HomeMy WebLinkAboutpcm_05082013 1 UKIAH PLANNING COMMISSION
2 May 8, 2013
3 Minutes
4
5 COMMISSIONERS PRESENT COMMISSIONERS ABSENT
6 Kevin Doble Laura Christensen
7 Linda Sanders
8 Mike Whetzel
9 Judy Pruden, Chair
10
11 STAFF PRESENT OTHERS PRESENT
12 Kim Jordan, Senior Planner Listed below, Respectively
13 Jennifer Faso, Associate Planner
14 Cathy Elawadly, Recording Secretary
15
16 1. CALL TO ORDER
17 The regular meeting of the City of Ukiah Planning Commission was called to order by
18 Chair Pruden at 6:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Ukiah Civic Center, 300 Seminary Avenue,
19 Ukiah, California.
20
21 2. ROLL CALL
22
23 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Everyone cited.
24
25 4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES — The minutes from the April 10, 2013 and April 24, 2013 will be
26 available for review at the May 22, 2013 meeting.
27
28 5. COMMENTS FROM AUDIENCE ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS
29
30 6. APPEAL PROCESS — Chair Pruden read the appeal process. For matters at this meeting, the
31 final date to appeal is May 20, 2013.
32
33 7. SITE VISIT VERIFICATION - Confirmed by Commission.
34
35 8. VERIFICATION OF NOTICE - Confirmed by staff.
36
37 9. PRESENTATION
38 9A. Mendocino County Public Health Presentation on the Relationship between Greenhouse
39 Gas Emissions and Public Health. Mendocino County Public Health presentation on the
40 relationship between greenhouse gas emissions reduction methods and improved health of the
41 community. This presentation is a follow-up to the City of Ukiah Municipal and Community
42 Greenhouse Gas Emissions (GHG) and Climate Action Plan (CAP) workshop held on April 24t"
43 This presentation addresses the relationship between GHG emissions, CAP strategies, and
44 impacts on public health.
45
46 Staff from Mendocino County Public Health (Jessica Stull-Otto, Senior Program Specialist, Kristin
47 Fladseith, Senior Public Health Analyst, and Tina Tyler-O'Shea, Program Administrator) gave a
48 presentation on the relation between Greenhouse Gas Emissions (GHG) and the corresponding impacts
49 on public health the contents of which are incorporated into the minutes as Attachment 1.
50
51 Commissioner Sanders:
52 • Referred to item 4C, Indicators, Improve Air and Water Quality, stormwater runoff: 5% of projects
53 are required to implement LID treatment mechanisms (County) and 10% of projects include LID
54 treatment mechanisms (Fort Bragg) and inquired about the target/desired outcome of 100% of
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2013
Page 1
1 new development projects utilize LID techniques, when feasible by 2012. Is not clear when
2 feasible is utilized.
3 • What is the status of the County's stormwater ordinance?
4
5 Mendocino County Public Health:
6 • The aforementioned was a target the City of Fort Bragg selected. Has no knowledge what the
7 City of Fort Bragg considers feasible, but the matter of new development projects utilizing LID
8 techniques is something Fort Bragg wanted to adopt.
9 • The County's stormwater ordinance is being worked on.
10
11 Chair Pruden:
12 • A public member indicated the survey related to GHG emissions and Climate Action Plan (CAP)
13 on the City's Website was problematic.
14
15 Senior Planner Jordan:
16 • Accessed the survey from the website today without any problems. According to the consultant
17 there have been 100 responses as of Monday afternoon. A person can complete a hard copy if
18 he/she is having problems with the online survey.
19
20 Chair Pruden:
21 • Related to CEQA and now having to address GHG emissions in environmental reports, supports
22 this becomes an element in the General Plan. Is of the opinion this would be the best and most
23 effective mechanism of bringing GHG emissions and climate change to the `forefront' such that
24 when developments are being considered the information/criteria is in place to determine whether
25 or not a project is consistent with the General Plan.
26
27 10. OLD BUSINESS
28 10A. Verizon Wireless Use Permit and Site Development Permit Condition Compliance, 1200
29 Hasting Road (Elks Lodge). On October 24, 2012, Planning Commission approved a Use
30 Permit and Site Development Permit to allow the construction and operation of a wireless
31 telecommunications facility (WTF) with a tree-pole to return to Planning Commission for review
32 and approval. The applicant has submitted the required plans and details from Planning
33 Commission review and consideration. Please Note: The appeal period for the approval of the
34 Use Permit and Site Development Permit has expired. The scope of the public meeting is limited
35 to condition compliance related to the tree-pole design.
36
37 Senior Planner Jordan advised applicant, Jay Gruendle of On Air Communications is available to
38 answer questions the Commission may have.
39
40 Chair Pruden:
41 • Was able to observe a cell tree pole having a Redwood tree design being erected among the live
42 Redwood trees in Windsor and noted the cell tower was not visible/obtrusive among all the
43 Redwoods.
44 • Is pleased with and approves of the sample board provided by the applicant. The design of the
45 tree-pole is substantially the same as the tree-pole WTF located on the west side of Highway 101
46 south of Arata Lane in Windsor.
47 • Requested clarification the same model is the one the Commission liked at the October 24, 2012
48 meeting.
49
50 Jay Gruendle, applicant/agent for Verizon Wireless:
51 • Confirmed the model is the same. Cell Trees, Inc. was used for Windsor and is also the vendor
52 selected by Verizon for this project.
53 • At the time of the previous meeting, Verizon had not yet selected the vendor, so could not provide
54 this information to the Commission.
55
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2013
Page 2
1 Commissioner Sanders:
2 • Inquired about when the natural trees around the tree-pole grow to the same height or above,
3 what happens to those trees? Is the applicant able to have the natural trees cut down because
4 they are interfering with cell phone reception for customers?
5
6 Jay Gruendle: Nothing happens to the natural trees. When the pole is sited, the location accounts for the
7 existing trees. The antennas are located in a way that they are not blocked by the trees and the 'line of
8 sight' is maintained. The primary service area for this project is downtown and the siting of the antennas
9 accounts for this.
10
11 M/S Whetzel/Doble to approve Verizon Wireless Use Permit and Site Development Permit Condition
12 Compliance. Motion carried (3-0) with Commissioner Sanders abstaining and Commissioner Christensen
13 absent.
14
15 PUBLIC HEARING
16
17 11A. Food Depot Use Permit for Outside Sales and Display, 350 North Orchard Avenue (Home
18 Deport). Planning Commission consideration and possible action on a Use Permit to allow the
19 daily operation of a stationary food vendor with picnic tables and umbrellas at 350 North Orchard
20 Avenue (Home Depot).
21
22 Associate Planner Faso: Presented the staff report.
23
24 Commissioner Sanders: How long has Food Depot been operating?
25
26 Mark Barra, applicant:
27 • Is the owner of Food Depot that has been operating since November 2, 2012.
28 Chair Pruden:
29 • Had lunch yesterday at Food Depot and thought food was very good.
30 • Likes the project and approves of the location for the business.
31 PUBLIC HEARING OPENED: 6:44 p.m.
32
33 PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED: 6:44 p.m.
34
35 M/S Doble/Sanders to approve Food Depot Use Permit for Outside Sales and Display, 350 North
36 Orchard Avenue (Home Depot)with Findings 1-6 and Conditions of Approval 1-21. Motion carried (4-0).
37
38 USE PERMIT FINDINGS TO ALLOW
39 A FOOD VENDOR TO OPERATE OUTSIDE
40 350 NORTH ORCHARD AVENUE, APN 002-370-26
41 FILE NO: 12-21-UP-PC
42
43 The following findings are supported by and based on information contained in this staff report, the
44 application materials and documentation, and the public record.
45
46 1. The proposed project, as conditioned, is consistent with the goals and policies of the General
47 Plan as described in the staff report and Table 1.
48
49 2. The proposed project meets the parking requirements of the zoning code in that the project will
50 provide.
51
52 3. The project approved with conditions would be compatible with surrounding uses based on the
53 following:
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2013
Page 3
1 A. The project site is located within an existing commercial area and would be accessory to
2 an existing permitted use.
3 B. The proposed food vendor project would not change the existing use of the site.
4 C. The primary customers of the proposed food vendor would be customers who are already
5 on the site and therefore there would not be a significant in traffic in the area.
6 D. The hours of operation for the food vendor would not extend past the hours of operation
7 of the existing Home Depot therefor the project would not have an additional impact of
8 the surrounding neighborhood.
9
10 4. The project would not be detrimental to the public's health, safety and general welfare based on the
11 following:
12
13 A. The proposed project would have similar hours of operation as the existing Home Depot
14 and therefore the surrounding neighbors are already familiar with the operations of the
15 existing commercial business and would not be additionally impacted.
16 B. The parking and circulation on the site would not change as a result of this project
17 because the food vendor trailer is accessory to the main use on the site, and would not
18 be located within existing vehicle or pedestrian circulation areas.
19 C. The project would be required to adhere to all standard city requirements, including the
20 City's noise ordinance and City's Commercial Property Maintenance requirements.
21 D. The project has been reviewed by the Fire Marshal, Police Department, Building Official,
22 and Public Works and any review comments from these departments have been included
23 as conditions of approval.
24 E. The project is required to comply with all federal, state and local laws, including the
25 Commercial Property Maintenance requirements.
26
27 5. The proposed project is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act
28 (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15303 (e), New construction and Conversion of Small Structures
29 accessory structures based on the following:
30
31 A. The proposed food vendor would be accessory to the existing commercial business.
32 B. The location is not environmentally sensitive and no drainage courses or bodies of water
33 (such as creeks or streams)are located on the site.
34 C.
35
36 6. Notice of the proposed project was provided in the following manner as required by the Zoning
37 Ordinance:
38
39 A. posted in three places on the project site on April 25, 2013;
40 B. mailed to property owners within 300 feet of the project site on April 25, 2013; and
41 C. published in the Ukiah Daily Journal on April 28, 2013.
42
43 USE PERMIT CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
44 TO ALLOW A FOOD VENDOR TO OPERATE OUTSIDE
45 350 NORTH ORCHARD AVENUE, APN 002-370-26
46 FILE NO: 12-21-UP-PC
47
48 1. Approval is granted for Use Permit 12-21-UP-PC to allow a food vendor to operate outside of the
49 Home Depot located at 350 North Orchard Avenue on a daily basis. Approval is granted for this
50 use permit as described in the project description dated March 22, 2013 and shown on the site
51 plan dated March 22, 2013, except as modified by the following conditions of approval.
52 2. The food vendor shall have the following operating characteristics:
53 A. Daily operation of a stationary food trailer
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2013
Page 4
1 B. Hours of operation shall be Monday through Saturday 6:00 am to 10 pm and Sunday
2 7:OOamto8pm
3 C. One full time employee and two part time employees
4 D. Three outside picnic tables with umbrellas
5 E. One sign located on the front of the food trailer
6 F. Seasonal barbeque
7
8 3. A sign permit is required for installation of sign on the front of the food trailer
9 4. Prior to commencement of business a City business license is required.
10 5. All outdoor dining furnishings and all exterior surfaces within the outdoor dining area shall be
11 easily cleanable and kept clean and free of debris.
12 6. The outdoor dining area shall be kept in a clean and safe condition.
13 7. The food vendor trailer and outdoor tables shall not encroach into any area designated for vehicle
14 or pedestrian circulation.
15 8. The food vendor shall not operate when Home Depot is not open for business.
16 From the Fire Marshall (Chuck Yates 463-6264�
17
18 9. Existing kitchen suppression system needs servicing every six months.
19
20 10. Portable fire extinguisher is required: Classification 2:A10:BC extinguisher (California Code of
21 Regulations, Title 19, Sec. 508, table 2 and 3)
22
23 11. Class "K"extinguisher must be hung
24 12. Fire extinguishers require annual inspections.
25
26 Standard Citv Conditions of Approval
27 13. This approval is not effective until the 10 day appeal period applicable to this Use Permit has
28 expired without the filing of a timely appeal. If a timely appeal is filed, the project is subject to the
29 outcome of the appeal and shall be revised as necessary to comply with any modifications,
30 conditions, or requirements that were imposed as part of the appeal.
31 14. Business operations shall not commence until all permits required for the approved use,
32 including but not limited to business license, tenant improvement building permit, have been
33 applied for and issued/finaled.
34 15. No permit or entitlement shall be deemed effective unless and until all fees and charges
35 applicable to this application and these conditions of approval have been paid in full.
36 16. The applicant shall obtain and maintain any permit or approval required by law, regulation,
37 specification or ordinance of the City of Ukiah and other Local, State, or
38 Federal agencies as applicable. All construction shall comply with all fire, building, electric,
39 plumbing, occupancy, and structural laws, regulations, and ordinances in effect at the time the
40 Building Permit is approved and issued.
41 17. In addition to any other condition imposed, any construction shall comply with all
42 building, fire, electric, plumbing, occupancy, and structural laws, regulations and ordinances in
43 effect at the time the Building Permit is approved and issued.
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2013
Page 5
1 18. A copy of all conditions of this Use Permit Amendment shall be provided to and be binding upon
2 any future purchaser, tenant, or other party of interest.
3 19. All conditions of approval that do not contain specific completion periods shall be completed prior
4 to commencement of services allowed by this use permit amendment.
5 20. This Use Permit may be revoked through the City's revocation process if the approved project
6 related to this Permit is not being conducted in compliance with these stipulations and conditions
7 of approval; or if the project is not established within two years of the effective date of this
8 approval; or if the established use for which the permit was granted has ceased or has been
9 suspended for 24 consecutive months.
10
11 21. This approval is contingent upon agreement of the applicant and property owner and their agents,
12 successors and heirs to defend, indemnify, release and hold harmless the City, its agents,
13 officers, attorneys, employees, boards and commissions from any claim, action or proceeding
14 brought against any of the foregoing individuals or entities, the purpose of which is to attack, set
15 aside, void or annul the approval of this application. This indemnification shall include, but not be
16 limited to, damages, costs, expenses, attorney fees or expert witness fees that may be asserted
17 by any person or entity, including the applicant, arising out of or in connection with the City's
18 action on this application, whether or not there is concurrent passive or active negligence on the
19 part of the City. If, for any reason any portion of this indemnification agreement is held to be void
20 or unenforceable by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remainder of the agreement shall
21 remain in full force and effect.
22
23 12. PLANNING DIRECTOR'S REPORT
24 Senior Planner Jordan: There will be a Planning Commission meeting on May 22.
25
26 13. PLANNING COMMISSIONERS' REPORT
27 Commissioner Sanders:
28 • The Department of Fish and Game Watershed Stewards are doing a vegetative workday near the
29 Assembly of God Church at Gibson Creek on May 25th beginning with registration at 9:30 a.m.
30 with the workday ending at 2:00 p.m. Lunch will be provided.
31 • Encourages the public to participate.
32
33 Chair Pruden:
34 • Related to the new City electrical substation at Gobbi Street and Orchard Avenue, it was her
35 understanding there would be brochures for the Interpretive Garden and noted there is none.
36
37 Senior Planner Jordan: The Electric Department has not requested a final on the project, so this item
38 has not been completed. It does need to be completed prior to final.
39
40 14. ADJOURNMENT
41 There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 6:50 p.m.
42
43
44 Cathy Elawadly, Recording Secretary
45
46
47
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION May 8, 2013
Page 6
e�#fi�c��r��n� �
4 Strategic Areas t+� educe reenhouse Gas Emissions
❖ Transportation and Land Use: SmarE Growth
• Smart Grawfh means building communities with housing and transportation
chaices near jobs,shops and schools.
• Complete Streets is an important element of Smart �rowth that involves streets
designed for all kinds of travelers, including pedestrians, cyclists, transit users,
and the disabled. Changes ta street design like enlarging sidewalks, installing '
medians and adding bike lanes are simple but yield huge reductions in tratfic
accidents and`fatalities.
• A compact community designed to be easier to get around ailows peapie to more
easily incorporate physical activity into their daily lives.
• More trips made by foot, bike, and public transit means`less greenhouse gases
and particutate matter* better water quality,'and fewer motor vehrcle accidents.
*Particulate matter is caused by power plants, gasoline and diesel engines, wood '
combustion, driving on dirt roads, high temperature industrial'processes such'as
smelters and steel mills, and forest fires:
❖ Energy consumption produces greenhouse gases and particulate matterthrough
the burning of fossil fuels. Energy efFiciency and conservation can decrease their
production.
❖ Water Conservation: water use requires electricity; electricity is produced through
the burning of fossil fuels. By conserving water, less electricity is consumed, and
less greenhouse gases are praduced.
❖ Waste Management: waste dispasal burns fossil fuels through have to transport
waste ta a IandfilL The production of greenhouse gases and particulate matter from
this pracess can be minimized through improved waste management.
• Recycling reduces greenhouse gases by avoiding the ene'rgy used during the
e�ctraction and processing af virgin raw materials to manufacture new praducts.
• Composting reduces greenhouse gas emissions by reducing waste at landfills
• Reducing tandfill reduces the amount of inethane—a potent greenhouse gas—
released into the atmosphere.
HQ GR -ENH�U E GA E I SI�N I PACT H ALTH
Gt"eel1hOUSe Gases {GNGs) are principally caused by burning fossil fuels sueh as coal,
natural gas and petroleum. Other causes'include deforestation and methane emitted fram
landfiils. Burning fossil fuels in cars, power plants, industry and hames accounts for 75% of
human-caused greenhause gas emissions.
Increased greenhause gas emissions leads to climate change. Climate change has the
fallowing direct health impacts:
• Cardiovascular Disease: heat stress increases the body burden of airborne
particulates; extreme cold and extreme heat directly afFect the incidence of hospital
admissians for chest pain, acute coronary syndrome, strake, and variations in cardiac
dysrhythmias.
• Cancer: increased duration and intensity af ultraviolet (UV) radiation leads to an
increase in skin cancers;heavy precipitation and flooding events may increase the
chance of taxic contaminatian leaks from storage facilities or runoff into water from land
containing toxic pollutants:
• Mental Health: displacement of populatians, damage to property, loss af loved ones,
and chranic stress can negatively affect mental health
• Infectious Disease: accelerated spread of disease primarily because warmer
temperatures enlarge the geographic range in which disease-carrying animals, insects
and microorganisms-as well as the germs and viruses they carry-can survive.
• Respiratory bisease: increased exposure to pollen {due to altered growing seasons),
molds (from extreme or more frequent precipitation), air pollution and aerosolized marine
toxins (due#o increased temperature, coastal runoff, and humidity) and dust (from
droughts).
Strategi�s to reduce greenhouse gas emissions have the fallowing indirect health
impacts�
• Diabetes: increased physical activity from transportation and land use changes
decreases the risk of diabetes
• Obesity: increased physical activity from transportatian and land use changes decreases
the risk af obesity and associated conditions, including cancer, cardiovascular disease, !
respiratory illness, and depression
• Access to Health Services: transpartation and land use changes can allaw residents to
more easily access health services
• Traffic-Related lnjuries and Death: transportation and land use changes can allow
residents to engage in more active modes of transportation (walking, bicycling); fewer
miles traveled by car reduces traffiic-related injuries and death
• Low Birth Weight: pregnant women with cardiovascular disease or exposure to high '
levels of particulate matter have an inereased risk of low birth weight babies
� � � � �
� tU � �� t� N CCS ' � ��
� � s,� t� tU � � �.1 � � � � N
� ,� ' � �N ' � , �N � � � � � � � � �
� -� � � � ,� t!� � � � � .tn � .ti�' `�
� C� � � U a�a N�' v� � ,� ' � C� a� t� �
� � � � � �
cC ~ � .°
-F--+ "��
U
t�
�
�
—
.
� �
.
Cn �
�
�
� w
�
.
�
:
' 4G. INDICATCIRS
Note: Preliminary baseline data are provided to the extent possible.An early task of the
Coordinator will be to research and assign definitive baseline measures for a11 indicators.
Improve Air Particulate matter(PM-10); PM101evels(19.6 Decrease Particulate Matter 10%by 2018.
and Water Ukiah,2008, 21.6 FB,2010)(cifydata.com) Reduce the number of days PM-10 exceeds
Quality ' the state standard
GHG emissions:95,865 MTCO2E in 2007(Fort
Bragg). Decrease GHG emissions by 15%by 2018
and by 20%by 2Q23.
Stormwater runoff:5%of projects are required to '
implement LID treatment mechanisms(Caunty) 10Q%of new development projects utilize �ID
and 10%of projects include�ID treatment techniques,when feasible,by 2012.
mechanisms(Fort Bragg):
Reduce Waste: In 2006,the waste sector Develap zero waste ordinance by 2018.
generated 4,Q86 MTCO2E, representing 3%of all
community GHG emissions:Wastewater ,
treatment facility generated 326 MTCO2E
Promote Pubiic Walkability and Bikability:Walkedlbikedlskated to Increase%of youth that walk or bike to school
Health or#rom schaol in past week in 2009: 50.2%o to>52%by 2020.
(CH/S) '
Pedestrian and motor vehicle injuries: Hospitalized Decrease hospitalized pedestrian injuries to
pedestnan injuries 2009: 7/year and hospitalized <5/year by 2020. '
motor vehicle occupant injuries 2009:59/year. Decrease hospitalized mator vehicle injuries to '
<55/year by 2020.
Population with asthma:Total population ever '
diagnosed with asthma 2009: 14.1% (CH/S) Decrease those diagnosed with asthma ta
<9%by 2020.
Overweightiabese population:Overweight or
obese adults, 2009:61.6%o and overweight or Decrease%overweight/abese adults to�57% '
obese law-income children in 2009:45:6°10(CHIS, and low-income childrento<42%by 2020. '
kidsdata.or
Promote Equity Energy audits and incentives:Current program for Increase access to energy audits and energy
weatherizatian assistance for low income efficiency improvements for low-income
(Caunty-Wide) (North Goast Energy Services); households. '
Green Business Program provides energy audits
far businesses(CountyiUkiah). (Ecanomic
Development and Financing Corporation)
Transportatian barriers: in 2006, 14.8%of Decrease%reporting transportation as a
, Mendocino County residents cited transportation problem in meeting health needs to<�0°10 by '
as a barrier to meeting health needs(California 2020.
Center for Rural Policy, Humboldt State
Universi
Increasing Affordable housing stock: Housing supply meets Increased number and variety of affordable ;
Housing regional Housing Needs Allocation for extremely housing. '
Affordability low,very law, and low income households:
Percent income spent on housing:47.1%of Reduce the proportion of those spending
mortgage holders spent>35°l0 of income on >35%0 of income on'housing to 40%for
housing in 2008-2010,as did 50.�%of renters mortgage holders and to 43%for renters by
(U.S. Census Bureau,American Community 2020.
Surve .
Promote Infill Mixed use and clustered development: <10%of Inerease mixed use and clustered '
Compact projects utilize compact development(Ukiah and development to 20%by 2020. '
Develo ment Fort Bra .
Revitalize Perception of safety:78:3%of Mendocino County Increase percentage of adults who feel safe in
Urban and adultsfielt safe in their neighborhoods 2009 their neighborhootls all of the time to>85%
Community (CHIS) by 2020.
Centers
Commercial occupancy rates:ln Ukiah,the July Increase percentage of downtown commercial
occupancy rate for office and retail properties buildings that are occupied,to 95%by 2020.
downtown was 88.8%. (Left a message at Main
Street Pro ram
Protect Natural Resource protection:60%of applicable projects 100%of future development projects
ResourceslAgri incorporate adequate protection measures. incarporate natural resource protections.
cultural Lands
Acres of farmland: In 2007,608,674 acres of land There will be no net loss af farm acreage in
were farms(USDA Mendocino by 2015.
http:/Iwww:agcensus.ustla:govlPublications12007tOniine_Highlig htslG
ounty_Profileslindex:asp .
Reduce Auto Vehicle Miles per Person per Day(VMT):VMT= Reduction in VMT by 10°/o by 2020.
Usage and 2$ miles per day.`
Fuel Decrease%o of commuters driving alone to
Consumption Percent of commuters driving alone: 69:5%o in <60%a by 2020. Number of people wha use
2006-2008(American Community Survey). alternative method of transportation at least
one day per week-Marie '
GHG emissions:64 MTCO2E per year in gasoline
and diesel related emissions Fort Bra . Reduction of 45 MTCO2E b 2015.
Improve ldentified infrastructure improvements: Capital 100%of new prajects are ranked according to
Infrastructure improvement programs do not currently consider GHG emissions and energy use criteria.
Systems GHG emissions,energyefficiency,etc.
Parks acres per resident: In 201Q Fort Bragg and Increase park acres per 1,000 residents to>3
Ukiah qualified as"park deficienY', having<3 throughout the county and ail Cities by 2020.
acres of parkland per 1,000 residents, as did
several unincor orated towns.
Promote Water Per capita water consumption: 234 gpd per person Reduce per capita water use by 2-3°/a by 2015
Conservation (Ukiah Valley)(Water Supply Assessment for the and by 20°lo by 202Q
Ukiah Valley Area Plan, Ocf. 2010); 188.9
(Mendocino County,2008)(aquanomics.com) Reduce to 145 gpd by 2020(Fort Bragg).
150 9pd per person(Fort Bra99)�City of FB}.
Reduce agricuitural water usage by 10% by
Agricultural water usage:25,669 acre-feet utilized 2020.
central inland area .
Promote Residential energy consumption: 115GWlyear Reduce residential energy consumption by
Energy (Ukiah). 20°/a by 2q20(based on fixture standards}.
Efficiency and
Conservation LEED certified buildings: 1 building in Fart Bragg,0 Increase percentage of new development that
in Ukiah. is LEED certified to �5°lo by 2015.
City operational energy use: 12,571 MMBtu in Fort Decrease total energy use by 15%by 2018
Bragg. and by 30% by 2033(total reduction of 3,770 '
MMBtu . ,
Strengthen the City sales tax revenue: In 2009,the sales tax Increase sales tax revenues by 15%above '
Economy revenues collected in Ukiah and Fort Bragg were baseline by 2015.
$3,558,18D and$1,273,165. '
Percent of households earning a living wage: In Increase percent af households earning above '
2009, 61.3°l0 of Mendocino County households the self-sufficiency standard to 65%by 202D.
earned wages above the self-sufficiency standard ,
(Insight Center for Community Economic Increase amount of land zoned for mixed use
�eV@�OpCT1211t http;!/www.insightcced.orglintlex.php?page=ca- fC0�T1—t0—by--
sss '
. 5/8/2013
Sustainable Communities
' ��� �,� U��,��, ��������;� �
e ������� `���.� ��� �"��� '
�.�,��„ �>,� � ����i������ v< �� �� "
�
��� � �s�a� �I��1�� '� ° � �. � ��
��� � � ��� �� � � ���� �
s �
�
� �" � 4 � t �,m�,+ w��. � �o ��
.�,`^� r s� «� � a� . 4���
4
��M � ,y �
e ��� ` �. e� �... ,���dP .
'� ,� ..� , � ���
� ��������������r��•µ.r
Health in all Planning
To create equitable,healthy,and sustainable communities ;
because a healthy economy depends on a heafthy population
Fragrem Qti�ecHves �� Indlcators�: TargetsiDeslred 0utcomes �.
improve Air antl � particulate matter Decrease pattkulate Matter 10%�by 2018
WaterQUality GHGelnis�fonS Deaease�HGerh(ssionsby15%by2018andby2tl%by2023� .
_`!l�21k8bllity��d Bikability � Inctease 1 af yoU�fi Ihat walk oebike fo school to>52°k by 2020� � �
� �Pedesfia�2ntl motor vehicle injuries �Deorease hospiialized pedestrian injuries to<5/year by 2o2D. �. .
Promote�Public . ���Decrease hospitaNzed mobrvehicle injuries to<55/year by 2020.
Heakh �Population with asihma-� � =Decrease�hose diagnosed with asthma to<9°k by 2020 . . �'.
. �. '-0venvBigfiUObeSepopUla6on ��.Decrease%overweighVobeseadullsfo<57%�andlow-incomechildreoto<42% '�.
. . . by 2020. � '�.
� '�Energy aUdi4S and inCen6ves ���Increase access to enerqy audils and energy efficiency improvements for low� �
Promote Equity inwme households. � ��
`-�TrBnspo![ation balriers �Decrease%reporling Iransporta�ion as a problem in meeting heelth needs to
<10°k by 202tl � �,
Reduce Auto Vehicle Miles per Person per Day(VMT) Reduotion in VMT by 10%by 2020.
UsageandFuel -Percentofcommutersdrivingalone � ��Decrease%ofcommulersdrivingaioneto<60%by202Q.
Consumption ���GHG emissions �� ��Reduction o(45�MTCO2E by 2015. .
��Identified infra5hucture improvemeots ��100%of new projecis are ranked according to GHG emissions and energy use �
Improve criteria
(nfrBStrUCtur¢ :�parkSaCre5perrBSidenf�� � ��Increaseparkacresper1,000rssidentsio>3thtoughoutihecountyandall� �.
Systems - Cities by 2020. ' � �
Promote INater ��Per capita water consumption ���Reduce per capita water use by 2-3%by 2615 antl by 20%by 2020. '�
GOnSeNati011 ���AgriCUltUtal watet USage� �-Reduce agriculWral water usage by 10kby Zb20.. � � .
PfomoteEne(gy �.R85identla�8nergyCOnsump6on� ����Reduceresidentialenergyconsumptionby20%by2020. �� � �
EHiciency and ���LEED cCitified buildings� � � � ��locrease percentage of newdevelopment�ia(is LEED certified l015%by 2015. ��.
Conservation ��City operational energy use � ����Decrease total energy use by 15%by�2078 and by 30%by2033.� . . ���.
��City S81B5 t2X teVC0u2 �Increase salas fau revenues by 15°!o above baseline by 2015.
Strengthen the ���percent of households earning�a living wage ��Increase percentof householdseaming above the self-sufficiency siandard to
Economy ��� � � � 65%by 2020. :
1
5/8/2013 �
How Greenhouse Gas
Emissions Impac� Health
P �,
� �
� �� �
a� � , �
�
' Oak Manor ' �';,, °
�z��
y = is�.,�... o �
� ` i � � �, + �,
k .. y�
`�l .�� � . �y ,��� 4� .
�� t •i
�k�ti¢4)��}kt
�;�Y�. ���'r ��y� . . . ����$'� .
�'���:
,
��
4_ m ° .
� em
. - <
a
+�_,.�'_��6�T,1� m'°�i �_^�,,�.... ��. . . � i��`;�
�
� � � � �
I��pl„ e
,
�� '��` � �
�,:. �
�,�
2
(
(
5/$/2013
;
.
�
e-
.
.
� �
.
��
�
3
518/2013
.
_ �
�
��
�
.
�
_,
������ � d-
�
�
, �
r .,. �. �
4
5/8/2013
�:��� . �� �
��V� �iaae�e�
, �
o��sit�+
HearE Disease&
Stroke
� � �
Cancer
� -° � �� �. Mental Healfi�
W . •-
Acce'ss fo Health �� �
�'u@tVIG@S,
T���fIG-I�eIBtBtf �
in�uries&Death
I�tife�ticsus
Diseas�
i�espiratory
C�isease
Low Birth Weight'
0
� ��
-- � - ; '
�
5
518I2013 �
�trategies for Tran�p�rtation and
Land Use ��°
�y,u :.
Expand commute options -
Bike-share program
Increase public transit
Car-pool/car sharing
Altemative vehicle i�frastructure ga Transportation
d ww
Jmproved bike&ped infrastructure Y ,
Qd
., ,..
:-�_,v��.�.�
Complete Streets Policy
Safe Routes fo School programs a
Localization "
�� Mixed-use and increased density along � � 9a+v�,,n�; ,,s,,�p� �� �����
transit�&services �� �111��� �`�1�,��$g,.�� ;
Compact development to preserve Y4
open space � ����
.� µ
Range of housing opportunities �and U�e °
Density credits for developers
Zoning codes&design guidelines � s�„�r
• '
"t4� f
� � . P����?WiPf�����k'wiy.�h4y} ����i�gut ���, `���
� ��Ssti°�,r �i�.a!s�r�'6°",9R�„3�1 ���-� aw➢+ 0;', ` .
� ���� �7; y, �� ,� ����,I�tM1�'..
�
�.,
� ', '
�
�,� _�.
,*
`
� .. .. � f i��k d �Y �.
�� ��i�,��z<��
6
;�
' 5/8I2013
;
5tra�egies for Ener�y EfiFiciency
������
' Require higher e�ciency than state codes �. �{�y�������
Require passive solar design for heating& '`� . 'pftAFTY? '
cooling ���;
Require light cofored pavements&shade tree -� ��' '
coverage � Doyau �`.�.�� ;',
s �nd 4oa
Promote"ener ye�cienc audits& � �, �{�� °3
improvement gfor existing buildings&homes �'►#����� � {J��� }
utitifie�? x�v:
^•^ Promote onsite energy generation ' "'
Promotion of existing financing&rebate
programs
,,,
Join Mendocino Gounty's residential Property - �
Assessed Clean Energy(PACE)program to
finance improvements
= Promote clean energy economy and"'green
collar"jobs
; Point-of-sale enetgy use disclosure for
technology
Develop local"Green Business°program to "
incentivize&celebrate sustainable practices �[�����
SAVtf'�IG
. '
� C
. y��t kt •�R��4� Ui
�i '�ti..�",:.5�, ZS`l
�^ Q � ° ^; r;�e ,� xazt�,v
y „t� ��,h� ;� i }a��s�•�,�¢�'
1`iQY� .i e� �T p�i i rf'yt I
�' �
`1'. .X�:� f ...��. ' . ,:i i..{ t �.
. � W ��,. .t �T�,.i�,t S �.
� �q
�r ( yx�
��� � ���y:�� ��.
..:, ..,.., ...i � ..
7
5/8/2013
Stra�egies for Waste �I�nagement
mn����.,n �����,.����,��� ,�� ,
City Zero Waste Plan
✓ City Zero Waste Resolution
✓ Restrictplasticbags ' '{
Improve/expand composting and - "
recycling
Develop restaurant food waste b�„ �' �
compostmg program pq ww re, , �
W �aW
Improve diversion and reuse of
construction waste
Adopt enviranmentally friendly ' ,
purchasing policy for municipal �' _ .
aperations `
? Restri�t sale of excess�packaging ���� ��„�•� �
Flaring landfill methane `' �
. '
a �
#a ��,
�o����
� ���
� ��
� �
_ a ` � �
,
�"�� �titi
�
� �,
ti
,
a_ a ; c��
� -� t ' `t's����
}
e ''�� Y2„ �
�!rri��li Y I'1��� 'll��'�V a
� �., � �r�a
�� � �
.. . �� �;,s;.� �+� . .
Y rv�
3�t
�5:fr�,�a, . ... . ���
C3 '
5/8I2013
Stirategies fQr Water Conserva�ic�in
� ,"
Public education and outreach
an conservation strategies '
Promote rebates for efficient
plumbing
Expand use of recycled water '
Instail purple pipes yF��9xq� §
��Graywater systems ��
���>�,'
�° Adopt water efficient ���� � ���� �
landscaping ordinance '
Increase rainwater harvest
,
��art a����s�a�
� p stroke
�
�,ii
� A_ m _ .
sm
m
9
5isi�o�s
.
Heart Disease& !
Stroke
- � � Gancer
�
�
s°
�
�
Heark;pisease& '
�froke �
° • Gancer
a Mental Health
a-
• `�
10
. 518/2013
.
r����r nrs����a� '
� Str�ke ���
- � o-
�2itCLi`
p. � w g ivienfal Wealth ;
a &a
�
' (II
Cnfec#�ous
Dfsease
.
tieart Dise�se� '.
5troke '
_ �
- � Cancer
� � m (Ulental Health . '
c-
a
. . : � ..... . ..
���' � � � �
8
� ���9 4.ti .���
����".{�r11��1'�S ' .
Disease
Respiratory
Dise�se '
11
5/�3/2013 �
�: :: �
I ���r��t�� -
� �
� �����i�
HeatY Disease&
SfCOke� ��
° � � *" � Cancer= ���
_� � b Mentai He�1tM
. e°
� � access ta Healfh
Seruiees
' TYaff�-I�ei�ted
Ir�jtiries&De�tli
Irifectious
Dise�se !
�Respitatory�,' � ���
[7iseas� '; '
i.aw Birth Weigt�t
;
Heart Diseas�& '
Stroke '
C�nc�r� � ��
� a . Mental Healtti '
�,A,���. .e
�
�Y li�,fl� e I'� ?��i6! �� Infectinus
Disease
Respiratory
C�isease '
12
. 5/$I2013
"s
Heart C}IS8aS4'& '
_� � m
.
�trok�
- o�
� � ��ncer �
Mental�Heal#h, ,', ��
InfectioUs
t�isease
� R@$�ill`8�.flt�1 ; ��.
[?I9��S@
'�
FI@art DISB&Se&
�trok�6 e�
�
a°
e
^ ��. �aneer
�
; • ,
Ment�I Health ''
tnfecflaus
Disease
�° ' « ° Respiratary
Disease
l.ow Birth Weight
13
5l8/2013
�
Heart disease&
5troke
__ � 4 ��«
.-
° C�ncer
Mental Heai#h
_ � �
InfeGtious
i�isease
", � - m - Respirafary,
disease
Low Bir#h VU�ight
Heat#Disease&
S#rake ,
'Canc€rr '
Transportatic�n
��Mental�He�ith ,�����
e
�a11fI I,JS�' .
tnfeCtlous
disease '
w a' ��'S}5(I"r��Of���.. �...
. . � ,.C}ISG'89� ,,
14 '
�IS�za7�
��� ie Q;���t�� �
��� $
N �� o������ ��
_
h � � ��, �. � � ��� _,
� � � ` � Hearf�fC3isease&���
�� �> �v�v.,i�.�t t1i�E r�t�
�,,,�"`""' � StrOke �,.�
k,e� ��
`�'�," � �
� ���.
�„ ��" C�ncer
Transparf�tion ��� � �
� �.�
�°�� Mentai Heaith �
� �„���,��,���..� �
�and Use
Infectious
Dlseas�
� Respiratary ;
� ` •gy I�isease
vw�� [Iiab�tes
� � � �, �� Obes'rty
�a, �°'� _ �
'�.�"`�~ ";°�., HearkiJisease&;'
ri���� ���;�.� ��
"� Strake
�"*�,�, �t..x
��
���ri
��� �
�� �� �� ��
�sn�er
Transportation � ° ° , _ w,�
Menfal Heaith ;
e . -W_�—
Land Use
� � Inf�cCious �
Disease
� t�es�iratary
�µ . •� i3isease
Cow Birtl�Weight,
15
5/8/2013
�=r� piaUetes �
.
� �:,� ��besiiy
, �� �
�,.,��•, , ��
� � t °"" Heart C?iseas��& �� �
a�. ,,, �, �k �
.��,� ���SfrUke
Cancer
��ranspartation ��� �
a m ,.�
� � �� ' M�ntal He�lth �
e
t_snd llse ,,, ,,, �
� '
�` infectious
bisease '
e R4'S�JIT�t01'j+, �..
° @- I��sease ; '
� 'I i� �,f'���i �i
�j, ' I,� �
Low'Birth Weight', '
�,,.� Diabetes
� �
� n,,„ ��f� ��Qbesity ;
����,� `° � Heart Disease&
^ �``� ��SCroke �
,
��,
�a, �
� �
���,, � ���"
Cancer
Transportatlqn � �� �
lUterital Health
.
Access t�Heaith
Services
t�and use
1'raf��-Rel�ted
_ � , injuries&Death '
�.�,. Infect�tius '
Ctis�:ase '
. Respiratory
. o- Disease '
� i (�'
Low Birth Weight;
16
n 518i2013
'�'I ' ' D�abetes � ��
. C s
l�be9i#y
Heart Dise�se&
7Mf;u�
Sttoke
�r,
" m �a�cer
. � . Nlental Heal#h '
, � --
� ACCess to Health
� . �, Seruices
, TrafflC-Relatr�tl �
Injuries&Death
irifectious !�
C}isease
Respiratory '
C1IS�ase
Low BIrCh VUei�ht
Di�betes
He�lth ,
oa����y
�••J������� Heart[�'rsease&
� Strake
� Cancer��
Nten#�I Health
Aecess#c�Health' '
..; S2CYIG�'S �.
7raffrG-Related ; '
Injuries&Death i
Infectious
bisease;
iRespir2toiy .
DiSease
Low Birth 1Neight'
17
518/2 Q 13
� �� ���a����
a�����
Meart Disease&
+ Str�ske '
C�ncer �
Merital Hea(th
ACCess fo Health
Services
TrafficvRelat�tl
injuries&[?eath
infeCtious
bisease
F2�spira#ory
bisease
Low Birkh Weight
' P�abete�
Obesity
hleart Disease&
° S#C6k2!,
�ance�
Merital He;�lth ��
AcCess to Heaifh
Services
Tra�ic=Related
I�juraes&Deatli
Infeciious
t�is�ase
Respiratory
Disease
i.ow Birth Weight, '
18 '
5/8/2D 13
���a����:
�� Qb�sity .
Ne�rt pise�se�& �
� �tto�Ce
Cancer
htientai Heal�h �
AcCess to Health
'Services
Traffic-Relatet�
Injuries&Death
InPectious
��Dls�ase�
Respiratory
Disease
Low 8irth We`rght
Diab�:tes
Obesify" '
Weark Disea���
° Stroke ,
Cancer '
Mental Health
Acc�ss to Heaith
Services
Traffic-ftelated '
Injuries&Qea#h
Inf�ctiqus
Disease
RespiratoCy
'C�isease '
�aw Birth Weight
19
5/8J2013
: Liabetes
: Obesity
HearE L�iseas�&:
� StroK� �' '
Cance�
Mer�tal Hea!#h '
ACCess to H�alth
5etyices
TraftiG°12elated
Injuries 8�beath
Infectlous
Dasease
�R�:spira�ory
Disease
l.ow Birkh Weighf
Diabetes '
Obesity
He��t L7is�ase�
° SttOke
Canc�:f
Merital Heal#h
Access to H�alth '
Services
�5`affic-Related
Injuries&Death
Infectious
Disease
Respiratary
C�isease
Law Birth Weight
Za
i
5I812Q 13
n�������
csbesrty
H�ar#D�se��e&
� " �troke
_ � Gance�� � ��
iUlental t-lealt�r
AcC�ss to Flealtli
5eruices °
Traffi�-Rela#etl
In�u�e�&Death� � �
Infectious
' Disease,
Respiratory
Disease
LouY Birth We�ghf,
Wha is most at risk?
Children
Qlder Adults
. Low-income
People with pre-existing conditions
21
518/2013
Sustainable Communities
,�� � ��_�� ��,�� �� e
�a������ A����� ����v��� , �
� �
���� ��� � ���`��°"�� " � '��a� �
�
��� q��� � � � ���.
� � ��� � .� �� ,�
��� "' � ` "�� e ���.' -��- �, � '�� °
r
.,...�.'"�� ���.. ��` � �.��kj� .� ,e '�a� � .
'�"�'i �. �..
�� a,� ,.� �
�.��,'�,�.-��,'.. � r.�.O . �4 P'�� �.
i;��~��.'�,.0 �`s��d�"�`,��� °a'w�r,3.^.:a`$�.,"�i�^.}t�,�+afiu�.��`.�ck �.i L=, .
*�.3.�'�`�5,�
Health in aII Planning
To create equitable,healthy,and sustainable communities
because a healthy economy depends on a heaithy population
..
«
, Thank yau! �or More
I nformation, Please Contact
�I�,s�i���tcal€-t�tta,r��ic�r�'ra�qr��ra S�aee��Ii�t
(TCl�}472-2��}E�
sfull�c�co.inendc�cinc�:ca.us
I�ci�tin�������I�r;��n�ca�°��aksl6c;Ft��lt�a���Ey�t
(7C}7}�7�-�7?�
flad��fhk a c��menelnr.ino:ca.m�s
�"ir��'��I�rM�"�h��, €�r�?gr�am�dsr�ini��ra��r
�7t�7}�7�-�6�� '
t�I��commendocino.ca.us
22