pacific.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 2:13 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Supporting Steve Scalmanini    Dear Council Members, Juan Orozco, Jim Brown, Josefina Duenas, Doug Crane,          I would like to recommend that you chose Steve Scalmanini for the vacant seat on the City Council.  I have read  what others have written about his qualifications, and, rather than repeat them all….I have to say that I agree 100% with  what was said.          I’ll add one thing….I am so impressed that Steve has  worked on creek clean‐ups around town, along with many  members of the community.  He’s not afraid to get dirty and do what needs to be done to keep our creeks safe and clear  of garbage.          Thank you for the opportunity to add my two cents!  Sincerely,  Trudy Morgan  408 W. Mill St.  Ukiah, CA      PS….my second choice would be Susan Sher!!  I loved every bit of her Applicant’s Statement!  Page 97 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Peggy Backup - Support for Steve Scalmanini ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Peggy Backup <pbackup1@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 2:21 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Vacant Council Position    Kristine,  Please make my comments available to the City Council.    I was disappointed that Steve Scalmanini was not re‐elected to the Council.  I value his knowledgeable approach, even when I disagree on particulars.  He is aware of so much going on in our City and knows who to contact.  I always consider him first when I have questions. I also value his calm demeanor and willingness to take unpopular  positions or ask difficult questions.  The discussion of various views is essential; I’m not looking for a rubber‐stamp.    One memorable problem he helped solve was a few years back when the City sponsored a Halloween event for adults.  Their haunted house included a partially dismembered female mannequin with splattered blood.  After viewing a picture on the front page of the UDJ, I called Steve.  He directed me to the staff person responsible, and we had a pleasant conversation, face‐to‐face. In addition, Steve  called the Executive Director of Project Sanctuary, who called the staff member. It was her phone call that canceled that  particular exhibit—not the event, just the most offensive portion.    I would also support Mari Rodin, although I don’t know her as well.  Thank you,  Peggy Backup    Page 98 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Tony Marsh - Support for Steve Scalmanini   From: tony@manzanitaservices.org <tony@manzanitaservices.org>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 2:45 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City Counsel    To the Mayor, and city council. My name is Tony Marsh. I am writing this to support Mr. Scalmanini. I have worked with  Steve these past 5 years on many projects around Ukiah. I believe that anyone willing to spend their time and own  money to support projects deserves to continue to serve as a voice on the council. He is still currently assisting different  agencies around town help clean up the creeks and other locations. Even after he lost the election. I feel his dedication  needs to be recognized. Thank you for your time.  Page 99 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Lorna Maslenikov - Support for Steve Scalmanini   From: Lorna Maslenikov <lmaslenikov@wildblue.net>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 8:20 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Appointment to fill open Council seat  Dear Ms Lawler -   I support appointing Steve Scalmonini to fill the open City Council seat. He has had experience as a Council member and has been active in some issues that I care about: 1) Banning herbicide use in the city's parks and 2) Climate Change issues. Sincerely, Lorna Maslenikov Page 100 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Robin Sunbeam - Support for Steve Scalmanini ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Robin Sunbeam <bodhirobin@pacific.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 8:22 PM  To: Meeting <meeting@cityofukiah.com>  Cc: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Appointment to Ukiah City Council    Please appoint Steve Scalmanini, who lost the election by only a few votes.  He is very familiar with the issues and does  his homework.  Steve is also a strong environmentalist, which is what I want on the city council.    Thanks,    Robin Sunbeam, RN, MSN, PHN  Page 101 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Marvin Kramer - Support for Susan Sher   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: marvin kramer <kramer@saber.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 8:00 PM  To: Meeting <meeting@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: letter of support for Susan Sher    Dear Council,    I am writing in support of Susan Sher to fill the vacancy in the Ukiah City Council. I believe Susan has valuable   professional experience as an attorney and mediator and wide range,long term experience in civic engagement. As a  long time resident of the Wagenseller neighborhood  she would bring personal perspective  to address the needs of  homeless people there. Her time serving on the Ukiah School Board Personnel commission and Climate Action  Mendocino also reflects valuable experience for a City Council member. I recently have come to know Susan's devotion  public service through beginning to work with her through Climate Mendocino on the issue of limiting auto idling with  its negative impact on the environment. Please consider the diversity and qualifications Susan would contribute to the  Ukiah City Council.                      Thank you,Yvonne Kramer, retired Ukiah Unified teacher    Page 102 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Sharon Kiichli - Support for Joel Soinila   From: kiichli@pacific.net <kiichli@pacific.net>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 3:54 PM  To: Meeting <meeting@cityofukiah.com>; Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Cc: joel@joelforsupervisor.com  Subject: City Council Member Appointment  I am writing to recommend that you appoint Joel Soinila to the vacant seat on the Ukiah City Council.  I have been a  resident of the City of Ukiah for over 50 years and I pay close attention to the work of the Council and the Planning  Commission.  Although I do not know all of the individuals who have applied for the vacant seat, I do know five of the  applicants: Soinila, Sher, Trouette, Rodin and Scalmanini.  I strongly believe that among these applicants, Joel Soinila is  absolutely the best candidate.   Soinila has a deep understanding of many of the issues that come before the Council, and he is committed to working  hard to improve the quality of life for all of Ukiah’s residents.  He is a good listener, open to new ideas and has  demonstrated his ability to work well with a team. He is intelligent, honest, accessible and reliable.  His personal and  professional contributions to this community have been significant.     I live on West Perkins Street (the “West Side”) where many of my neighbors expect to be represented by Council  members who promote the interests of one segment of the community.  It is refreshing to see that there is an applicant  who is open to the needs and interests of a cross section of the community.    Thank you for considering my opinion in this matter.  Sharon Kiichli    Page 103 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Karen Lee - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Karen Lee <directaccess@saber.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 6:40 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: empty city council seat    To All Concerned,  Thank you for all you do to make Ukiah an even better place to live.  Please consider that this city council is the least experienced that we've had in a very long time.  I recommend Steve  Scalmanini and Mari Rodin for the empty seat on the council because they both have plenty of experience.   I feel that people with more experience are vital for our city council, especially in these difficult times.  Both Steve and  Mari have proven their ability to handle difficult circumstances.  They are both hard‐working, thoughtful, honest,  trustworthy, and conscientious. I appreciate our City Council and all it contributes to making Ukiah a great place to live.   Mari and Steve will make a great addition to the team.  Thanks for your consideration.  Sincerely,    Karen Lee    Page 104 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Adina Merenlender - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Dr. Adina MERENLENDER PhD <adinam@berkeley.edu>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 5:51 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Council Appointment input  To: Mayor Juan Orozco, Councilman Jim Brown, Councilman, Doug Crane, Councilwoman Josephina Duenos Please consider selecting a fellow council member who has experience in city government, land use planning, and a vision for Ukiah. I can assure you that Mari Rodin offers extensive professional experience and is an honest hardworking public servant. Lastly, I want to share my approach to hiring which is always to hire people who are smarter than me so I can learn and we can achieve great things together. Mari is very smart and at the same time easy to work with. Thank you for considering this input. Sincerely, Adina Merenlender, 453 Mendocino Dr. Ukiah Page 105 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Joann Rosen - Support for Steve Scalmanini From: Joann Rosen <joannrosen@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 5:37 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>; Juan Orozco <jorova1@msn.com>  Subject: Support for Steven Scalmanini  To whom it may concern, I am writing in support of the appointment of Steven Scalmanini to the Ukiah City Council. In my opinion, this is a time of utmost stress, requiring clear thinking and a deep familiarity and experience being on the council. Steven has this record along with clarity and energy to perform the job well. Jo-ann Rosen Property Owner in Ukiah, 40 +year Ukiah resident -- 1. "Those who plant in tears, harvest in joy" psalm 126 Jo-ann Rosen, MA, LMFT 3751 Low Gap Road Ukiah CA, 95482 (707)462-7749 (cell) (707) 468-1673 landline Page 106 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Bill Taylor - Support for Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini From: Bill Taylor <edibleland@earthlink.net>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 5:33 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Steve Scalmanini or Mari Rodin for City Council    Dear Kristine Lawler, I am writing to support either Steve Scalmanini or Mari Rodin. I have known Steve for some time and find his commitment to the environment and social justice to be just what the City Council needs. I met Mari briefly and got the sense she is level-headed, energetic and committed. With climate disruption one of the most serious threats we face, either of them would bring that commitment to take bold action to Ukiah. I have moved to Massachusetts but stay in touch with my community; 17 years in Mendocino County and Redwood Valley from 2012 to November 2020. Sincerely, Bill Taylor, Floodgate Farm 707-272-1688 Page 107 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Judy Luria - Support for Steve Scalmanini, Mari Rodin, and Susan Sher From: Judy Luria <judya@pacific.net>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 9:36 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Re: fifth city councilmember  Dear Ukiah City Council, I am writing to support three of the best candidates for City Council. I hope that when you make your choice, you will consider that Steve Scalmanini is experienced, super hardworking, does his homework, supports making Ukiah a safe, diverse and resilient community. Also, Mari Rodin has plenty of experience, ability to bring in funds and connects with a diverse community.   And Susan Sher has lots of qualifications too, attorney, mediator, advocate for underserved Ukiah neighborhoods and serves on the Mendocino County Climate Action Advisory Committee. Any one of these three would be great! There is so much work to be done, we need all hands on deck! thank you, Judy Luria, Ukiah voter Page 108 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Larry Sheehy - Support for Susan Sher ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Larry Sheehy <ecotopialarry@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 9:42 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Cc: Larry Sheehy <ecotopialarry@gmail.com>  Subject: Support for Susan Sher    To the City Council Members,    I'm supporting and advocating for Susan Sher for the vacant City Council seat. There are some very good applicants  including Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini (both who have served well on the Council before), but I'm supporting Susan  Sher for the same reason I supported Council person/mayor Maureen Mulheren. Both have worked hard at being  engaged in the community and being involved with neighborhood improvement projects, and in Susan's case,  specifically in her Wagenseller neighborhood, where she serves on the board of the Wagenseller Neighborhood  Association. Susan is also a member of Climate Action Mendocino, the local organization working to help curtail the  effects of climate change at the local level.    I feel she would be an excellent City Council person!    I ask the City Council members to please consider Susan Sher for the vacant seat. Thank you.    Larry Sheehy,  Watershed Poetry Mendocino  Page 109 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Jim Robbins - Support for Michelle Johnson From: Jim Robbins <jrobbins323@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 10:03 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City Council ‐ Michelle Johnson  Dear City of Ukiah Council Members, I would like to enthusiastically recommend Michelle Jonson for the replacement seat of former Council Member Mo Mulheron. I've known Michelle for a number of years and have worked with her in the community. We have shared many conversations about important local issues, and I am impressed by her mature and thoughtful ideas. It is apparent that Michelle understands and cares about local government and has both the enthusiasm and experience to make a positive impact. She is a very active community member and a successful city planner, in addition to being a devoted mom. Michelle has the ability to look at issues from multiple perspectives and work with others to achieve the best possible outcomes. She understands the issues that face Ukiah and would make significant contributions to the existing team of council members. Sincerely, James W. Robbins Page 110 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Nora Sanchez - Support for Mari Rodin ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: nora sanchez <norafisette@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 11:24 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City council appointment     To Juan Orozco, Jim Brown, Josephine Dueñas, Doug Crane, I urge you to appoint Mari Rodin to the vacant city council  seat. Mari has the experience necessary to do a good job on the council. I have found her to be intelligent, thoughtful,  and easily accessible to me to work on issues that I feel are important for our community. Having previously served on  the council, she will be able to hit the ground running and effectively serve on the council. Thank you, Nora Alejandra  Sanchez    Sent from my iPad  Page 111 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Rhea Hollis - Support for Michelle Johnson   From: Rhea Hollis <rheahollis@yahoo.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 11:43 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Michelle Birdsall Johnson support  To Whom It May Concern: Greetings. My name is Rhea Hollis. I have been a community member and educator in our community for twenty years. I have had the pleasure of knowing Michelle Birdsall Johnson for several of those years. My support of Michelle Johnson for the City of Ukiah City Council comes from personal experience and knowledge of her integrity and commitment to our community. She has raised five children here and brings great insight and new ideas Over the years Michelle has been an active volunteer in the community. She is passionate, approachable, articulate and understands community issues. Ms. Birdsall Johnson is a good listener and not only asks poignant questions, but also seeks to find open-minded and inclusive solutions. Due to her local government experience she brings knowledge and expertise which will be valuable. Thank you for considering my support of Michelle Birdsall Johnson in her pursuit of serving our community. Sincerely, Rhea Hollis Page 112 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Deb Attaway - Support for Mari Rodin   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Deb Attaway <baldaway2@gmail.com>   Sent: Monday, January 25, 2021 3:29 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Mari Rodin    I would like to offer my support as a Mendocino county resident. Sincerely deb attaway    Sent from my iPhone  Page 113 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Ede Morris - Support for Steve Scalmanini ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Ede Morris <edemaemorris@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 12:48 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Steve Scalmanini    I am writing to support Steve Scalmanini's application to the City Council . Steve has years of experience working as a  City Council member . He listens and is responsive to the concerns of his constituents and the needs of our community .  Steve practices the "Precautionary Principle" in making his decisions,  and we need his voice especially in this time of  economical and environmental challenges .   Steve has proven that he can work well with his other Council members , and has cultivated a close relationship with the  Latino and native communities . Steve has been outspoken and passionate about equal rights and racial justice . I urge  you to appoint Steve to the Ukiah city Council .              Thank you ,                           Ede Morris   Page 114 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Ruth Van Antwerp - Support for Steve Scalmanini   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: roody@pacific.net <roody@pacific.net>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 12:01 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: recommendation of appointee to City Council      January 26, 2021    Ruth Van Antwerp  Ukiah  CA  95482      Ukiah City Council Members  Ukiah  CA  95482    Dear Council Member,    I wish to recommend Steve Scalmanini as your appointee to City Council.  Steve has served our city well, doing the necessary research beyond the required City staff reports.  We need his  educated decision making and  independent voice.   Due to his persistence, downtown State Street does  not have a median which could impede emergency vehicles.    Steve works for all Ukiahans whether he holds public office or not.  He is a quality person that we need, with seven years  of experience serving on the Council.    Sincerely,  Ruth Van Antwerp    Estimados Miembros del Concilio,    Me gustaría recomendar que nombren a Steve Scalmanini como Miembro de Concilio de Ukiah.  Steve ha servido la  ciudad muy bien.  El investiga más allá de los informes requeridos del personal de la Ciudad.  Nosotros necesitamos su  habilidad de tomar decisiones informadas y su voz independiente.  Debido a la persistencia de Steve, no hay camellón en  el medio de calle State, lo cual podría causar impedimento a los vehículos de emergencia.    Steve sirve a todos los residentes de Ukiah, si es oficial público o no.  Es una persona de calidad que necesitamos, con siete años de experiencia sirviendo en el Concilio de Ukiah.    Sinceramente,  Ruth Van Antwerp        Page 115 of 141 2   Page 116 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Leslie Kirkpatrick - Support for Susan Sher ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: L Kirkpatrick <brightstarrysky@icloud.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 7:50 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Applicant for the City Council     Esteemed Council Members,    Please give strong consideration to the application of Susan Sher, Esq, for the open seat on our Council.    Ms Sher possesses the varied skills and qualities required for this complex public service job.  She has been a successful  attorney and mediator living in our County for many years, helping her clients achieve equity and justice, as well as  managing the delicate process of helping disagreeing parties come to fair and clear resolution.  Her work for the  Wagonseller Neighborhood has spanned decades, as the area has changed and grown.    She is committed to social justice and will work hard to ensure our community is one where all can live safely and well.    Sincerely,  Leslie Kirkpatrick        Sent from my iPhone  Page 117 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Charlene Light - Support for Steve Scalmanini   From: Charlene Light <charlenelight@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 12:51 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>; Steve Scalmanini <sscalmanini@yahoo.com>  Subject: Letter in support of Steve Scalmanini  January 27, 2021 Dear Mayor Juan Orozco and City Council members Josefina Duenas, Doug Crane and Jim Brown, I highly recommend that Steve Scalmanini be appointed to fill the vacant seat on the Ukiah City Council. I have known Steve since 2003 when I moved to Ukiah from Humboldt County. Soon after moving here I joined him in working to ban GMO's from our County. It was while working with him that I discovered what a tireless and dedicated worker he was for the causes in which he believes. I also served with him on Alliance for Democracy and again was impressed by how dedicated and very involved he was. Steve's interests and undertakings are very diverse and comprehensive. He helps with creek cleanups and is not adverse to getting his hands dirty or rolling up his sleeves to do whatever is needed or necessary. Steve has so much experience and energy to give to the City Council that I cannot think of anyone more qualified and deserving to fulfill this vacated position. The obvious is that since he has recently been a member of the Council he would need absolutely no catching up to do. Steve is one of the most sincere, intelligent, compassionate and dedicated people I have met in my 77 years on this planet. I especially liked that on his application Steve stated that there was nothing in his personal philosophies that would conflict with the best interests of the City of Ukiah. I have found this to be true about Steve. In addition, I highly recommend Mari Rodin and Cameron Ramos be appointed to the Ukiah Planning Commission. Sincerely, Charlene Light, MA Retired School Teacher 170 Cleveland Lane, Ukiah Page 118 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - David & Wendy Cram - Support for Steve Scalmanini ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: wendav@pacific.net <wendav@pacific.net>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 2:36 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Letter of Support for Steve Scalmanini    We would like to express our support for Steve Scalmanini to be appointed to the city council seat recently vacated by  Ms. Mulheren. As a former council member he has the necessary experience to immediately take on the duties of the  position. We appreciate his support for rent control, fair rates for water and sewer increases and other issues affecting  the economically disadvantaged people of our community.    Sincerely,  David & Wendy Cram  Beth Thompson  Margee Wesott  Susan Cox    Page 119 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Lauren Simmonds - Support for Michelle Johnson   From: Lauren Simmonds <lsimmonds@mendocino.edu>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 3:01 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Michelle Birdsall Johnson‐ Letter of Support  Kristine, I am submitting this letter of support for Michelle Birdsall Johnson to serve out the remaining two years on Ukiah City Council of newly elected Board of Supervisor Maureen Mulheren. Immediately upon meeting Michelle, it was clear that she is passionate about facilitating positive change within our community. Her vision, dedication, and compassion make her an ideal candidate. Working with her professionally through the Mendocino College Career Hub led to getting to know and appreciate Michelle on a level that is rare. She is truly a gem, as her endearing commitment to community volunteering and public servitude shows. I am confident that Michelle would serve our beloved community exceptionally well as a member of Ukiah City Council. Warmly, Lauren Simmonds Career Center Specialist Mendocino College 707.468.3044 Page 120 of 141 Page 121 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Sarah Marshall - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Sarah Marshall <smarshall@ncoinc.org>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 3:54 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Support for Mari Rodin    Dear Council Members,  I'm writing today in enthusiastic support of Mari Rodin to be chosen as your appointee for the vacant city  council seat.    Mari's background in grant writing coupled with her experience as a council member while Ukiah faced the  worst of the 2008 financial crisis add to her credentials as the most qualified candidate to take on this position  during unprecedented challenges to city budgets, the livelihood of residents, and the financial strength of our  local businesses caused by the global COVID‐19 Pandemic.     Reducing the barriers to equitable access to information, services, and leadership positions for all Ukiah  residents, regardless of identity or language preference, is one of the issues closest to my heart. I admire how  Mari has taken action to improve language justice at the city and county level. One example: at the beginning  of the Pandemic, when critical health information was not yet available in an equitable and timely manner to  Ukiahans who speak Spanish as their first language, Mari worked with the local Spanish Language newspaper  Al Punto to record conversational videos explaining the public health orders in easy‐to‐understand terms. She  stands out among the candidates for her ability to work with people from a wide variety of backgrounds,  identities, and belief systems to come to a common place of agreement and understanding in order to  improve quality of life for all.     Mari's compassionate understanding of homelessness as a humanitarian crisis, and experience working closely  with the Continuum of Care, make her a trusted advocate to address this issue that so many in our community  identify as their top concern.      I trust Mari to consider the climate in the decisions she would make as a city council member, thanks to her  track record of upholding environmental values through her actions. Her careful consideration of land use,  knowledge of water supply, and experience creating the Great Redwood Trail active corridor to reduce  greenhouse gas emissions within the City are just a few examples.     Mari is personable, passionate about improving our community, and the candidate I support to serve on city  council.     Thank you for your consideration,   Sarah Marshall    Page 122 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Cynthia Coale - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Cynthia Coale <cdcoale@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 4:17 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Mari Rodin , City Council Appointment  Re: Mari Rodin, City Council Appointment Dear City Council Members: Mayor Juan Orozco Jim Brown Josephina Duenos Doug Crane If you want to make a decision that will repay you many times over, appoint Mari Rodin to the Ukiah City Council. Mari is really something. First off, she is an exceptionally good person. She believes in teamwork. She can understand and sympathize with many different types of people from farm workers to hospital administrators. Even when she does not support a particular point of view, the various parties feel heard and included. That in itself is a real skill. But there’s lots more to Mari. Having already served on the City Council, she knows the city administrative and fiscal systems. She knows how the various departments are organized, how they relate to each other and to outside community programs. As a past Mayor, Mari is familiar with procedural and legal expectations for operating a city council. She understands the role a city council plays in providing direction to city government and the role the City Council has in representing interests of the community to City, County, and State and Federal bodies. Mari has years of valuable experience under her belt which can only help serve as a resource for undertakings of the Ukiah City Council. In her work as a professional grant writer, Mari's efforts have, over the years, brought millions of dollars of new money into Mendocino County. Her successful grants have benefited a wide variety of governmental and civic interests. She has brought funding to the non-profit agencies in our community helping them fulfill their public missions. Funding from her grants has positively affected job creation and economic development. As a result of her grant writing, Mari has acquired a wide-ranging acquaintance with activities and services underpinning the life of our community. Mari also was an influential member of LAFCO, the Local Agency Formation Commission. This group is concerned with coordination and planning of efficient systems of city and special districts with an eye to guiding development towards urban land areas and preservation of agricultural and open space lands. Page 123 of 141 2 You have probably guessed, but I’ll say it anyway: Mari is intelligent and scrupulously honest. She's a problem solver and a virtuous, diplomatic, yet straightforward person. She believes in transparency and in keeping channels of communication open. Though Mari is talented, she is not out to advance her own interests or boost her reputation. Rather, she cares about those of us who live and work here and the quality of our lives. She cares about our economic well-being and the well-being of our business community. She cares about minority well being and inclusion and preserving the natural beauty of the Ukiah Valley. Mari’s skills and character are a resource, and she is a delight to work with. Please do appoint Mari to join the Ukiah City Council. You will be glad you did. Regards, Cynthia Coale Page 124 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Jamie Connerton - Support for Jeff Trouette   From: Jamie Connerton <jamieconnerton@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 4:21 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Support for City Council Candidates  Please enter this with comments about candidates for appointment to Ukiah City Council position. Thank you. I believe Jeff Trouette is the best candidate for appointment to the open position on the Ukiah City Council. He combines love for the town he grew up in - shown by his volunteering - with a hard-acquired business sense. His intellectual curiosity leads him to study the business, pleasures, and politics of Ukiah. Yes, he will bring tough questions before you, and they will be well-thought-out and from the heart and mind. I know nobody who's spent more of his private time viewing and reading about council meetings and city affairs, and gives so much back in coaching, pro bono plumbing, various civic organizations and events. Jeff is honest. Trust the satisfied customer of a master plumber to recognize honesty. You will do the town well to appoint him to your council.   Yours truly,   James (Jamie) Connerton Ukiah Page 125 of 141    `ATA? cáçv{A Counselor January 27, 2021 To Whom It May Concern: Re: Susan Sher Appointment to Fill the City Council Vacancy I am submitting this letter in support of Susan Sher to fill the vacant position on the City Council. I have worked with Susan for over eight (8) years as a member of the Ukiah Unified School District, Personnel Commission. She is thorough, conscientious, organized, bright, intelligent, and very community oriented. She attends all of the meetings and is well prepared to discuss the issues. During the course of commission discussions, the thoroughness of her preparation is evident. Even though on occasion we may disagree on a particular idem, she is very professional during the course of the discussions as we attempt to reach a mutually acceptable solution. It has been a real pleasure to serve with Susan Sher on the Personnel Commission and if she is chosen to fill the City Council vacancy, we will definitely miss her. Sincerely yours, KATHY JAMES Page 126 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Jonah Walsh - Support for Michele Johnson From: Jonah Walsh <jonahwalshlaw@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 6:08 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: In Support Of Michele Johnson  To whom it may concern:  I am writing to you today because I wanted to voice my support for Michele Johnson for Ukiah City Council. I have known Michele for many years and I believe she would bring a vast wealth of knowledge and experience to the Ukiah City Council.  Michele has an ideal background for a position on the Council. She has previously worked as Assistant Planner and as an Associate Planner for the City of Ukiah. Michele has also worked as a Planner II for the City of Novato. Currently Michele works as an Assistant Planner for the City of Willits.   Not only does Michele have an exceptional background for a position on our City Council but I know Michele is strongly committed to the betterment of our town and our local community. Michele would bring a unique combination of passion and insight to the Council and for all the reasons stated I strongly support Michele Johnson for Ukiah City Council.   Sincerely,  Jonah S. Walsh Attorney at Law Law Office of Jonah S. Walsh 280 North Oak Street Ukiah, CA 95482 Phone: (707) 336-2780 CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: Privileged and Confidential. Attorney-Client Communication & Attorney Work Product. This communication and accompanying document are confidential and privileged. They are intended for the sole use of the addressee. If you receive this transmission in error, you are advised that any disclosure, copying, distribution, or the taking of any action in reliance upon the communication is strictly prohibited. Moreover, any such inadvertent disclosure shall not compromise or waive the attorney-client privilege as to this communication or otherwise. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by replying to this e-mail and by deleting the original message and any copies. Thank you Page 127 of 141 LittLe Lake Fire Protection District __________________________________________________________________________________________________ 1575 Baechtel Rd. Willits, California 95490 Chris Wilkes (707)459-6271 Fax (707)459-7898 Fire Chief January 27, 2021 Subject: Letter of Recommendation for Michelle Johnson Dear Ukiah City Council Members, It is a pleasure to be writing this letter of recommendation for Michelle Johnson. I have a first-hand understanding of the commitment, dedication, professionalism and complexities that come with being a city council member in todays political and social environment. I believe my understanding of a council members position adds validity to this recommendation. As the Fire Chief/Fire Marshall for the City of Willits I work directly with Michelle within the Community Development Department on a consistent basis. She is extremely professional and has a strong understanding of local and state process, and statutory requirements. Although these qualities are hard to find and are extremely beneficial to a municipality it is her other qualities that make her attractive as a city council member. Michelle knows how to listen, work as a team, understands economic development, but most of all, she has vision. If you put all of those factors together you end up with a council member that can achieve goals by establishing a vision based on the social and economic needs of your community all the while providing balance between the two. Based on my own experiences in the City of Willits, it is not often a qualified and dedicated person comes forward to run for a public office. I see the City of Ukiah as a growing community and the economic heart and soul of Mendocino County. Strong decisions being made from behind the dais by the elected or appointed city leaders benefits everyone in our county. For this reason, I strongly suggest the appointment of Michelle Johnson to your city council. You will not be left in regret over your decision. Sincerely, Chris Wilkes Fire Chief, LLFPD Page 128 of 141 Subject: Letter in support of Steve Scalmanini January 27, 2021 Dear Mayor Orozco and City Council members Brown, Crane and Duenas, I join others to recommend that Steve Scalmanini be appointed to the vacant seat on the Ukiah City Council. Steve’s energy is boundless, he is thorough, he is technical, he is compassionate, and he is devoted to the good of the community. He is sensitive to the needs of the less fortunate, working tirelessly to help establish better situations for unhoused among us. With his hands-on approach he is always there for the public good— with city-wide cleanups, with creek cleanups. In fair or foul weather, volunteers can count on Steve to do the heavy lifting. He is a vital cog in the wheels of Ukiah. The City of Ukiah is facing some difficult issues. For instance, the homeless situation mentioned above and the airport and its future. Steve is uniquely qualified to work with the other council members in figuring out the airport’s problems. The runways need expanding in a time when there is commercial pressure not to expand the runways. Something has to give. The problem requires experience as an elected official in Ukiah as well as technical knowhow to develop with other engineering council members an equitable solution for the community. Steve Scalmanini is the right person at this time to serve the City. Sincerely, Pinky Kushner Retired Professor 504 N. Oak St. Ukiah, CA 95482 510 459-8289 mobile Page 129 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Chuck Williams - Support for Susan Sher   From: Chuck Williams <chukwil@yahoo.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 4:53 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Susan Sher for council person  To Council members: Not everything in Ukiah is OK. In the past things have been swept under the rug until they explode in our face ( Sanitation District Lawsuit). Part of the job of council members is to oversight the staff. The tail should not be wagging the dog. Susan Sher can help in that area, plus she will add to the political and cultural balance of the council. Chuck Williams, 3 Betty St. Ukiah. Page 130 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Andrea Davis - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Andrea Davis <wrecodesign@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 4:37 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Email in support of Mari Rodin for City Council    Dear Councilmembers,  I am writing in support of Mari Rodin’s application to serve as a City Council Member for the City of Ukiah. As a friend  and active community member I have been aware of Mari’s dedicated and accomplished service to the community for  over fifteen years. Mari’s education, experience, and communication skills make her a fantastic candidate.  Mari has shown an ability to work well and collaboratively as a professional grant writer and as a City Council member.  Ukiah’s City Council has been very productive, and I believe this is largely due to Council members working well  together. It is critically important in these desperate times to ensure our elected representatives can work  collaboratively. With Mari there is no risk, her history on the Council is proof that she will be a strong, predictable and  reliable member of this team.  With one brand new member on the Council, and one with only a year’s experience, I believe it is critically important to  bring on an experienced Council member. Mari’s previous tenure as councilwoman included the financial challenges of  the 2007 – 2009 recession. Her leadership during those years makes her especially suited to govern during our current  situation.  As we collectively deal with the trauma and economic fall out of the pandemic, and as we set a path to  recovery, it is imperative that we do not take chances on unknown, or little‐known applicants. I urge you to take the  safest path and appoint Mari Rodin to serve our community as a Council member.     Thank you,  Andrea Davis  wrecodesign@gmail.com  707 272 8831  Page 131 of 141 DorothyGayle Haas 3451 Low Gap Rd. Ukiah, Ca To the members of the Ukiah City Council: I am writing in support of your appointing Susan Sher to the empty seat on the city council. I have known Susan for over 20 years as a friend, a parent, and as a lawyer and mediator. Susan has a bright and inquiring mind and is always seeking to find the deeper truths to the situations that she sees presented in our community and in the larger world. She is inquisitive and is able to ask questions in a manner that generally solicits truthful responses. Her training as both a lawyer and later as a mediator has taught her the skill of deep listening. Susan’s choosing to live and be involved in the Wagonseller neighborhood speaks to her ability to live in the “thick of it”. She has tirelessly worked for the betterment of her neighbors and neighborhood. Her commitment to “doing the right thing’ is evident in her everyday life, her parenting, and her professional commitments. I also want to add that Susan has a real sense of humor in the midst of it all, a very necessary ingredient when working in committee. Thank you for your consideration, dorothygayle Page 132 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Russell Green - Support for Michelle Johnson From: Russ Green <terminalc@gmail.com>   Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 7:33 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Letter of Support for Michelle Birdsall Johnson for city council seat.  To whom it may concern: My name is Russell Green. I am a 5th generation resident of mendocino county, and lifelong resident of Willits. I own along with my dad GlenMark Storage in willits and I founded Kure Wellness, among other things. I am writing you today to support Michelle Birdsall Johnson's application to finish out the two years of the open Ukiah city council seat. I have known Michelle for several years and feel that she is an asset to the city. She has been great to work with, always friendly, fair, and prudent. She cares about the communities that she serves. Although I don't want Willits to lose her, I support her endeavors and urge you to select her for this position, you won't regret it. Russell Green terminalc@gmail.com Page 133 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Jacqueline Lee - Support for Steve Scalmanini   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Jacqueline M Lee <jacquiegarden@icloud.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 10:16 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Steve Scalmanini     I would like to support Steve Scalmanini for the empty City Council seat. He is experienced and has served the City of  Ukiah well. The environment  and looking out for all the people are important to him.  Sincerely,    Jacqueline Lee  438 N Pine St  Ukiah, 95482    Sent from my iPhone  Page 134 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Linda Helland - Support for Steve Scalmanini   From: Linda Helland <linda_helland@yahoo.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 10:12 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Steve Scalmanini for Ukiah City Council Seat  Dear Council Members Duenas, Orozco, Brown, and Crane,    I respectfully urge you to appoint Steve Scalmanini to the open seat on the Ukiah City Council. Steve has put in  the time and effort to listen to his constituents deeply, to carry out the wishes of the majority of the residents  of Ukiah from his seat on the council. He and Mari Rodin both possess the experience and ability to continue  to serve the City in this capacity. The difference is that Steve ran for the Ukiah City Council in the November  election, and received the highest number of votes of those that have applied to be appointed to the position.  In that sense, Steve has earned this seat, and it would be unfair to appoint another candidate.     Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Linda Helland Page 135 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Kerry Levin - Support for Mari Rodin   From: Kerry Levin <hrsedoc@gmail.com>   Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 11:45 PM  To: Meeting <meeting@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City Council  I support Mari Rodin for a seat on the Ukiah City Council. Sincerely Kerry Levin DVM Ukiah California Page 136 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Stephen Groff - Support for Rodin and Scalmanini ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Stephen Groff <swgroff@icloud.com>   Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 11:52 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Support for Rodin and Scalmanini    Mari Rodin and Steve Scalmanini both have proven their skills and intentions in regards to serving our community at the  grass roots government level.  I worked on Mari’s campaign and supported Steve’s during their running for office.  They  both have my support in their chance to fill Mo Mulheren’s vacancy.    Respectfully,    Stephen Groff  175 Giorno Ave  Ukiah, Ca 95482  Page 137 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Kathleen Thomas and Luca Szabo - Support for Susan Sher   From: Kathleen Szabo <mitowoman@gmail.com>   Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 11:54 AM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Open City Council Seat  We are writing today in full support of Susan Sher for the open city council seat. We have known Susan to be responsible, tireless, tenacious and caring with the too often elusive balance of qualities of high intelligence and empathy. She is a fierce lover of humanity, of grassroots local neighborhood character and progress, of history and future, of the planet, and of people who don’t look or worship or sound like her. In the almost 9 years we have lived in the Wagonseller neighborhood we have seen all the many many actions she has contributed to make a positive difference in our community with one beautiful act of decency at a time. We have seen her personally reach out to every single resident of our neighborhood, old and new about issues that directly impact all of us. She understands that democracy is dialogue. Ms. Sher has and will continue to improve outcomes in public education, housing, infrastructure, health, climate change and workforce development through her deep commitment to our shared community standing tall. The fact that Ms. Sher has the full and unequivocal support of all 3 generations of our household; Boomer, Gen X and Z shows the full breadth of her capable reach and vision. Page 138 of 141 2 We humbly offer our highest endorsement of Susan Sher for City Council with Steve Scalmanini and Mari Rodin as second and third choice. Sincerely Thomas, Kathleen and Luca Szabo -- Kat Szabo Page 139 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Eileen Mitro - Support for Steve Scalmanini and Mari Rodin and Susan Sher   ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐  From: Eileen Mitro <eileenm234@gmail.com>   Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 3:49 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: City Council Appointment    Hi Kristin,    Please consider this my letter to advocate for the appointment of Steve Scalmanini or Mari Rodin, who have experience  as City Council members.  Susan Sher would also be a good appointment as she has had numerous board positions.  It is  a time to have someone with experience on the City Council as the General Plan and the final decisions on building  codes and zoning come before the council.    Thank you for passing this information on to the City Council.    Eileen Mitro  Ukiah, CA  234‐0380  Page 140 of 141 1 Kristine Lawler Subject:Correspondence Received - Cathy Anello - Support for Michelle Johnson   From: Cathy Anello <anellotax@gmail.com>   Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2021 6:36 PM  To: Kristine Lawler <klawler@cityofukiah.com>  Subject: Michelle B Johnson    To whom it may concern:      Hi!   My name is Catherine Anello. I am writing in support of Michelle Johnson's appointment to the Ukiah City Council  position that recently came open.    I am a small business owner of an Accounting and Tax firm here  in Ukiah, and have been a resident  for over 30 years.  I  was a neighbor of Michelle for several years and was always in awe of her parenting skills, her innate ability to juggle  work she is passionate about, and raise 5 outstanding children at the same time.     I also worked with her professionally at the Ukiah Athletic Club where her ability to motivate and help people has always  kept her students coming back for more.     I am writing in support of Michelle Johnson for City Council because I know she is tenacious and passionate about the  work she does. She has been an active volunteer in the community for many years and she brings great insight with her  years of experience to our local government.     I am very vocal in this community, and,  pre‐ COVID times,  I attended many City Council meetings with concerns about  many subjects, most recently the downtown streetscape project.  I welcome the fresh, open minded, skills and  knowledge  that I believe Michelle would bring to this position.   I am confident she is the right person for this job!      Sincerely,  Catherine Anello  Anello Tax Service  413 W Standley St   Ukiah, Ca 95482          Page 141 of 141