Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutmin 1975-04-16 a' MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH APRIL 16, 1975 - PAGE 1 The City Council convened in regular session in the Council Chambers at 8: 04 p.m. with Councilmen Norgard, Wood, Simpson and Mayor WeinkaufpresEn Councilwoman Pearson was absent. INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The Reverend Dr. Elmer Schmitt led in the invocation and Councilman Simpson led the Pledge of Allegiance. PROCLAMATION - REALTOR WEEK Mayor Weinkauf read a proclamation declaring the week of April 20th to 26th as Realtor Week. PAYROLL WARRANTS On a motion by Councilman Norgard, seconded by Councilman Simpson it was unanimously carried Payroll Warrants #1163 to #1351 inclusive for the period of March 23 to April 5, 1975 inclusive in the total amount of $77, 841. 97 be approved. GENERAL WARRANTS On a motion by Councilman Wood, seconded by Councilman Norgard it was unanimously carried General Warrants #858 to #1036 inclusive in the total amount of $268, 572. 27 be approved and ordered paid. FLUORIDATION HEARING City Manager reviewed a letter from the County Health Officer, Dr. R. L. Holtzer dated February 4th urging the City to fluoridate its water supply. Council considered subject matter at the meeting of March 5, 1975, and approved purchase of equipment to fluoridate the City' s water supply. Council action stimulated citizen interest which led to the need for further input on subject matter. The hearing scheduled at this time is for this purpose. The City Manager reviewed correspondence received from 12 individuals, including Ukiah Unified School District Health Advisory Council, the Mendocino Lake County Medical Society, Oak Manor Elementary School, and several doctors expressing the merits of fluoridation. Opposition to fluoridation of the water system was expressed from citizens who lived within and outside the city limits. Public hearing was declared open at 8 :11 p.m. The following persons present in the audience spoke in favor of the addition of fluoride to the city' s water system: Dr. Don Vidmar, 1230 South Dora Dr. Daniel Corrigan, State Department of Health Dr. John Myers, 1120 W. Standley Dr. Robert Werra, 721 South Dora 1. There is no possibility of poisoning from fluoride in small amounts. Some areas of the country have high concentration of � fluoride already in the water naturally. Nature has more than ade- quately proven that fluoride in the water is not harmful. 2. Fluoride not only controls cavities in children, but increases bone density in adults. 3. No disease has ever been linked to fluoride in the water. 4. Ukiah, as a municipal corporation would not be required to have an election on subject matter. In the case of a municipal water district, it would be necessary to have an election since no single body in said district makes the decisions. 5. Cost benefit: 67 million dollars is being paid to welfare recipients for denistry - millions of dollars in taxes could be saved if all areas of the state had fluoride in the water. MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH APRIL 16, 1975 - PAGE 2 6. Prevention is the logical approach - fluoridation reduces tooth decay. 7. March 17, 1975 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association contained an article wherein it states medical proof favors f lurodation� that fluoride can be added safely at the optimum level. The following persons present in the audience spoke in opposition to the addition of fluoride to the city' s water system: Dr. Matthew Howard, South Dora Rose Lewis Alice McClendon Charles Fielding, 1260 South State Street Stash Williams Tim Day, Redwood Valley-Petition placed on file with the Clerk. Ted Feibusch, Highland Avenue Mr. Cornwell, 1107 Church Walter Heady, Redwood Valley Elaine Dunn Pat Kinny, 700 E. Gobbi Charles Hays Warren Tribe 1. There is no good reason why government should force fluoridated water on those who do not want it. 2. Fluoride can be administered individually 3. Government does not have a right to force fluoride on the citizenry without a vote. 4. Harmf u 1 to the body. 5. Alternative ways to dispense without forcing on everyone. 6. Public agency has no right to be concerned over a private health matter. 7. Fluoridation causes mottling of the teeth. 8. It would be well for doctors to campaign against sugar instead of for fluoride - young children drink little water and large amounts of soft drinks. 9. It has not been proven that the U. S. Public Health Service has made an in depth study of fluoride before endorsing its use in water. 10. Fluoride causes or worsens many internal diseases 11. Fluoride has corrosive effect on pipes. 12. Fluoride delays eruption of teeth. 13 . Subject matter is not a matter of public health. 14. Put the efforts on purifying the water supply. Public hearing was closed at 9: 49 p.m. Councilman Wood stated he has listened to the pros and cons and is not overwhelmed by either. In his opinion subject matter is a political issue rather than an economic or medical issue. He stated after other Councilmen had expressed their thinking., he may introduce a motion to amend the budget to purchase subject equipment. Councilman Simpson stated he feels a responsibility to do the best for people of the city after being informed. He stated he tries to be consistent and referred to Council action on the formaldehyde issue When concern and fear was expressed by the citizens. In his opinion the same fear has been ex- pressed with fluoride; people should be able to choose. Councilman Norgard reported the City of Healdsburg has had fluo- ride in the city water for 20 years. There have been no com- plaints and no rust in the pipes. In his opinion, the benefits are so great that if Councilman Wood makes the aforementioned motion, he would second it. Mayor Weinkauf stated the benefits outweigh the negative aspects. MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH APRIL 16, 1975 - PAGE 3 On a motion by Councilman Wood, seconded by Councilman Norgard the following roll call vote to amend the budget and authorize the purchase of the necessary equipment to fluoridate the city's water supply resulted in a tie vote. AYES: Councilman Norgard and Mayor Weinkauf NOES: Councilman Wood and Councilman Simpson. The matter will be considered again when there is a full Council. M - m MAYOR WEINKAUF DECLARED A RECESS AT THIS POINT IN THE MEETING 10. 05 p. . JAPANESE STUDENT INTRODUCED Mr. Kruth, Director of Public Works, introduced Miss Kumiko Suzuki, American Field Service Exchange Student from Japan. Mie Suzuki is attending high school and living in the home of Dr. Fisher during her stay in the United States. Miss Suzuki was accompanied by Mrs. Annette Kruth who was attending the Council meeting for the first time. VARIANCE APPLICATION NO. 75-41 GEORGE F. WEEKS - 18 HIGHLAND DRIVE Subject variance application is a request to reduce minimum side yard from 5' to 4 ' to accommodate construction of partially en- closed carport. City Manager reviewed Planning Commission findings dated April 9, 1975, recommending approval of the application. There was no one present in the audience to speak concerning subject matter. Council action is set forth in the following resolution. RESOLUTION NO. 75-63 GRANTING VARIANCE TO GEORGE F. WEEKS On a motion by Councilman Simpson, seconded by Councilman Norgard it was unanimously carried Resolution No. 75-63 be adopted and the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to sign same, "Resolution Granting Variance To George Weeks" . INTRODUCTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 668 (UNIFORM BUILDING CODES) AND ORDINANCE NO. 669 (ICBO UNIFORM FIRE CODE), On a motion by Councilman Simpson, seconded by Councilman Norgard it was unanimously carried to introduce Ordinance No. 668, "An Ordinance Of The City Council Of The City Of Ukiah Repealing And Amending Certain Chapters And SEctions Of Division 3 Of The Ukiah City Code (Building Regulations) " and Ordinance No. 669 , "An Ordinance Of The City Council Of The City Of Ukiah Repealing Chapter 3 Of Division 6 Of The Ukiah City Code And Adding A New Division 6 To The Ukiah City Code Adopting By Reference The 1973 Uniform Fire Code: Also Renumbering Chapter 4 of Division 6" . APPROVAL OF REQUEST FROM CHAMBER OF COMMERCE FOR FUNDS FOR DOWNTOWN STUDY The Downtown Revitalization Committee of the Chamber of Commerce requested funds in the amount of $200 to match equal amounts already allocated by the Chamber of Commerce and Downtown Merchants Association. Subject funds will be utilized for a study of the needs of the downtown area by Architects, Max Kappeler and Bob Axt. Mr. Lee Enemark, representing the Revitalization Committee was present in the audience and spoke concerning the needs of the downtown area for parking, traffic control, landscaping, store front design and sign ordinances. The study is expected to be completed in 1 1/2 months. Mr. Ted Feibusch was present in the audience and voiced his objection to the proposed expenditure. In his opinion each business- man should finance his own improvements; not depend on taxpayers money to do it for them. MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH APRIL 16, 1975 - PAGE 4 On a motion by Councilman Wood, seconded by Councilman Simpson it was unanimously carried to contract in an amount of $200 for a report and recommendation from the Revitalization Committee of the Chamber of Commerce for a study of the needs of the downtown area. OFFER OF PROPERTY REFERRED TO PARKS & RECREATION COMMISSION i Correspondence from Dr. Bernarr Johnson inquired of the City' s interest in a 10 acre parcel of land south of town for a proposed park site at a price of $60, 000. Council expressed concern with the potential high maintenance cost, current budget status, possible cooperation of school district with City for costs, and the need for input from the Parks and Recreation Commission. On a motion by Councilman Simpson seconded by Councilman Wood it was unanimously carried to refer the proposal from Dr. Johnson to the Parks and Recreation Commission along with the concerns registered by the Council. CLAIM FOR DAMAGES DENIED ALICE Y. THORNHILL, 1000 W. PERKINS On a motion by Councilman Simpson, seconded by Councilman Wood it was unanimously carried to deny the claim in the amount of $351. 78 filed by Alice Thornhill and refer same to the insurance carrier. CLAIM FOR DAMAGES DENIED MRS. LILLIAN ALBERTI, 460 E. GOBBI On a motion by Councilman Norgard, seconded by Councilman Wood it was unanimously carried to deny the claim in the amount of $44. 00 filed by Mrs. Lillian Alberti and refer same to the insur- ance carrier. RESOLUTION NO. 75-64 AMENDING PAY PLAN & CLASSIFICATION PLAN BY ADDING POSITION OF DEPUTY POLICE CHIEF On a motion by Councilman Norgard, seconded ''by Councilman Wood, it was unanimously carried Resolution No. 75-64 be adopted and the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to sign same, "A Resolution Of The City Council Of The City Of Ukiah Amending The Pay Plan Dated July 1, 1975, And The Classification Plan By Adding Position Of Deputy Police Chief" . BID AWARD FOR POLES TO MCCORMICK & BAXTER BID AWARD FOR CROSS ARMS TO OESER CEDAR CO. City Manager reviewed bids received for subject equipment and recommended bid be awarded to the low bidder. 24-45' Class 4 Poles-Fir 100-8 ' Cross Arms McCormick & Baxter '53649.29 $1269. 00 B.J. Carney & Co. 3972. 00 1240. 00 Oeser Cedar Co. 3926. 40 40._00 Koppers Co. 3724 . 80 1240. 00 Pacific Tank & Pipe No Bid 1204. 00 J. H. Baxter Bid not signed On a motion by Councilman Norgard, seconded by Councilman Simpson it was unanimously carried the bid for poles be awarded to McCormick and Baxter in the amount of $3649. 20 and the bid for cross arms be awarded to Oeser Cedar Company in the amount of $1040. 00. MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH APRIL 16, 1975 - PAGE 5 APPROVAL OF CONTRACT FOR ENGINEERING POST, BASHFORD AND ASSOCIATES, INC. FORD STREET BRIDGE PROJECT Subject project is an approved project from AB 325 Tax Funds. The City has received approximately one third of the estimated project costs for development of the plans and specifications, and the balance of project costs have been requested from 325 funds now accumulating and for which the City is eligible. Proposals from three local Engineering Consultants to provide the required design and construction engineering services has been requested. Analysis of the two proposals received has been made. It was recommended the proposal from Post, Bashford and Associates be accepted. On a motion by Councilman Norgard, seconded by Councilman Simpson it was unanimously carried to accept the proposal of Post, Bashford and Associates as consulting engineers for design of the Ford Street Bridge,as recommended by the Director of Public Works. REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY IMPLEMENTATION Council had been provided with resolutions that would provide operating funds and establish a survey area for the Redevelopment Agency. There is an urgency in completing the Redevelopment Plan by the statutory date of August 19th so we will not lose a full year of tax increment. Outside resources will be needed to meet this deadline. It was recommended to retain three consultants on the basis of charges based on time and materials with a maximum expenditure limit established by Council. Mr. Ted Feibusch was present in the audience and voiced his objections to the establishment of the redevelopment agency. He referred to the experience cities in the Bay Area have had where redevelopment costs have gone millions of dollars beyond the original cost.&Feibusch pleaded with the Council to forget the matter and let free enter- prise take its course. Mr. Lee Enemark, Book Revue stated downtown merchants main impetus came from what Mr. Feibusch has done by restoring buildings in the downtown area - the redevelopment agency will assist in this area as well as providing parking and enhancing the general beauty of the area. The City Manager explained the Agency is the Council; it is not replacing the Council. It was also pointed out that the ordinance establishing a redevelopment agency was introduced several months ago. At that time it was determined that public hearings be scheduled to give merchants in the area an opportunity to voice their objections, if any. The public hearings were held, after which the ordinance was adopted. The next order of business sets forth Council determination of subject matter. RESOLUTION NO. 75-65 AUTHORIZING LOAN TO UKIAH REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY On a motion by Councilman Simpson, seconded by Councilman Wood, it was unanimously carried Resolution No. 75-65 be adopted and the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to sign same, "Resolution Of The City Council Of The City Of Ukiah Authorizing Loan To Ukiah Redevelppment Agency." RESOLUTION NO. 75-66 ESTABLISHING REDEVELOPMENT SURVEY AREA On a motion by Councilman Simpson, seconded by Councilman Wood, It was unanimously carried Resolution No. 75-66 be adopted and the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to sign same, "Resolution Of The City Council Of The City Of Ukiah Establishing Redevelopment Survey Area". ..................... ... ... MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH APRIL 16, 1975 - PAGE 6 AUTHORIZATION TO RETAIN CONSULTANTS FOR REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY On a motion by Councilman Simpson, seconded by Councilman Wood it was unanimously carried to authorize the City Manager to schedule a meeting and have the necessary documents to enter into an agreement with Genge Consultants, Ms. Donna Vaiano, and Attorney Joseph E. Coomes with the understanding the work will i commence April 17, 1975. REQUEST & AUTHORIZATION TO CALL FOR BIDS FOR TWO POLICE VEHICLES On a motion by Councilman Norgard, seconded by Councilman Wood it was unanimously carried the Clerk be authorized to call for bids for two police vehicles, bids to be received prior to 2 : 00 p.m. May 13, 1975. COUNCILMAN SIMPSON Councilman Simpson reported favorable comments regarding the looks of the city as a result of the sidewalk construction pro- ject. COUNCILMAN WOOD Councilman Wood stated a possibility of a no quorum meeting the second meeting in May due to a League meeting in Sacramento re- sulting in the absence of some members of the Council. GOLF PRO Mr. Bill Clarke, a member of the ad hoc committee of the Mens Golf Club was present in the audience to speak on the matter of renewing the contract with the Golf Pro. Mr. Clarke re- quested Council reconsider the matter by receiving input from the Recreation and Parks Commission and allow a hearing so the' f acts of the matter can be weighed again. Council discussion of the matter continued in closed personnel session. ADJOURNMENT Mayor Weinkauf adjourned the meeting at 11 : 25 p.m. after which the Council reconvened in Closed Personnel Session. Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk