HomeMy WebLinkAbout1115 Storm Water DischargeORDINANCE O. 1115
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF UKIAH ADDING CHAPTER
8 TO DIVISION 4 OF THE UKIAH CITY CODE, ENTITLED: STORM WATER
DISCHARGE
The City Council of the City of Ukiah hereby ordains as follows:
SECTION ONE.
Division 4, Chapter 8 of the Ukiah City Code is hereby added as follows:
DIVISION 4, CHAPTER 8. STORM WATER DISCHARGE
§4090.1: Purpose.
The purpose and intent of this chapter is to ensure the health, safety, and general welfare
of the residents of the City of Ukiah, and protect and enhance the water quality of
watercourses and water bodies in a manner pursuant to and consistent with the Federal
Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. § 1251 et seq.), and National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System (NPDES) Phase II storm water regulations for small municipal separate storm
sewer systems, by reducing pollutants in storm water discharges to the maximum extent
practicable and by prohibiting non-storm water discharges to the storm drain system.
§4090.2: Definitions.
For purposes of this chapter, the following terms shall be defined as follows:
"Best Management Practices" ("BMP") means activities, practices, and procedures
implemented to prevent or reduce the discharge of pollutants directly or indirectly to the
municipal storm drain system and waters of the United States. Best Management Practices
include, but are not limited to: treatment facilities to remove pollutants from storm water;
operating and maintenance procedures; facility management practices to control runoff,
spillage or leaks of non-storm water, waste disposal, and drainage from materials storage;
erosion and sediment control practices; and the prohibition of specific activities, practices,
and procedures and such other provisions as the City determines appropriate for the
control of pollutants.
"City" means the City of Ukiah.
"Clean Water Act" means the federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. § 1251 et
seq.), and any subsequent amendments thereto.
"Construction Activity" means activities subject to National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System ("NPDES") Construction Permits. These include construction projects resulting in
land disturbance of one or more acres. Such activities include, but are not limited to,
clearing and grubbing, grading, excavating and demolition.
"Hazardous Materials" means any material, including any substance, waste, or combination
thereof, which because of its quantity, concentration, or physical, chemical, or infectious
characteristics may cause, or significantly contribute to, a substantial present or potential
hazard to human health, safety, property, or the environment when improperly treated,
stored, transported, disposed of, or otherwise managed (California Health and Safety Code
§ 25117).
"Illegal Discharge" means any direct or indirect non-storm water discharge to the storm
drain system, except as exempted in subsections 4090.5(B) (1) through (3).
"Illicit Connection" is defined as either of the following:
1. Any drain or conveyance, whether on the surface or subsurface, which allows an
illegal discharge to enter the storm drain system, including, but not limited to, any
conveyances which allow any non-storm water discharge including sewage, processed
wastewater, and wash water to enter the storm drain system and any connections to the
storm drain system from indoor drains and sinks, regardless of whether said drain or
connection had been previously allowed, permitted, or approved by a government
agency; or
2. Any drain or conveyance connected from a commercial or industrial land use to the
storm drain system which has not been documented in plans, maps, or equivalent
records and approved by the City.
"National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Storm Water Discharge
Permits" means general, group, and individual storm water discharge permits which
regulate facilities defined in federal NPDES regulations pursuant to the Clean Water Act.
The California Regional Water Quality Control Board, North Coast Region (hereinafter,
"Regional Board") and the State Water Resources Control Board have adopted general
storm water discharge permits, including, but not limited to, the general construction activity
and general industrial activity permits.
"Non-Storm Water Discharge" means any discharge to the storm drain system that is not
composed entirely of storm water or any release of pollutants that potentially or actually
discharges to the City's storm drain system.
"Pollutant" means anything that causes or contributes to pollution. Pollutants may include,
but are not limited to: paints, varnishes, and solvents; oil and other automotive fluids; non-
hazardous liquid and solid wastes and yard wastes; refuse, rubbish, garbage, litter, or other
discarded or abandoned objects, articles, and accumulations, so that same may cause or
contribute to pollution; floatables; pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers; hazardous
substances and wastes; sewage, fecal coliform and pathogens; dissolved and particulate
metals; animal wastes; wastes and residues that result from constructing a building or
structure (including but not limited to sediments, slurries, and concrete rinsates); and
noxious or offensive matter of any kind.
"Pollution" means the human-made or human-induced alteration of the quality of waters by
waste to a degree which unreasonably affects, or has the potential to unreasonably affect,
either the waters for beneficial uses or the facilities which serve these beneficial uses
(California Water Code § 13050).
"Porter-Cologne Act" means the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act as amended
(California Water Code § 13000 et seq.).
"Premises" means any building, lot, parcel of land, or portion of land whether improved or
unimproved including adjacent sidewalks and parking strips.
"Storm Drain System" means publicly-owned facilities operated by the City by which storm
water is collected and/or conveyed, including, but not limited.to, any roads with drainage
systems, municipal streets, gutters, curbs, inlets, piped storm drains, pumping facilities,
retention and detention basins, natural and human-made or altered drainage channels,
creeks, reservoirs, and other drainage structures which are within the City and are not part
of a publicly owned treatment works as defined at 40 Code of Federal Regulations Section
122.2.
"Storm Water" means any surface flow, runoff, and drainage consisting entirely of water
from rainstorm events.
"Waters of the United States" means surface watercourses and water bodies as defined at
40 Code of Federal Regulations § 122.2 including all natural waterways and definite
channels and depressions in the earth that may carry water, even though such waterways
may only carry water during rains and storms and may not carry storm water at and during
all times and seasons.
§4090.3: Applicability.
This chapter shall apply to all water entering the storm drain system generated on any
developed and undeveloped lands lying within the City.
§4090.4: Administration.
The City Manager of the City shall administer, implement, and enforce the provisions of this
chapter. Any powers granted or duties imposed upon the City Manager may be delegated
in writing by the City Manager to persons or entities acting in the beneficial interest of or in
the employ of the City.
§4090.5: Prohibition of illegal discharges.
A. The release of non-storm water discharges to the City's storm water system is
prohibited.
B. The following discharges are exempt from the prohibition set forth in subsection (A) of
this section:
1. Any discharge in compliance with an NPDES permit issued to the discharger and
administered by the State of California under the authority of the United States
Environmental Protection Agency;
2. Discharges from the following activities will not be considered a prohibited discharge
to the City's storm water system when properly managed: flushing of potable water from
potable water lines and other discharges from potable water sources, landscape
irrigation and lawn watering, irrigation water, diverted stream flows, rising ground
waters, uncontaminated ground water infiltration to storm drains, uncontaminated
pumped ground water, foundation and footing drains, water from crawl space pumps, air
conditioning condensation, springs, runoff from individual residential car washing, flows
from riparian habitats and wetlands, dechlorinated swimming pool discharges, flows
from emergency fire fighting, and other flows necessary for implementing BMPs
directed or approved by the City Manager;
3. With written concurrence of the Regional Water Quality Control Board, the City may
exempt, in writing, other non-storm water discharges that are not a source of pollutants
to the storm drain system or waters of the United States.
C. Any discharge that would result in, or contribute to, a violation of any NPDES permit for
storm water discharges from within the City and any amendment, revision, or reissuance of
such permit, either separately considered or when combined with other discharges, is
prohibited. Liability for any such discharge shall be the responsibility of the person(s)
causing or responsible for the discharge, and such persons shall defend, indemnify and
hold harmless the City, its officers, agents and employees in any administrative or judicial
enforcement action relating to such discharge.
D. It is unlawful to establish, use, maintain, or continue unauthorized drainage connections
to the City's storm water system.
E. It is unlawful to establish, use, maintain, or continue drainage connections to the City's
storm water system that are or may be a source of prohibited discharges.
F. It is unlawful to commence or continue any unauthorized and/or prohibited discharges to
the City's storm water system.
G. No person shall throw, deposit, leave, keep or permit to be thrown, deposited, placed,
left or maintained, any refuse, household hazardous wastes or other hazardous wastes,
garbage, debris, or other wastes, or other discarded or abandoned objects or articles in or
upon any storm water system or upon any public or private plot of land in the City so that
the same might become a pollutant, except in lawfully established waste disposal facilities.
§4090.6: Requirements for reducing pollutants in storm water.
A. Any person engaging in activities that may result in pollutants entering the City's storm
water system shall undertake all practicable measures to reduce and/or eliminate such
pollutants. All activities that do actually, or may potentially, result in the deposit of pollutants
in or on the City's storm water system, in any tributary of this system, and all land which
drains to either this system or any of its tributaries shall be construed as activities which
may result in pollutants entering the City's storm water system. Examples of such activities
include, but are not limited to, ownership and use of premises that may be a source of
pollutants such as parking lots, gasoline stations, industrial facilities, business enterprises,
and dwelling units.
B. Any construction contractor performing work in the City shall implement appropriate best
management practices to prevent the discharge of construction wastes or debris or
contaminants from construction materials, tools, and equipment from entering the storm
water system.
C. Persons owning, operating, or maintaining a paved parking lot, the paved areas of a gas
station, a paved private street, road, or driveway and related storm water systems shall
clean those structures as frequently and thoroughly as practicable in a manner that does
not result in discharge of pollutants to the storm water system.
D. Every person owning property through which a watercourse passes, or such person's
lessee, shall keep and maintain that part of the watercourse within the property reasonably
free of trash, debris, excessive vegetation, and other obstacles that would pollute,
contaminate, or significantly retard the flow of water through the watercourse. In addition,
the owner or lessee shall maintain existing privately owned structures within or adjacent to
a watercourse, so that such structures will not become a hazard to the use, function, or
physical integrity of the watercourse. The owner or lessee shall not remove healthy bank
vegetation beyond that actually necessary for maintenance, nor remove said vegetation in
such a manner as to increase the vulnerability of the watercourse to erosion. The property
owner shall be responsible for maintaining and stabilizing that portion of the watercourse
that is within his or her property lines in order to protect against erosion and degradation of
the watercourse originating or contributed from their property.
E. The occupant or tenant, or in the absence of occupant or tenant, the owner or proprietor
of any real property in the City in front of which there is a paved sidewalk shall maintain that
portion of the sidewalk in front of the property free of dirt or litter to the maximum extent
practicable. Sweepings from the sidewalk shall not be swept or otherwise made or allowed
to go into the gutter or roadway or any element of any drainage system, but shall be
disposed of in receptacles maintained as required for the disposal of solid waste and/or
yard waste, as appropriate.
F. Each discharger associated with construction activity disturbing more than one acre, or
other discharger described in any general storm water permit addressing such discharges
as may be adopted by the United States Environmental Protection Agency, the State Water
Resources Control Board, or the California Regional Water Quality Control Board, North
Coast Region, shall provide the Notice of Intent, comply with, and undertake all other
activities required by any general storm water permit applicable to such dischargers, and
shall provide a copy of the Notice of Intent and of each annual report pursuant to any
general storm water permit to the City Manager, and shall pay any associated monitoring
and enforcement fees to the City that may be set by the City-Council. Each discharger
identified in an individual NPDES permit relating to storm water discharges shall comply
with and undertake all activities required by such permit.
G. Where best management practice guidelines or requirements have been adopted or
published by the Environmental Protection Agency, the Regional Water Quality Control
Board, or the City, for any activity, operation or facility which may cause or contribute to
prohibited discharges, every person undertaking such activity or operation or owning or
operating such commercial facility shall comply with such guideline or requirement.
H. The City Manager may require any business in the City that is engaged in activities
which may result in prohibited discharges to develop and implement a storm water pollution
prevention plan, which must include an employee training program. Business activities
which may require a storm water pollution prevention plan include, but are not limited to,
maintenance, storage, manufacturing, assembly, equipment operations, vehicle loading or
fueling, or cleanup procedures which are carried out partially or wholly out of doors.
1. The City Manager may adopt requirements identifying appropriate best management
practices to control the volume, rate, and potential pollutant load of storm water runoff from
new development and redevelopment projects as may be appropriate to minimize the
generation, transport and discharge of pollutants. The City shall incorporate such
requirements in any land use entitlement and construction or building-related permit to be
issued relative to such development or redevelopment. The owner and developer shall
comply with the terms, provisions, and conditions of such land use entitlements and
building permits as required in the ordinance.
§4090.7: Requirement to eliminate illegal discharges.
The City Manager may require by written notice that a person responsible for an illegal
discharge immediately, or by a specified date, discontinue the discharge and, if necessary,
take measures to eliminate the source of the discharge to prevent the occurrence of future
illegal discharges.
§4090.8: Requirement to eliminate or secure approval for illicit connections.
A. The City Manager may require by written notice that a person responsible for an illicit
connection to the storm drain system comply with the requirements of this chapter to
eliminate or secure approval for the connection by a specified date, regardless of whether
or not the connection or discharges to it had been established or approved prior to the
effective date of this ordinance.
B. If, subsequent to eliminating a connection found to be in violation of this ordinance, the
responsible person can demonstrate that an illegal discharge will no longer occur, said
person may request City approval to reconnect. The reconnection or reinstallation of the
connection shall be at the responsible person's expense.
§4090.9: Requirement to remediate.
Whenever the City Manager finds that a discharge of pollutants is taking place or has
occurred which will result in, or has resulted in, pollution of storm water, the storm drain
system, or waters of the U.S., the City Manager may require by written notice to the owner
of the property or the responsible person that the pollution be remediated and the affected
property restored within a specified time.
§4090.10: Requirement to monitor and analyze.
The City Manager may require by written notice that any person engaged in any activity or
owning or operating any facility which may cause or contribute to storm water pollution,
illegal discharges, or non-storm water discharges to the storm drain system or waters of the
U.S., shall undertake at said person's expense such monitoring and analyses and furnish
such reports to the City as deemed necessary to determine compliance with this chapter.
§4090.11: Notification of spills.
A. The owner of a commercial facility or the persons responsible for emergency response
for a commercial facility have the responsibility to train facility personnel and maintain
notification procedures to assure:
1. Immediate notification is provided to the City Department of Public Works of any
suspected, confirmed, or unconfirmed release of material, pollutants, or waste creating
a risk of discharge into the City storm water system;
2. Immediate notification is given to the "9-1-1" emergency response system if said
discharge poses an immediate threat to the public health or safety and/or the
environment;
3. Written notification is provided to the City Manager within five working days.
B. Training of personnel shall assure that all BMPs are being fully and correctly
implemented and that all releases of any non-storm water discharge or of any pollutant that
threatens to enter the City's storm water system are immediately recognized and that
appropriate response is taken in the event of such release.
C. As soon as any person in charge of a commercial facility or who is responsible for
emergency response for a commercial facility has knowledge of, or reasonably could be
expected to have knowledge of, any suspected, confirmed or unconfirmed release of a non-
storm water discharge entering, or of any pollutant that is threatening to enter, the City
storm water system from such facility, such person shall take all necessary steps to ensure
the early discovery and containment and clean up such release and shall immediately
notify the City Department of Public Works. In addition, written notification shall be given to
the City Manager within five working days. This written notification shall contain, as a
minimum, a narrative describing the circumstances resulting -in the release, or threatened
release, the effort taken to clean up the release and the measures being taken to prevent
reoccurrence. This notification requirement is in addition to, and not in lieu of, other
required notifications.
§4090.12: Authority to inspect.
Whenever necessary to make an inspection to enforce any provision of this ordinance, or
whenever the City Manager has cause to believe that there exists, or potentially exists, in
or upon any premises any condition which constitutes a violation of this ordinance, the City
Manager may enter such premises at all reasonable times to inspect the same and to
inspect and copy records related to storm water compliance. In the event the owner or
occupant refuses entry after a request to enter and inspect has been made, the City is
hereby empowered to seek assistance from any court of competent jurisdiction in obtaining
such entry.
§4090.13: Authority to sample, establish sampling devices, and test.
During any inspection as provided herein, the City Manager may take any samples and
perform any testing deemed necessary to aid in the pursuit of the inquiry or to record site
activities.
§4090.14: Notice of violation.
Whenever the City Manager finds that a person has violated a prohibition or failed to meet
a requirement of this ordinance, the City Manager may order compliance by written notice
of violation to the responsible person. Such notice may require without limitation:
A. The performance of monitoring, analyses, and reporting;
B. The elimination of illicit connections or discharges;
C. That violating discharges, practices, or operations shall cease and desist;
D. The abatement or remediation of storm water pollution or contamination hazards and the
restoration of any affected property;
E. Payment of a fine to cover administrative and remediation costs; or
F. The implementation of source control or treatment BMPs.
If abatement of a violation or restoration of affected property is required, the notice shall set
forth a deadline within which such remediation or restoration must be completed. Said
notice shall further advise that, should the violator fail to remediate or restore within the
established deadline, the work will be done by the City or a contractor designated by the
City Manager and the expense thereof shall be charged to the violator.
§4090.15: Appeal of Notice of Violation.
Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 4090.20 below, any person receiving a notice of
violation under Section 4090.14 above, may appeal the determination of the City Manager
to a hearing officer appointed by the City Council. The notice of appeal must be received by
the City Clerk within five days from the date of the notice of violation. The appeal shall state
the name and address of the appellant, the nature of the determination being appealed, the
reason the appellant believes the determination is incorrect, and what the correct
determination of the appeal should be. Failure to file such a statement within the time or in
the manner required waives the appellant's right to an appeal and the decision of the City
Manager shall become final. Unless the appellant and the City agree to a longer time
period, the appeal shall be heard by the an impartial and qualified hearing officer within
thirty days of receipt of the notice of appeal. To be considered qualified, the hearing officer
shall have substantial education, training and/or experience in construction, hydrology,
environmental science, law or related fields. At least ten days prior to the hearing, the City
shall mail notice of the time and place of the hearing to the appellant. The hearing officer
shall hear and determine the appeal on the basis of the appellant's written statement and
any additional evidence deemed appropriate. The appellant may present testimony and
oral argument at the hearing either personally or by counsel. The hearing officer shall issue
a written decision within ten days of the date of the hearing. The decision of the City
hearing officer is final.
§4090.16: Method of Giving Notice.
Whenever notice is required or permitted under this chapter, it shall be given by personal
delivery or by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested. Notice shall be given to
the City, attention: City Manager, at Ukiah Civic Center, 300 Seminary Avenue, Ukiah, CA.
95482. Notice shall be given to a property owner at the owner's address as contained in
the Mendocino County Assessor's records. Notice shall be given to an occupant or tenant
of property at the address of the property. Notice shall be given to a contractor at the
address on file with the California State Contractor's Licensing Board or on a City of Ukiah
business license issued to the contractor. Notice shall be deemed given and received on
the date personally delivered, on the date on the return receipt or 72 hours after deposit in
the United States mail, whichever first occurs.
§4090.17: Abatement by City.
If the violation has not been corrected pursuant to the requirements set forth in the notice of
violation, or, in the event of an appeal under Section 4090.15, within ten days of the
decision of the City Council upholding the decision of the City Manager, then the City or a
contractor designated by the City Manager shall enter upon the subject private property
and is authorized to take any and all measures necessary to abate the violation and/or
restore the property. It shall be unlawful for any person, owner, agent, or person in
possession of any premises to refuse to allow the City or designated contractor to enter
upon the premises for the purposes set forth above.
§4090.18: Charging cost of abatement/liens.
Within thirty days after abatement of the nuisance by the City, the City Manager shall notify
the property owner of the cost of abatement, including administrative costs and attorneys'
fees. The property owner may file a written protest objecting to the amount of the
assessment with the City Clerk within fifteen days. The City Clerk shall set the matter for
public hearing by the City Council. The decision of the City Council shall be set forth by
resolution and shall be final.
If the amount due is not paid within ten days of the decision of the City Council or the
expiration of the time in which to file an appeal under this section, the charges shall
become a special assessment against the property and shall constitute a lien on the
property for the amount of the assessment in accordance with Government Code §
38773.5. A copy of the resolution shall be filed with the County Auditor so that the Auditor
may enter the amounts of the assessment against the parcel as it appears on the current
assessment roll, and the Tax Collector shall include the amount of the assessment on the
bill for taxes levied against the parcel of land.
§4090.19: Urgency abatement.
The City Manager is authorized to require immediate abatement of any violation of this
ordinance that constitutes an immediate threat to the health, safety or well being of the
public. If any such violation is not abated immediately as directed by the City Manager, the
City is authorized to enter onto private property and to take any and all measures required
to remediate the violation. Any expense related to such remediation undertaken by the City
shall be fully reimbursed by the property owner and/or responsible party. Any relief
obtained under this section shall not prevent the City from seeking other and further relief
authorized under this ordinance.
§4090.20: Violations.
A. It shall be unlawful for any person to violate any provision -or fail to comply with any of
the requirements of this chapter. A violation of or failure to comply with any of the
requirements of this chapter shall constitute a misdemeanor, except that, notwithstanding
any other provisions of this chapter, any such violation constituting a misdemeanor under
this chapter may, in the discretion of the enforcing authority, be charged and prosecuted as
an infraction.
B. Any person who submits a report required by this chapter, which she or he knows, or
should have reason to know, contains falsified data shall be subject to a fine not to exceed
the amount that the City may be fined by the State Water Resources Control Board or the
amount of any civil liability imposed on the City for noncompliance with the municipal storm
water discharge permit for the City.
C. Every day or any portion thereof any violation of this ordinance continues shall constitute
a separate offense.
D. Concealing, aiding, or abetting a violation of any provision of this chapter shall constitute
a violation of such provision.
§4090.21: Penalties.
A. Infractions. An infraction is punishable by:
1. A fine not exceeding one hundred dollars for the first violation;
2. A fine not exceeding two hundred dollars for a second violation of the same code
provision within a twelve-month period;
3. A fine not exceeding five hundred dollars for each for each additional violation of the
same code provision within a twelve-month period;
4. An offense, which would otherwise be an infraction, is a misdemeanor if a person has
been convicted of three or more violations of the same code provision within a twelve-
month period. For the purpose of this subsection, a bail forfeiture is considered a
conviction of the offense charged;
5. An infraction is not punishable by imprisonment. A person charged with an infraction
is not entitled to a jury trial nor to a pubic defense unless arrested and not released.
B. Misdemeanors. A misdemeanor is punishable by a fine not exceeding one thousand
dollars or imprisonment not exceeding six months, or both.
§4090.22: Compensatory action.
In lieu of enforcement proceedings, penalties, and remedies authorized by this chapter, the
City Manager may impose upon a violator alternative compensatory actions, including, but
not limited to, storm drain labeling, attendance at compliance workshops, and creek
cleanup.
§4090.23: Violations deemed a public nuisance.
In addition to the enforcement processes and penalties herein provided, any condition
caused or permitted to exist in violation of any of the provisions of this chapter is a threat to
public health, safety, and welfare, and is declared and deemed a nuisance, and may be
summarily abated or restored by the City at the violator's expense, and/or a civil action to
abate, enjoin, or otherwise compel the cessation of such nuisance may be taken by the
City.
§4090.24: Acts potentially resulting in a violation of the federal Clean Water Act
and/or California Porter-Cologne Act.
Any person who violates any provision of this chapter or any provision of any requirement
issued pursuant to this chapter, may also be in violation of the federal Clean Water Act
and/or the Porter-Cologne Act and may be subject to the sanctions of those acts including
civil and criminal penalties. Any enforcement action authorized under this chapter shall also
include written notice to the violator of such potential liability.
SECTION TWO.
1. COMPLIANCE WITH CEQA. The City Council finds that this ordinance is not
subject to the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") pursuant to Sections
15060(c)(2) (the activity will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect
physical change in the environment), or 15061(b)(3) (there is no possibility the
activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, In addition, the
City Council finds that the ordinance is categorically exempt from CEQA as a Class
7 and Class 8 exemption for actions by regulatory agencies taken to protect natural
resources and the environment. (14 CCR 15307 and 15308.)
2. SEVERABILITY. If any provision of this ordinance or the application thereof to
any person or circumstance is held invalid, the remainder of the ordinance and the
application of such provision to other persons or circumstances shall not be affected
thereby. The City Council hereby declares that it would have adopted this
Ordinance and any section, subsection, sentence, clause or phrase thereof
irrespective of the fact that any one or more sections, subsections, sentences,
clauses or phrases be declared unconstitutional or otherwise invalid.
Introduced by title only on May 6, 2009, by the following roll call vote:
AYES: Councilmembers Landis, Thomas, Crane, Rodin, and Mayor Baldwin
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Adopted on 20th day of May, 2009 by the following roll call vote:
AYES: Councilmembers Landis, Thomas, Crane, Rodin, and Mayor Baldwin
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Philip Baldwin, Mayor
ATTEST:
Lin a C. iir~,:!City Clerk